5 ms·
84% want stronger online privacy laws, but Congress's corruption stalls progress
- aurizon 2y agoIn a party based assembly(UK, Canada) the party leader tells each party member how to vote = the party line. Members can not vote against the party = out. In the US assembly(Congress and Senate) each members votes as he/she wishes. In all houses the votes(hands) are visible. This turns a vote into a currency. A lobbyist can see he gets what he has paid for and the 'bag' is passed. Every US voter has what both the Senate and Congress do not have = a secret ballot. Why? = $$$ How to fix = 2 votes, a secret ballot AND a show of hands, the secret ballot carries. There is no longer a cause/effect monetisation link. The lobbyist will see his paid for vote by show of hands pass, but lose by secret ballot = fully deniable as a member can say is was not me that wavered. Ever hear the squeals of hundreds of stuck pigs? That will happen. I wonder if the Supreme Court can interpret the current laws to ensure a secret ballot?
- wpasc 2y agoWhy wouldn't a congress person in this instance do the opposite? Give a show of hand for sake of TV and voters. Say they voted one way, but then vote the way they might be lobbied/influenced to? The public votes of congress people is frequently a campaign talking issue by virtue of opponents lambasting each other's vote records. How would secret ballots in congress have anything but the opposite effect of what you intend?
- snowpid 2y ago" In a party based assembly(UK, Canada) the party leader tells each party member how to vote = the party line. Members can not vote against the party = out. I " Im not sure about UK and Canada, but the general statement is plainly wrong.
- VancouverMan 2y agoI wouldn't say that statement is wrong, at least for Canada. MPs, MPPs, MLAs, etc., that belong to a party typically don't deviate from the party line, even if it means going against their own constituents' wishes and interests, especially for prominent issues. A party typically has a member who acts as what's called the "party whip", and whose role is to ensure the rest of the party's members vote as the party wishes them to, and to punish those who might not. Voting against one's own party doesn't guarantee that that a representative will be kicked out of caucus, but it certainly has resulted in expulsions in the past (Nunziata, Casey, and Karahalios are cases I can think of off the top of my head). I think it's reasonable to believe that Canadian politicians represent their party and themselves to a greater degree than they represent their constituents.
- NotACop182 2y agoThis would break the trust in voting. People want to know how someone voted if they can lie to their constituents on how they voted we will lose faith in democracy. Ban lobbying is the solution.
- thevillagechief 2y agoIdeally, your representative's ballot should be open, so you know they are representing your concerns, not their own. So no, absolutely not. I do not want my representative voting secretly. Focus on fixing the corrupting influence of money instead.
- Etheryte 2y agoIt's unclear to me what value the public vote would add in the system you propose. What's the point of raising hands if it doesn't matter in the least anyway?
- lenerdenator 2y ago> I wonder if the Supreme Court can interpret the current laws to ensure a secret ballot? There is no way the current bench on the Supreme Court of the United States of America does any sort of interpreting towards a stronger administrative state, regardless of popular support for it.
- 4RealFreedom 2y agoWhy not keep everything transparent and make lobbying illegal? I know neither secret voting or making lobbying illegal will ever happen but it seems like you're just putting a bandaid on an issue without regard for the consequences. People that vote for representatives like to know how they vote. Why even have the theater of a transparent vote that does nothing?
- soco 2y agoSecret or not, please don't generalize - in Switzerland they can vote as they please (even expected, although often parties will decide a certain line)
- glitchc 2y agoThe real truth is that strong privacy laws would cause economic harm to flagship corporations. That would have a ripple effect on the economy as those corporations are responsible for thousands of high-paying jobs. The elected representatives know that people care more about the economy (specifically what's in their wallets) than about privacy.
- Retric 2y agoPrivacy has minimal overall economic impact because of the zero sum nature of advertising. Specific companies get harmed, but advertisers don’t suddenly have less money if advertising is less targeted. Net result that money is simply going to support different jobs. Similarly with more/less efficient advertising consumers have just as much money so total spending stays the same, so the only change is which companies capture it.
- zooq_ai 2y agoThis is clueless understanding of economics (and very prevalent in HN) Economics 101 : There is no fixed pie of $$$$. $$ (as in wealth, productivity) can absolutely disappear from the economy or grow from nothing.
- Retric 2y agoThe economy grows or shrinks with productivity but advertising specifically is zero sum. Coke vs Pepsi makes a great deal of difference to those specific companies and little else. If anything it’s slightly negative due to inefficiency because the winner isn’t the best product.
- zooq_ai 2y ago[flagged]
- codedokode 2y ago> cost of acquiring a customer > cost of serving a customer For a successful and popular product the cost of acquiring a customer is low. Heavy investments in advertising are needed for unpopular, overpriced products that naturally have a low demand. For example, almost everything that I buy I bought not because of advertising but based on the comparison of product price and quality.
- freitzkriesler2 2y ago[dead]
- zooq_ai 2y agoThis is just another clueless populist article. The key to actually ask people "What are you willing to give up for X"? Are you ok being more annoyed with popups asking your permissions every time? Are you ok with a recession in Ad-based ecosystem (merchants, ad brokers, stock market depression, fewer IPOs) that may result due to this? Would you be OK with paying for services instead of an Ad model? (and before Virtue signaling HNers jump in, how many of you have subscribed to YouTube premium) Any idiot will say Yes to "Do you want $1000?" Change the question to reality "Do you want $1000, but have to pay back $1100 tomorrow?" and see the numbers drop. Passing legislations has to deal with reality. Do lobbyists influencing law making? Yes. But the lobbyists is a necessary evil because general population will always want $1000. Lobbyists are there to remind you of the costs and prevent from populism destroying civilizations. Edit : Expected nothing better than downvotes from massively brainwashed HNers with ZERO independent thinking. The irony isn't lost that they are the 84% ers
- linotype 2y ago> Are you ok being more annoyed with popups asking your permissions every time? No, I’m really not. The EU regulation that caused every site to have a stupid cookie pop-up/banner has made the Web a significantly poorer experience.
