7 ms·
The Case for Hypochondria
- PaulHoule 2y agoWhat I observe is people who build a whole identity around illness and disability, I wonder sometimes if my town (or maybe myself) attracts this sort of person. This kind of person probably has a real disease to some extent but sure as hell they are depressed by the DSM definition and have given up on life. Contrast that to other people, like a blind student who climbed a 12,000 foot mountain with the search and rescue club and was in the group that reached the summit fastest.
- Loughla 2y agoI have noticed that sometime in the last decade the message of "it's okay to have a disability" has kind of morphed into, "it's okay to not be a functioning member of society because of your disability". Maybe it's just because I'm getting older, but I do see less resilience in college students today versus the start of my career.
- exitb 2y agoIt seems like a much broader issue than disability. A general approach to difficulty switched from attempting to overcome, to acknowledging and accepting. That being said, this sounds suspiciously similar to what every older generation would say about every younger generation. I wonder if there's any data to back this up.
- Der_Einzige 2y agoWe have lots of data showing that the kids really are different than their parents in a way never before seen in history You know it’s bad when public health officials are like: “hmm, the kids aren’t having sex, drinking, doing drugs (except vaping), or commuting vandelism/violence - but their mental health has cratered and they just sit at home playing fortnight or watching cat videos. Seriously, public health officials think that the kids are literally too good, too prude, and too tuned out. Maybe they’re right…
- lawlessone 2y ago>You know it’s bad when public health officials are like: “hmm, the kids aren’t having sex, drinking, doing drugs (except vaping), or commuting vandelism/violence - but their mental health has cratered and they just sit at home playing fortnight or watching cat videos. Well most of those things are expensive. Bedrotting to cat videos is free. Smoking has always been an issue.
- badwolf 2y agoI'd also point to a lack of third spaces for everyone from kids to elderly folks. Parents wait in a line of cars to drop their kids off at school, then pick them up in the same line of cars to drive them home. Maybe replacing malls and diners with social media and fortnite isn't the best thing we could be doing.
- Der_Einzige 2y agoAsia is full of third places and has even worse issues than we do with these social problems. They are not the solution
- Paul-Craft 2y agoWhat exactly is "wrong" with not being a "functioning member of society" because of a disability?
- smeej 2y agoI don't think it's a problem when it's real, but for a long time, people with a variety of disabilities have been fighting to find ways they can contribute to society, not using it as an excuse not to have to. I don't have data on it, but there does feel like there's been a cultural shift to seeking exemption from the expectation that one contributes to society to the extent that one is able. I think what the strivers have noticed is that there's an inherent dignity that accompanies contributing what you can. People have compassion for people who are making efforts despite their challenges. But if there's a cultural shift away from expecting an attempt to contribute, people who would otherwise want to get the message that it's not worth it to provide them the support they would need. People would rather just subsidize their lives entirely than take on the more complicated task of helping them work, even when the work does end up net-positive after the help.
- Paul-Craft 2y agoLet me shoot back with another cultural phenomenon: there's been article upon article over the past couple of years especially about how young people just plain have it rougher than their parents did starting out. Suppose this is true. Isn't it then individually rational to pursue some strategy other than working as hard as possible?
- smeej 2y agoNo. And no, to the extent that I can't even figure out how you're thinking it might be? "It's harder now, so I shouldn't try" is a complete non sequitur. If it's harder now, we have to work harder, not less hard. The only way I can come up with to try to bring rationality into your framing requires adding some other premise, like, "and I don't want the things previous generations had," but that's a giant change to the way you framed it.
- 2y ago
- parpfish 2y agoI think this has a few big social components to it. - If you find yourself surrounded by a community that’s unsupportive, making disability a part of your identity could be an attempt to extract what you need from a community that’s unwilling to give it - If you develop unrealistic standards or expectations, you might reason that “I can’t do $hard_thing is $self_diagnosis” and not “actually, everyone struggles to do $hard_thing”
- bob1029 2y ago> I wonder sometimes if my town (or maybe myself) attracts this sort of person No. They're everywhere now. It's not just you. Over time it has grown to feel like people without some kind of serious health issue are the odd ones out. Right now, ~50% of the US is actively taking at least one prescription drug.
