4 ms·
Big Tech Sees Like a State (2020)
- cjs_ac 2y agoI haven't read Seeing Like a State, but I find the list of legibility criteria to be very interesting, purely because of how many don't apply here in the United Kingdom. > Lives at a particular location, and has an exact address. A person in the UK may live at any natural number of places, including zero. The NHS has specific provisions for providing healthcare to the homeless. At the other end of the spectrum, landowners with property in different parliamentary constituencies were entitled to vote in all of those constituencies until the passage of the Representation of the People Act 1948. > Has a specific name. In the UK, a person has no specific legal name. A person may use any name they wish, including multiple names, without the need for a deed poll or any other legal instrument. > Earns money in a currency which the government understands, and pays taxes in it. The UK has a thriving (although regulated) cryptocurrency sector. Tax policy is a little lax, and it's very easy for someone to live in the UK unbanked and untaxed, which is probably a contributing factor to so many irregular immigrants moving specifically to the UK, rather than remaining in the first 'safe country'. > Was born on a particular date, and can thus be called up for jury duty or conscription. The UK is good at tracking when and where people were born, and to whom, but someone can slip through the cracks of the system if they put a little effort in to avoid service to the state. > Doesn’t steal other people’s goods, trespass on their land, injure them, or kill them. (Except as a result of the aforementioned conscription situation.) Due to reductions in policing budgets, shoplifting is currently rife and, when the value is low, not addressed, but this is a temporary state of affairs. Trespass is generally a civil matter, and is only criminal in specific situations, such as when the trespass is into a home. > Speaks a language intelligible to the government employees who are responsible for checking all of the above. The UK's only official language is Welsh, and Welsh only has that status in Wales. Some legislation is written in Norman French. On the other hand, I grew up in Australia, where that list very much applies, because Australia is a nation that learnt civilisation from prison guards. It's not a bad list - the UK is just a very peculiar place.
- narski 2y ago>shoplifting is currently rife and, when the value is low, not addressed, but this is a temporary state of affairs. Remember though, how often in the history of states, the temporary cannily usurps permanence. It's hard to tell what's a brief deviation from the mean, rather than an early glimpse into the new normal. I have no idea what I'm talking about, either in terms of understanding society nor the UK specifically, but your phrasing tickled my paranoia about that phrase a sort of famous last words for civilizations, lol.
- Onavo 2y agoThen why is the UK still so authoritarian about free speech and insisting on policing online activity?
- actionfromafar 2y agoBecause the UK is very peculiar?
- Onavo 2y agoIndeed, the perennial excuse of every authoritarian; they are "#Not like other countries".
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- patcon 2y agoAh interesting. I'm now colliding this thought with how unnerved I was by the tacit acceptance of very visible elements of the surveillance state in UK. I wonder if the state needed different tactics to make the population legible, and so (without express intention) needed to recruit citizens as more willing participants to reach the functional level of legibility...
- cjs_ac 2y agoIt's well known that about a third of all traffic speed cameras in the UK are decoys; I assume that something similar goes on with CCTV cameras. The British state is administered on the principle of maximum effect for least effort and least cost. The Empire was administered in the same way, although, as Lord North discovered, that principle has limits. The surveillance state is very visible because its primary purpose is deterrence, not solving crime at scale. The population isn't made legible; it's made to think that it's legible. A few years ago, there was a lot of media coverage about 'super recognisers'[0]. This is because CCTV footage has to be reviewed by humans. There's a reality TV series that shows how much human work has to go into turning the information from the surveillance state into actual outcomes on the ground.[1] It's not an everyday thing. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super_recogniser https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super_recogniser [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hunted_(2015_TV_series) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hunted_(2015_TV_series)
- PaulHoule 2y agoFunny the concept of “legibility” is on my mind because I’ve been working on content understanding systems and I quickly came to the conclusion that some content was more legible than other content to the system as opposed to better or worse. (E.g. I hate political image memes because my filters can’t look inside the image easily)
- bawolff 2y agoThis feels like its framed in the wrong way. The much simpler explanation is that both governments and big companies are large groups of people. You need to make simplifying assumptions to make large groups of people work together at scale. That's true of any system at scale. Just consider how people give their servers unique names at small scale and numbers at big scale. Its just how scaling works. Whether that is a good or bad thing is an entirely different question.
- rosecross 2y agoThat’s the whole point, though. The need to make things interpretable from the center is what it means to “see like a state.” A society doesn’t need to be interpretable to exist. Large groups of people can relate to one another peerwise.
- nostrademons 2y agoIsn't that basically what the article is saying? The article is using the vocabulary of sociology, where "legibility" in reference to the state is a well-known concept. The article specifically references Seeing like a state and James Scott's other writings, but he's not the only one to think in terms of such concepts. Foucault's idea of the Panopticon is very similar - it's about the state maintaining control through the citizenry always knowing that they're watched - while Habermas's idea of a "lifeworld" ("metis" in this article) which is "colonized by expert systems" is the same phenomena.
