4 ms·
You can coherently argue that encryption doesn't matter, but you can't reasonably argue that Telegram is a serious encrypted messaging app (it's not an encrypte
by tptacek 2y ago
You can coherently argue that encryption doesn't matter, but you can't reasonably argue that Telegram is a serious encrypted messaging app (it's not an encrypted messaging app at all for group chats), which is the point of the article. The general attitude among practitioners in the field is: if you have to reason about how the operator will handle legal threats, you shouldn't bother reasoning about the messenger at all.
- EGreg 2y ago[flagged]
- kasey_junk 2y ago> you can install a reproducible build of Telegram and be sure it's end-to-end encrypting things. This is incorrect. The construction for group chats in Telegram is not e2e at all. The construction for dm’s is considered dubious by many cryptographers. It does not matter if you can reproduce a non-e2e encrypted message scheme, you must still trust the servers which you have no visibility on. Trustworthy e2e is table stakes for this for that reason. Reproducible builds aren’t because we can evaluate a bunch of different builds collected in the wild and detect differences in implementation. This is the same thing we’d do if reproducible builds were in effect. There are lots of reasons splitting jurisdictions makes sense but you wrote a whole bunch of words that fall back to “hope Telegram doesn’t change their protections in the face of governmental violence”.
- EGreg 2y agoThe reproducible build of Telegram lets you evaluate the code doing end-to-end encryption. Once you satisfy yourself it's doing this kind of encryption without implementation-level backdoors, then you don't need to worry about servers reading it (except for #5 above). I didn't claim it encrypted "group chats". I said "things". If you want me to be specific, the "things" are individual 1-1 end-to-end encrypted chats.
- kasey_junk 2y agoReproducible builds are not required to evaluate the encryption algorithm used in Telegram. Software auditors use deployed binaries as a matter of course. They’d do so even if reproducible builds are on offer because the code and the binary aren’t promised to be the same even with reproducible builds and validating that they are can be more problematic than the normal case of auditing binaries.
- EGreg 2y agoCan you show me any audits of Telegram binaries or similar software?
- kasey_junk 2y agohttps://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S2666281722000166?via%3Dihub https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S26662...
- skeledrew 2y agoIt's interesting how all these years later and cryptographers can still only be dubious; nobody has actually cracked the implementation (or if they have, they haven't publicized it for whatever reason).
- tsimionescu 2y ago> On the question of balancing privacy and security, there are in fact solutions, but you have to get away from the idea of a centralized police force / centralized government, and think in terms of a free market of agencies, that can decrypt limited evidence only with a warrant and only if they provide a good reason. The warrant could be due to an AI at the edge flagging stuff, but the due process must be followed and be transparent to all What does this mean? How can "we" move away from centralized states to "a free market of agencies"? How can there be a "market" of police forces, even in principle? Who are the customers in this imagined market? Who enforces the laws to keep it a free market? At first glance, this sounds like libertarian fan fiction, to be honest, but I am curious.
- EGreg 2y agoHave you read the article I link to in that point? After you read it, you'll have a better idea, and then if you have a specific point, we can discuss.
- tsimionescu 2y agoI read it now, and I saw nothing at all about a free market of LEAs, either police or intelligence agencies. It's only speaking about some silly idea of filming every private scene but relying on magic encryption with keys that are stored... Somewhere?... And somehow the keys to decrypt these most private moments are only accessible when it would be nice to do so. It's clearly not a serious idea, so it gives me a good idea how wild the speculation goes about the broader trends.
- EGreg 2y agoWell, at least you got the broad strokes. Since the parent post was flagged, I do not see any sense to continue, since no one will really see this conversation. I do interviews with the top people. I build solutions. I give it away for free. I discuss the actual substance. And in the end it's just flagged before a serious conversation can be had. HN is not what it once was.
- chadsix 2y ago> if you have to reason about how the operator will handle legal threats, you shouldn't bother reasoning about the messenger at all. That's true. You need to run your own platform people. XMPP is plenty simple, plenty powerful, and plenty safe -- and even your metadata is in your control. Just self host. There's no excuse in 2024. Wake up people! Why should the arrest of someone else affect YOU?
- nrr 2y ago"You need to run your own platform people." What problem does this solve? I'm someone who's been on the business end of a subpoena for a platform I ran, and narcing on my friends under threat of being held in contempt is perhaps the worst feeling I'm doomed to live with. "XMPP is ..." not the solution I'd recommend, even with something like OMEMO. Is it on by default? Can you force it to be turned on? The answer to both of those is, as it turns out, "no," which makes it less than useful. (This is notwithstanding several other issues OMEMO has.)
- immibis 2y agoNote in particular that the Ethernet connection to xmpp.ru/jabber.ru's server was physically intercepted by German law enforcement (or whatever-you-think-they're-actually-enforcing enforcement), allowing them to issue fraudulent certificates through Let's Encrypt and snoop on all traffic. This was only noticed when the enforcement forgot to renew the certificate. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37961166 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37961166
- zaik 2y ago> The answer to both of those is, as it turns out, "no" This is not true, it depends on the client. Conversations has OMEMO enabled per default.
- nrr 2y agoI don't see any practical difference between "it depends" and "no" here.