3 ms·
I guess the problem with a long article, even an interesting long article like the one submitted here, is that it is hard to read to the end. Near the end of th
by tokenadult 14y ago
I guess the problem with a long article, even an interesting long article like the one submitted here, is that it is hard to read to the end. Near the end of the submitted article is this paragraph:
"A second problem is that even when it comes to alternative energy sources, Germany doesn't reward carbon dioxide reduction. Rather, its policy establishes well-defined subsidies for specific technologies: a kilowatt-hour of solar power is rewarded more than power from offshore wind, which in turn earns more than power from onshore wind. Even though solar subsidies have been reduced to rates far lower than the ones Leurs locked in, solar power still pays the highest rates. If reducing emissions were the focus, however, more money would be directed toward reducing energy use. 'If you could choose the optimal instruments, focusing on those areas first where you can achieve your goals most inexpensively, you would focus not so much on renewables but much more on efficiency,' says Pittel, the energy economist from Munich."
This ignores the advice of Amory Lovins
http://www.rmi.org/Amory+B.+Lovins http://www.rmi.org/Amory+B.+Lovins
(Amory Lovins profile page at Rocky Mountain Institute website)
http://www.ted.com/speakers/amory_lovins.html http://www.ted.com/speakers/amory_lovins.html
(TED profile)
http://www.ted.com/talks/amory_lovins_a_50_year_plan_for_energy.html http://www.ted.com/talks/amory_lovins_a_50_year_plan_for_ene...
(TED Talk video "A 40-year plan for energy")
and generally the advice of any thoughtful scholar on how to improve worldwide energy efficiency. The German Energiewende plan is a remarkable example of intentionally wrong policy choices that waste the money of German taxpayers and utility rate-payers and delay innovation. It's a good thing that other countries have differing policies that better encourage innovation, especially innovation to reduce energy consumption.
AFTER EDIT:
Another subthread here talks about the economics of importing energy versus producing it domestically. An astute HN participant mentioned the principle of comparative advantage. For onlookers who may not have seen a good reference on comparative advantage, I suggest "Ricardo's Difficult Idea,"
http://www.pkarchive.org/trade/ricardo.html http://www.pkarchive.org/trade/ricardo.html
by an economist who has been awarded the Nobel memorial prize in economics, an essay that explains why trading for resources is generally much, much better than trying to produce all resources within national borders.
There are some other good explanations of the principle of comparative advantage easily found via an online search:
http://www.econlib.org/library/Topics/Details/comparativeadvantage.html http://www.econlib.org/library/Topics/Details/comparativeadv...
http://www.wto.org/english/res_e/reser_e/cadv_e.htm http://www.wto.org/english/res_e/reser_e/cadv_e.htm
http://iang.org/free_banking/david.html http://iang.org/free_banking/david.html
- ThomPete 14y agoGreat quote in there "If a problem can't be solved, enlarge it" Eisenhover. Edit: Oh and buying the book for sure. Good stuf thanks.
- lukeschlather 14y agoThis isn't a decision grounded in economics, obviously. This is about minimizing side-effects from energy production. The sun blasts roughly 10,000 times our electricity needs at us each year. (And that's just what directly impacts the surface.) I'd say we have some wiggle room in which it makes sense to focus on being cleaner rather than more efficient. We should worry about efficiency if we have serious scarcity issues, but I don't think we really have a scarcity problem at the moment. (We could definitely get there surprisingly quickly, but I think the cleanliness risk is serious and immediate, and we shouldn't focus on hypotheticals.)
- andreasvc 14y agoThis 10,000 times figure is meaningless because it is theoretical; in reality that energy comes in diffuse rays which make it very difficult to capture anywhere near the amount of electricity that is actually needed. Hence the need to turn on coal power plants, which are harmful to the environment (very unwise to have turned off those nuclear plants IMO). Therefore, we SHOULD worry about efficiency, to avoid such things as much as possible.
- Xylakant 14y agoWe haven't turned off nuclear plants (yet). Those which are currently off have either reached EOL (1 or 2 IIRC) or are down for scheduled maintenance or because of unexpected failure of critical components.(pretty much all the rest) But yes, we actually had some days where we were running without nuclear power. And I don't think it's unwise to turn them off. Few people are actually aware but in 1977 we had a catastrophic failure with a similar characteristic as the Fukushima accident: Block A of the Grundremmingen [1] nuclear plant suffered a power failure followed by a catastrophic loss of main coolant. The block had to be given up since it was not economic to repair and refit it. So while it may be true that a safe reactor can be built, I'm absolutely certain that humans can never safely operate it. We just make too many errors. [1] Close to Ulm and Augsburg, smack in the middle of Stuttgart and Munich. No more Octoberfest if that blows up.