5 ms·
After private equity takes over hospitals, they are less adept of providing care
- htrp 2y agoI feel like this is instantly obvious, when you have an owner that doesn't care about the core fundamental mission of the business, business will likely decline
- xtacy 2y agoHonest question: Are there successful cases where a PE takeover has transformed the company that has helped the company's mission?
- beardedwizard 2y agoI can't think of one. The most determined brands sometimes buy themselves back from PE - a recent example is Wahoo
- wiether 2y agoWell, hello fellow endurance person!
- blakesterz 2y agoMaybe Barnes and Noble? https://www.theverge.com/23642104/barnes-and-noble-amazon-bookshop-ecommerce-decoder-podcast https://www.theverge.com/23642104/barnes-and-noble-amazon-bo... At least according to that interview, it was going well at the time about a year ago.
- bdcravens 2y agoQuite possibly, though the last time I was in B&N, earlier this year, I found it a fairly disappointing experience (though given how much they shifted shelf space to current hot genres, it's likely they are succeeding with a much different audience than in the past)
- notaustinpowers 2y agoI worked at B&N for 4 years (2 before and 2 after the sale), it actually has been pretty good so far for the business. The stores have been given much more creative control over what they stock so it takes advantage of what's popular at that location (my location was known for our manga and young adult variety). There have been some bad moves taken at the corporate level (cutting the book procurement team, massive reductions in corporate headcount, etc). This makes the stores have to be a lot more self-reliant and increased workloads. Pay kinda increased, but is still way below the average for retail. Ultimately, it's good for the business, but it's not as great of a place to work at anymore. When I started, the average non-managerial employee tenure was 6 years, now it's only 2 years there.
- ekidd 2y agoUsually my rule of thumb at work is that if a key SaaS vendor gets bought by private equity, we start planning a migration project. We just about always wind up needing one, as the private equity firm tries to milk customers for all they're worth while degrading service.
- RandomCitizen12 2y agoMaybe Dell in 2013. But the point of PE buying a company is so that the company can help PE's mission, not PE helping the company's.
- mdorazio 2y agoThe "good" ones I know of tend to be smaller deals where the PE firm is pursuing a buy-and-hold approach in a sector where it has some knowledge and advantage. For example, Summa Equity bought Norsk Gjenvinning in Norway (a recycling company), refocused it on circular economy practices, and by most metrics it seems to be doing well for everyone. The Keiretsu companies an Japan are another example of the process working fairly well. On the flip side, the high-profile "pump and dump" PE deals almost always seem to be bad for everyone but the PE firm and shareholders.
- coredog64 2y agoOn Semiconductor was spun out of Motorola at the height of the dot com bubble. Their primary business at the time was commodity parts, a capital intensive and cyclical industry. At their lowest, TPG became a majority shareholder and strongly influenced operations. The initial plan was a quick fix, but TPG saw opportunity and helped OnSemi make the jump up the component food chain. A major part of this was the low cost structure that TPG drove. This then allowed for cheaper credit options which freed up money for M&A.
- rs999gti 2y agoHilton - https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/050415/what-are-some-examples-successfully-executed-leveraged-buyouts.asp https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/050415/what-are-som... Hilton was in trouble after 2008 crisis. Blackstone purchased them as a lifeline. Under Blackstone, Hilton reorganized itself and then Blackstone sold them off.
- imranhou 2y agoGlad there are non profits running some of them
- nullindividual 2y agoUnfortunately in my state the majority of those non-profit hospitals are religious institutions. Fortunately I live near two of the community-run hospitals and the associated clinic network.
- whywhywhywhy 2y agoNon profit means very little and opens the doors to worse forms of corruption, just means board members are greatly getting enriched instead of shareholders.
- rqtwteye 2y agoExactly. In many cases these non-profits are as greedy as for-profit.
- ceejayoz 2y agoOh, they make plenty of profit. You just have to use it on executive pay, perks, expensive consultants who happen to be friends with the board, conferences in Tahiti, etc. instead of directly distributing it to shareholders.
- WarOnPrivacy 2y agoPurposefully destructive investment strategies are better described as parasitical - than a benefit to society. It's unclear why allowing this is in our benefit.
- uoaei 2y agothe story goes, we let people run amok in markets because they're "self-correcting". the reality is, we continue to ignore the effect of delayed corrections and what damage might be incurred in the interim.
- rqtwteye 2y agoTrue. In many cases the self-correcting cycles of markets may take decades or centuries.
- rsprinkle 2y agoThe is called privatizing profit and socializing risk. Current management philosophies are all about mining assets and when the mine is empty, move on. It used to be about growing assets.
- uoaei 2y agoanother way to articulate that dichotomy is through the lens of industrial vs financial modes of capitalism.