- PaulHoule 2y agoRoughly 73% are overweight or obese, a bit more than 50% have a "chronic condition" although that is often something controllable like hypertension or high cholesterol.
- candiddevmike 2y agoI think panic attacks can trigger life long hypochondria, especially really traumatic ones. I also think for a lot of folks (myself included) it's anxiety over healthcare. I get freaked out that something is wrong, but I get more freaked out that the healthcare system won't be able to fix it in time/appropriately/cost effectively way. In the US, a lot of folks have WebMD syndrome because it's cheaper than going to their doctor.
- FollowingTheDao 2y agoPanic attacks are a health problem. If hypochondria arises out of panic attacks then hypochondria is a health problem as well (that the US healthcare system can also ignore).
- kayo_20211030 2y ago> WebMD syndrome That is absolutely a thing.
- elric 2y agoI had untreated sleep apnea for years, which presented in two ways: snoring, and something that looked an awful lot like panic attacks. Every doctor I saw kept insisting that everything was fine, everything was healthy, every test came back clean, brain MRIs and epilepsy screening, chest x-rays, and more cardiologist exams than I care to remember. Sleep apnea is super common, but no one thought to look for it because I was thin. At one point, some idiot doctor threw the phrase "Could be MS.." at me. That lingered in the back of my mind for years. I've worked in hospitals, I know my way around the system, I'm pretty intelligent, and I usually have my shit together. But that whole experience left some scars, and I'm a lot less mentally robust against illness than I used to be.
- FollowingTheDao 2y agoThe doctors thought I was a hypochondriac. But the truth was they could not yet see what was wrong with me.
- Cthulhu_ 2y agoMedical malpractice and / or mysoginy is another common problem unfortunately; afflctions like endometriosis take years to be taken seriously and diagnosed, instead of brushed away.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoYes! Women are constantly ignored on conditions like this. It’s infuriating when you realize all the recurring regular gynecology visits are basically performative.
- Der_Einzige 2y ago[flagged]
- FollowingTheDao 2y agoOnce you are diagnosed with a psychiatric issue, everything else you complain to the doctor about is hypochondria. As a male with a serious mood disorder, I feel your pain.
- jamesdubs 2y ago[dead]
- zabzonk 2y agois there an inverse for hypochondria? and if so, how would it manifest?
- delichon 2y agohttps://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Ni0YfrSK570 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Ni0YfrSK570
- bjornsing 2y agoMy parents were both medical doctors. They were extremely concerned about hypochondria, to the point where it was essentially forbidden to think about one’s own body or health. To me that’s just as unhealthy as hypochondria, and in a sense its inverse.
- zabzonk 2y agonever diagnose family members, i had a friend who had a mild attack of polio as a kid, and his medic dad just ignored all the first symptoms because he couldn't accept them.
- kayo_20211030 2y agoIs such a prohibition really that unhealthy? If the only result of a consideration of one's own health is anxiety inducing and lacks a path to a diagnosis and treatment, is it worth doing? Of course, _some_ self-awareness is crucial. But, it's a balance between concern and obsession. The former is sensible and the latter borders on the pathological. If something is identifiably wrong, there is something to be done; and that's reassuring, at least. If nothing is identifiably wrong, but only suspected, reasonably or otherwise, there's nothing to be done apart from testing the next hypothesis; that's a very anxious time for the sufferer. At some point, one must decide to stop worrying about what's not known and can't be addressed.
