10 ms·
Greenwich schools to ban most cellphones, Apple Watches, Fitbits and more
- xoa 2y agoHaving used a Palm Pilot to genuine benefit in highschool in the 90s, and having finally just gotten a smart watch in part specifically to reduce smartphone usage, I have mixed feelings about broad restrictions. Networked smart phones absolutely have major addictive and disruptive effects, and are hard to police in practice. But watches provide some pretty useful health and emergency benefits, while IME have lived up to my hopes of being high enough friction/miserable enough to use for browsing or the like that the effect is nothing like a phone. Putting it all in the same bucket feels overboard, though maybe is necessary in practice. But pendulums seem to often have a tendency to swing between extremes and I wish officials were willing to try more tailored measures before sledgehammers more often. Still I think the overall trend looks positive.
- tourmalinetaco 2y agoMe and my wife were discussing this earlier, and we both agreed we missed the days of cellphones + PDAs. That era was so much less predatory to our time, and there’s something to be said about the mental separation between “fun text time” and a dedicated work device. It’s just a shame that given the current technological landscape the closest we have to PDAs are tablets, which are typically too large to pocket (and nonetheless an attractive option).
- katzinsky 2y agoMan I miss PDAs. My dad worked for 3com so I had a palm since about when I learned to read. I was early with smartphones because I thought they'd essentially be PDAs with a modem ("They're just working out the kinks.") Smartphones have to be the most disappointing thing that's happened to consumer computing. It's kind of funny that with pervasive networking I miss having to be mindful and sync everything I wanted to take with me.
- tyre 2y agoyeah let em have flip phones with T9 word and snake. those Nokias had the benefit of being invincible
- BlueTemplar 2y agoSmartphones and tablets do come in all sizes : https://ewritable.com/best-e-ink-tablets/#Best_Dedicated_Note-Taker_Supernote_A6X2_Nomad https://ewritable.com/best-e-ink-tablets/#Best_Dedicated_Not...
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> watches provide some pretty useful health and emergency benefits Fitbits let you “see calls, texts & smartphone app notifications on your wrist when your phone is nearby” [1]. It has all the attention, focus and de-socialisation problems of a smartphone. [1] https://www.fitbit.com/global/us/products/smartwatches/sense2?sku=521BKGB https://www.fitbit.com/global/us/products/smartwatches/sense...
- cwillu 2y agoUnless a fitbit has a convenient keyboard I've been missing for years, no, it does not remotely have all of the attention, focus and de-socialisation problems.
- asadotzler 2y agoProbably 90% of what kids do on phones is consumption, not production.
- umbra07 2y agoOf social media. Not texts - and tbeir friends can't message them during school hours anyways.
- WalterBright 2y ago> But watches provide some pretty useful health and emergency benefits For kids? How ever did anyone survive before 1990.
- xoa 2y ago>How ever did anyone survive before I really, really hate this mindless, lazy line of argument in general. It gets tossed out with absolutely everything, from the internet to vaccines to modern farming. The simple answer in many cases to "how did anyone survive before X" is "well, often they didn't". Life expectancies were in fact lower in the past. More people died, or were maimed, with no hope of treatment. Or sometimes it's "they did, but much less efficiently and we come to depend on each growth of the economy which at the foundation is literally about being able to do things more efficiently". Ease of communication, knowing what the weather is, all sorts of things mean less wasteful use of time and energy. Sometimes "they did, but perhaps less happily". A loved relative was in and accident, went to the hospital and you never got the chance to be involved when it mattered. And of course in some cases it's "new things have created downsides that create a need for other new things, the world has changed". Sometimes we can do something about that in the near term. Sometimes we cannot. Low effort responses like you made are discouraged on HN for good reason. Yeah, absolutely new negatives have come with the new positives and seeking to reduce the former matters. But productive discussion and activity tends to focus on specifics vs generalities. Reducing the benefits of real time communication devices to a binary "life/death" and then NOT grappling with modern trends in everything from natural disasters to school shootings to reduced bussing doesn't strike me as great Walter.
