35 ms·
Brazil Court votes unanimously to uphold X ban. Users switch to Threads, Bluesky
- Fidelix 2y agoThese are the only ones that voted: Flávio Dino (Appointed by Lula) Cármen Lúcia (Appointed by Lula) Cristiano Zanin (Appointed by Lula) Luiz Fux (Appointed by Lula)
- rbanffy 2y agoTwitter is not a fundamental right, as access to users isn't a right to a company. If the company wants the product to be available, then it should respect local laws the same way it did in Turkey and India.
- gruez 2y ago>Twitter is not a fundamental right, as access to users isn't a right to a company. What about the rights of people who want to use twitter? Would you use the same characterization for Chinese censorship (ie. "The New York Times is not an fundamental right, as access to users isn't a right to [The New York Times Company]")?
- anon291 2y ago[flagged]
- mensetmanusman 2y agoAccess to the NYT in China or X in Brazil could destabilize their societies. One could argue that their current development status necessitates authoritarianism until a transitional event happens (which took the west many centuries).
- prepend 2y agoFree speech destabilizes society. It’s a suitable price to pay, I think. The goal is absolute harmony. Especially at the expense of rights.
- mensetmanusman 2y agoIf western history is the route, many millions die on the road to free speech. Maybe fewer die if it’s more gradual in the transition?
- tirant 2y agoThat might be your goal. But that does not mean it needs to be everyone else’s goals. For me, freedom of speech is part of what brings societies forward, and that includes deep changes which obviously means unstable societies at some point. Humans would be stuck in Stone Age if we would have had only stable societies.
- prepend 2y agoHa, sorry autocorrect changed my “the goal isn’t” to “the goal is.” I agree with you and mistyped. I really need to proof my comments better. I think the goal is not harmony but value and beauty.
- KerrAvon 2y agoYou don't have the right to patronize a restaurant that gets shut down for health code violations after it's shut down. There's no difference in principle here. Banning Twitter itself for failing to comply with the law isn't a free speech issue. Now, part of the order makes it illegal to use VPN to access Twitter, which is an actual free speech issue, if you'd care to argue on those grounds.
- nickff 2y agoIsn’t the use of a VPN analogous to using a back door (alley entrance) to visit the condemned restaurant? What difference would there be in your analogy?
- gruez 2y ago>There's no difference in principle here. Banning Twitter itself for failing to comply with the law isn't a free speech issue. All the websites China bans are also ostensibly for "failing to comply with the law". Would you say those bans are also "not a free speech issue"?
- Qem 2y ago> Now, part of the order makes it illegal to use VPN to access Twitter, which is an actual free speech issue, if you'd care to argue on those grounds. This part was later struck down by the court.
- dangus 2y agoThis question isn’t relevant to this situation because Musk’s Twitter has already proven to not have any moral standing on this question. Musk is willing to censor for Turkey but not for Brazil. It’s a massive double standard. His company has major shareholders who are part of the Saudi monarchy. Twitter under Musk isn’t a company that can make any honest claim to care about democratic free speech. He’s already suspended left-wing and Musk-critical journalists and activists without a specific TOS violation or explanation while not doing the same for anyone that aligns with his ideology. He doesn’t have kind of the moral high ground that other companies do on these matters, e.g., the kind that Google had when they exited China. I also think that using china’s style of censorship as an analogy to other styles of censorship is also potentially a flawed exercise. I would argue that things like Germany’s censorship of Nazi ideology is a positive for human rights and democracy. Even the USA’s prohibition of the government’s speech on the topic of religion and political speech is technically a form of censorship - self-censorship, essentially. I could imagine a hypothetical democratic government where speech is generally free but anti-democratic ideology is not tolerated, since that speech oversteps the boundaries of free speech and crosses into a territory of speech that harms others. In other words, a society that overcomes the paradox of tolerance. For example, Trump has spoken of elimination of term limits, becoming a dictator for a day, and has generally advocated for political violence. Because of his rhetoric there are a large percentage of people in the USA who would end democracy entirely if it meant that their dear leader Trump was president for life rather than a member of the opposition party. In the USA the first amendment protects him, but I would argue that it should not - that a democracy that intends to survive the constant onslaught of opportunistic authoritarians should criminalize anti-democratic activity and speech. (I am not specifically commenting on Brazil’s orders to censor people on the Twitter platform because I am not equipped with that context. I don’t know specifically who those people are, what those people said, said and whether that court order was sensible. I merely speak in philosophical hypotheticals here - and at the end of the day whether my hypotheticals are “right” or “wrong” is irrelevant in the context of Elon’s asymmetrical application of “free speech”)
- Qem 2y ago> What about the rights of people who want to use twitter? Interoperability should cover this. If the platform is barred from doing business in a given country, users should be able to download all their data and move it to another platform of their choice. People must not be made hostages of the platforms.
- anon291 2y agoElon musk who is the owner of Twitter -- an individual -- actually has a fundamental right to speak to Brazilians via his service. Companies absolutely have rights especially when they're owned by an individual. Banding together in groups does not eliminate human rights.
