6 ms·
GM to Cut More Than 1k Software Engineers, Mostly in US
- practicemaths 2y agoIn a time when cars are increasingly more connected than ever. More sensors and controls. Literally more software in cars today than ever before and they do this? I suspect this a poor move on GM's part.
- sneed_chucker 2y agoPar for the course. Have you driven a modern GM vehicle? Full of issues and borderline worthless once the warranty is up. Really great company that the tax payer was forced to rescue.
- notyourwork 2y agoGM repaid all the debt given during the rescue, please don’t conflate a bail out with the companies poor decisions.
- SoftTalker 2y agoIf they had been making good decisions they would not have needed the bailout.
- GolfPopper 2y agoNot per Wikipedia[1]:"Through the Troubled Asset Relief Program the US Treasury invested a total $51 billion into the GM bankruptcy. Until December 10, 2013, the U. S. Treasury recovered $39 billion from selling its GM stake. The final direct cost to the Treasury of the GM bailout was $11-12 billion ($10.5 billion for General Motors and $1.5 billion for former GM financing GMAC, now known as Ally)." 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_Chapter_11_reorganization#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_Chapter_11_reor...
- tadfisher 2y agoDid you miss the next sentence? > A study by the Center for Automotive Research found that the GM bailout saved 1.2 million jobs and preserved $34.9 billion in tax revenue. The whole point was to avoid the economic fallout of a GM collapse (and with it, yet another bank for the FDIC to deal with).
- thallium205 2y agoAn automotive special interest group concluded that a $10.5B bailout for the automotive sector was a good thing!
- tadfisher 2y agoI went and checked their funding, and only a quarter of it is from corporate interests. Governments actually fund them more.
- olalonde 2y agoAs if those 1.2 million people would have just been twiddling their thumbs.
- plasmatix 2y agoWhy do you think it’s called “The Great Recession”?
- olalonde 2y agoBecause a business cycle contraction occurred? If GM had been allowed to fail, other companies would have filled the gap in the market, and new businesses would have emerged, most likely generating even greater tax revenue over time. While there may have been some short-term thumb twiddling, the market would have eventually created new jobs elsewhere, jobs that would have been even more productive. There's a great opportunity cost to "saving" millions of unproductive jobs.
- shrubble 2y agoNot true at all; both the bondholders, who under the law were supposed to be senior, got screwed over, and certain non-union salaried employee pensions, were severely cut out of pension money by the PBGC.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- thallium205 2y agoNonsense. The government took a $10.5B loss when it converted the loan to equity. At one point the government owned 61% of GM. Wild.
- SkyPuncher 2y agoThe remaining legacy, domestic auto manufacturers are just kind of circling the drain. They all have stupid problems and largely seem to have ridden the coat tails of an older generation that vowed to buy American. Anecdotally, but my Ford F-150 has so many software bugs it’s insane. It’s mechanically reliable, but the software is terrible. * backup sensor don’t work about 10% of the time * backup camera won’t engage about 1% of the time * main screen will boot loop a few times before it fully turns on about 5% of the time * heated and cooled seats seem to choose random setting when the car is remote started. * lane centering system will crash if you try to take it through a turn that’s too tight. Have to turn the vehicle off, open the door to fix it. * my trailer system won’t remember custom made trailers. I don’t really have a use for the system, but annoying none the less. * auto power folding mirrors often get confused about their state when shutting down or starting the car up. Annoying, but easily fixed. * my digital instrument panel will occasionally not turn on * my digital instrument panel will occasional forget all of my custom settings. Different problem than above. * Not really a bug, but the car has soooooooooo many popup notifications. There will literally be status messages that are overlaid by an almost identical, but different message. Thank you, F-150, I know that I plugged my cooler into the outlet in the bed. Please stop asking me if I want the generator on. The car is running, I want the generator on. The physical vehicle is rock solid and I’m extremely happy with that. However, I just want to rip out all of the electronics and replace them with the magic that Kia/Hyundai built in their vehicle. I largely get this impression anytime I step into an American vehicle. It feels like it was designed by a committee of out of touch executives.