- WalterBright 2y agoI stand by my assertion. How many times in your 12 years in school was instant 24/7 communication for everyone in the school been of significant benefit, or would have been if they had it? It's zero in my case. Then look at the downsides, which are pervasive - inattention, disruption, distraction. If you still want it, put a landline phone in each classroom on the teacher's desk. The principal can also have a switch to turn it off in an emergency.
- noufalibrahim 2y agoI can sort of squint and see the logic in your argument but I'm not convinced that allowing smart devices in schools and especially during class hours has enough good to consider seriously. I don't let my kids use a smart phone for entertainment. They use it sometimes for chatGPT and Google translate especially when they study but not beyond that and I intend to keep it that way till they're old enough (17 or so).
- knallfrosch 2y ago> But watches provide some pretty useful health and emergency benefits I'm sure you can get an exception for a glucose monitor if you have diabetes.
- bitwize 2y agoGood. School is not the time or the place for that. I think there's something to be said for banning smartphones while allowing cellphones that can take calls like feature phones. Nevertheless, I hate to be that guy -- one of the Gen Xers now seen yelling at clouds on TikTok -- but we seemed to manage just fine when anything called a "phone" was connected to the wall, not constantly on our person; and if our parents wished to reach us at school they had to call the front office and ask for us. Smartphones, those endless distraction generators, have about as much place in school as do Game Boys and Nintendo Switches. The ability to focus is a habit you can develop; school is a great place to learn that habit while you're still young.
- trte9343r4 2y ago[flagged]
- DiggyJohnson 2y agoDo you have personal experience with this or something? Seems like a rather specific fear.
- trte9343r4 2y ago[flagged]
- NotACop182 2y agoI got a solution for you then. Any kid caught using their phone in school is expelled. We shall put personal responsibility and consequences as the primary objective. Does this solve your issue.
- trte9343r4 2y ago[flagged]
- Version467 2y agoAre you alright? This reads like it was written by someone actively experiencing psychosis or a manic episode.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- trte9343r4 2y agoI am quite alright, thanks. Just want dog owners to take some responsibility.
- NotACop182 2y ago
- skybrian 2y agoI’m wondering what the distraction potential of a Fitbit is? Do they have more features now?
- pacbard 2y agoMy guess is that they had prior experience with asking students not to use cellphones and they observed students start using wearables to skirt the ban, which led them to just ban all of them. An interesting consequence about the wearable ban is that they also banned medical electronic devices (e.g., heart monitors or blood sugar monitors) and parents are required to meet with administration to approve their use [1]. [1]: https://greenwichfreepress.com/schools/greenwich-schools-announces-cell-phone-policy-220517/ https://greenwichfreepress.com/schools/greenwich-schools-ann...
- rrobukef 2y agoPacemaker and hearing aids as well, eventually a temp-teacher will cause a right mess.
- mbrumlow 2y agoIf they asked them not to use cell phones and they did not follow the rules, what will happen when they are banned? Simply put. They had rules in place but failed to enforce them. Why will banning them make the enforcement problem solved?
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Why will banning them make the enforcement problem solved? Whether the phone was being used is debatable. Whether it exists is not. Banning makes communication and enforcement easier.
- mbrumlow 2y agoWe have videos of kids attacking teachers for taking away devices. These things, whether we like it are not, are ingrained in society. Taking a phone away can be akin to saying you are going to cut a part of my brain out. Kids fe still going to bring them, and kids are going to still feel as it’s their right to have them. On top of that only a few people in the sv bubble would agree with taking phones away.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- teruakohatu 2y agoNew Zealand just banned student mobile phones recently in all schools [1]. I would guess LTE connected devices would also count. I think banning fitness trackers is a bit much, they are very useful for sports such as cycling, running, tri & swimming. [1] https://www.education.govt.nz/school/digital-technology/cellphones/ https://www.education.govt.nz/school/digital-technology/cell...
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> banning fitness trackers is a bit much Fitbits let you “see calls, texts & smartphone app notifications on your wrist when your phone is nearby” [1]. Unless you’re doing a full backpack and pocket search, permitting Fitbits seems like a guaranteed loophole. [1] https://www.fitbit.com/global/us/products/smartwatches/sense2?sku=521BKGB https://www.fitbit.com/global/us/products/smartwatches/sense...
