5 ms·
Companies keep going at it the wrong way. Instead of saying "We have AI, let's find products we can make out of AI!" they should be saying, "What products do pe
by ryandrake 2y ago
Companies keep going at it the wrong way. Instead of saying "We have AI, let's find products we can make out of AI!" they should be saying, "What products do people want, let's use whatever tools we have (including maybe AI) to make them."
The idea that a company is an AI company should be as ridiculous as a company being a Python company. "We are Python-first, have Python experts, and all of our products are made with Python. Our customers want their apps to have Python in them. We just have to 'productize Python' and find the right killer app for Python and we'll be successful!" Going at it from the wrong direction. Replace Python in that quote with AI, and you probably have something a real company has said in 2024.
- sroussey 2y agoThis has been the case for decades. Look at the internet and .com’s. Mobile. Etc.
- slg 2y agoIt really is one of the more effective ways to identify a bubble when companies shift to selling themselves on the tools and technology they use rather than the problem they are solving.
- candiddevmike 2y agoI blogged about our glorious journey Becoming an AI Company (TM) https://candid.dev/blog/becoming-an-ai-company/ https://candid.dev/blog/becoming-an-ai-company/
- batch12 2y agoI was unmoved until I hit "Natural Language™".
- necroforest 2y agoI don't entirely disagree with you, but "what products do people want" is overly conservative. Pre-ChatGPT, very few people wanted a (more or less) general purpose chatbot.
- dragontamer 2y agoOne of my local car dealerships is using an chat system of some kind (probably an LLM?). It's awful and a complete waste of time. I'm not sure if LLMs are getting good use yet / general chatbots are good or ready for business use.
- lancesells 2y agoBut this is like companies forcing self-checkout at retail. Companies get to cheap out on their customer support by paying a monthly fee instead of paying a person to do it. It doesn't matter if it's worse for you, as every business is getting sold on using this technology. You misery and wasted time is their improved stock price and bonus package.
- AlexandrB 2y agoThis works if you have a dominant market position, like Meta or Amazon, but a business like a local car dealership might be very ill served with this model since their customers can just go elsewhere.
- dyauspitr 2y agoWho cares. I literally use ChatGPT 30 times a day. It answers incredibly complex queries along with citations I can verify. Isn’t “this not good enough yet” line getting old? There nothing else that can estimate the number of cinder blocks I need to use for a project and account for the volume of concrete required for it (while taking into consideration the actual available volume available in a cinder block and settling) with a few quick sentences I speak to it. I can think of literally thousands of things I have asked that would have taken hours of googling that I can get an answer for in minutes. I think the problem is you haven’t shifted your mindset to using AI correctly yet. Edit: More everyday examples from just the last 3 days - Use carbide bits to drill into rocks. Googling “best bits for drilling rocks” doesn’t bring up anything obvious about carbide but it was the main thing chatGPT suggested. - gave it dimensions for a barn I’m building and asked it how many gallons of paint I would need of a particular type. I could probably work that out myself but it’s a bunch of lookups (what’s the total sq footage, how many sq ft per gallon, what type of paint stands up to a lot of scuffing etc.) - coarse threaded inserts for softwood when I asked it for threaded insert recommendations. I would have probably ended up not caring and fine threaded slips right out of pine. - lookup ingredients in a face cream and list out any harms (with citations) for any of them. - speeds and feeds for acrylic cutting for my particular CNC. Don’t use a downcut bit because it might cause a fire, something I didn’t consider. - an explanation of relevant NEMA outlets. Something that’s very hard to figure out if you’re just dropped into it via googling.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mondrian 2y agoI 95% agree, but "what people want" is probably not a strong indicator on the thresholds of paradigm shifts, since people don't know what's possible.
- johnnyanmac 2y agoI'd look at the collorary. "what people DON'T want" is a stronger (but still imperfect) indicator of how far you can push the overton curtain. If you can't convince people that this is benefiting them, and instead focus on talking to investors about how much you can kill off the working class (aka, your "customers" and nowadays "product audience"), you will make it harder to properly sell your product nor audience. Companies have forgotten who the real customers are, no wonder their products aren't resonating.
- xbmcuser 2y agothis is how things evolve everything was .com company when internet started going mainstream then real product and service providers were left standing
- cooperx 2y agoIts the same as all the "we are a blockchain company" startups that popped up looking for a problem to solve with their tech rather than the right way round. However, a lot of those got a bunch of investment or made some decent money in the short term. Very few are still around. We will see the same pattern here.