- surgical_fire 2y agoElon Musk is not a Brazilian citizen, nor he his a resident of Brazil, not holds any permission to stay in the country as of now. He has, in fact, zero rights to communicate in Brazil.
- inglor_cz 2y agoBeing able to read stuff written by other people is pretty close to a basic human right, though. At least in the liberal Western tradition.
- timeon 2y agoI often can't read Twitter because I do not have account. Is my human right violated?
- inglor_cz 2y agoThe coercion inherent in the Brasilian ban (massive fines for users who dare use VPN to access Twitter, massive fines for ISPs who don't comply) is many orders of magnitude greater than the coercion inherent in a paywall.
- Marsymars 2y agoWell, I think it would be very reasonable for a government to compel Twitter to allow access without an account to at least certain accounts that dispense information that is of real-time public interest. e.g. In the case of some recent wildfires here, updates about the emergency were primarily available on Twitter. The sanest implementation would probably just be some nominal monthly charge that an account holder can pay to Twitter to have their account publicly accessible to all.
- ripjaygn 2y agoAccounts are free and easy to create, so it's your choice rather than a restriction on your rights. You have a right to vote in your country, doesn't mean that you can demand they collect the vote in your bedroom and claim your rights are violated if they refuse.
- kaba0 2y agoThat’s why regulation should apply to services like that, the same way a private company should not be able to block a highway that is critical to the functioning of a country. Twitter since elon’s criminal “leadership” has become a bot-infested cesspool of racist bullshit, where he unilaterally censors whatever he dislikes in his sissy fits. In this form, this is a manipulation device, and good riddance.
- hwhwhwhhwhwh 2y agoTurkey and India is probably not the best examples humanity want to try to emulate when it comes to human rights. And this is coming from someone born and raised in India.
- rbanffy 2y agoAnd yet Musk had no issue complying with local law.
- hwhwhwhhwhwh 2y agoMaybe he learned it was a mistake?
- wongarsu 2y ago> Twitter is not a fundamental right Before Musk bought Twitter there were plenty of people arguing on here that in the age of the internet Twitter and places like it are essential as forums of public discourse, and access to them should be as unlimited as possible. Twitter refusing bans and continuing operations in a hostile country was some people's wet dream just a couple years ago. I guess it's a lesson to be careful what you wish for.
- rbanffy 2y agoComplaints were about presidents blocking people so they wouldn’t see their postings. That’s a fair complaint. When there is no other venue to communicate or to get informed about things vital to them, it is perfectly fair to complain about that. In this specific case, Twitter doesn’t provide an essential service and, if it did, that’d need to be regulated and forced to provide services in an equitable and fair way.
- _heimdall 2y agoThe claim is that the ban request doesn't actually comply with Brazilian law. I'm no lawyer and don't know how accurate that is, but if correct that Twitter would be complying with local laws by refusing the unlawful order.
- defrost 2y agoThe claim by Musk (who is also not a lawyer, nor Brazilian) is that a single renegade Brazilian Suprem Court Justice has made a non compliant unconstitutional ban request. The report here asserts that every single other Brazilian Supreme Court Justice has backed that ban. You may not be a lawyer, like Musk, but I'm led to believe that all the Justices of the Braziian Supreme Court are, and that they understand the Brazilian Legal system.
- _heimdall 2y agoI, unlike Musk, don't have a team of lawyers though. Its common for people to attribute business decisions directly to Musk, but do we actually know he was the one and only person at Twitter involved in this decision?
- defrost 2y agoSeems like weak tea. Musk et al bent over backwards for India and Turkey and suddenly gained principles in Brazil? A Supreme Court Justice who rules on constitional law is fairly definitive, now even more so .. in India and Turkey X-itter sided with the the ruling conservative right wing party in power, in Brazil X-itter sided with the losing conservative right wing party that spread election denial propaganda. There's a clear pattern.
- _heimdall 2y ago> Musk et al bent over backwards for India and Turkey and suddenly gained principles in Brazil? The question isn't what morals the company decides to stand on other than the moral that they will only comply with government requests and court rulings that are legal under that jurisdiction's laws. I don't know details of Turkish or Indian law, but I do generally understand their governments to be more oppressive than the US. It seems plausible that the requests made by those governments were legal there, as opposed to the Brazilian request that Twitter is claiming not to be legal there. Supreme Court justices are in fact fallible. There have been a handful of decisions coming out of SCOTUS that many have been extremely unhappy with to the point of claiming the rulings were unlawful or unconstitutional. Is it impossible that the Brazilian judge made a request/demand and threat that isn't actually lawful?
- kranke155 2y agoApparently Brazil only asked for Twitter/X to have a local office (so they could be dealt with inside Brazilian law) and ban like 7 accounts.
- koolba 2y ago> … and ban like 7 accounts I’m sure that number will never increase.
- marcinzm 2y agoDidn't seem to stop Twitter in India and Turkey.