- blibble 2y agoyou see this in the UK water companies PE buys some operation, loads it up with debt and then pays dividends to itself directly from that borrowed money (via a chain of subsidiaries) it continues doing this until the company debt situation becomes unsustainable, then dumps the company on clueless investors (e.g. state pension funds) paying dividends from debt is illegal, but apparently not if you launder it through enough subsidiaries in different countries this is essentially exploiting a design flaw in capitalism
- monooso 2y agoPresumably this comes as a surprise to someone, but I have no idea who that person might be.
- elteto 2y agoNo surprise there. Providing quality care is in direct contradiction with optimizing for profit. I think hospitals should only be allowed to operate as non-profits. With maybe some carve outs, but fundamentally be non-profits. Another problem is the large hospital conglomerates that end up owning all local hospitals in some areas. Large corporate structures always end up disconnected from reality and optimizing for the wrong things.
- rqtwteye 2y agoBut not as non-profits as they exist right now. They are as greedy as for-profit with the only difference that the profits go to execs and their business friends and not to shareholders.
- chromatin 2y agoPhysician-owned (even for-profit) hospitals historically provided the best care. The ACA ("Obamacare") outlawed new physician-owned hospitals. Now we find that PE-owned hospitals both cost more and provide worse care. Neither patient protection nor affordable care.
- SkyPuncher 2y agoPhysician owned was a joke of a marketing term. Physicians have the exact same incentives as business people - especially at a leadership level. It’s all about the money.
- ProllyInfamous 2y ago>It’s all about the money. I think this is more about the retaliation of "having earned it/more," for all the decades of sacrifice becoming a thankless-physician entails. Money is a simple metric for simple people, but yes, absolutely it's about the money to a lot of people. I dropped out after the first year, because I realized I would self-delete (at some point) should I continue on the careerpath to physicianhood. I am so grateful to still be here, xx years later, doing anything else: If you want to help people and/or make lots of money, there are dozens of other career opportunities to do BOTH more-easily/better.
- blakesterz 2y agoIt doesn't seem like the study lines up with that headline. I am NO fan of private equity at all, so I'm not defending them. Here's the actual study. https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2821826?guestAccessKey=00d9206e-c4e5-468b-be37-9ba2a2b551fd&utm_source=For_The_Media&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=ftm_links&utm_content=tfl&utm_term=073024 https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2821826?gu... Hospital Assets Before and After Private Equity Acquisition Private equity acquisitions appear to have depleted, rather than augmented, hospital assets. Although funds from asset drawdowns might be redeployed to enhance care or efficiency, previous studies suggest such effects may not occur. Financial outcome of private equity hospital acquisitions and effects on patient care require further study.
- nabla9 2y agoAsk any healthcare economist. Private healthcare sector has the most market failures in any sector. 1. Adverse Selection loop: Individuals in poor health are more likely to purchase health insurance, leading to higher payouts for insurance companies. Premiums may rise, discouraging healthier people from buying insurance, and so on. 2. Moral Hazard: Insured use more healthcare services than necessary or neglect preventive measures, when insurance will cover the costs. This leads to inefficient resource and costs. 3. Information Asymmetry: Patients lack information to make informed choices. 4. Monopoly Control and Entry Barriers lead to higher prices and limited choices for consumers 5. Interdependent Demand and Supply: supply and demand are not determined independently. Often more demand -> less supply. 6. Externalities, such as the spread of communicable diseases, can't be efficiently addressed by the market. 7. Public goods: non-excludable and non-rivalrous, are underprovided by the market
- fourier54 2y agoInteresting, would like to read more, can you provide references?
- spencerchubb 2y agoAny undergrad economics textbook will have chapters about market failure. Do you want something more specific?
- vundercind 2y agoWe covered it a lot in international political economy (IPE) since market failure scenarios tend to be exactly when even (non-looney/non-bad-faith) capitalism fans want governments to get involved. Guessing textbooks and readers on that sub-field would also be helpful. (This is also why other posters here observe that examples of sectors prone to market failure have high levels of government involvement)
- dredmorbius 2y agoPublic sector economics and health economics generally. The principles discussed are fundamental to both subdisciplines and should be covered in the introductory chapter(s) of a basic textbook on the subject. I'd used a textbook by Joseph Stiglitz several decades ago whilst at uni, and there should be an updated version of it out. I think this might be it or close: Economics of the Public Sector, Fourth Edition. By Joseph E Stiglitz (Author, Columbia University), Jay K Rosengard (Author, Harvard University). <https://wwnorton.com/books/9780393925227 https://wwnorton.com/books/9780393925227> The table of contents looks promising, particularly chapter 5. Also at: <https://search.worldcat.org/title/39485400 https://search.worldcat.org/title/39485400> You might also find this in Handbook of public economics by Alan J. Auerbach, Martin S. Feldstein, Raj Chetty, and Emmanuel Saez. <https://search.worldcat.org/title/13360368 https://search.worldcat.org/title/13360368>
- zx8080 2y agoPE buys and pays money. They seek for ROI. If something is wrong, the free market is expected to fix things, eventually.