- PaulKeeble 2y agoThe rate of misdiagnosis in the medical field is genuinely frightening. Its not uncommon for chronically ill people to need 20 to hundreds of appointments to get a diagnosis for the disease they clearly have. Worse I think is all the "hysteria" and "hypochondria" misdiagnoses along the way that extend how long it takes to get the diagnosis and causes denial of treatment by other clinicians. This stuff has a very long history and I can't tell they exist or not what I can say is that doctors miss the real condition all the time. For chronic illness the actual appointment to diagnosis rate is less than 5%, that is an enormous waste of everyones time and money and its made worse by the fact it comes along with a bad diagnosis that dismisses the patient. This is a much bigger problem than investigating someone who thinks they are ill and actually isn't.
- nradov 2y agoThat is medical misinformation. It is totally irrational for most people to be frightened of misdiagnosis. The diagnostic criteria for the most common chronic diseases such as diabetes, heart failure, obesity, arthritis, hearing loss, and depression are reliable and straightforward. Misdiagnosis is only a serious concern for more rare conditions or atypical presentations. Occasional misdiagnoses do occur but let's not contribute to hypochondria by exaggerating the problem.
- mapt 2y agoThe medical field has identified around 10,000 "rare diseases" that are estimated to affect fewer than 200,000 Americans each. On net, 10% of the population is estimated to be afflicted by a rare disease, with rampant underdiagnosis. It's less "misdiagnosis" in that the picture is being identified clearly as something other than what it is, but that few doctors have the entire picture, recognize it as one unified syndrome, and recall the title of that syndrome. The mind also loses most information that goes unused, so a disorder that a doctor only encounters once per every thousand years of practice would need a great deal of luck to be recognized, especially by someone who isn't just out of med school. Even something seen only every hundred years or every ten years of practice is usually missed. There are lots of zebras out there that we're calling horses. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK56184/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK56184/ > To have a rare disease is often to have a condition that goes undiagnosed for years while concerned physicians who have never seen the condition before may offer one diagnosis and then search for another when new or advancing symptoms belie the original diagnosis. Once accurately diagnosed, patients with rare conditions may be treated by physicians who have little evidence or guidance to help them—physicians who may experience the frustration imagined by the patient quoted above. Particularly when a condition is extremely rare, patients and families frequently have to travel long distances to consult with the few experts who have experience in treating and studying their rare diseases; patients and their families may even relocate to make access easier. Although the features of specific rare diseases can differ in myriad ways, the effects on life and functioning are often similar and are emotionally and financially devastating for the affected individuals and their families. Patients and family members may feel isolated and alone as they face the challenges of finding helpful information, learning a new medical language, and generally charting their way in a daunting new world. > As described in Chapter 1, some rare conditions are extremely rare, found in only a few or a few dozen people. Others occur in hundreds, thousands, or as many as 200,000 people in the United States. Many are genetic in origin or have a genetic component. Others arise from exposure to infections or toxins, from faulty immune responses, or occasionally from adverse responses to therapeutic interventions for other conditions. For many rare conditions, the causes are frustratingly elusive. > Although people may think of a rare disease as something that happens to someone else, rare diseases can afflict anyone, at any age. They can be acute or chronic. Many are debilitating and present an ongoing risk of death. Some are inevitably fatal given current medical options. Approved therapies are available to treat several hundred of these conditions, but most currently have no therapy that cures or modifies the disease itself. One of the things that various AI expert systems would be great at compared to human doctors, is recognizing the possibility of rare diseases based on abundant data (or full body scans, for that matter) and proactively testing hypotheses. But... well... the only people with access to that data, the insurance companies, are strongly incentivized not to.
- swayvil 2y ago[flagged]
- Cthulhu_ 2y agoThe fact you reduce transgender people to "a man dressed up as a woman" already tells me that you don't have any respect for them to begin with; why turn it around and claim they're the ones demanding it? Respect should be the default, not demanded (by them) or earned (by conforming to your ideas).
- swayvil 2y ago[flagged]
- dang 2y agoCould you please stop posting unsubstantive comments and flamebait? You've unfortunately been doing it repeatedly. It destroys what this site is for, and we have to ban accounts that keep doing it. If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful.
