4 ms·
What is the point of "No-car"? Better to focus on actual outcomes like safe, efficient, fast, cheap transportation instead of pre-determining the implementation
by xnx 2y ago
What is the point of "No-car"? Better to focus on actual outcomes like safe, efficient, fast, cheap transportation instead of pre-determining the implementation. If the emphasis were on outcomes it's unlikely that 100% private cars or public transportation would be the solution. A blend of self-driving cars, personal mobility, and busses might be the best mix.
- mc32 2y agoIdeology, rather than rationality is the basis for this kind of decision making. That said, go for it; ensure it’s a dud. Make sure it’s the last useless waste of US taxpayer money for the Olympics. Idiots were concerned about the “authenticity” of breakdancing. Are they also seeking authenticity for any of the other sports, judo, martial arts, skating etc? Maybe they even go back to turn of previous century equipment to ensure authenticity. Actually, I might enjoy truly retro Olympics without space age materials, etc.
- mplewis 2y agoCities and people are more prosperous when they have better access to resources. Families spend more money on their local economy when they aren’t spending it all on road taxes, car payments, and gasoline. Self-driving cars aren’t real.
- xnx 2y ago> Cities and people are more prosperous when they have better access to resources. Definitely. Existing public transportation is a major hinderance to many people finding good work, quality groceries, and other necessities of life. > Self-driving cars aren’t real. I'm not sure what this means. Waymo does 50K paid trips every week including in Los Angeles.
- TacticalCoder 2y ago> What is the point of "No-car"? I really don't understand that, especially seen the more pressing issues that cities are facing: insecurity, people defecating in the streets (yup, it is an issue), "zombies" under the Tranq drug, homeless people, etc. My car happens to isolate me very well from all that. Before you'll get me to use public transport, you better first create a safe and clean city.
- sagarm 2y agoCars aren't clean or safe, so that's step one.
- seanmcdirmid 2y agoAs long as I don’t have a passenger high on fent who is waving a knife at me, a car is already a step up from the D line (a bus). I still take the bus anyway (parking is tough in downtown Seattle), but I can’t really deny the issue.
- sagarm 2y agoI get what you're saying, but every instance where I've felt physically threatened in my neighborhood is from malicious or incompetent drivers -- I often yield my right of way when walking because I feel I'll be injured otherwise. Drivers really are the greatest menace in the city as far as I'm concerned. The other issues are both rarer and don't make me feel physically threatened. Though of course nobody wants to see human suffering.
- seanmcdirmid 2y agoSeattle has been going through a rough spot with its drug addiction/homeless problem, which has basically ruined a lot of things that we took for granted a decade or two ago. It also doesn’t really make sense: it doesn’t take a lot to just remove people from a bus if they take out a knife, yet the city/county has deprioritized public safety, which tips the safety advantage back to car travel. You are lot more likely to get murdered on a bus (or on Link or in a Link station after you get off the train) than in your own car, even if the risk of accident is higher.
- jltsiren 2y agoBecause 4 years is a short time. At this point, the organizers need concrete solutions, not abstract goals. They need a good enough solution that is guaranteed to work on the specific dates, not something potentially better but uncertain and at a risk of being delayed. If you have a mass event and most people arrive by car, you need much more space for parking than for the event itself. If you don't have that space, you need strong incentives against driving. The last thing you want is more people arriving by car than there is parking space. Street capacity can also be an issue. If you have tens of thousands of people arriving/leaving a venue at the same time, repeated several times around the city, you don't want to waste capacity on small vehicles carrying only a handful of passengers. You load the people in public transit, drop them off anywhere else, and let them figure out how to reach their actual destinations from there.