- t-writescode 2y agoIf you can't respond, what's the problem?
- neverartful 2y agoWouldn't it still be an unnecessary distraction for the student?
- zarzavat 2y agoAs opposed to all the other bullshit going on in schools? Wouldn’t even register.
- WillPostForFood 2y agoOne way, inbound sms is like 1 out of 100 in distractions, whereas having a phone with internet, social media, bidirectional messaging is 100 out of 100.
- haswell 2y agoI forget who originally suggested this so I can’t take credit. But what if device manufacturers worked with schools to implement some kind of “School Mode” on these devices? Students could retain their access in exchange for schools setting policies on what’s allowed, e.g. you can keep wearing your watch, but it’s effectively in collection-only mode during the school day. Nothing intrusive to the students; more like Apple’s “Focus” modes but mandatory on school property. I can also imagine all kinds of technical issues with this, but as our devices become increasingly wearable and integrated with daily life, it seems like a ban is only a temporarily viable solution, even if it’s the right option at this moment.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> what if device manufacturers worked with schools to implement some kind of “School Mode” on these devices? How would you enforce this? > as our devices become increasingly wearable and integrated with daily life, it seems like a ban is only a temporarily viable solution I’m a strong proponent of these technologies. But the truth is we mandate, and as a result do, zero testing on how it affects kids before deploying them. For the consumer market, test after selling makes sense. For kids, European-style whitelisting might be better. We are trending towards a world where kids of the poor and middle class are addicted to screens. That’s a horrifying class divide.
- haswell 2y agoEnforcement is definitely one of the sticking points, but seems solvable. The simplest option would be a geofence on school grounds, but I realize this comes with issues and kids will figure out how to bypass it. Another approach is to have some kind of scan-in/scan-out system where you’re allowed to maintain physical access by scanning some device upon entering the school which has been programmed to safely enable the mode without requiring intrusive access to the device itself. It’d unlock upon scanning out for the day or by a parent. This would require deep integration by Apple/Google/etc. similar to Apple’s work on digital driver’s licenses. I describe a beacon-based approach in a sibling reply. I think a feature set like this would need to be fairly dumb in that it should not require positive identification of individuals and should instead be focused on a fairly simple binary “you scanned into a limited area” type of decision. I don’t know how I feel about these options or even the whole approach, but I’m bringing them up mostly as a way to explore the concept.
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoThere is a striking divide between how the rich and FAANG employed treat technology around their kids versus everyone else. The single most potent difference I’ve seen as a result is their kids’ ability to maintain eye contact during conversation.
- Loughla 2y agoEveryone in our life has spoken about how impressed they are by our kids' ability to have conversations. My friend group asks us what the secret is. Secret: very limited phone and tablet time. Like how life was for millennia before smartphones.
- tirant 2y agoSame situation here. Everyone loves how much and how well our kids can speak despite being trilingual (we speak three languages at home), and how rich their vocabulary is compared to monolingual kids around us (studies show delayed language development in bilingual and trilingual kids) The difference is that their screen time is around 30 mins to 1 hour per week. While for other kids I observe easily that amounts to at least a couple of hours per day. Obviously parenting becomes easier with screens around. But being a parent is not about choosing the easiest path for yourself.
- Jolter 2y agoJoke’s on you, I’ve never been able to maintain eye contact with anyone and I grew up long before smartphones were a thing.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> I’ve never been able to maintain eye contact with anyone and I grew up long before smartphones were a thing Sorry. I was using eye contact as an indicator of involvement, focus and a general ability to engage in conversation. I didn’t mean to suggest it’s bad per se. I have colleagues on the spectrum. They don’t tend to maintain eye contact when they speak. But their conversation is deeply engaging. The cell phone kids, on the other hand, have a specific vacant gaze that, once you see it, almost gives an “is anybody home” vibe. Their sentences are short and abrupt, diction well below where it should be at their age. (And these aren’t stupid kids. They’re just bad at interacting off screen.)
- WalterBright 2y ago[flagged]
- noah32 2y agoi think the fcc might have something to say about that
- WalterBright 2y agoFix the fcc.
