3 ms·
Neon: A serverless open-source alternative to AWS Aurora Postgres
- aantix 2y agoneon.tech's offering looks good - the $69 offering. Any reviews?
- brigadier132 2y agoI've used it, it's one of the only dbs you can use for free. It's extremely easy to get started. The only thing I'm worried about is the bait and switch, the offering is so much better than the alternative that I'm certain there will be a squeeze eventually.
- lysace 2y agoI don't understand the business model. I guess the goal is to be acquired by AWS/GCP/Azure etc?
- brigadier132 2y agoIt's cheap to have a live db because the compute is detached from storage. This means they can spin up your compute on demand. While the compute is running it's around the same price as aws, gcp, azure, etc but you pay for more storage because it's replicated. One really nice thing about this is that you do not need to shut down the db to upgrade the machine and you get what are essentially free read replicas. I think the business model makes sense, I just think they will eventually raise prices because they can.
- lysace 2y ago1) That's how e.g. RDS is already implemented, right? It's an AWS cash cow. 2) Who is going to use an external (from the perspective of your cloud or internal work load) RDBMS?
- brigadier132 2y agoRDS isn't implemented like that and if you are on AWS you can get neon to be in the same datacenter and even pay via AWS. I don't work for neon, I've just gone pretty deep on all the managed db offerings.
- lysace 2y ago(As in "compute is detached from storage", not all of the specifics.) > if you are on AWS you can get neon to be in the same datacenter and even pay via AWS Nice.
- the_duke 2y agoAs the title says... Aurora is somewhat implemented like that. RDS just runs regular database servers and provides some nice management automation around it.
- tristan957 2y agoThe business model is to sell a Database as a Service, similar to Mongo, DataStax, etc.
- ok_dad 2y agoIsn't the storage kinda expensive? It's $15 per 10 GiB, which is ~10x more expensive than AWS SSD storage and ~100x more than bulk storage with an S3-like service. It's $1500 per TiB, which is a lot of money. I guess it might not be designed for time series data like I am used to collecting, which requires thinking on the TiB scale at the very least. I do appreciate it's Apache 2.0 licensed, so you can run it yourself. I can't complain too much about pricing for what looks to be my dream database that I have always wanted with branching and separated storage and compute.
- adwf 2y agoYeah that storage pricing is a killer. Given Aurora is $0.1/GB, I just wouldn't even consider this.
- tristan957 2y agoNeon is a lot more than just storage. It's branching, autoscaling, (cheap) read replicas, serverless computing, etc. If you only care about storage pricing, Neon is not the service for you. As you've said, storage pricing is cheaper elsewhere.
- adwf 2y agoSure, but I've got serverless computing with Aurora v2. I've got upto 15 read replicas, blue/green deployments, upto 128 cores per replica at a cheaper price... I'm just not really thinking that a bit of branching will make up for a 10x or more increase in cost. Those increased storage costs make the decoupled compute and the associated auto-scaling benefits almost irrelevant as far as the overall cost picture goes.
- tristan957 2y agoWe have former Aurora users come to Neon who tell us they saved money by switching. If someone like yourself were to migrate, they definitely would be an enterprise sale, which has different pricing than what is available in our current tiers.
- lysace 2y agoThe company's site https://neon.tech/ https://neon.tech/ made it easier to understand what it is, for me. The Github README struggles with identifying its audience, IMO.
- nikita 2y agoPlease say more of what you would change in the README and we will update
- rohan_ 2y agoThis is the company vercel has bet on to power their managed DB. Stacked team behind it. One of the few managed postgres companies that will still exist years from now.
- ChocolateGod 2y agoThis has got to be one of the slickest websites I've seen on the web, kudos strongly deserved. On the tech itself, it's a shame nothing like this exists for MySQL, but not surprising.
- nikita 2y agoWe debated internally if we wanted to provide MySQL too. On one hand it’s not that different and our storage can be adapted to run MySQL. On the other hand focus and product identity are very important for startups. So it’s only Postgres
- ChocolateGod 2y agoThere's a project to try get a MySQL compatible extension for Postgres going, which may work. https://nextgres.com/ https://nextgres.com/
- endorphine 2y agoIsn't this what PlanetScale is all about?
- ChocolateGod 2y agoIt's not open source, and whilst its built on Vitess, Vitess alone doesn't do what Neon does, just makes it easier to horizontally scale.
- ljm 2y agoWhat makes this attractive to me is the ‘database branching’ functionality and simple setup for it. Managing databases locally and in CI isn’t much fun when dealing with migrations, so the fact you can trivially work with a copy in a branch, or deploy preview builds in PRs with their own DB branch, is a great innovation. I mean, sure you could slap something similar together with some scripts, but having it out of the box is good dev ex.
- mahtodeepak 2y agoShouldn't the title be, Neon: A serverless open-source alternative to Amazon Aurora PostgreSQL Compatible.
- hadlock 2y agoHere is the helm chart: https://github.com/neondatabase/helm-charts/tree/main https://github.com/neondatabase/helm-charts/tree/main Although documentation is sparse. Percona has a good walkthrough on how to spin up neondatabase via plain docker containers, which is a good way of pulling the system apart into logical units (storage broker, safekeeper, pageserver), and branching from an existing tenant/timeline: https://www.percona.com/blog/using-docker-to-deploy-neon-serverless-postgresql/ https://www.percona.com/blog/using-docker-to-deploy-neon-ser...