- somat 2y agoFor some reason we think of corporations and governments as different things. but an incorporation is a government, and a government is an incorporation. that is the whole point, that is why a cooperation is formed. A group of people want to run their enterprise under rule of law and this requires a government. this legal entity we call a corporation. it may be a for profit endeavor. it might be a public good physical area monopoly(a town, county, state, country). It might be a for profit physical area monopoly(these were some of the first licensed corporations, but you don't see it much now days). anyway there are many types of corporations. Usually to achieve the desired legal protection a license is acquired from a parent corporation that lets you form the government needed to run the corporation. it's corporations all the way down. At the top level they are peers(nominally) and must guarantee their protection the hard way(armed force). Organized crime is an example of an unlicensed cooperation, there is still a government, but the endeavor is run unlicensed, in rebellion to whatever larger entity claims jurisdiction over the area.
- nostrademons 2y agoOne interesting question is if you can get the benefits of legibility without the very human downsides of corruption, authoritarianism, poor decision-making, and self-dealing that come from having humans at the top of this pyramid of legibility. I work for one of those Big Tech companies, and internally, it is anything but legible. Very consequential decisions are made by a small team that happens to have responsibility for the codebase in question, oftentimes very far down in the org. Culturally at least there is a respect for data and a sincere effort to do the right thing, but when your decisions impact 3 billion people there is no way a human can fully evaluate them. And ironically, a recurring problem for the last 20 years is that the CEO has no idea what's going on within the company. Most records about what's being worked on, why, how far along they are, who's involved, etc. are firmly in the realm of metis, tribal knowledge that's passed down in 1:1s and watercooler conversations. The more I encounter other powerful government bureaucracies (like building codes, local government, zoning, legislation), the more I suspect they work the same way. Somebody at the time it was formalized decided "this is how it should work" on the basis of the best information available at the time, and then once it's formalized, it's virtually impossible to change. I'm interested in crypto not for the "get rich quick" or even the "currency" aspect, but for the prospect of replacing corporations and executives. Crypto's big innovation is in creating a shared reality everybody accepts without a centralized authority to enforce that reality. This is exactly the same efficiency advantage that having a single executive gives. Could you use blockchains to essentially create an "artificial executive", a plan of record that everybody gets behind that doesn't fall prey to human fallibilities?
- ben_w 2y ago> Could you use blockchains to essentially create an "artificial executive", a plan of record that everybody gets behind that doesn't fall prey to human fallibilities? Yes but it will either be a rigid bureaucracy, or subject to manipulation by interested parties, or an inscrutable AI, or some combination of those. It's not like we have good results when trying to write flawless code, that never needs big fixes, and that is so future proof as to never need updates.
- nostrademons 2y ago
- GolfPopper 2y agoEven the most dysfunctional and abusive states can generally manage a deeper vision for the future than the next quarter's management bonuses.
- aussieguy1234 2y agoInstall a good ad/tracker blocker like UBlock Origin on your computers and install a DNS content blocker on your phone like DNS66/Rethink DNS (get them from F-Droid if they've been removed from the Play Store). I have no regrets on robbing the corporate media and user hostile advertising companies of their revenues, while keeping my browsing experience clean and thwarting most trackers. I go a step further and run GrapheneOS instead of normal Android, so not even Google themselves can track me. Google Play Services is running in a sandbox that makes it behave. What were dealing with today is much worse than the old banner ads, these things track your every move online and even track the GPS on your phone.
- mindslight 2y agoI take issue with your characterization as "robbing". The consumer surveillance industry exploits security vulnerabilities in browsers and OSes (including ones they themselves put there), and then leverages the proceeds into minor attacks on users that net a few pennies at a time. Fixing the security vulnerabilities isn't "robbing" these companies, rather it's merely putting things right and preventing them from being able to take what they have been taking. Furthermore, that the surveillance industry has been normalized and even held up as an exemplar of innovation just illustrates the extent of the rot.
- fancl20 2y agoI think https://doi.org/10.1017/9781009159418 https://doi.org/10.1017/9781009159418 has a different framing of the issue. There's a fundamental conflicts between policy implementation and policy effectiveness. If policy is designed locally or at least allowed to be adapted to the local context, it could be more effective but with the possibility of inconsistency; Otherwise the policy is implemented flawlessly but with the cost of effectiveness because of lacking local context. Any attempt of increasing legibility means a policy being implemented consistently across different contexts so everyone can assume the same thing regardless of the context, and, as expected, not able to incorporate the complexity of local social orders.
- NaOH 2y agoPrevious discussion: Big Tech Sees Like a State - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25009130 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25009130 - Nov 2020 (14 comments)