3 ms·
That is medical misinformation. It is totally irrational for most people to be frightened of misdiagnosis. The diagnostic criteria for the most common chronic d
by nradov 2y ago
That is medical misinformation. It is totally irrational for most people to be frightened of misdiagnosis. The diagnostic criteria for the most common chronic diseases such as diabetes, heart failure, obesity, arthritis, hearing loss, and depression are reliable and straightforward. Misdiagnosis is only a serious concern for more rare conditions or atypical presentations.
Occasional misdiagnoses do occur but let's not contribute to hypochondria by exaggerating the problem.
- mapt 2y agoThe medical field has identified around 10,000 "rare diseases" that are estimated to affect fewer than 200,000 Americans each. On net, 10% of the population is estimated to be afflicted by a rare disease, with rampant underdiagnosis. It's less "misdiagnosis" in that the picture is being identified clearly as something other than what it is, but that few doctors have the entire picture, recognize it as one unified syndrome, and recall the title of that syndrome. The mind also loses most information that goes unused, so a disorder that a doctor only encounters once per every thousand years of practice would need a great deal of luck to be recognized, especially by someone who isn't just out of med school. Even something seen only every hundred years or every ten years of practice is usually missed. There are lots of zebras out there that we're calling horses. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK56184/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK56184/ > To have a rare disease is often to have a condition that goes undiagnosed for years while concerned physicians who have never seen the condition before may offer one diagnosis and then search for another when new or advancing symptoms belie the original diagnosis. Once accurately diagnosed, patients with rare conditions may be treated by physicians who have little evidence or guidance to help them—physicians who may experience the frustration imagined by the patient quoted above. Particularly when a condition is extremely rare, patients and families frequently have to travel long distances to consult with the few experts who have experience in treating and studying their rare diseases; patients and their families may even relocate to make access easier. Although the features of specific rare diseases can differ in myriad ways, the effects on life and functioning are often similar and are emotionally and financially devastating for the affected individuals and their families. Patients and family members may feel isolated and alone as they face the challenges of finding helpful information, learning a new medical language, and generally charting their way in a daunting new world. > As described in Chapter 1, some rare conditions are extremely rare, found in only a few or a few dozen people. Others occur in hundreds, thousands, or as many as 200,000 people in the United States. Many are genetic in origin or have a genetic component. Others arise from exposure to infections or toxins, from faulty immune responses, or occasionally from adverse responses to therapeutic interventions for other conditions. For many rare conditions, the causes are frustratingly elusive. > Although people may think of a rare disease as something that happens to someone else, rare diseases can afflict anyone, at any age. They can be acute or chronic. Many are debilitating and present an ongoing risk of death. Some are inevitably fatal given current medical options. Approved therapies are available to treat several hundred of these conditions, but most currently have no therapy that cures or modifies the disease itself. One of the things that various AI expert systems would be great at compared to human doctors, is recognizing the possibility of rare diseases based on abundant data (or full body scans, for that matter) and proactively testing hypotheses. But... well... the only people with access to that data, the insurance companies, are strongly incentivized not to.
- pjc50 2y agoNot in that list, really prevalent (approximately 10% of women!), and frequently mis- or not-diagnosed: Endometriosis.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Paul-Craft 2y agoThe question we should be asking isn't how easy is it to diagnose the X most common conditions. The question should be given someone goes to a doctor, what's the probability that their condition will be misdiagnosed. And further, what is the lifetime probability that someone will be misdiagnosed? Those numbers, I would wager, are significantly higher than the probability that anyone will be misdiagnosed with diabeetes, heart failure, obesity, arthritis, or hearing loss. Note, however, I've left off depression. This one actually does get missed somewhat frequently by primary physicians, in part because they don't think to screen for it, or they don't screen for it at an initial visit. Primary specialists tend to look for physical conditions first before moving on to mental health conditions. Continuing with the article's theme about women being misdiagnosed frequently, here's an abstract that notes depression in female patients being misdiagnosed at a rate of 30-50%: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0277953696001591 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S02779.... So lets keep in mind that reliability of diagnosis of individual conditions, however common they may be, may have relatively little to do with the overall lifetime probability that someone will be misdiagnosed at some point in their life. Edit: Some even more shocking mental health misdiagnosis statistics from https://justpoint.com/knowledge-base/everything-you-need-to-know-about-mental-health-misdiagnosis/ https://justpoint.com/knowledge-base/everything-you-need-to-... > Misdiagnosis rates for major depressive disorders were at 65.9%, > Misdiagnosis for Bipolar disorders was at 92.7 percent, Panic disorder was at 85.8%, generalized anxiety disorder was 71.0 percent, and > Social anxiety disorder was 97.8%. Given that 1 out of 2 people will develop a diagnosable mental health issue in their lifetime according to https://hms.harvard.edu/news/half-worlds-population-will-experience-mental-health-disorder https://hms.harvard.edu/news/half-worlds-population-will-exp... this suggests a fairly high rate of overall misdiagnosis.
- nradov 2y agoDepression screening is a standard HEDIS clinical quality measure. Some providers might still skip it and some patients slip through the cracks, but overall most patients who are receiving regular ongoing care do get occasionally screened for depression. Of course patients who never go in for an appointment don't get screened. There's certainly a gap with people who lack access to care or don't seek it out.
- y-c-o-m-b 2y agoThis comment is so out of touch with the reality of the current medical system that I think you're in for a very rude awakening in the future. I can go on for days about all the stories I have to counteract this point. Even doctors themselves are feeling the diagnostic failure issues. My child's pediatrician went into the ER and said "I think my appendix is about to burst". They thought she was just being dramatic and they wanted to discharge her with Zofran and tell her to come back if it got worse. After hours of arguing with the ER doctors and nurses, she convinced them to do imaging. Boom, appendix about to burst. She had an operation 2 hours later.
- nradov 2y agoI'm actually pretty in touch with the reality of the current medical system. There are plenty of stories about diagnostic failures but what does the data show? The vast majority of patients are diagnosed correctly, or misdiagnosed in a way that doesn't significantly impact outcomes. I think a lot of technologists have unrealistic expectations about healthcare. The reality is that most of it is still more art than science, and outcomes vary based on the skills of individuals in ways that usually impossible to accurately quantify. Anything involving biology is kind of squishy and uncertain. We should try to improve the state of clinical practice but we should also be thankful for how much it has already improved just within our lifetimes.
- mapt 2y agoWhat data? Are you proposing that there is a reliable way to adjudicate ongoing misdiagnoses for rare or even common illnesses? It seems like the only ones likely to have any investigation are those that end up being lethal in the short term.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]