3 ms·
> My younger sister, Sophie, isn't worried about retirement – but she's not exactly optimistic about it, either. "We've got climate change, war – it's like, are
by ryandrake 2y ago
> My younger sister, Sophie, isn't worried about retirement – but she's not exactly optimistic about it, either. "We've got climate change, war – it's like, are we even going to be here to retire?"
I see this belief in a lot of younger co-workers. Newsflash: You're highly likely to outlive your ability to work. If your plan is to die the day after you retire, that may happen, but in all likelihood you won't, and not having savings is going to end up unpleasantly for you. Save for retirement, people!
- etrautmann 2y agoThis also seems like a natural consequence of crazy inflation and outlandishly unaffordable house prices. When the target is out of reach, it's hard to motivate to even try.
- pixl97 2y agoWhen you're spending almost everything on food, rent, and healthcare surviving till tomorrow is a much bigger issue than figuring out what to do 20-50 years from now. Late stage capitalism is doing a good job of sucking up excess money and returning it to the investor class via rents, if you're not in the infestor class then you are struggling.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- janalsncm 2y agoIt is true, and that’s why I dislike the top line metrics. The stock market is doing great! Unemployment is low! GDP is up! But the hidden assumption, that these metrics would be coupled with second-order metrics like life expectancy, home ownership, health, and well-being? That no longer holds. These consequences today are all the results of political decisions made decades ago. The unfortunate reality is that turning this ship around will also take decades.
- JohnFen 2y agoIt was a common belief amongst my own age group (roughly GenX) as well, and a whole lot of people are in a lot of trouble now because of it.
- ehPReth 2y agoI have literally no extra money to save. Everything I have is maxed out or near maxed out. my retirement plan is an overdose.
- juujian 2y agoOoooh, that's a lot more concrete and realistic than my retirement plans.
- Alupis 2y ago[flagged]
- sosodev 2y agoEven with compound interest $100/mo is only going to yield retirement like savings over 40 years with >=10% interest rates and monthly compounding. It also neglects the fact that the cost of retirement might be much higher when that time comes. Your whole spend less argument ignores the whole point of the article. These disillusioned people aren’t going to spend less because they don’t think it’s going to pay off. They’re optimizing for happiness in the present moment and that might end up being the right choice.
- Alupis 2y ago[flagged]
- antisthenes 2y ago> everyone can find an extra $50-100 monthly to stash away for retirement. With compound interest over a 40+ year working career, this is not trivial money. This amount of money is likely to pay for a couple of surgeries (assuming no other complications or chronic illnesses eating your savings before then) past the age of 50, given how expensive health care is. It's not a significant amount of money to let you retire in any kind of comfort. Maybe just not starve. No amount of financial prudence is going to change the math for you if your set of skills caps out at $20/hour on the employment market.
- Der_Einzige 2y agoThis is slightly less true for tech work though. If they don't have a cure for carpel tunnel syndrome by 2050, I'll retire I guess - but why should I when tech is so lucrative if it still somehow looks like how it does today? Everyone seems in such a rush to stop earning money. Maybe be in a rush to get a "rest and vest" job instead? I plan to be some senior director at the 2050 equivalent of a sleepy and comfy giant company like IBM or Salesforce. By the time they realize I've stopped delivering value half a decade ago and lay me off, I'm already old enough to get the maximum possible monthly social security benefits AND will have prolonged my tech wealth earnings, likely with a house which is hopefully paid off. And I haven't even mentioned the golden parachute of long term severance packages! I get it if you're doing back breaking work, but this is HN! Most of the folks here have nothing more to worry about except eye strain/blindness, deafness, and carpel tunnel.
- giraffe_lady 2y agoWe still have dreams beyond labor.
- ryandrake 2y agoIt's probably worse in tech, due to the rampant age discrimination that's been normalized in this industry. Your plan to become "some senior director" is probably the only way to remain employed at a tech company in your 60s, 70s, 80s, or 90s. Good luck doing that as an individual programmer or low-level manager.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- tivert 2y ago> It's probably worse in tech, due to the rampant age discrimination that's been normalized in this industry. I haven't worked many places, but I have a feeling that working for a company that has tech but doesn't identify as a tech company is probably the way to go. Also stay the hell away from the Bay Area. Tech company culture seems so dysfunctional (e.g. the normalized age discrimination, etc.).
- cooolbear 2y agoYou might be really missing the point here in simply echoing the conventional wisdom of the last 100 years
- janalsncm 2y ago> Save for retirement, people! The article names many reasons why it isn’t so simple. None of those reasons are that Gen Z decided against saving money. I do agree that opening with a quote about other larger issues may not have been helpful. It’s not like other generations didn’t have to worry about e.g. nuclear war. It’s really not the point though.
- lagniappe 2y agoHang on, what retirement? There's no social security, there's no potential to live on a fixed income, inflation has effectively restarted the clock on a lot of retirement plans. I'm not gen-z but I fully understand I will need to work as long as my heart beats. I say this -with- a retirement fund.
- janalsncm 2y agoAgreed. I think you’re objecting to the line I quoted. The reason people don’t trust institutions is because the institutions aren’t working for them.
- jhanschoo 2y agoI feel like graduating college with so much debt (at least on paper) fucks with your relationship with money and what financial goals seems realistic.