6 ms·
Dexcom starts selling its new over-the-counter glucose monitor in the U.S.
- bookofjoe 2y agohttps://archive.ph/n1eNl https://archive.ph/n1eNl
- vineyardmike 2y agoI'm wearing one now, bought it when it came out, because I love fitness trackers and the "Quantified Self" idea. Not convinced it's really going to change much, probably won't repurchase. That said, it is great to see costs and accessibility drop to the point that over-the-counter purchases are feasible (~100USD/mo). It's pretty cool, completely painless to implant (didn't even realize it went in), but made my arm surprisingly sore for a few day. I don't think the science of interpreting glucose levels is clear and deterministic enough to find actionable insight from the data unless you're generally concerned about being pre-diabetic. Seeing a glucose spike isn't bad, and not seeing a spike isn't bad. If you're not diabetic or pre-diabetic, your body will adjust and maintain homeostasis, so the data isn't particularly actionable. Oh and the packaging has a TON of waste. Each sensor comes with a single-use applicator which a prescription user would re-use for months. PS - I’d love to see better and more accessible monitors or testers for things that your body can’t self regulate as easily, like cholesterol levels.
- janice1999 2y agoDo you worry that such data (not actionable or easy to interpret) is actually a net negative? The nocebo effect [1] is very real in my experience. I now leave it to a doctor to tell me the important side-effects of medication and forbid myself from Googling it further for example. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nocebo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nocebo
- vineyardmike 2y agoNot at all (it's a fair question). I think the idea of deferring exclusively to a doctor is wrong (for me at least). People wear fitness trackers to count their steps without damaging their exercise goals, and I view other medical testing similarly. First, I'm not "undergoing treatment" so I don't think my negative perceptions would cause anything to have a worse efficacy (which is my understanding of "nocebo"). Second, I think that measurement is ok (great even) as long as you have correct expectations. Doctors will often say that you shouldn't get tests unless undergoing a differential diagnosis from a doctor, because tests all have ranges, and slightly off results can freak out patients who are otherwise healthy. Frankly, I assume it's actually a cost/effort thing. I disagree because (1) you have to wait until something is wrong before getting a test and (2) its would good to have a baseline level of <thing> for when something goes wrong to avoid red-herrings. If you have a mole or lump, a doctor would not recommend you undergoing surgery, or even get an invasive biopsy unless it's really scary looking at start. Many/Most are benign. BUT a doctor generally would suggest you watch it regularly in case it changes. Clearly monitoring benign-looking things is good, because it can become less benign or it can be a symptom of something dangerous. Concretely, I'm a very healthy and active individual, but also a vegetarian. Vegetarian diets can easily be vitamin deficient, so I get tested. Doctors generally don't want to test me because I "clearly look healthy and don't have symptoms of deficiency". But I was absolutely deficient for years, and while I felt fine, supplementing for my deficiency showed me I could feel better than before.
- janice1999 2y agoThanks for the response. I do think there is a big difference between routine checks of a mole and daily quantifying of a biometric signal that is of questionable use outside elite sports or specific illnesses. My point about nocebos is that people can take data, knowledge of potential side-effects for example, and cause themselves ill effects by worrying about them. I can easily imagine some of my friends checking their perfectly healthy but noisy glucose levels and worrying that there is something wrong. I guess it's about mindset (mostly curiosity?) for self-quantifiers.
- vineyardmike 2y ago
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoI have heard that these glucose monitors are very inaccurate compared to blood tests - like as much as 25% off when measuring levels after meals. What has been your experience?
- vineyardmike 2y agoI don't have diabetes, so I'm not regularly comparing it to alternatives, so I can't comment on my personal accuracy against clinic measurements. Which is obviously a nice privilege to ignore for "hobby" usage. A huge portion of glucose management (even for diabetics) is the actual trend of the data vs the actual blood glucose levels. These CGMs capture trends correctly, even if the absolute value is off. A prescription variant would have periodic calibrations as an option. If you eat a meal that spikes blood glucose level, the CGM probably won't smooth out a peak, so you'd still see the magnitude of the effect. The other thing to consider is that when read from the arm or a "fleshy" bit, a change in glucose level is about 20min delayed from blood levels. The healthy range for a non-diabetic is ~70-140 mg/dL, and your body regularly can swing up more than +50mg/dL after a meal. This is a pretty big range and swing, and being 15% off (in either direction) is not particularly problematic. Your bodily response to the same meal can vary more than 25%. One test I did do is consume "glucose tablets" (which are basically candy), they're products meant to spike your blood sugar (for diabetics who get "low"), and all you can predict is that my levels go "up fast". Again, all that matters is the trend, especially if your body can self-regulate. The FDA does study how accurate these products are, and they conform to certain expectations. That said, you're not wrong that it can be 25% off sometimes. According to a study (linked below), ~99% of the time, the device is within 30% of clinical test levels, and about 90% of the time, the device is within 15%. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35157505/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35157505/
- worstspotgain 2y ago> PS - I’d love to see better and more accessible monitors or testers for things that your body can’t self regulate as easily, like cholesterol levels. Not sure if this overlaps with your interest, but you can now self-order tests from mainstream labs. e.g. [1]. Personally I think this cuts into the attractiveness of single-purpose devices. You can order a whole bunch of tests with one blood draw, and selectively only repurchase those that need monitoring over time. You're also likely getting higher-quality data in both the average and worst cases. [1] https://www.questhealth.com/product/cholesterol-lipid-panel-94355M.html https://www.questhealth.com/product/cholesterol-lipid-panel-...