- zamadatix 2y agoThe FCC is already on a pretty optimal answer in this case, it's physics you'd want to fix. Completely jamming all cell signals disrupts the public and private airspace well beyond the school.
- WalterBright 2y agoI'm not an electromagnetic radiation expert, but I know my garage door opener has a useful range of about 10 feet, and my wifi about 30 feet.
- zamadatix 2y agoIt's difficult to explain accurately without making one into an RF expert but you've essentially said the radio equivalent of "my headphones aren't really useful past 10 feet" and concluding any sound so loud as to make the headphone use unintelligible across an entire school would also cease to exist a few feet away. If one absolutely had to get rid of usable signals originating from outside the school a much more practical way would be to add RF shielding to the exterior elements. After all, if you want to get rid of a signal then subtracting it even intuitively feels a lot more reasonable than trying to add so much other signal you don't notice the original anymore.
- chrisamiller 2y agoOur middle school has banned phones during school hours, and it's been great. Even though most kids own phones and have them in their backpacks, they aren't seen. There are less problems during classes and kids have to talk to each other during lunch instead of going head down in their phones. Parental pushback has been really minimal - most parents love it, and it's good for the kids. Making no phones a blanket policy in all schools should be an absolute no-brainer.
- sweeter 2y agoit's all good until that thing that happens at American schools, happens... That is my one hang up here. It would be idealistic to believe that the Police would protect kids, but in reality there are far too many cases of them being grossly negligent in this exact circumstance... in many of those cases, having a phone played a pivotal role in security. I don't want to get too far into details on HN for the sake of keeping things civil, but I hope you catch my drift. Im sure there is some happy medium solution here, like putting your phone in a basket or cubby or something like that, at the very least. But I think this is something that has to be seriously addressed and considered. Phones are obviously bad for all of us, more so for children whose minds are far more elastic and far more prone to social alienation. The endless stream of notifications is almost at a gambling / casino level. I think you have to address the root cause of that as well
- nytesky 2y agoBetween teachers phones, intercoms, cameras, and hardline phones there should be plenty of communication equipment available for a crisis. If anything having a phone could put someone in jeopardy by making noise and giving away position or distracting owner. What is the scenario that it has helped? Have police coordinated response based upon students phoned in reports and telemetry?
- stackskipton 2y agoNot really. There have been phone calls to 911 during school shootings but reading a few reports, it's never made a difference since schools tend to be hardwired straight to dispatch which is most important. Big failings like Uvalde has been terrible response by first responders which is "Push forward till threat has ended." Yes, parents have been called by students during incident but that generally makes situation worse as parents run to the school causing delays for first responders.
- troyvit 2y agoMy daughter's school gives all the kids ipads and she got a new one this year. The IT guy gave it to her before locking it down so she installed all the dumb apps she wanted on it before handing it back over. The point, aside from how proud I am of my daughter, is that kids are going to find a way to get what they want. This is an arms race. It'll be interesting to watch.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mixmastamyk 2y agoLocal morons gave ours an ipad with its own data plan, free access to youtube, and screentime disabled. I had zero control but to physically take it. Bet you can’t wait to find out what happened next! Many months later we got a stern letter that yt had to be blocked because students weren’t using it for assignments. Who could have predicted such a thing? :-P It all started during covid too so I had very limited ability to say no.
- zamadatix 2y agoI think that's two separate battles which are part of the same topic. Battle #1 is combining the complexity and abundance of electronic devices with the time, dedication, and cleverness of kids requires (literally) writing a bug free operating system & application ecosystem as well as nearly every school employee having a completely accurate understanding of how to manage them. The goal here is never to get to 100% compliance but to add friction to noncompliance so it's easier for workers to do their job and get through the day. Battle #2 (the part these kinds of bans focus on) is on setting expectations for when electronic devices are allowed at all. Whether or not students always comply isn't even the goal of this battle, it's all about making the problem clear and swift to deal with: "I saw your phone during school hours so you're caught and it's confiscated" isn't about preventing kids from being sneaky, it's about making the enforcement easy.
- rpcope1 2y agoI've never heard a good, convincing explanation as to why on earth children need iPads for any reason. Are the schools just not doing their jobs, and letting the iPads "teach" the children rather than a person doing it?