- lubujackson 2y agoNot to mention those women that wear pants instead of dresses, or men that don't play baseball or wear pink shirts... But seriously, recognize that "crazy" has always been a catch-all dismissal of people you'd rather not bother understanding. And if you think crazy means anyone that doesn't follow societal norms, that says a lot about you and very little about anyone else.
- steveBK123 2y agoI think a lot of hypochondria & WebMD hysteria is a poor grasp of probabilities. You can also blame this on WebMD type sites not really calling out probabilities and even in many cases, doctors poorly communicating probabilities. A lot of people for example might google "my eye hurts" and leap to "possible nerve issue that can lead to blindness!!" when really the probability cascade is something like (I AM MAKING THESE UP) - 40% sinuses, 40% stye, 10% some sort of abrasion, 5% some sort of infection, and sub-1% probabilities of a bunch of stuff that's actually serious. Different people experience different maladies at different frequencies as well. The first time you experience something can be scary, even if its a routine non-threatening issue with easy treatment.
- edgyquant 2y agoProbabilities are not physical laws of the universe. A disease having a 0.01% chance in no way is an actual measure of you having or not. If everyone with cancer wrote it off based on probability many more people would go undiagnosed
- steveBK123 2y agoI guess I should go further and suggest actually exposing conditional probabilities & flow charts, which is essentially how a lot of GPs triage diagnosis. If you have these additional symptoms, it rules out X, and conditional probabilities are now Z.. If you tried a warm compress/ibuprofen then it rules out Y and your now looking at these probabilities. Etc. Right now you google stuff and get a WebMD page with a list of stuff varying from "its nothing" to "its cancer" without a lot of color ..
- Paul-Craft 2y agoI agree with this. I do google symptoms myself on occasion, but I always try to make sure that what I see online reflects what's actually going on with me to the extent possible, and I don't freak out when one of the possibilities ends up being, for instance, "cancer," because it's relatively unlikely that I have cancer, and a lot of things end up being symptoms of various cancers. Here's a great example: I had some weird calluses show up on the very sides of my thumb pads and on the ventral aspect of the first phalangeal joint of each of my index fingers. The areas in which these calluses showed up was exactly mirrored on each hand. I googled a little bit and found a whole lot of nothing, but I did find a reference to calluses and esophageal cancer. I clearly do not have esophageal cancer. I have none of the symptoms so it's just a wildly improbable diagnosis. What I did was show them to a friend of mine who's a family med doctor. I have an agreement with all my doctor friends that I will not ask them personal medical questions beyond "hey, is this weird and should I go see someone about it?" My friend said those were extremely weird places to have calluses given that they weren't the result of some activity I'd recently taken up using my hands (and they weren't). Eventually, I ended up in a dermatologist's office where they diagnosed hyperkeratotic hand eczema. Given I have asthma, allergies, and I've had eczema issues in the past, that's a reasonable diagnosis. And when I went to a doctor, I didn't say "I googled this and these things came up." I said "I have these weird calluses. I don't know why they're there because I haven't started any new activities recently so I'm a little concerned about them."
- smeej 2y agoI'm in this fun loop right now where I have an undiagnosed small mass. Everyone agrees the best way to diagnose it would be with an MRI, but no one knows which kind of specialist to have order the MRI or what kind of MRI to order...because we don't know what kind of mass it is. We know it's near a few things, like my lungs and my spine, but it's apparently not connected to them ("apparently" in reference to the cardiac MRI that picked it up incidentally). Everyone who has seen it (original MRI reader, cardiologist) is defaulting to "PCP should order," but PCP doesn't know what to order. Meanwhile I'm sitting here saying it's asymptomatic, very small, "nonaggressive," "well-circumscribed," and incidentally discovered. Can't we just ignore it? We'd never have known about it but for this unrelated test. But no. Everyone agrees we oughtn't do that. They just don't know what we ought to do instead. The system is hard enough to navigate when you're brighter than average and generally well. I have no idea how they expect people to do it when they're ill and have no idea how to read medical research. ETA: I'm only in this situation subsequent to my sister's idiopathic sudden cardiac death. Medical examiner's report recommended any siblings or offspring be screened for heritable cardiac channelopathies. She had been called a hypochondriac from the time she was 12 until she died suddenly at 29 and surprised the heck out of everybody.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- OfficialTurkey 2y agoI'm sorry for your loss. May her memory be a blessing.