- javiramos 2y agoI had already forgotten about the blockchain
- _heimdall 2y agogit still works pretty well, I just wouldn't try to use it as a bank account.
- sham1 2y agoWell, Git's also not a blockchain at least in the way commonly meant by the term. But yeah, it'd be a pretty bad bank account (and an even worse way of doing money transfers.)
- lagniappe 2y agoGit is by the literal definition a blockchain.
- turkey99 2y agoSeems a bit of a stretch. Git is not linear, and there’s no consensus mechanisms
- _heimdall 2y agogit is linear, if multiple users have a different main branch history you have a problem. Pull requests in github is actually very similar conceptually to a consensus mechanism used in crypto currencies. Everyone has an identical copy of the main branch with an identical history of every commit in order, a PR is saying "I think this commit goes next" and, if you use code reviews, the PR approval is consensus.
- lispisok 2y agoYou're suggesting boring business way to do things. The tech ecosystem is full of startups doing that ridiculous thing you said chasing the hot new thing and raising huge amounts of money off the hype. This AI hype cycle is really bad and before that we had cryptocurrency.
- tux1968 2y agoIt was likely the same back when the steam engine was invented. Everyone who could start a steam engine company, started a steam engine company. Because learning how to be a steam engine company was difficult, new, and unique. It would be a while before finding all the products that could be sold to people incorporating that new tech.
- KineticLensman 2y agoTech was very different then. The first commercial steam Engine appeared in 1712 - big static thing thing that could pump water out of mines. It took about about 100 years until 1804 to get to a steam engine small but powerful enough to pull a train. Mines and factories were pretty much the only users for decades and there were very few people who had a steam engine for the sake of it
- __MatrixMan__ 2y agoHow was tech different then? We've been working on AI for 70 years now, seems comparable.
- KineticLensman 2y agoWe’ve been working on digital computers for 70 years and AI is just one part of that. Computers are everywhere and suddenly AI is being crammed into every product, it seems. In the first 90 years of steam, steam engines did not suddenly appear everywhere. Outside of factories and mines, they essentially did not exist. No one had a steam engine in their home. Innovation happened very slowly, no equivalent of Moore’s law, no continuous year on year improvements to the basic tech
- __MatrixMan__ 2y agoThe products are different, sure. And there are more people participating now than then. But I'm not convinced that the two are that fundamentally different. Some technologies just take the better part of a century to mature.
- ants_everywhere 2y agoThere's still a lot of real work to be done knowing what can be built and operated profitably, because the underlying tech is so new. So just zooming out, we need people trying to figure out what can be built with this Lego set. We also need people like you're saying to work the other side so everyone can meet in the middle.
- DylanDmitri 2y agoI’m seeing a lot of meh products that take like 4 units of effort to integrate. I think multiple LLMs, deeply integrated into a cohesive product with 100+ effort units, that can be great. An AI that’s familiar with the use of every settings menu on windows would be awesome
- slavboj 2y agoA ton of the industrial revolution was actually motivated by that input-driven thinking. You don't decide you want an Eiffel Tower from first principles, you consider "what is the coolest thing I can make out of wrought iron".
- GeneralMayhem 2y agoBut the Eiffel Tower is an art project, not something of actual utility...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ebcode 2y agoIt was actually scheduled to be demolished, but then they added an antenna: https://www.toureiffel.paris/en/news/130-years/why-was-eiffel-tower-kept https://www.toureiffel.paris/en/news/130-years/why-was-eiffe... Also: https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/eiffel-tower-grows-six-metres-after-new-antenna-attached-2022-03-15/ https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/eiffel-tower-grows-six-... Utility may have been an afterthought, but it's still there.
- diatone 2y agoEhhh it’s a spectrum. First you innovate, then you commercialise. Even Google took a few years to successfully monetise and they weren’t the first mover in web search. LLMs have been around for, what, coming up on three years? Probably two to four more years to see results.
- honestjohn 2y ago[flagged]
- lallysingh 2y agoThat requires they you understand the capabilities and limitations of the tech way better than anyone does. So instead "let's see what we can do with this" is the underlying approach.
- kohbo 2y agoMight be a good philosophy for a hobbyist, not (usually so) for a business.
- lallysingh 2y agoFor VC funded startups, this is exactly the business model. Each company is a different lottery ticket for them.