- meroes 2y agoIf bugs weren’t so prevalent I’d think a squirrel’s been eating your wires haha. That’s a lot. My Honda has a few but I’m happy with it although I think someday it might kill me with these phantom lane corrections.
- SkyPuncher 2y agoIt’s a 3 year old vehicle. The backup sensor might be a wiring issue, but everything else is pure software issue. Many of the “won’t turn on” things actually involve the component powering on (like the backlight turns on), but the digital components just don’t work.
- SoftTalker 2y agoThe sensors and controls are made by companies like Bosch. GM doesn't need any expertise in this stuff, they just buy parts from companies that have it.
- greenthrow 2y agoHave you ever written integration software?
- AlotOfReading 2y agoNot true. A few exceptional vendors like Bosch excepted, manufacturers are increasingly in-sourcing development away from the tier suppliers. It's a lot of work managing them to get quality outcomes and that system has repeatedly bitten manufacturers hard in the past decade. It also lengthens development timelines significantly and raises the cost of mid-development changes, when they actually need faster, more responsive development practices. The issue with companies like GM is that while most people recognize what I've just said internally, there's a lot of conflict between traditional management processes/styles/cultures and the changes they need to make to adapt. These kinds of layoffs tend to result from the financial fragility they've built up. When some minor event puts clouds on the financial horizon, management only understands one tool to make changes and that's layoffs/pay cuts.
- IncreasePosts 2y agoCutting 1000 software engineers doesn't necessarily mean they won't be needing the services of 1000 software engineers. They could just be moving to contract out the work instead of having more in-house staff.
- gjsman-1000 2y agoMaybe we should have talent tariffs. Hiring overseas? 50% tariff. Watch employers “suddenly” find qualified talent at home.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- happytoexplain 2y agoPlease, please disagree with this comment instead of downvoting it. As a normal person, I have no idea if there is a good counterargument, or if the downvoting is just kneejerk politics or a disapproval of tone.
- dotnet00 2y agoA 50% tariff on foreign workers means you're forcing companies to pay employees in other countries much more than in the US. They obviously aren't just going to shut down their international presence, so that's just transferring money from the US to these other countries. Since the companies would just raise prices in the markets that can most afford it (ie the US), and use those to offset the increased costs elsewhere. If they're referring to hiring immigrants in the US, it's still kind of the same thing. A 50% tariff on immigrant employees means it's cheaper to just outsource, so now all that money is just going outside. On the other hand, the money the immigrant employee makes is mostly being spent within the US. If you wanted to limit the ability of companies to pay immigrant workers less, you'd be better off making the initial immigration process harder, but the immigration to permanent residency process faster, that way fewer skilled immigrants get in, but once in they're not exploitable for very long. Since they can't easily import more workers, they're forced to deal with everyone at an equal level. If you want to limit outsourcing, you'd have to start with onshoring the supply chain and either encourage automation or provide an incentive strong enough to keep those companies globally competitive.
- nothercastle 2y agoDidn’t they also go with a plan to cut CarPlay and android auto. Seems like they are on track to shittify and get left behind
- notyourwork 2y agoPersonally, I will not buy a car without CarPlay goi g forward. I assume for most that’s close to a deal breaker.
- indemnity 2y agoI thought so too, but to be honest I haven’t missed it too much in my Tesla. It already covers my streaming music use cases, and built in navigation is good enough.