- bradlys 2y agoYou cannot do this in certain states like NJ and NY. You will need an MD to order the tests. Same with other things like ordering insulin syringes or whatnot. Means I have to buy stuff from out of state or fly out of state to do my bloodwork. Same issue as before. The medical establishment always trying to find a way to get a cut on everything when it’s entirely unnecessary.
- worstspotgain 2y agoQuest excludes AZ, AK and HI, but it does include NY and NJ.
- vineyardmike 2y agoYou should be able to do this in NY - but I think the phlebotomist has to go to your house. I know people in NYC who get at-home blood work. Your situation may be different, but maybe the laws changed and you should check again if you care.
- vineyardmike 2y agoYes! I've actually done this (several companies offer this service now). I think this is great if you have a family pre-disposition to something, or want to regularly check for a specific issue. It's also great because many doctors are hesitant to provide blood tests without a diagnosis. I don't think it has the same use cases as at-home monitoring devices though. To use the example of cholesterol, you can be morbidly, dangerously high in your LDL levels, where doctors will put you on medication that day and warn you to basically stop eating. But you can also just have levels that are high - but where lifestyle change alone is effective. Ideally, you'd want to be able to reflect daily/weekly and adapt. The tighter that feedback loop, the better. Quest charges $70 for a cholesterol panel, which for many, is too high for a regular purchase to build a positive feedback loop. Its probably in the "purchase quarterly" and maybe "monthly" range, but I doubt many would be able or willing to go weekly.
- umvi 2y agoI hate that doctors are gatekeepers of so many things. Why should a small computer that measures blood sugar be gated behind a doctor in the first place? The only reason I can think of is: supply is short and they need to be preserved for diabetics. But if supply is not short, why should I need to go through a gatekeeper to measure my own biometrics? Same with glasses. If I want to buy a pair of glasses with arbitrary optical properties, why shouldn't I be able to? Seems like the medical world is sometimes a bit too paternalistic, probably to keep themselves cemented as middle men, like a car dealer preventing consumers from buying directly from source. To be fair, certain things are dangerous and probably should be gated behind a doctor for safety reasons, but sometimes I think Rx fever gets a bit out of hand.
- phoronixrly 2y agoIt's to protect people like you (and in fact many on HN) from themselves (and their incompetence). I don't expect you to understand, but self-diagnosing and self-medicating is not safe for you when you don't have the credentials.
- throwadobe 2y agoBecause doctors never misdiagnose or prescribe wrong medications... I'd rather make my own choices, thank you very much.
- rqtwteye 2y ago"I don't expect you to understand, but self-diagnosing and self-medicating is not safe for you when you don't have the credentials." This is extremely condescending and also very profitable for the medical industry. On the one hand we have a wild west market where hospitals, pharmaceuticals and doctors can see all data and charge whatever prices they feel like. For the patient it's a market where we aren't even allowed to collect data about ourselves, aren't allowed to import drugs that are approved and safe somewhere else and with many treatments we won't even get an price before it's done. But we have to pay. Talk about asymmetry! Speaking of self diagnosing: I went to several doctors about my joint pain and chronic headaches. they all wanted to describe steroids, anti inflammatories and whatever. Turns out if I reduce sugar, I am totally fine. I came up with that after reading some literature and testing on myself. None of the doctors mentioned this for the hundreds of dollars in deductible and copay this cost me. Self diagnosis works. I know there are limits to this but many of us can read the medical literature as well as doctors and draw our own conclusions.
- Cupprum 2y agoI once spoke to Scott Hanselman [1] on a conference. He is diabetic and also makes talks about IT and diabetes. I liked one point he made: people without diabetes should not buy these products, as it only brings the prices up, meaning that not everyone by can afford them. Edit: forgot to specify link. 1: https://www.hanselman.com/ https://www.hanselman.com/
- OutOfHere 2y agoIt is complete nonsense. In fact, it is scale that drives competition, and it is competition that brings prices down. Moreover, the product models for diabetics are different.
- elihu 2y agoCompetition is usually good for bringing prices down (basically discouraging price-gouging by the manufacturer), but scale in itself can bring costs down too. The manufacturer has to amortize their development and regulatory approval costs across devices sold. Or you could say that competition reduces the price ceiling, whereas scale reduces the price floor.