- ankit219 2y agoBeen on neon for a while. Using it for simple queries and RAG (pgvector). The thing I like about it most is the speed where I can get query output in 200ms-500ms. Incredibly fast. Given the serverless nature, it's my go to for any POCs or tests I do personally. In production, querying on neon is faster than our inhouse postgres we provision from AWS. One really hacky application I saw was a pg search and show results without the user having to press a button. Here: https://next-ai-news.vercel.app/search?q= https://next-ai-news.vercel.app/search?q=
- peterldowns 2y agoI've been using https://neon.tech https://neon.tech in production at Devlog https://dev.log.xyz https://dev.log.xyz for the last few months, really quite happy with the pricing and the performance. Clearly made by and for developers. The only surprise I had was that they don't show you any database logs! Turns out I haven't needed this so it's not a big deal, but that's the biggest departure from a "traditional hosted postgres" service. Aside from that, the only missing feature is the ability to create an Organization rather than hosting projects in a personally-affiliated account, but this is apparently coming soon. The branching features work really well and I've used it a few times now to debug issues and test migrations without impacting production. I haven't set up the per-pull-request-preview-environment stuff yet but I plan to and I like that Neon makes it easy. EDIT: oh, the one other annoyance is that last time I checked, it was not possible to create a read-only replica in a different region than the primary compute node. Or something like that, I'm still not sure, and multi-region read replicas are not particularly necessary for me right now (Devlog still in early alpha, not a lot of customers) so I just moved on. Issue tracked here https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/4178 https://github.com/neondatabase/neon/issues/4178
- tristan957 2y agoNeon is a managed service versus a hosted service FWIW. Exposing logs is something that we'd like to do in the future.
- peterldowns 2y agoApologies, I'm not super clear on the difference between managed and hosted. Very much a happy customer already and excited to see continued improvements!
- tristan957 2y agoHere[0] is a breakdown. [0]: https://www.hostreview.com/blog/210610-what-is-the-difference-between-hosting-and-managed-services https://www.hostreview.com/blog/210610-what-is-the-differenc...
- ilaksh 2y agoI thought that Postgres was an open-source alternative to AWS Aurora Postgres?
- hosh 2y agoHm. I thought that AWS Aurora Postgres is a proprietary alternative to Postgres?
- hosh 2y agoSounds like a neat idea. Is it compatible with postgresql extensions? (Do most extension live in the compute layer?)
- tristan957 2y agoHere is the list of Postgres extensions we support: https://neon.tech/docs/extensions/pg-extensions https://neon.tech/docs/extensions/pg-extensions. The extensions are bundled into the compute images.
- zk 2y agoI'm curious what the largest DB hosted on Neon is currently? Can you potentially scale postgres infinitely with neon without needing to shard etc?
- brigadier132 2y agoI can't find where I read it but my current understanding is that you can't. You can scale to the largest AWS instance available for writes. They allow for automatic read replicas which I imagine can scale horizontally?
- tristan957 2y agoPostgres itself has limits that Neon cannot help: https://www.postgresql.org/docs/current/limits.html https://www.postgresql.org/docs/current/limits.html. Neon currently serves TB-sized databases. Our storage team has put in a ton of work to enable that. Neon does not currently support something like Citus. Neon has cheap read replicas however, which can allow your primary to just service writes.
- brigadier132 2y agoIf any neon product people are on here, please bring it to gcp
- tristan957 2y agoWe just announced upcoming Azure support today[0]. Right now we are fully invested in AWS and Azure. Launching in additional regions can take quite a bit of work, but that pales in comparison to another cloud. We'd love to launch everywhere that our customers or potential customers are, but it also requires a larger team. We've been hiring[1] for Azure-specific positions recently, and I assume we would do the same for GCP, OCI, or IBM Cloud. [0]: https://neon.tech/blog/neon-is-coming-to-azure https://neon.tech/blog/neon-is-coming-to-azure [1]: https://neon.tech/careers https://neon.tech/careers
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jablongo 2y agoThis is crazy I just stumbled upon this company earlier today via search when I realized that Aurora Postgres Serverless V2 no longer allows you to scale down to 0 in times of low usage. AWS makes you select 0.5 ACUs as the minimum for V2 where with V1 you could select 0... is this just a straight up money grab by AWS to make the minimum monthly cost for aurora like $50 or is there a justifiable reason behind making you run virtual servers continually when there is no usage. I may be switching soon!
- ko_pivot 2y agoI'm guessing AWS simply did not build reading/writing the current DB state to/from S3 into Aurora Serverless v2. Neon has done a ton of work to make scale to zero happen in terms of treating the actual database disk as nothing more than a cache.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- TheAnkurTyagi 2y agoI’m a big fan of Neon postgres. It’s pretty much unbeatable value for the price. The documentation is good and multi-tech stack friendly and I created a repo in which I added all the awesome links about Neon Postgres - https://github.com/tyaga001/awesome-neon https://github.com/tyaga001/awesome-neon and wrote a tutorial https://www.freecodecamp.org/news/build-an-invoice-saas-app-with-next-js-and-neon-postgres/ https://www.freecodecamp.org/news/build-an-invoice-saas-app-...