5 ms·
Science is interested in anything you can reproduce.
by Dylan16807 2y ago
Science is interested in anything you can reproduce.
- kranke155 2y agoHow could I reproduce this experience ? It’s absolutely beyond me.
- Dylan16807 2y agoFor something like this, probably multiple people that can see the entity and give independent matching descriptions.
- kranke155 2y agoEven when the lady removed the Voice from me, I wasn’t sure it was real. It was only when she reproduced the voice tone, cadence and choice of words perfectly (after it had left my body) that I thought “oh shit, this is real”. It was like someone doing a spot on Jack Nicholson impression, but Jack Nicholson was an invisible man in my head. How can one explain that?
- deciplex 2y ago>How can one explain that? She didn't actually do it, or at least she didn't do it to the degree that you think she did. Instead, you had an intense enough experience that your memories of the tone, cadence, and choice of words of your voice, were altered after the fact. (Human) memory is extremely unreliable.
- kranke155 2y agoIt’s not memory, it happened at the time, within around 30 seconds, between me hearing the voice and her imitating it. Good way to disqualify the opinion or experience of anyone.
- truculent 2y agoParent poster is being unnecessarily smug and dismissive, but the point is that however close in time the events were, they are now entrenched in fallible memory.
- deciplex 2y ago> Parent poster is being unnecessarily smug and dismissive Can you elaborate? I tried to keep a neutral tone.
- Dylan16807 2y ago> It’s not memory, it happened at the time, within around 30 seconds, between me hearing the voice and her imitating it. People can mix up exact details and whether two things feel the same in that amount of time, especially if they recently took drugs. > Good way to disqualify the opinion or experience of anyone. Look, you specifically asked for a skeptical explanation. You're right that it's not a disproof, but it does mean your experience isn't particularly convincing as an anecdote.
- kranke155 2y agoI hadn't taken drugs for a month when I met the shaman song lady. I don't take drugs in general due to my bipolar.
- deciplex 2y agoI mean people have deja vu which is literally your brain misinterpreting a currently-happening experience as a memory. Medical literature is filled with tons of quirks of human perception and memory, and we frequently find new ones and new twists on existing ones. It is not remotely a stretch to attribute "I recognized this woman's voice as someone else's voice" as just a run-of-the-mill fault of perception and memory. Especially when the alternative at hand is apparently something supernatural (or, at least, new physics).
- kranke155 2y ago
- Almondsetat 2y agoExactly. For all we know, externally, you could be just making everything up.
- lend000 2y agoYes, which can be a huge limitation if you religiously attach yourself to the null hypothesis for anything science doesn't have an explanation for yet.
- deciplex 2y agoI don't know about "religiously" but did you have a better idea? Am I supposed to believe suppositions as though they are fact, for literally no reason?
- lend000 2y agoYou could instead say something like "I don't know." Unfortunately, a lot of people (especially engineers) default to attempting to discredit people's strange experiences and instead regurgitate some hand-wavy materialistic explanation that is incorrect or at least so incomplete and hand-wavy as to just derail the conversation instead of improving it. I was this guy when I was younger, but I prefer being open-minded nowadays. Specifically with regard to people's experiences, I tend to treat them with a strong curiosity. You can never really tell on the internet, but in person, I think people are generally quite honest and don't really lie about things that don't benefit them in some way. If you approach things with an open mind, people tend to be more open with their experiences, and it seems like at least 10% of people I know well and possibly many more have had some inexplicable experiences of the variety described by the parent poster (albeit usually over a much shorter period).
- deciplex 2y agoTo me "I don't know" is pretty close to "didn't happen" anyway. I mean we will even say "hmm, I don't know about that" to indicate skepticism. I suppose you are picturing someone who is obstinately refusing to believe or even investigate a claim, but when I hear "null hypothesis" it's really just "you haven't given me any reason to believe this." And that's not quite the same as "I don't know" but it's not that far off either, is it? Maybe it's just me.
- deleted 2y ago
- mandmandam 2y agoIdeally, yes. Practically though, there could be problems if the research interferes with a big industry, or disrupts 'well established practices'. Or if it damages the professional reputations of important people, or clashes with 'belief perseverance', or makes powerful people look bad, or makes the university likely to lose funding, or goes against the current cancellation third rail, etc, etc. There's no shortage of historical examples: tobacco health research, Semmelweis, plate tectonics (!), lockdown cost benefit analyses, etc. There was very little 'science' in outlawing cannabis research for decades. Same goes for MDMA, LSD, psilocybin, etc, all with massive therapeutic potential that has been held back for decades by politics & industry.