- anon291 2y agoWhy not just be glad they're taking a stand now? I'm so confused. Edit: also looking at the history here... They fought those bans too. I'm guessing, due to Indias importance to the IT industry, twitter was unable to pull out entirely, leaving their employees vulnerable if they didn't comply. Not sure about turkey, but it looks like in this case, they are able to avoid censorship by pulling out entirely. Brazil is an inconsequential country.
- marcinzm 2y agoThey're not taking a stand. Turkey and India have right wing authoritarian governments that Musk is literal friends with. Brazil does not. I don't want un-elected social media billionaires making political decisions for me.
- anon291 2y agoTwitter isn't a government and doesn't make political decisions. The more pressing issue is governments censoring opposition
- 2y ago
- breadwinner 2y agoNote that Elon Musk's definition of free speech includes anything that is not outright illegal, including fake news, see links below. I find it disturbing. The world will be better off without X. https://www.nytimes.com/2024/07/27/us/politics/elon-musk-kamala-harris-deepfake.html https://www.nytimes.com/2024/07/27/us/politics/elon-musk-kam... https://www.businessinsider.com/elon-musk-grok-ai-fake-election-photos-misinformation-x-twitter-2024-8 https://www.businessinsider.com/elon-musk-grok-ai-fake-elect...
- ein0p 2y agoMainstream media outlets often publish fake news or don’t publish legitimate news that do not support their agenda. I don’t see anyone hyperventilating about that. Would we be better off without them, too? I happen to think that we would.
- ceejayoz 2y ago> Note that Elon Musk's definition of free speech includes anything that is not outright illegal... Unless it's @ElonJet tweeting. Or journalists tweeting about @ElonJet.
- atwrk 2y agoOr you mention gender using "cis": https://imgur.com/gallery/state-of-xitter-2024-kYonTt4 https://imgur.com/gallery/state-of-xitter-2024-kYonTt4 Making this a about about free speech is astounding in multiple ways. First, are people not aware that Brazil is a different sovereign nation, where the US idea of free speech may not apply? And a country with a military dictatorship not many years ago, with laws specifically in place to prevent another coup, which Twitter chose to ignore here?
- rsrsrs86 2y agoThe us idea of free speech doesn’t apply even in the us.
- breadwinner 2y ago
- MBCook 2y agoAnd Madtodon! Here’s a post from Eugen Rochko on August 31st (2 days ago): “Aug 10, 10 sign-ups from #Brazil. Aug 28, 152 sign-ups from Brazil. Today, 4.2k sign-ups from Brazil. Portuguese (Brazil) has already entered the list of top 8 active languages for the last 30 days.” https://mastodon.social/@Gargron/113059113589150365 https://mastodon.social/@Gargron/113059113589150365
- brianolson 2y ago2 million new bsky accounts https://bsky.app/profile/bsky.app/post/3l36zm4e6ee2w https://bsky.app/profile/bsky.app/post/3l36zm4e6ee2w
- dark-star 2y agowhat keeps them from banning bsky too in the coming months?
- ceejayoz 2y agoCompliance with court orders?
- ivewonyoung 2y agoBecause Bsky will censor. They are celebrating X not censoring with all these posts boasting about the numbers.
- TacticalCoder 2y agoIsn't Bluesky (I know nothing about it: heard about it for the first time on HN following the X ban in totalitarian Brazil) decentralized?
- tmottabr 2y agoin theory it is.. but the only site that implement their protocol is bluesky.social
- flykespice 2y agoBy not enabling blatant (harmful) misinformation accounts to proliferate in the platform, just like X/Twitter did. And of course, complying with the law and courts order
- ivewonyoung 2y agoDoes BlueSky have a legal representative in Brazil?
- BadHumans 2y agoI'm not sure I agree with Brazil wanting to compel platforms to ban accounts and I don't agree with fining people who try to access the service and if Elon is to be believed, I really don't agree with threatening Twitter's legal rep with prison. Elon is also a hypocrite having done the exact thing Brazil is asking for with India and Turkey in the past and he clearly has no problem inventing reasons to ban people who he doesn't like. ElonJet, accounts that campaign for Harris, journalist, etc. Everyone in this situation sucks.
- KerrAvon 2y agoIs there a reason to give Elon the benefit of the doubt for anything at this point?
- blastonico 2y agoBluesky is decentralized, it's virtually impossible to ban this thing once it gets enough nodes running around the globe. Not sure if it's better than Twitter for censorship.
- threatofrain 2y agoIt's not exactly impossible to ban since the court is threatening individuals with a $9k daily fine for trying to access via VPN. The court also previously ordered Google & Apple to delete VPN apps off people's phones.
- breadwinner 2y agoMeanwhile Musk has become one of the biggest purveyors of fake news: https://www.cnn.com/politics/live-news/trump-harris-election-09-02-24/index.html#:~:text=Elon%20Musk%20posts%20fake%20image%20of%20Harris%20in%20communist%20uniform https://www.cnn.com/politics/live-news/trump-harris-election...