- al_borland 2y agoHow does it work when you have something in your calendar? I will often put locations in my calendar, get in my car, and then I can tap the location of my next appointment in CarPlay to route me to my next location. I think I’d miss similar integration with a lot of apps that require my personal data to be useful. I can’t see something from the OEM doing this well, especially if I’m not willing to send all my data to them. I would have been squeamish about it before, but it’s a hard no after the auto marker privacy report came out and everyone did horribly. https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/blog/privacy-nightmare-on-wheels-every-car-brand-reviewed-by-mozilla-including-ford-volkswagen-and-toyota-flunks-privacy-test/ https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/blog/privacy-nightmare-on-...
- bhuber 2y agoTesla owner here. If you have the Tesla app installed on your phone, you can "share" addresses from map apps to it and it will auto-sync them to your car. So the workflow is open calendar on your phone, click on location for appointment, open with Tesla app. It's not quite as seamless as android auto, but much better than having to type everything in manually.
- pstrateman 2y agoI'm sure their outsourcing will go differently to every other outsourcing operation.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- sebazzz 2y agoI think it will confirm the same.
- upon_drumhead 2y ago> The moves come two months after former Apple Inc. executives David Richardson and Baris Cetinok were promoted to senior vice president roles in the group I wonder if they're doing this to just move the jobs to the Bay Area.
- hipadev23 2y agoThey're laying off engineers in Michigan and overseas to move jobs to the Bay Area? You're going to have to connect the dots for me on this one.
- fma 2y agoConnect the dots as in why it makes sense? Or provide evidence? I can't tell you why it would make sense to the executives, but below are job searches for keyword software. You can yada yada and say maybe it's fake postings in which case I'm not sure what to say - but it's well known internally GM wants to expand the Mountain View office. 42 jobs listed in Mountain View https://search-careers.gm.com/en/jobs/?search=software&location=Mountain+View&pagesize=20#results https://search-careers.gm.com/en/jobs/?search=software&locat... 6 in Detroit https://search-careers.gm.com/en/jobs/?search=software&location=Detroit&pagesize=20#results https://search-careers.gm.com/en/jobs/?search=software&locat... 16 in Austin https://search-careers.gm.com/en/jobs/?search=software&location=Austin&pagesize=20#results https://search-careers.gm.com/en/jobs/?search=software&locat...
- hipadev23 2y agoWhere did I, or anyone, suggest they're fake job postings? I'm pointing out the bit of your logic where they didn't offer the ~600 engineers in Michigan comparable jobs in the Mountain View office. And due to COL changes, you know damn well they'd have materially lower salary expectations than Mountain View natives. That's the part of your "just move the jobs to the Bay Area" theory which doesn't make sense. Relocating trained employees is massively more cost-effective than firing + hiring + training.
- tims33 2y ago
- greenthrow 2y agoCompanies have been really hammering software engineers with layoffs, but the need for software to be written has only been increasing. I think the execs at these companies have been snowed over by Copilot demos and vastly overestimate the productivity gains it can realize.
- cyberax 2y agoA big brain move. First, they cut CarPlay/Android Auto because they want to provide a full custom experience. Second, they fire the people who are supposed to be responsible for that experience.
- initplus 2y agoMore engineers doesn't automatically mean better software. Sometimes the opposite.
- CydeWeys 2y agoLarge-scale layoffs almost never means better software though.
- e3bc54b2 2y agoLayoffs almost always mean the few engineers that can do better than more engineers are on the way out, if not via layoffs, then voluntarily.
- CydeWeys 2y agoAnd the ones that remain have terribly reduced morale and lose productivity.
- K0balt 2y agoThis seems like a great Reason to avoid hiring as much as possible , and use contractors for any work that could potentially be lost by non-renewal of contracts or program cancellations.
- CydeWeys 2y agoAgreed on your first point, not on your second point. Lots of tech companies did over-hire during the pandemic in a way that had entirely foreseeable results, but everyone simply got caught up in the FOMO. On the contractor front though, you aren't going to remotely get the best and brightest by going that way, not unless you're actually contracting with industry leaders who are going to be charging way more than FTEs will cost you (and there aren't that many industry leaders). There are so many good tech companies out there offering FTE positions, so a company offering a lower-paid, lower-benefits contracting positions is simply not going to be competitive in the labor marketplace.
