3 ms·
"The docking mechanism is simple—since the asteroid is likely to be iron-rich, Vestri will use magnets to attach itself." While that sounds simple, it does mak
by dylan604 2y ago
"The docking mechanism is simple—since the asteroid is likely to be iron-rich, Vestri will use magnets to attach itself."
While that sounds simple, it does make it sound like the mining part just became much more difficult.
Thinking about some of the sci-fi regarding asteroid mining, I've always liked the idea of bringing the asteroid to park into an orbit around earth to make it easier/cheaper for multiple deliveries, but I've always wonder what kind of ownership claims that would imply. If I took the time and effort to park an asteroid in orbit, would I have sole ownership of it or would you be able to mine from it as well?
- choeger 2y agoI don't think that moving the whole thing into our orbit would make much sense. The biggest amount of delta-v is necessary to leave Earth's gravity well. Once you're there, going from and to asteroid is time-consuming but doesn't need that much delta-v, moving ore from the asteroid to Earth would cost some fuel, proportional to the mass. So moving it into orbit would save time but require us to pay for the fuel all at once. So why should someone do this, unless you need a permanent human presence on the asteroid?
- dylan604 2y agoI think we're all scared of the actual question posed or something as we've totally ignored it in everyone of these responses. Nobody cares in sci-fi about whether something should/could be done. That's not the purview of the plot. It's also not the purview of the original comment.
- nordsieck 2y ago> So why should someone do this, unless you need a permanent human presence on the asteroid? Activity is only economically valuable if it is valued - i.e. by people. Unless there's a population of people living in space, the ore or products derived from ore need to eventually make their way to Earth in order to be worth while.
- nordsieck 2y ago> I've always liked the idea of bringing the asteroid to park into an orbit around earth to make it easier/cheaper for multiple deliveries I think you're dramatically underestimating the difficulty of doing this. If you look at rockets, they're 90-95% propellant. Even relatively svelt upper stages like Centaur III (the upper stage from Atlas v) are more than 50% propellant. And that's for just taking payloads to LEO - for higher energy missions, the usable payload gets smaller, which means the percent of the upper stage that's propellant increases. How difficult would it be to get an amount of propellant, say, 5 times the mass of the asteroid to the asteroid? You'd also have to get the engines and other structures to let you use the propellant in a productive way. It's way easier to extract valuable parts from an astroid and move a lot less mass there and back.
- api 2y agoMoving mass back with a free return trajectory is much easier than getting stuff out of Earths gravity well and up there. Escape velocity from an asteroid is low and if you yeet it with enough precision you can send it on a trajectory that will land it on Earth. As for moving the asteroid you could use extremely high specific impulse ion thrusters, in situ propellant from the asteroid itself, or a solar sail. But you are right that simply firing the valuable stuff back to Earth is probably easier.
- lolinder 2y agoNot to mention the governance and liability implications of the plan. If a company mining something on Earth screws up really badly, they can ruin the environment for a hundred miles around. If a company mining an asteroid in LEO screws up really badly, the literal blast radius would wipe out a significant percentage of life on earth.
- dylan604 2y agoWhy does it need to be parked in LEO? It could be kept in an orbit at the same distance as the Moon and it would still be relatively close compared to where it is now