5 ms·
Evidence stacks up for poisonous books containing toxic dyes
- lupusreal 2y agoBad idea to lick your fingers when leafing through Aristotle's lost treatise on laughter.
- baerrie 2y agoThis is from a movie right? I remember watching it but not the name.
- golan 2y agoThe name of the rose
- glandium 2y agoFrom the novel by Umberto Eco. With a French director, Sean Connery, Christian Slater, Ron Perlman and more. Great movie.
- mikub 2y agoYep great movie. Was filmed in 'Kloster Eberbach' germany, not far from where I live, always worth a visit. https://kloster-eberbach.de/ https://kloster-eberbach.de/
- amiga386 2y agoIt was also a good 8-part miniseries: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Name_of_the_Rose_(miniseries) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Name_of_the_Rose_(miniseri...
- seszett 2y ago> a French director Who even has a name: Jean-Jacques Annaud.
- redprince 2y agoIs is from a movie and a novel which the movie was based on. Both go by the title "The Name of the Rose". The author of the novel is Umberto Eco.
- klondike_klive 2y agoMy favourite Bond film. Where he goes undercover as a 14th century Benedictine Monk.
- Bluestein 2y ago(I was waiting for this comment :)
- DiscourseFan 2y agodon't remind me of all the great works buried deep in the in the cheek of history
- ErigmolCt 2y agoDefinitely a bad idea!
- bashmelek 2y agoThe motif also shows up in the 1001 Nights
- kreyenborgi 2y agohttps://sites.udel.edu/poisonbookproject/ https://sites.udel.edu/poisonbookproject/ ( via https://arstechnica.com/science/2024/08/that-book-is-poison-even-more-victorian-covers-found-to-contain-toxic-dyes/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2024/08/that-book-is-poison-... ) lists the New York Cook Book containing the lead chromate. Yum!
- lukas099 2y agoIt's too bad, because they are some beautiful book covers. Arsenic green: https://sites.udel.edu/poisonbookproject/arsenic-bookbindings/ https://sites.udel.edu/poisonbookproject/arsenic-bookbinding... Lead chromate yellow: https://sites.udel.edu/poisonbookproject/chrome-yellow-bookcloth/ https://sites.udel.edu/poisonbookproject/chrome-yellow-bookc...
- mandmandam 2y ago> "I find it fascinating to know what previous generations thought was safe, and then we learn, oh, actually, that might not have been a great idea to use these brilliant dyes," Weinstein-Webb says. Yep. William Morris was a divil for this, and refused to acknowledge the dangers well past when they were known. I wonder though - in terms of human potential and lives lost, do all of those examples put together come anywhere near what we're doing today with PFAS, microplastics, agricultural & industrial runoff, neonicotinoids, etc.? It's easy to point fingers now and laugh at the Victorians smearing lead pain on their face, or the folks taking radioactive suppositories for health... Fun too. But like... We're in the most glassy house imaginable. We know better, like Morris, but we're still letting people away with this stuff (and even imprisoning the activists fighting it). Takes a lot of the fun out of it :/
- SturgeonsLaw 2y agoThe thing too is that we know better, but we still use those toxic substances because the people who are profiting off it aren't the ones suffering ill effects. Well, at least the petrochemical people flooding the world with microplastics also have it in their bodies.
- mandmandam 2y ago> Well, at least the petrochemical people flooding the world with microplastics also have it in their bodies. Hate to smudge your consolation, but the tech is probably there for them to filter their blood now, or it will be soon. [0] Course, it will be far too expensive for poor people. Still! At least the microplastics in their brains will be harder to clean! [1] ... Seriously, these people need stopping. They're never going to stop on their own. 0 - https://www.mdpi.com/2673-8929/3/3/28 https://www.mdpi.com/2673-8929/3/3/28 1 - https://www.smh.com.au/national/human-brain-tissue-made-up-of-0-5-per-cent-microplastics-study-reveals-20240822-p5k4ed.html https://www.smh.com.au/national/human-brain-tissue-made-up-o...
- the8thbit 2y ago> 1 - https://www.smh.com.au/national/human-brain-tissue-made-up-o https://www.smh.com.au/national/human-brain-tissue-made-up-o... holy shit 1/200 molecules in your fucking brain is straight up plastic jesus christ
- Exuma 2y agoI like painting, and have always liked emerald green: https://www.winsornewton.com/na/articles/colours/spotlight-on-emerald-green/ https://www.winsornewton.com/na/articles/colours/spotlight-o...
- dghughes 2y agoFine. I won't eat the books then if they're poisonous.
- harimau777 2y agoSomething that I've noticed, that I wonder if it could be an useful (although very blunt force) heuristic for thinking about chemicals: Chemicals with strong effects (e.g. bright colors, the ability to permanently set dye, powerful adhesives and epoxies, breathable waterproofing, etc.) often achieve their effect via strong chemical reactions. Strong chemical reactions have a good chance of being able to interact with your body's chemical reactions and make you sick. Therefore, you should default to handling chemicals with strong effects with caution (e.g. wearing gloves and a respirator if there are fumes). Of course this is just a rule of thumb. Fruit juice is brightly colored but generally doesn't require special handling. Mineral sunscreen works via physical rather than chemical properties. Etc.