- FabHK 2y agoGood idea. If individual parents prohibit their kid from using a cellphone in school, it would be standing out in a weird way, thus creating a classical collective-action problem, tragedy of the commons etc. The school taking the step to ban the devices fixes it.
- thedingwing 2y agoI went to high school when cell phones were common and most students had them. But, at least at my school, if you had one out during class it was instantly confiscated and returned by the front office after school. I assumed this was the norm, so articles about "cell phone bans" as a new policy are surprising to me. I assumed it always was this way. When did schools start allowing cell phone use during class? Do teachers no longer have the power to confiscate devices that are used at inappropriate times?
- jimbob45 2y agoSame policy here. Seemed like it worked just fine. If you really needed to use it, you had time between periods and during lunch.
- teekert 2y agoUsing a phone during class was indeed never an option, but, can I ask you since you went to school with smartphones (I am much older): Is your experience that most students pull their phone out as soon as they exit the classrooms? Do they spend most of their breaks on their screens? If so do you have the feeling you have poorer conversational skills because of this and would you not rather have just enjoyed school engaging with the people around you? I see youngsters now that have hundreds of messages a day, on many platforms, and consequently hours of screen time a day. Does it not feel like this time would be better spends in face to face engagements? I read about girls that are just tired, they have a good time, everybody gossips on Social Media, they have to maintain "status" there, streaks, presence, likes, it never ends, last thing before sleep, first thing after waking up. It sounds so exhausting.
- hparadiz 2y agoBanning cell phones from class hours doesn't actually change the social media rat race in any way. You still have to maintain presence. That's just part of being social. We had the same distractions before smart phones. We would just hide in the computer lab and browse the Internet while playing games and trying to look busy. A hundred messages sounds like about a half hour of conversation on any chat platform. We would still play games on our calculators, sign in to IRC, and post on forums. Now it's cell phone games, discord, and twitter but really it's the same shit. The idea behind banning cell phones is more about attention span and the unfortunate reality of constant dopamine hits.
- danielodievich 2y agoOur school district is implementing identical thing, very similar, justifying this with health and emotional wellness and anti-cyber-bullying. They are checking in the phones into Yondr pouches. I wish them luck on the implementation... I think there have a steep challenge ahead of them. One thing my boys told me is that they have QR codes for homework/assignments/worksheets that everyone used phones to scan and do work on there with GSuite - and the school provided laptops won't be able to do this. The that everyone in K-8 everyone has can do QRs okay though.
- ImJamal 2y agoWhat ever happened to blackboard and the like?
- chgs 2y agoBlackboard is part of the problem A Mobile First Approach to Learning Today's active learners have a need for speed. The Blackboard App gives students the information they want, the connections they crave, and the personalisation they demand, on the go. We're putting learning directly in the hands of your students, so they can stay connected with their educational journey anytime, anywhere.
- knallfrosch 2y ago> The Economist: American parents want their children to have phones in schools | But phones in the classroom are disruptive. What should schools do? > The adults unlock the [Yondr] pouches with special magnets as pupils leave for the day. > Unsurprisingly, pupils have hacked the system. (“What do you expect?” Eva says. “We’re middle-schoolers.”) The girls recite a list of workarounds. Those magnets have become hot commodities, and a few have gone missing. Pupils have been seen banging pouches open in the toilets. Other pupils have faulty cases that no longer lock but have kept that information to themselves. The girls say that since phones have become a forbidden fruit, pupils only crave them more. https://www.economist.com/united-states/2024/06/06/american-parents-want-their-children-to-have-phones-in-schools https://www.economist.com/united-states/2024/06/06/american-...
- dyauspitr 2y agoGreat move. This along with banning under 18 social media use should be nationwide.
- teekert 2y agoHere in the Netherlands many (middle) schools have banned them by now, just in time for my son to enter school. Looking forward to him having nice conversations with his schoolmates. I hope his generation is not like some of the students we got at our company who join the lunches but picked seats at the very edge of the table and had their eyes on their screen the whole time. Yes, every youngster has some fears communicating with people experienced in their proffssion of choice, but it is up to the experience people to engage with them and up to them to do the same. Locking themselves out of conversations during lunch is not a habit that builds good and valuable relations with colleagues. It really feels like these youngsters are addicted, or at least they are not in the habit of joining conversations, lacking the skill as everyone does at the start, but now also a method available to avoid honing those skills.