- shagie 2y agoI would like to remind people that the main European Union site ( https://european-union.europa.eu/index_en https://european-union.europa.eu/index_en ) has a cookie popup as well as the site for European Commission for Data Protection https://commission.europa.eu/law/law-topic/data-protection_en https://commission.europa.eu/law/law-topic/data-protection_e... If this is the way that the flagship sites for the EU are going to do it and show how to be in compliance with the law, any other approach is too risky to implement.
- codedokode 2y agoDisagree, every time I use a EU proxy, I feel like a first-class citizen who has a privilege to opt-out. For comparison, other citizens only have the "agree" button.
- 23B1 2y agoOnce again campaign finance reform should be on the ballot, and once again the duopoly has made sure we're not even talking about it let alone voting on it.
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 2y agoDuopoly? One party is totally unelectable
- octopoc 2y agoEveryone agrees on that but nobody agrees on which party that is though
- kjrfghslkdjfl 2y ago[dead]
- Pxtl 2y agoDisappointing the article goes for the usual "congress is corrupt" instead of getting into details of who within the US congress is corrupt and being controlled by whom. It's like the DJ-3000 automated DJ inane chatter bot from the Simpsons "Looks like those clowns in Congress did it again. What a bunch of clowns." "How's he keep up with news like that?"
- A4ET8a8uTh0 2y agoOn the one hand, it is a clear indication that citizen's wishes are ignored. On the other, US is supposed to be a republic and politicians are supposed to be smarter than to give in to the mob, who will always vote itself whatever it currently wants. The problem is that while 84% ( I am taking that number at face value for the time being ) say they want stronger privacy laws in aggregate, as individuals they differ on what that actually means. While this is happening, corporations and interests that are opposed to that know exactly what they want and coordinate appropriately. Privacy needs lobbyists too , I suppose? I am not sure at what point it breaks. Ellison famously quipped that privacy is long dead anyway.
- latexr 2y ago> On the other, US is supposed to be a republic and politicians are supposed to be smarter than to give in to the mob, who will always vote itself whatever it currently wants. Just the other day I learned of the Sunshine Protection Act. From the first paragraph on Wikipedia¹: > the Senate passed the bill by unanimous consent, although several senators stated later that they would have objected if they had known that the bill could pass. Maybe politicians are “supposed to be smarter”, but they’re not. ¹ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunshine_Protection_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunshine_Protection_Act
- scarface_74 2y agoAnd yet in other countries when Facebook was forced to give users a choice of pay for the service or accept targeted advertising, people chose to keep their free service. The ad tier of services like Hulu makes more than the paid tier.
- mhuffman 2y agoIt seems like the "give users a choice" part is the important part here. Most of use that have almost no social media footprint are still being tracked and targeted with ads.
- gizajob 2y ago84% spend all day yakking online posting under their real names
- SteveSmith16384 2y agoMaybe they're letting the big corps get fatter ready for a big EU-style lawsuit.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- josefritzishere 2y agoIt is very telling that half a dozen states have managed to pass GDPR-like laws, and at the Federal level we have nothing but inaction. The IAPP maintains a good state-by-state tracker. https://iapp.org/resources/article/us-state-privacy-legislation-tracker/ https://iapp.org/resources/article/us-state-privacy-legislat...
- lintiergan 2y agoThis problem of “representatives” failing to represent their constituents, let alone their supporters, was the impetus for me to develop my most recent political advocacy. I call it “expand the powers of justice by jury”. Essentially, bills in congress will be litigated by representatives, in front of a judge, for a jury, and the jury ultimately casts the vote either for or against the proposed legislation. I think this would resolve many of the issues that we are seeing in contemporary politics; mainly the negative effects of the influence of money.
- AlexandrB 2y agoWhy would jurors be harder to buy than career politicians? Especially when there are probably no career consequences for a juror if such a scheme found out. The other obvious problem is jury selection. You can basically choose the outcome by selecting the "right" jury.
- teoingdri 2y ago> Why would jurors be harder to buy than career politicians? Because the juries are selected from random pools. Are you truly sincere in your question regarding the ability to buy off career politicians vs random peers? Are you aware of jury tampering laws? > The other obvious problem is jury selection. You can basically choose the outcome by selecting the "right" jury. I was unaware you are so passionate about reforming the current jury system. What groups are you currently working with to improve the existing system? I can agree there are flaws in the current system but rather than throwing my hands up in defeat I think such problems can be addressed. How would you better address the issue from the linked article?
- teoingdri 2y agoHere’s a clip of Jon Stewart laying it out for you: @11:00 > “And that, ladies and gentlemen, I present to you, is why we need courts. Whatever flaws the American justice system has, and they are legion, especially for non billionaire former presidents, it does appear to be the last place where you can’t just say whatever the fuck you want regardless of reality.” That’s the energy I want to bring to congress. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=qmxzQJt80XI&t=660 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=qmxzQJt80XI&t=660