5 ms·
Wow, that's crazy-town even for Musk. They keep using the term "illegal" to refer to everyone's right to decide who they will or won't do business with. I'm eag
by JohnFen 2y ago
Wow, that's crazy-town even for Musk. They keep using the term "illegal" to refer to everyone's right to decide who they will or won't do business with. I'm eagerly anticipating hearing what law(s) Musk thinks were broken.
This looks for all the world like a desperation move.
- ralferoo 2y agoYeah, he might have a case if they were all trying to collectively negotiate a massive discount. But when they all walk away and effectively say "enough is enough, we're done here" and have zero interest in returning to advertise whatever the price, there's no basis for a case.
- AnimalMuppet 2y ago> Musk’s X has filed an antitrust lawsuit against a trade group and several advertisers, alleging they conspired to withhold “billions” of dollars in ad spending over concerns that X would “deviate from certain brand safety standards for advertising.” Yeah, if you're carrying stuff that I don't think is safe for my brand to associate with, that's not "withholding" advertising from you. That's me saying that your site has become a cesspool, and I don't want to get any of it on my brand. You didn't have a right to my advertising that I'm unjustly "withholding" from you. There is (or the lawsuit claims there is) an active House Judiciary Committee investigation of GARM (the trade organization in question), for whatever that's worth. My take: I don't know the legal ins and outs on this. But Musk sounds like he thinks he's entitled to our ad dollars. That doesn't seem likely to attract more business - rather the opposite. (If you're going to sue people who once advertised and don't any more, then maybe it's better if I never start advertising on your platform in the first place.)
- JohnFen 2y ago> But Musk sounds like he thinks he's entitled to our ad dollars. That's what, in my view, makes the whole thing insane. The very idea that companies (or people) have some sort of obligation to spend their advertising dollars in any particular outlet is very hard to comprehend. I don't know, but I'd be willing to bet that Musk is a person who believes that spending money is a form of free speech. If that's the case, then how does he square the idea of "free speech" with the notion of "compelled speech"?
- ralferoo 2y agoAnd contradicting myself, I found this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Refusal_to_deal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Refusal_to_deal > Though in general, each business may decide with whom they wish to transact, there are some situations when a refusal to deal may be considered an unlawful anti-competitive practice, if it prevents or reduces competition in a market. The unlawful behaviour may involve two or more companies refusing to use, buy from or otherwise deal with a person or business, such as a competitor, for the purpose of inflicting some economic loss on the target or otherwise force them out of the market. So I guess I don't know!
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoIs it really crazy town? What he’s alleging here is that there is a cartel of advertisers that are behaving in anti-competitive ways. And I think that is obviously true when you look at how the ad agencies and their clients (whose spend is controlled by these agencies) act at the same time in politically charged situations. There are a few big ad agencies and they happen to control advertising through various means like their size, network effects, various practices, and also by trying to outsource their collusion into frameworks like GARM. I am honestly surprised at the hostile response to this from HN. The right to associate freely is not what is being debated here - the article clearly says this is about anti trust. Corporations do not have the right to just do whatever they want. But leaving aside the technicalities - the existence of powerful corporate lords that control what speech is allowed is just bad. If this situation were reversed, where a small group of powerful advertisers were colluding to suppress your speech, you would definitely be upset and not would not be defending corporate power hindering free speech, which is a foundational piece of democracy.
- ab5tract 2y agoAd agencies may consult with corporations as to whether a given venue is worth their investment. However, it is ultimately up to the company whether they follow that advice. They don’t “control” the advertising spend for that corporation. According to the logic of this ruling, however, a corporation could be sued for deciding to stop spending ad money with a given agency.
- ab5tract 2y agoDownvoting on HN was never supposed to be about punishing inconvenient truths.
- JohnFen 2y ago> the article clearly says this is about anti trust. Yes, I just don't see how anti-trust laws apply here. > Corporations do not have the right to just do whatever they want. Correct. And the main thing (in terms of cartel/monopoly behavior) is that they can't abuse a monopoly position in order to give themselves an unfair advantage. If they avoid doing that, it's entirely legal to be a cartel or monopoly. I am failing to see how choosing not to do business with Twitter is giving themselves any kind of unfair advantage. > If this situation were reversed, where a small group of powerful advertisers were colluding to suppress your speech, you would definitely be upset I certainly would! But I don't think that's what's happening here. Nobody's speech is being curtailed here. It's companies choosing what sort of thing they do and don't want to be associated with. Twitter can continue to do whatever it likes, and even if there are enough advertisers avoiding it that it ends up putting the company out of business (which I seriously doubt), everyone on it can still speak freely as they always could. They'll just use any of the numerous other outlets to do that with. In any case, we're just the peanut gallery and what we think isn't actually important. It's what happens in court, and in court, I am very confident that Musk will lose hard.