7 ms·
ISPs worry that killing FCC net neutrality rules will come back to haunt them
- rsingel 2y agoISPs want it all the ways. It's such a vital telecommunication service that the government should give them subsidies to build out networks and provide subsidies to people with low incomes to purchase their services. But when it comes to regulation, they want to argue that they are no different than Gmail and that neither the states nor the FCC have any authority to impose basic common carrier rules. That's not even mentioning the oddness that for the sake of wiretapping, ISPs are considered common carriers subject to CALEA and, like phone services, have to use equipment that complies with federally created specs that allow real-time wiretapping. But unfortunately the federal judiciary is on a campaign to undermine Congress and federal agencies, so we're at the point where the judiciary is saying that the Federal Communications Commission has no jurisdiction over the most important communication system ever invented despite Congress clearly giving it an authority to do so and providing a framework.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 2y agoThe govt stepped in and broke up Ma Bell only for the megacorps to stratify the internet the next level higher.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- aeonik 2y agoI thought the ISPs already got 400 billion for expansion, they ended up keeping the money, and not following through. http://irregulators.org/bookofbrokenpromises/ http://irregulators.org/bookofbrokenpromises/
- linsomniac 2y agoQ.com has recently been going around our town laying fiber. This is CenturyLink. Back in 1995 I was working at QWest (now Century Link), and there was a neighborhood in West Omaha that was a trial for fiber to the home. QWest got a tariff increase approved, to pay for deploying fiber to the home for rural customers, by the year 2K. They never seemed, in any real way, to take steps toward that. In fact, in the later '90s they were actively NOT deploying fiber to DSLAMs in neighborhoods, to give good DSL, because doing so would allow CLECs to have access to put equipment in neighborhoods. So we all had to suffer with whatever DSL we could get on cable runs that went back to one of two switch buildings serving the town. Now, 30 years later, they're finally laying fiber. This is after the city is just finishing up laying their own fiber lines to every home and business in town, and I'm imagining that is partly responsible for the telco upgrades.
- ChoHag 2y ago[dead]
- jmclnx 2y ago>ISPs asked the US Supreme Court to strike down a New York law that requires broadband providers to offer $15-per-month service to people with low incomes With this US Supreme Court, I expect this New York Law will be overruled. But I believe NY has another option. Tax all ISP revenue (before deductions) over a certain amount at 99% (I wanted to say 100). Those funds could then be distributed to the poor. In the ACA Case, the US Supreme Court upheld the ACA because part of it was considered a Tax. They said they cannot overrule Tax Policy. So this would be an option for New York and other States.
- smlavine 2y ago> With this US Supreme Court, I expect this New York Law will be overruled. Why? Just because the court is conservative and this is a progressive law, or is there is an actual legal basis for the court to overturn this law?
- Retric 2y agoThe Supreme Court isn’t limited to what has an actual legal basis. Like jury nullification it’s a loophole arising from being the ultimate arbitrator.
- smlavine 2y agoYeah, but they still have to argue something in the decision that isn't "we don't like this law". They have to argue that the state doesn't have the constitutional authority to make the law, or something like that.
- lokar 2y agoI’d like to see Netflix cut off any ISP that refuses to follow the neutrality rules voluntarily. See how long they last with most of their customers pissed off.
- iwontberude 2y agoNetflix used to be the champion you think of, but in the past ten years has a moat because of this anti-competitive behavior. OpenConnect keeps them competitive by reducing the margins paid to brokers like Akamai.
- dartos 2y agoThey’d just pay the ISPs to be in the fast lane and gain an edge over the competition
- toast0 2y ago> See how long they last with most of their customers pissed off. I suspect Netflix will last a shorter amount of time with their customers pissed off than the ISPs will last with their customers pissed off. Personally, I have lots of ISP choice. I can have 80/15 VDSL with consistent speed and latency (22ms to nearest internet exchange), I can use Starlink which is supposed to be pretty reasonable bitrate and 15-50 ms latency, I can use 5G/LTE residential internet with actually good speeds but terrible buffer bloat, or I can pay about $30k to get municipal fiber and a monthly cost above DSL and 5G. No cable for me, Comcast says it's too expensive, even though I'm confident they're on the pole at the corner of the property. I committed to fiber recently, because a neighbor is doing it for their lots which the phone company refuses to service at all, and sharing construction costs means this is the best deal I'll get. And the trenching company came by and said they'll do directional drilling to get under my driveway so it won't be a big mess. But I don't think any 'normal' people in my situation would ever switch from DSL. If Netflix wants to play the blackout games, there's lots of other streaming services to pick from.
- nateglims 2y agoTV Channels frequently did this game with satellite TV providers and usually came out on top. I suspect Netflix has more leverage than most streaming services do.
- iwontberude 2y agoWith ̶S̶t̶a̶r̶l̶i̶n̶k̶ small satellites like cubesat and other wireless technology, it will soon be feasible to bring your internet service directly to the consumer without an ISP in the middle at all.
- mmanfrin 2y ago> without an ISP What do you think Starlink is if not an ISP?
- iwontberude 2y agoI have edited my original comment, sorry for the confusion.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]