- siruncledrew 2y agoThe market is sorting itself out right now, and eventually the wheat will get separated from the chaff. Every cycle, theres all types of people hop on board whatever the hype train is... it's the same mindset as pioneering for gold in the wild west. I just hope we can move along more in the "wheat" direction with AI products. There's so much low-effort crap already out there.
- mu53 2y agoAI is trending right now. The most important thing for new companies is finding investors, and those people have been throwing cash at any company with AI. Customers are also more interested in AI products. The tech industry has stagnated for years with incremental improvements on existing products. ChatGPT and generative AI are new capabilities that draw interest, and companies have been doing anything they can to stand out today.
- widenrun 2y agoYou are forgetting marketing is temporal. Fifteen years ago you could sell your software as the Cloud version of a legacy app. Right now, there's a window that being the AI version will get you a call.
- johnnyanmac 2y agoif you're some Python contractor company, the angle makes sense. but of course, very few AI companies are out there trying to help others solve problems.
- SkyPuncher 2y agoI only partially agree with this. Having spent a lot of time in the “find a problem then the solution” way of working, I’ve found the solutions are often too tame and lack innovation. When you’re truly bring novel new value to things, sometime you need to say “we can do this cool thing, but don’t know what that means”. Simply knowing that capability opens you up to better sets of solutions.
- 8n4vidtmkvmk 2y agoWhat's wrong with tame and lack of innovation? Sometimes people just need to get things done. There are lots of businesses with basic needs that aren't being met.
- tourmalinetaco 2y agoEspecially amongst programmers the feeling of constantly pushing boundaries and grinding to a new unexplored territory is far more interesting than working on practical “tame” solutions. See for instance the amount of people who spend tons of time hacking at and opening up platforms for GNU/Linux that are poor fits for the OS. It would make far more practical sense for say Marcan to spend his time working on the Linux kernel more directly than playing around with Apple devices that are made to burn out in a year and become ewaste. However, he feels more satisfaction working on that “new frontier”, regardless of its practicality.
- seydor 2y agoPeople want a faster horse
- goatlover 2y agoAlso one that flies, fueled by atomic power.
- _xiaz 2y agoTo be fair, astral is the python company and thank god they are. I love ruff and uv
- tim333 2y agoA python company is too specialized but software companies are a thing, Maybe AI will be another tool for software companies.
- highfrequency 2y agoI'm not so sure. When a technological wave is big enough, it seems reasonable to start by asking: "what business can be built on this exponential wave?" This is contrary to standard YC advice (make something people want right away, don't create a solution in search of a problem) but empirically a lot of big companies started this way: - Bezos saw the growth rate of the internet, spent a few months mulling over the question: "what business would make sense to start in the context of massive internet adoption" and came up with an online bookstore. - OpenAI's ChatGPT effort really began when they saw Google's paper on transformers and decided to see how far they could push this technology (it's hard to imagine they forecasted all the chatbot usecases; in reality I'm sure they were just stoked to push the technology forward). - Intel was founded on the discovery of the integrated circuit, and again I think the dominant motivation was to see how far they could push transistor density with a very hazy vision at best of how the CPUs would eventually be used. I think the reason this strategy works is that the newness of a truly important technology counteracts much of the adverse selection of starting a new business. If you make a new To-Do iPhone app, it's unlikely that people have overlooked a great idea in that space over the last 10 years. But if lithium ion batteries only just barely started becoming energy dense enough to make a car, there's a much more plausible argument why you could be successful now. Said another way: "why hasn't this been done before?" (both by resource-rich incumbents as well as new entrants) is a good filter (and often a limiting one) for starting a business. New technological capabilities are one good answer to this question. Therefore if you're trying to come up with an idea for a business, it seems reasonable to look at new technologies that you think are actually important and then reason backward to what new businesses they enable. Two additional positive factors I can think of: 1. A common dynamic is that a new technology is progressing rapidly but is of course far behind traditional solutions at the outset. Thus it is difficult to find immediate applications, even if large applications are almost guaranteed in 10-20 years. Getting in early - during the borderline phase where most applications are very contrived - is often a big advantage. See Tesla Roadster (who wants a $100k electric sports car with 200mi range and minimal charging network?), early computers (what is the advantage of a slow machine with no GUI over doing work by hand?), and perhaps current LLMs (how valuable is a chatbot that frequently hallucinates and has trouble thinking critically in original ways)? It's the classic Innovator's Dilemma - we overweight the initial warts and don't properly forecast how quickly things are improving. 2. There is probably a helpful motivational force for many people if they get to feel that they are on the cutting edge of technology that interests them and building products that simply weren't possible two years ago.