- jhoechtl 2y agoThese bans will come worldwide. Soon we will also understand the realtionship between mental disorders in teens and "always on". Not to mention the distraction these devices generate in schools.
- McDyver 2y agoIn some countries (namely Portugal and France) you are not allowed to be contacted by your employer out of office hours, so that you can get that disconnect. At the same time, children are targeted to be constantly "on" and "engaged", and we seem to be OK with that.
- Hamuko 2y agoThe general agreement for the IT services sector in Finland says that we're entitled to an hour's wage if we need to take phone calls outside working/on-call time. Two hours for 21-06, Sundays and holidays. Granted, it's one of those clauses that can be negotiated down in one's contract.
- underbooter 2y agoI was in Greenwich Public Schools from K-12 and graduated GHS 2016. One kid in my elementary school, Alessandro Espa, brought his first-gen iPod Touch to class in 4th or 5th grade. He was showing off the magic trick apps of the age: the lighter, soda/beer. The only tech hardware we'd used before then was old iMacs with yellowed vinyl keyboard covers and ancient Windows XP desktops. The Touch was like a magic alien object. Everyone was magnetically attracted to looking at it. It looked like a shiny stainless steel candy bar. Everyone in the room knew immediately they'd be the coolest if they got a phone by high school. Previous generations got flip phones in high school - around the time they got their learner's permit. The only apps were calling, SMS, or tetris. You could tell how cool a phone was by its color. Forget swappable screen backgrounds; the coolest phone of 2006 had colorful swappable front and back plastic plates. Sending text messages was powerful before phones arrived. It was basically telekinesis. I missed that entire era. My generation was not satisfied with just SMS. They needed to be organizing parties through emails. They needed to be trading drugs and candy through Snapchat. They needed to be covertly taking photos of classmates and teachers and emailing them to each other. They needed to be coordinating fractal-style bullying strategies through group chats. By the time I got to 9th grade, every one of my peers had phones: first gen Androids, Blackberries, Samsung S, their parents' old iPhones. Everything happened at once. Facebook. Twitter. Instagram. Temple Run. Minecraft. Tumblr. Hidemyass. Snapchat. Pinterest. I missed the boat on most of those, but Tumblr was fun. Some friends from Syosset and I did wacky role-playing games via the anonymous question asking boxes. It was the highlight of the year. Bart Palosz committed suicide after some kids (whose names GPS has still managed, or been bribed, to conceal) bullied him and smashed his phone. Did they ever see any consequences? In 11th grade, was told by a teacher that I should be happy when I scratched my laptop because it meant I wouldn't be able to worship it anymore. The teacher was right. After my 10th grade the school instituted a Chromebook program. I never picked mine up. As far as I know students only ever used them to write Google docs, watch porn, play Miniclip flash games, cyberbully each other, and click through shitty Aplia homeworks. Did any of you HN readers work on or found Aplia? If so, fuck you. Especially you, Paul Romer. As far as I'm concerned the $250 the Chromebooks cost apiece would have been better spent on $100 of books, $100 of legal pads, and $50 of nice pens and pencils and erasers. But tragically, one just can't hustle your way to the top of GPS IT and earn a six-figure salary in Connecticut by promoting old-fashioned tech that has worked for hundreds of years. No; you need to be selling Silicon Valley dogwater HTML and plastic. The district has a history of being dependent on technology to appear forward thinking. It aims to appear 2-3 years ahead of the rest of the country, so nobody can say "GPS should have known better!" The only reason they're so happily agreeing to "ban" phones is that nothing has changed in the last 5-6 years. Students have gotten dumber and more addicted to technology. There's no more new technology to get a raise from introducing except maybe LLMs. P.S. I would bet $10,000 GPS won't genuinely enforce the ban due to threats from the 20ish students in the system with paranoid billionare helicopter parents. Sent from my iPhone
- hannob 2y agoI mean, I somehow understand the motivation behind a phone ban. But Fitbits? I understand there's probably a problem creating a clear separation, but in times where lack of movement and exercise is causing major health problems, we probably shouldn't disincentivize young people using fitness devices.