- smeej 2y agoThank you. It really has been.
- paulsutter 2y agoPlease just go get a scan somewhere honest (not the US). You might want scans at regular intervals to see if it’s stable, growing, etc, discuss with multiple doctors In your case nobody in the US system wants the liability of saying you can keep it under observation for a while, and insurance doesn’t want to pay for any more scans. In Japan I got a shoulder MRI for $300 with an appointment available the next day. For $75 more I sat down with the radiologist who showed me the scan and talked me through it. You can probably get them cheaper in Mexico, just as fast, with similar quality if you do a little searching US healthcare is literally a scam. At Swedish Cherry Hill a doctor sent me down to the emergency room for a scan which cost me $8000. I got numerous bills from different parties, plus I was trapped in that room for eight hours under vague threats of legal consequences if I left, while they ran up the tab.
- AStonesThrow 2y agoHypochondria snuck up on me (it's called "Somatic Symptom Disorder" now and it's not something that gets openly diagnosed, in my experience.) I had definitely flawed perceptions of physicians and health care in general. I viewed a doctor as someone who'd help you heal if you came in with a complaint. Someone who dispensed good advice and recommendations to be your best, like "here's a good diet. get some rest. take 3 days off work to heal. let me list some exercises you can do." And I was primed to trust physicians and eager to follow good orders like that. After decades of pursuing health and wellness and attempting to partner with my PCP and specialists I've realized that they do none of that. A PCP's primary purpose, for me, seems to be screening and testing until they find disorders that match up with the medications in their formulary and the treatments on the insurance company's list. I've had multiple encounters where the doc/nurse reassures me that I'm really healthy and there's no issue to treat and I'm making mountains out of molehills. It became frustrating to me because I felt so bad! And perhaps I did have burgeoning issues that were simply untreatable. Physicians are so often frustrated by patients who've abused and neglected their health, then we show up on their doorstep as a hopeless, lost cause wanting to be rescued. By analogy, I learned that I shouldn't bug my landlady about maintenance unless something is truly broken and inoperable. The fix often causes more problems -- "the cure is worse than the disease", right? I'm trying to reorient my relationship to HCPs. I need to relate health complaints to my ability to work or function in daily life, rather than minor annoyances or concerns about future problems. It doesn't pay to complain needlessly, and the medications are just a penalty for seeking help. Hypochondria may be reinforced by physicians' tendency to find treatments and prescribe stuff. You get rewarded with attention and tasks to do, even if they don't heal you. "Oh doc I feel really bad!" Well let's run some tests and go fishing! Daddy needs a new Ferrari! (My dentist literally drove one. My current dentist adorns his office walls with his own photography of exotic travel destinations instead.)
- peterbonney 2y agoMy son was born _very_ premature, which gave me an intensive crash course on interacting with the medical system. I know two (mildly contradictory) things to be true about that experience: - My son would not be alive and healthy without the incredible care and expertise of his doctors and nurses, along with decades of scientific advancements on the treatment of prematurity. - Around the margins, his health outcomes would have been worse if my wife and I had simply trusted that same expertise without ever questioning decisions and pushing back on recommendations. It’s so hard to have a nuanced conversation about the blind spots of our medical system. People want to force you into one of two buckets: you believe in medicine, or you believe in mysticism. But there _are_ blind spots, because doctors are human and fallible, they aren’t generally experts in every subject that is useful for medical diagnosis (usually including statistics and often including genetics), and it isn’t just doctors themselves that are involved but a whole medical bureaucracy whose incentives don’t always align with optimal patient outcomes.