6 ms·
Boeing Halts 777X Flight Tests over Damage Found in Engine Mount
- mjevans 2y agohttps://archive.is/o8Za8 https://archive.is/o8Za8 Since I can't read the article otherwise.
- justinclift 2y agoThat seems like a pretty broken capture. :(
- richwater 2y agoEngine mounts are critical single points of failure. Not good.
- AdamJacobMuller 2y agoNot exactly a single point of failure. It's obviously not good if one fails and the engine falls off the plane, but, a 777X should still be able to fly with a single engine. Of course, that capability is more geared to "we saw a high temperature on the engine so let's proactively shut it down and land as soon as we can" and not "the engine fell off the plane and landed on someone".
- SoftTalker 2y agoAnd if one falls off due to a structural weakness, the other might well soon follow.
- giosalinas 2y agoobviously not good if one falls off the plane????!! you are talking about major structural damage to the airplane, the center of mass will be completely off and the airplane will fall as hard as a rock.
- wkat4242 2y agoIf one falls off the way it was planned it will be a very bad but not necessarily terrible situation. Someone else already linked to the excellent admiral cloudberg article that describes how it should have happened (which there it didn't), as designed the engine would flip over the wing and not hit anything. Though of course the damage to the wing and pylon might rip hydraulics or wiring out or something. It's never a good thing. Also, the engines are pretty close to the centre of mass so it's not a huge deal. Asymmetric thrust will be a problem but the drag situation will be better than with 1 engine disabled! After all there is no inactive engine face catching a whole load of air. And an engine failure situation is already a known situation.
- giosalinas 2y agoWell, El Al 1862 crashed anyways, isn't it? You can't compare losing 1/4 engines to 1/2 of the massive GE9X engines and center of mass will be off by a lot. There are several crashes related to weight imbalance (usually cargo bay) and there is a reason why there are several precautions regarding how to load a plane. We also have the 737-Max, that needs a counterbalance mechanism to make it work.
- wkat4242 2y agoYes but it crashed because the pylons failed in the wrong way. It was a design flaw. Also, if it had failed as designed it would have only lost one. The other one was only lost because the first engine hit it on the way out. As well as the leading edge of the wing and the slats. The plane was doomed but not because of imbalance. It just could not fly under 270 knots.
- jojobas 2y agoStructural damage aside, modern planes have ridiculous safety margins on center of mass, drag and lift. A cleanly separating engine wouldn't be that much of a problem, mostly sorted by pumping fuel and rudder trim.
- epc 2y agoYou wouldn't think a single engine could be a single point of failure but the crash of AA 191 in 1979 was due to a cracked engine mount.
- pixl97 2y agoThere was a 747 crash in (poland or the netherlands) where the bolts broke off the engine and the failed engine managed to hit the other engine on the wing. The plane fell straight out of the sky and cut an apartment building in two killing at least 40 on the ground. Engines falling off a plane are very very bad and cause a lot of secondary damage.
- alvah 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/El_Al_Flight_1862 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/El_Al_Flight_1862
- FabHK 2y agoA DC-10 can't fly when one engine comes off unplanned (and it has two engines left in that case...): as the aircraft was beginning its takeoff rotation, engine number one (the left engine) separated from the left wing, flipping over the top of the wing and landing on the runway. As the engine separated from the aircraft, it severed hydraulic lines that lock the wing's leading-edge slats in place and damaged a 3-foot (1 m) section of the left wing's leading edge. Aerodynamic forces acting on the wing resulted in an uncommanded retraction of the outboard slats. As the aircraft began to climb, the damaged left wing produced far less lift than the right wing, which had its slats still deployed and its engine providing full takeoff thrust. The disrupted and unbalanced aerodynamics of the aircraft caused it to roll abruptly to the left until it was partially inverted, reaching a bank angle of 112°, before crashing in an open field by a trailer park near the end of the runway. The engine separation was attributed to damage to the pylon structure holding the engine to the wing, caused by improper maintenance procedures at American Airlines. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Airlines_Flight_191 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Airlines_Flight_191
- fransje26 2y ago> Not exactly a single point of failure. It is a safe-life part, so yes, it is a single point of failure part for that engine. And, if something fails unexpectedly, it could significantly damage the wing too, as has happened in the past with deadly consequences. The problem being encountered on two other test planes, makes it a lot more problematic, as the probability of the second engine shearing off then becomes a lot, lot higher.
- yongjik 2y agoFrom what I heard, they are obviously critical but not a single point of failure. In fact they're made of several points that are expected to fail in a pre-determined order to cover the "engine falling off the plane" scenario. I learned this from this superb article describing what happened when they failed in the wrong order: https://admiralcloudberg.medium.com/concrete-and-fire-the-crash-of-el-al-flight-1862-7f2e8fa4bee9 https://admiralcloudberg.medium.com/concrete-and-fire-the-cr...
- fransje26 2y agoThat still makes it a single point of failure. It's a safe-life part, not a fail-safe part. Once one mounting point fails, the other ones will fail as well. The mounting points are engineered to try to minimise wing damage when that happens.