- NeoTar 2y agoI think the assumption that having a Fitbit, or other fitness device increases movement and activity levels in under-18s needs confirmation. In fact, to be honest I'd not be convinced that it works even in over-18s.
- pndy 2y agoI'd guess it's because even small thing as band can provide some of kids distraction. It's not about if you can play games on such device but play with it, touch, wander around the interface - had enough distraction to not focus on class and teacher. Bands are being perceived as digital rattles here.
- knallfrosch 2y agoWearing a tracker doesn't actually increase your fitness.
- Ylpertnodi 2y agoIt will track some things you do to improve fitness. I had a fitbit (until it crapped out, and i lost faith in the company) and would walk in the mornings, lunchtimes and - if i hadn't got my steps in - I'd walk at night, too. Without a tracker - as i am now - up, work, home: and certainly not as fit as i was when using a tracker.
- tuggi 2y agohttp://archive.today/nsNqA http://archive.today/nsNqA
- Refusing23 2y agomy kid has a phone that is so boring to use (only snake, texting and calling) that he has it in the bottom of his backpack and only takes it out when he needs to call me its truly amazing and i hope to keep it this way forever. meanwhile the rest of his class mates have smartphones and stare at it from the moment they leave their home ... and i assume till it runs out of battery. they dont even watch where they're going.
- dyauspitr 2y agoI dread the day when my daughter (who is now 3) tells me that she is a laughing stock and pariah because she misses out on every event that happens at school because she doesn’t have a smart phone/no social media. The only way to correctly do this is to outright ban kids from having smart phones and accessing social media nationwide. Being the handful that selectively buck the system is a hard road.
- chgs 2y agoYou’re absolutely right (I suspect some have read this as 3 year olds need phones). But aren’t kids already banned from many places they congregate. WhatsApp, Fortnite, etc. A ban only works if 1) significant numbers support it 2) the ban is enforced And neither of those are likely outside of school, and in my experience are unlikely in school.
- dyauspitr 2y agoOh yeah, to clarify, I mean when she like 10. I believe banning kids from using smart phones is much more enforceable than individual bans on particular sites
- monero-xmr 2y agoI had a gameboy with a special cartridge loaded with roms I ordered from a strange European import site that took 3 months to arrive, and this was 2002! I played video games in every class. I was a bad student. I set a bad example. Yet learning how to load roms on it, the firmware, the command line. My poor mother didn't know what to do with me - I was constantly late, skipping school, in detention, hanging out with burn outs. My siblings didn't do that stuff until college. And now I'm wealthy and the most successful graduate of a 700 person class! Food for thought for the parents of "burn out" tech addicted youths...
- dt3ft 2y agoGood.
- iamnotsure 2y agoMost schools do not expect being banned by cellphones, watches and more.
- chgs 2y agoOur son’s high school (Shropshire) requires a phone - homework is set via app (no website option), sometimes homework requires an app to do it, all comms is via app (so parent also need an app) They are sometimes told to get their phones out in class to perform work. In theory phones are banned outside these hours, but unless a teacher is in the room that’s not enforced.
- kwhitefoot 2y agoHow can a UK school require a mobile as an educational tool? I thought primary and secondary education was supposed to be free in the UK.
- lukecarr 2y agoCan't speak on behalf of GP, but I suspect when they said "require," it's more loose than that. I've experienced UK schools that have a shared pool of iPads for students who haven't got a compatible device (for a multitude of reasons). So in that sense, students "require" a device from the perspective of learning, but don't "require" to own one outright (so it's not a barrier to education).
- n4r9 2y agoOP may send their child to a private secondary school, like 18% of secondary school students in the UK. Private schools tend to have kids from wealthier backgrounds as well as the resources to provide devices to those who can't afford them. A friend of mine works in a boarding school where the pupils are provided tablets in order to do their work, join video calls etc... .
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ta8903 2y agoLooks to me like Greenwich is really mean on timekeeping devices.
- kwhitefoot 2y agoWhy can't the children be taught to behave better?