3 ms·
It actually isn't - if you factor out the leverage. The returns in real estate ONLY look amazing because of the leverage. However, your own HOME being leverag
by bombcar 2y ago
It actually isn't - if you factor out the leverage.
The returns in real estate ONLY look amazing because of the leverage.
However, your own HOME being leveraged can make the returns astronomically insanely good.
- matwood 2y agoRE is one of the only ways the 'average' person can get that sort of leverage and favorable tax treatment.
- LunaSea 2y agoCould you explain your point in more details? Sorry, I'm not super knowledgable about this topic.
- bombcar 2y agoCalculate appreciation in a hot market area over time, and the returns aren't terribly exciting. Short periods of wild appreciation and decades of nothing. I picked a random house in Southern California, it is up 42% in the last 10 years, sounds great, right? But that is only an annual rate of return of 3.572%. Nothing at all exciting. Where it becomes exciting is where you bought that $500k house ten years ago with $50k down, and sell today for $800k - ignoring everything else like taxes, etc, you made $300k on a $50k investment (leveraged) - which is an 18% a year return. THAT is something to take notice of! Of course, you have to factor out all the associated costs, but the leverage is the be-all and end-all of your "investment". If you could leverage against stocks the way you can against single-family houses, you could go nuts. The advantage to leveraging real estate that you live in is that you basically have a heads I win, tails you lose scenario; if the house crashes you walk away (at least in non-recourse states like California, and practically almost everywhere).
- gambiting 2y ago"where you bought that $500k house ten years ago with $50k down, and sell today for $800k" The problem is that in those 10 years you also paid a bunch of interest on the mortgage necessary to buy that house. For instance: Assuming a 20 year mortgage with a fixed 5% interest rate, in 10 years you paid 200k just in interest. Makes that 300k look really much less appealing.
- ProfessorLayton 2y ago>Makes that 300k look really much less appealing. It's a bit more complicated than that though: - A house mortgaged 10y ago isn't paying 5% interest. - A house mortgaged today isn't necessarily going to be paying 5% interest for the life of the loan, one can refinance if/when interest rates become more favorable. Interest rates are set to start coming down next month. - 20k/yr in interest isn't really 20k once one factors in the tax deduction on that money. - Making 300k by other means is a lot harder, requires a lot more capital or much riskier leveraging than an asset like a home.
- gambiting 2y ago>>- 20k/yr in interest isn't really 20k once one factors in the tax deduction on that money. You get any tax deduction on your mortgage payments???
- ProfessorLayton 2y agoOn the mortgage interest, yes (U.S.)
- gambiting 2y agoThat's crazy. Wish that was a case here in UK.
- ProfessorLayton 2y agoAs a beneficiary, it's nice, but overall I believe it's unfair that homeowners get a tax break, while renters do not. Also it's a bit of a wash, as prices end up reflecting the tax break because bidders are ultimately going right up to their budget, and they take that into account. I wish there was enough housing so that it isn't seen as some sort of investment vehicle that distorts prices for basic human necessities.
- bombcar 2y ago
- owyn 2y agoIt can be even more insane than that. Not knowing what I was doing, I bought a house during the sub-prime boom thing (2004). I paid $10k in fees (zero down) for a $400k house with an interest only mortgage because I was able to "finance" the %20 down payment as a home equity loan. Fun times! I remember paying about $1700/mo total in interest payments ($20k/year). I checked Zillow all the time and the house was "making" 50k a year in appreciation just sitting there so it was essentially free. I sold it after 3 years (dec 2007, good timing) and after all the fees I walked away with $130k in cash right before the housing market crash (tax free!). I didn't know what I was doing then either. The people who bought it from me tried to flip it but walked right into the chainsaw of 2008 and had to sell it at a loss. I could have bought it back for even less than I paid for it the first time a year later! Whoever did buy it got a great deal because now 15 years later it's worth $1.3 million and I feel like I should have just kept it. I definitely haven't managed to save $1m in the last 20 years.