- technick 2y agoWe need some laws that will prevent companies from outsourcing those positions for up to 36 months after laying off Americans.
- dexwiz 2y agoOut sourcing can predate the layoff. You gotta train the new people before you let go of the old.
- baron816 2y agoWhen you do this kind of stuff, you make American companies less competitive as a whole. If GM can get as good software for cheaper by outsourcing (granted, they almost certain cannot), then they should do it because that might help save tens of thousands of other jobs within the company and broader economy. The government should not generally be in the business of telling companies how to build software.
- lispisok 2y agoWhat if the money saved isnt used to help save thousands of other jobs but makes its way up to the C suite compensation?
- pylua 2y agoI don't agree with this. The US government needs to encourage an economic structure that is best for US citizens. The company is not looking to save other jobs, but rather to increase their profits for stakeholders. Other industries are highly regulated, such as Medicine, Law, or otherwise have tariffs that combat against this. This is also a slap in the face to the US citizens that bailed out the company previously. Literally everything that does not require a US stamp or certification is being outsourced. Mechanical Engineering, Civil Engineering, non-software architecture, customer support, project management, and even accounting. This is not good for the US as a country. American workers are not competitive right now, unfortunately, considering the high cost of living and strength of the dollar. Also, American workers will find it hard to get a work visa in a very low cost of living country if they do wish to pursue a career where their field has been outsourced.
- taeric 2y agoI have a slightly contra view here. Conway's law means you often ship your engineering structure in your code. As such, larger dev teams will necessitate more modules. This will lead to more code and to more bugs Some modularity is desired. Enough to support a thousand devs? Hard to say.
- AlotOfReading 2y agoDon't take this as defending specific headcounts, but rather a response to the general idea. Modern vehicles have probably the highest inherent complexity of any thing most people regularly interact with. These are heavily regulated, safety critical electro-pneumo-mechanical distributed systems built to survive decades of severe conditions and piecemeal maintenance by the kind of people who work at jiffy lube. Every one of those attributes adds an order of magnitude to the headcount. There's simply no option to do small teams that might escape Conway's law. Sometimes I'm amazed cars work at all.
- taeric 2y agoYeah, this is why I said some modularity is desired. You also should want stability in ways our industry just doesn't. Large teams churn in ways smaller teams don't. Competing teams, as the different product teams almost certainly are will be different.
- gsky 2y agoThanks to 3hour workday videos, now everyone thiks that Software engineers are lazy and unproductive
- postalrat 2y agoIf you are hiring remote workers why choose the ones that cost more?
- gkuhl21 2y agoWe need better bike infrastructure, like everywhere. Let's spur some competition in that area, so we can cook ourselves more slowly by taking cars off the road, and also let the invisible hand of the market take GM out of business.
- FMecha 2y agoThe government wouldn't let GM go out of business for the same reason they wouldn't let Intel met the same fate - even from said invisible hands.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ChrisArchitect 2y agoErr.. fix the Google cache link. Did you do that to get around the earlier submission? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41291031 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41291031 https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-08-19/gm-to-cut-more-than-1-000-software-engineers-mostly-in-the-us https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-08-19/gm-to-cut... [dupe] either way Some more discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41290899 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41290899 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41290795 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41290795
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 2y ago"Software is eating the world"
- dzonga 2y agomy friend is a tech lead at GM - his biggest complaint, working with people without adequate basic skills.
- fma 2y agoI guess your friend must be disappointed to find out the layoff wasn't a performance based layoff.
- gaws 2y ago> working with people without adequate basic skills. like what, exactly?
- SkyPuncher 2y agoI know some good software engineers at GM, but it’s simply not a place that attracts top tier talent. Why work at GM, as a second rate employee (physical engineering is first tier) for much lower than what you make at basically any tech company.