- sixdimensional 2y agoI can go one step further with an anecdote- in the small town I live in, private equity bought our small hospital, and the land it sits on. Consequently, it changed policy, raided the equipment to take expensive equipment to other hospitals, ran it into the ground, and then closed it permanently on the grounds that it was too expensive to operate. The hospital sat derelict for probably more than 6 years as the city fought with the owner to try to get a hospital + emergency room back to no avail. It was then promptly razed to the ground, and now the highly valuable real estate is currently sitting there growing weeds, as the owners contemplate what to do next. We believe they will build luxury senior housing there, but nobody knows. The closest ER to my house used to be less than 5 miles away. Now it is more than 15 miles to the north, and it is shared by a much larger area. The nearest ER in any other direction is 30+ miles away. It destroyed the hospital, and our local medical community in the process. So yeah, at least in my case (and I suspect I'm not alone), private equity was completely destructive to our hospital.
- gosub100 2y agoRespectfully, "raised" you probably meant razed.
- sixdimensional 2y agoThanks, fixed it!
- katzinsky 2y ago[flagged]
- WesternWind 2y agoprivate equity does seem to be kinda crap at running stuff, even screwing up with successful brands. It's not a surprise that hospitals and smaller businesses also get screwed up. Like Toys'R'Us, Sears, Gymboree, Payless, Claire's, Radioshack, Sports Authority, Brookstone, all of them filed for bankruptcy, some closed for good. Now maybe they would have anyway, but it's hard to say. But I guess they get money out of them. If you pile on debt and pay yourself, and then the company goes bankrupt, well you got paid, that's what matters to PE investors, right? Not how good the care is at hospitals.
- cokeandpepsi 2y ago[dead]
- matwood 2y agoPE acts as vultures (not in a negative way) who come in and clean up dead carcasses. They are typically not the cause but a symptom of a failing company. We all have nostalgia for small chains or companies at the mall in our youth. Almost all of those are terrible and failing businesses now. It's a bit like the movie Up In the Air where Clooney goes around firing people. He's the face of the bad news, but he's not the cause. For the article at hand, hospitals really should be non-profit. Providing great care at low costs means the goal is a terrible business.
- dopylitty 2y ago>They are typically not the cause but a symptom of a failing company. This isn't true in most cases. PE has killed many profitable companies by taking deliberate steps which resulted in the companies directing their incomes to servicing unsustainable debts rather than running or improving the businesses. For example the eldercare company ManorCare was profitable and successful prior to being bought and destroyed by a PE group. The PE firm loaded ManorCare with the debt that the PE firm used to buy it in the first place and then sold ManorCare's real estate and forced ManorCare to rent it back, causing ManorCare to spend $500 million/year on rent[0] Forcing companies to take on debt and sell their assets is a standard part of the PE playbook and inevitably ends in the death of the company regardless of how it was performing prior to being taken over. 0: https://skillednursingnews.com/2018/11/washington-post-blames-private-equity-manorcare-woes/ https://skillednursingnews.com/2018/11/washington-post-blame...
- mperham 2y agoHealthcare should be universal and socialized. Full stop.
- nojvek 2y agoHealthcare could be an open transparent market, and it'd still work. The problem is US healthcare is neither open and transparent, neither universal and socialized.
- hungie 2y ago[dead]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- the_real_cher 2y agoThe orthopedist at my "private equity" hospital said he didnt know how to read an MRI...
- from-nibly 2y agoTitle should be, "After private equity takes over a business, it is less able to produce value for customers" Private equity is the customer. Once private equity takes over, you are the product, even if what you are getting isn't free.
- dopylitty 2y agoI've been reading a book called "Plunder"[0] which covers private equity's impact on several sectors including eldercare, medical, housing, finance, and retail. It lays out how the PE firms' MO is to destroy companies while extracting every ounce of value from them leaving a husk that quickly falls apart. There are several different strategies used by PE firms such as selling off property and renting them back to the companies they own, forcing companies to take on debt to pay the PE firms, and strategically breaking the law because the PE firms are not liable for the broken laws. It also covers how PE firms buy up all companies in a particular region and sector so that competition is not possible and consumers have no choice but to use the PE owned providers. It shows that the impacts PE has on hospitals such as those in this study are not side effects but are the known and intended goals of PE firms as they extract the value from the company. These firms need to be regulated out of existence but unfortunately the book also covers how many high profile government movers and shakers are tied up with private equity. For instance former secretary of the treasury Geithner now runs a PE firm and former president Trump is good friends with a PE exec (CEO of Blackstone). 0: https://www.hachettebookgroup.com/titles/brendan-ballou/plunder/9781541702103/?lens=publicaffairs https://www.hachettebookgroup.com/titles/brendan-ballou/plun...