5 ms·
I’m completely sympathetic to that view. However, until such data breaches regularly lead to severe outcomes for subjects whose data was leaked, and those outco
by layer8 2y ago
I’m completely sympathetic to that view. However, until such data breaches regularly lead to severe outcomes for subjects whose data was leaked, and those outcomes can be causally linked to the breaches in an indisputable manner, I’m afraid that we won’t see any such penalties.
- croemer 2y agoVery good point. In addition, my email address etc has been breached so many times that each extra leak has almost no marginal impact.
- Loughla 2y agoIs almost like publicly accessible information like email, phone, address, and, honestly, ss# at this point shouldn't be used for anything serious that doesn't require some sort of authentication beyond itself. Weird.
- BobbyTables2 2y agoAnd the fact that this is now pretty obvious seems to make such continued use an astounding display of mass negligence.
- franga2000 2y agoCredential stuffing isn't the only threat. Leaked emails and phone numbers become spam and phishing targets and phishing can get a lot more convincing when they also have your home address and other details.
- stackskipton 2y ago>However, until such data breaches regularly lead to severe outcomes for subjects whose data was leaked, and those outcomes can be causally linked to the breaches in an indisputable manner Which means nothing gets done because it's pretty hard to prove where any one misusing your information got it from. My identity was stolen after breach but when I took it up with entity that lost my information, they were like "Prove it" which of course I couldn't because people who did it to me were never caught.
- davisr 2y agoI own my email domain, and I register for each service with a different address. For example, flightaware-20240817@mydomain.net. This way, I know where my email addresses leak from.
- michaelteter 2y agoWith some email services including Gmail and Protonmail you can add +whatever to your username part of the email address to get the same result. My name+flightaware@gmail.com for example… And many mail hosting services let you assign a catch-all, which allows you to simply use anything@mydomain.com to get the same result.
- maeil 2y agoThe former would seem ineffective, surely anyone buying such a dataset would just remove the "+___" part in emails that have them?
- iamacyborg 2y agoWhy would they bother?
- InvertedRhodium 2y agoTo limit evidence of culpability in the event of a data leak exactly like the one we’re discussing.
- iamacyborg 2y agoWhy would the hacker care about that?
- daedalus_j 2y agoBecause they assume you've set name+spam@gmail.com to be filtered directly to spam, and they can easily evade those filters by removing the ±spam part. Big companies do this. I have signed up for things using a +filter email address, only to receive the emails from that company that is signed up to get at my plane address, without the +filter part.
- MrJohz 2y agoWith GDPR, simply leaking personal data is enough to earn you penalties. If your security is insufficient that someone can take this much personal data (and based on some of the other comments here it was a lot of personal data), then you have not upheld your responsibility according to GDPR. So I disagree, we don't need to wait until the data breaches lead to any particular outcomes, we need laws that make it clear that data breaches alone constitute damages to the people whose data was released. More people should be protected by GDPR-style laws, and more companies need to recognise that data security is something they need to take deeply seriously.
- robertlagrant 2y agoIs there precedent for this? E.g. if I accidentally sell a faulty door lock, does that constitute damages automatically? Don't damages require damage?
- MrJohz 2y agoMy private details leaking is damage, that's the point here. If I trust you with my confidential details (which can be anything from my bank details to my email address), and your data security protocols mean that my data gets stolen, then I have suffered damages, and GDPR comes into play.
- dwattttt 2y agoIANAL. Damages are relevant in-so-far as a relevant law addresses or requires them. Nothing stops a law from assuming damages under some circumstances.
- District5524 2y agoThat's not how it works. I think you are mixing up damages to be awarded by courts to an individual data subject (right to compensation, Article 82) with penalties (Article 83-84) - the latter having a special meaning, in practice covering the administrative fines by authorities (DPAs). There was a case by the ECJ (C 300/21) saying that for damages to be awarded to the individual, they have to prove the material or non-material damages involved. Regardless, any data protection authority can and do fine companies for breaches such as this one and also for late filing, and while DPAs also have to take into account the damages caused to data subjects when deciding the amount of fine, that's not a standard that has to be proven for each data subject separately and is therefore not as strict as the right to compensation. FlightAware definitely should be fined... Like Booking, NTT or Twitter or banks for breach obligations, for more than €400k. But it's still strange that very few US companies were fined so far in relation to no or late breach notifications - not that they were not fined heavily for failure to comply with other obligations. https://www.enforcementtracker.com/ https://www.enforcementtracker.com/
- amsterdorn 2y agoI don't like this take, companies use this same mentality to justify inaction with their impact on climate change. Who decides what a "severe" outcome is? The companies themselves? Why don't we hold them to a higher standard?
- harshaxnim 2y agoOf course it's not a likeable take, but it's a grounded one. And it's exactly the reason why companies don't care about climate change either.
- croemer 2y agoClimate change is a terrible analogy because: a) everyone is impacted by climate change, not just the customers who gave their data b) climate change has very real consequences for people
- amsterdorn 2y agoHow does this explain that it's a bad analogy? Both of these are true and can apply to both. Read up on the SSN leak from last week, I didn't give them my data. And it can have real consequences.
- chii 2y ago> justify inaction with their impact on climate change. but this is the correct justification. If the customer is the one buying these products that cause climate impact, why is it the sole responsibility of the company to pay the cost of rectification? In such situations, where externality is problematic, it is up to the gov't to push regulations to prevent it. A carbon capture tax, for example, is one such way. > Why don't we hold them to a higher standard? why should companies be held to a higher standard than a person?
- immibis 2y ago> why is it the sole responsibility of the company to pay the cost of rectification? It isn't - it's the company's responsibility to pass the cost to the customer.