- AdamJacobMuller 2y agoThe amount of Boeing failures is so problematic, it points to the kind of cultural failure within the company where in almost every other circumstance it should just be shut down and sold for parts. The problem is that that is such an unacceptable situation that it can't ever be allowed to happen. Boeing is a huge employer in the US, not even counting all the direct subsidiaries who would shut down if it was shut down. Boeing is developing critical space hardware for NASA. As great as SpaceX is, the US should not rely on a single company for this. I don't think even SpaceX wants this. If Boeing did fail, that leaves Airbus as the only commercial jet manufacturer? I don't think anyone, including Airbus and definitely not any airline which has used the airbus-boeing dance during price negotiations wants this to happen. Not to even mention the supply chain issues with keeping our massive fleets of Boeing airplanes flying if Boeing goes defunct. We also have to consider the defense implications of loosing what is now our only serious domestic manufacturer of many military aircraft and other ordinance. Boeing literally can not be allowed to fail, the implications would be too great. I also literally see no other path for Boeing but failure. I also think out of the ashes of that failure something much more focused and better would emerge and that, without that failure, it probably never will but still the failure cannot be allowed to happen.
- fsckboy 2y agoyour comment is bascally copypasta for a different topic, it's normal during flight tests to find and fix problems.
- SoftTalker 2y agoI agree, on the one had this is normal, there are issues discovered and corrected during testing of all new aircraft types. But I also wonder if we aren't pushing the limits of what's reasonable for a 2-engine passenger airliner. I get that the more people you can put on a flight the more money the airlines make from that flight, but there's a practical limit somewhere.
- upon_drumhead 2y agowe're still making huge leaps forward in the quality of the base materials, until we stop making progress there, I don't think we're able to say that we're at the practical limit.
- DidYaWipe 2y agoUnreadable. The article text just fades out and there's no way to proceed.
- shiroiushi 2y agoLooks ok to me, though at the very end it has this odd paragraph: `(Adds analyst comment in fourth paragraph.)` Are you using an ad-blocker? If so, the problem might be a paywall. I suggest adding this line to your uBO custom filters: https://gitflic.ru/project/magnolia1234/bypass-paywalls-clean-filters/blob/raw?file=bpc-paywall-filter.txt https://gitflic.ru/project/magnolia1234/bypass-paywalls-clea...
- DidYaWipe 2y agoThanks! I'm indeed using uBO, but only to block one element on Reddit. Otherwise I haven't even explored (or changed) its default settings. I plopped that filter text in, and... BOOM. Problem eliminated! Thanks man.
- h_tbob 2y agoI want to share something important with everybody. I read a long time ago that the Boeing CEO was cutting costs by outsourcing as much as possible. He said that this was the way forward and was financially wisest. This was before the MAX problems. I think we can compare this to the massively vertical integration of companies like Tesla, or even US steel back in the day. Does anybody think there is a link between vertical integration and quality? That maybe all this outsourcing messed things up? I’d love to hear your thoughts.
- lmz 2y agoThe other big aircraft company, Airbus is quite a distributed operation: https://simpleflying.com/airbus-commerical-jet-manufacture/ https://simpleflying.com/airbus-commerical-jet-manufacture/
- wkat4242 2y agoYes though it's not really because of a drive to outsource but more because it was a European multi-state project, that want to see returns on their investment.
- lmz 2y agoBut it suggests that construction simply being split across multiple entities does not explain the quality difference. Maybe they're not under cost pressure though.
- TheAmazingRace 2y agoI'm not sure if Tesla is a great example here, considering they also suffer quality control issues, at least in their US manufacturing. The amount of panel gap issues and fitment problems I've witnessed with Teslas have been more than I care to admit. Being truly vertically integrated is no guarantee for quality in my experience.
- bamboozled 2y agoAgreed, Tesla now has a reputation for low quality. Even taking to randoms who do t know much about EVs or Teslas just say this now. It’s become common wisdom Toyota make good cars, Tesla make crap.
- metadat 2y agohttps://archive.today/ihAH5 https://archive.today/ihAH5
- hindsightbias 2y agoAircraft with largest composite wing and engines ever conceived has problems with engine mounts after 1000s of test hours and longer certification requirements by FAA. News at 11.
- fransje26 2y ago> has problems [..] has significant structural problems on three test aircrafts [..]
- hi-v-rocknroll 2y agoSeparately, Rolls-Royce wants to create the largest fan ever made as a geared engine (Ultrafan).
- bankcust08385 2y agoAnd I wonder which subcontractor made those. DuCommun by hand perhaps like with the 737 NG bear straps?
- alistairSH 2y agoThis was shared in a comment and has more details. - Issue found on 3 test aircraft - During certification tests (ie very late in the game) - Boeing-designed thrust link is cracking (this links engine to wing). Made of titanium. There are two on each engine for redundancy. https://www.seattletimes.com/business/boeing-aerospace/boeing-discovers-engine-part-defect-and-grounds-its-777x-test-airplanes/ https://www.seattletimes.com/business/boeing-aerospace/boein...