- kakoni 2y agoAnd is this usable for Person with T1d? Seems So, https://www.diabettech.com/cgm/dexcoms-stelo-by-numbers-could-a-15-day-g7-be-imminent/ https://www.diabettech.com/cgm/dexcoms-stelo-by-numbers-coul...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- vineyardmike 2y agoYou should not use this if you have Type-1 diabetes. It's (supposedly) not cleared to the same FDA standards, and if you tell the app you're diabetic, it locks you out from using this. I'm under the impression the Stelo (OTC version) is the same as the G7 (prescription version) with a different logo and box. I think the only practical difference is that this version has a longer lifespan (15 vs <10 days), and that it's not configured to actually alarm when it detects something dangerous. I'm not sure if any science showed the last 5 days have reduced accuracy, but I wouldn't risk my health on it if there were alternatives available. If you have T1d, you've been able to get the prescription-variant of this product for years with insurance, so there really is no reason to get this unless you're un-insured.
- medimikka 2y agoThe lack of a hypo alarm is the reason the Stelo is not past FDA, yet. Luckily, there's xDrip4iOS and xDrip++, not to mention Suggah and others, who will happily do the alarming part for you. Not to mention, that to many of us T1D, the CGM is just a secondary data point for our loop, which has a CGM already built in.
- kakoni 2y agoI beliebe xdrip is not (yet) steel compatible. Also interesting to see if this thing really sends data only every 15mins or is it done in the app. 15min is way too much for looping.
- brayhite 2y ago
- OutOfHere 2y agoThere is a theme of extreme gatekeeping in several comments for this article. In fact, such gatekeeping is a common experience in healthcare. The strong conflict of interest is obvious. Don't let it stop you from taking power in your own hands.
- Oarch 2y agoI bought and used this new one during August for £35. The connection to Apple Health worked well and I used a glucose monitor app (MyLevels) without any issues.
- OutOfHere 2y agoFor non-diabetics, I strongly encourage measuring HbA1c instead of glucose. It will tell you all you need to know in this regard, at a cheaper price too, at home, and without the need for fasting. Optimizing HbA1c will for most people indirectly automatically optimize glucose. Keep it below the prediabetic range.
- voisin 2y agoHow do you test this “at home”?
- firesteelrain 2y agoCVS sells a kit. Results in 5 mins. My wife uses it
- OutOfHere 2y agoIf you go to Amazon and search for "a1c test" (by pts Diagnostics), the pack of twenty is cheapest per test. You will also need a pack of disposable lancets, a finger lancing device. You will also optionally alcohol swab to sanitize your finger without contaminating it, but soap and water work too. Remember to shake it well when testing, otherwise the result is an error. Always discard the lancet after use. You need to test only once every 1-3 months. Refrigerate everything, but let it warm to room temperature before testing. If I remember correctly, the result number is like an exponential moving average over about three months. If you're in the prediabetic range, things like avoiding high-AGE foods, processed carbs, and red meat should help bring it down, as should consuming ceylon cinnamon, flaxseed, and berberine. Of course cardio also will easily bring it down. Every factor contributes in the ballpark of 0.1, so one needs a lot of changes to gradually bring it down into an optimal zone.
- wl 2y agoIf you’re worried about developing type II diabetes, yes, A1C is probably as much data you need. However, there are plenty of other reasons to want to measure blood glucose. Just one example I see: Endurance athletes already use these off-label to keep an eye on fueling.
- 2y ago
- firesteelrain 2y agoI am not entirely clear what changed in the CGM device or FDA guidelines. Though I am happy to see an OTC of this now approved. If we could do the same for CPAP then that would be another step in the right direction.
- dexcomyech 2y agoCan anyone here verify that Dexcom has updated their iPhone app to cease collecting customer metadata? As recently as three months ago, Dexcom's G7 app made hundreds of daily connections both to dexcom's own servers and third party metrics servers. Note that this was the case regardless of whether you opted out of their online services (like sharing). I checked my firewall logs before I posted this comment, and suddenly I no longer see these queries. Since I have two years history of monitoring and blocking similar Dexcom traffic, it's hard for me to believe they actually stopped. I would welcome stronger laws to stop this sort of behavior. I'm essentially a captive audience to a maker of expensive medical gear, and it's a lousy feeling to have them slurping up data about me every time I check my blood sugar.
- dexcomyech 2y ago...and the skepticism was justified. Today I see hundreds of attempts in my logs to connect to: • shareous1.dexcom.com • *.dexcom.siteintercept.qualtrics.com ...and many, many others. Dexcom: slurping up patient data because hey they can.
- bankcust08385 2y agoCBGM is important for the category of type-1 diabetics who also have dysregulation of increasing blood glucose sufficiently and carry a rescue glucagon autoinjector.