- pennomi 2y agoFruit juice also doesn’t retain its color over long periods of time. Good dyes in general are hard to make safely, and we use a lot of dyes in our society.
- tokai 2y ago>physical rather than chemical properties The field of physical chemistry is going to blow your mind.
- harimau777 2y agoYa, I'm definitely speaking in VERY broad strokes here because this isn't my area of expertise! I was just meaning that in comparison to what's called "chemical sunscreen" which, according to my admittedly limited understanding, works by undergoing a chemical reaction when exposed to UV.
- tokai 2y agoI understand, I just couldn't help myself :)
- kragen 2y agothis is backwards. yes, the un-set dye is reactive. but the set dye isn't reactive. that's what's 'set' about it
- ralferoo 2y agoIt didn't seem to be mentioned in the article, but have these covers always been unsafe to handle, or has the problem got worse as the books get older and maybe the chemicals are more likely to leech out or be released as dust etc? If they've always been toxic, I'm kind of surprised that it wasn't noticed at the time. And presumably, there was a point when we stopped using these dyes. Was that because we knew the risks they posed, in which case why did we lose that knowledge, or was it just that we switched to cheaper processes that just happened to be safer?
- tokai 2y agoThey were always toxic, and people got poisoned. Generally safety was not something victorians spend a lot of energy on. Sometimes things are weird like that. Like how lead was put in petrol even when the toxicity of lead was known.
- llm_trw 2y agoVictorians put a lot of energy on safety. It's just that the safety they cared about was vastly different to what were the actual things killing them. If you want a modern take on it observe our obsession with stranger danger for children while we happily fill them up with plastic.
- viscountchocula 2y agoWhat was the safety they cared about?
- jzemeocala 2y agoI'm curious as well.
- ThinkingGuy 2y agoFor one thing, they really seem to have worried about accidentally being buried alive: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Safety_coffin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Safety_coffin
- kragen 2y agothis is overblown copper acetoarsenite is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paris_green https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paris_green and is deadly, but still used by artists as a pigment today (though it's no longer used for things like wallpaper, clothing, and rat poison) lead oxide is a mild concern; it's sweet, and back when it was the most common white pigment for painting houses, kids would chew on it. at that time there was a massive subclinical lead poisoning outbreak that probably resulted in an unprecedented decades-long crime wave in the usa, but that was probably more due to leaded gasoline than the paint. and the amount that can potentially flake off a book is even smaller than what kids got chewing on paint chips but lead chromate is basically nontoxic under any normal exposure conditions. it's something you don't want to eat, though people commonly use it as a food dye; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lead(II)_chromate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lead(II)_chromate says: > Despite containing both lead and hexavalent chromium, lead chromate is not acutely lethal because of its very low solubility. The LD50 for rats is only 5,000 mg/kg. Lead chromate must be treated with great care in its manufacture, the main concerns being dust of the chromate precursor. (...) It is used (illegally) to enhance the color of certain spices, particularly turmeric,[8][9] particularly in Bangladesh. (...) Unlike other lead-based paint pigments, lead chromate is still widely used, especially in road marking paint. and lead sulfide is pretty much completely nontoxic. there's no way to get lead poisoning from it. that's why egg whites are an antidote to lead poisoning. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lead(II)_sulfide#Safety https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lead(II)_sulfide#Safety if you tried to murder someone with lead chromate and lead sulfide, you would fail. they would probably be unharmed now, it's also possible the lead is in some other form that's more dangerous. and it's not clear that you'd put lead sulfide in a book on purpose; it's black, but carbon is cheaper, and making carbon black is both safer and easier. so maybe the excess lead is in some form that's of real concern. but the compounds they've identified are harmless, except for the green menace we already knew about phys.org and the acs should be ashamed of having printed this baseless fearmongering
- retrac 2y agoDeath, magic, alchemy, transmutation, poison (and so perhaps by extension, radiation) are all associated with fluorescent green to some degree. (Do a Google image search for "necromancy" or "poisonous dragon" and the majority colour is fluorescent green.) This might be partly influenced by the arsenic greens of the Victorian era.
- _ntka 2y agoRadiation would perhaps be better pictured with a light blue glow (Cherenkov radiation). The green glow used in pop culture has its origin in the widespread use of radium paint to achieve a glow-in-the-dark effect (e.g. on watch faces) in the early 20th century. I still own a radium watch. The paint was always fluorescent green. And it did glow.
- BoxOfRain 2y agoIsn’t it usually the phosphor that wears out rather than the radium decaying that stops them glowing? Would it be possible for someone with the correct safety equipment to apply a new layer of fluorescent paint?
- cyberax 2y agoIt's possible, but it's a bad idea, unless you just want it for display in a sealed case. If you want a sane version, get modern tritium-based glowing capsules.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 2y agoThere's an allegory in there. Toxic books.
- sharksauce 2y agoAny Nethack veteran knows this can happen to you if you try to read a cursed spellbook.
- hatenberg 2y agoObligatory William of Baskerville quote "Monkeys do not laugh. Laughter is particular to men"
- hinkley 2y agoI thought this was something new, but it’s Vienna Green still out there causing mayhem every time we forget about Vienna Green. Which they don’t even mention, they just call it copper acetoarsenite. Nobody is going to call a Victorian book or wallpaper “copper acetoarsenite” they’re gonna call it what it is, which is Vienna Green.