13 ms·
How the music industry learned to love piracy
- bookofjoe 2y agohttps://archive.ph/P4TFy https://archive.ph/P4TFy
- politelemon 2y agoSome places such as Amazon and Bandcamp still allow downloading the music files. Is there a similarly lopsided revenue model in these cases, as there is for streaming? Anyway it seems that the industry is pleased with where it ended up, the link between then and now is a bit tenuous. However it's also on us that we willingly handed over control to streaming companies for the convenience. Think about the number of times we've justified something by it being the cost of a few coffees a month. TV, music, Adobe.
- mrsilencedogood 2y ago>Amazon Guarantee you these are lots of bootlegs and other-region copies behind resold. So probably Amazon is worst for the artists because even the labels are getting cheated there. >Bandcamp As I understand it, this is (was?) one of the few places an artist could still get a good deal. Bandcamp positions itself more as a marketplace and takes (iirc) 16ish percent. Let me check that against their website: "when a fan buys something on Bandcamp, an average of 82% of the money goes to you" (https://bandcamp.com/artists?from=footer https://bandcamp.com/artists?from=footer) So yeah, they get a lot of the niche weird music. I buy a lot of NWOTHM music off there for this reason.
- diggan 2y agoAlso, Bandcamp has "Bandcamp Fridays" (or similar name), where for the entire day, 100% goes to the artists. I keep a list of music that I add to when I come across something I want to buy, then when the Bandcamp Friday comes around, buy everything on the list.
- burgrchf 2y ago[dead]
- jay_kyburz 2y agoHello fellow NWOTHM fan. (So much of it is so bad, but every now and then there is something awesome)
- Semaphor 2y agoNot normally a big fan of the genre, but in case you missed it, there was the slightly proggy, slightly powery trad release last year that exploded in popularity (relative terms, 281 Bandcamp buys which is more than most of the music I buy :D) earlier this year: Mother's Guilty Pleasure Part One by Noor https://noorband.bandcamp.com/album/mothers-guilty-pleasure-part-one https://noorband.bandcamp.com/album/mothers-guilty-pleasure-...
- hardwaresofton 2y agoI follow 2 rules: 1. If an artist has a bandcamp, I buy. 2. there is no second rule
- freedomben 2y agoIndeed. I used to buy amazon mp3s, but they jacked around a couple of times to make it harder to download whole albums, at which point I stopped and won't buy on amazon anymore. I know currently it's pretty easy to download whole albums, but they torched my trust. On Bandcamp, I buy it. Not on Bandcamp, nope.
- skydhash 2y agoQobuz has a pretty chill process too. I don't actually trust their servers that much, (or anyone server) so I download albums as soon as I bought them. What I wish for when downloading digitally is getting the booklet (or liner notes) of the albums. It's nice knowing who was involved in the project and the thoughts/story of the artists.
- lancesells 2y ago0. If an artist sells direct I buy directly from their site.
- comprev 2y agoOnly if that artist can provide me with a voucher code to “purchase” the bandcamp music which allows me to stream/play offline in the app. Exception being vinyl-only releases by which usually a high quality WAV is provided to buyers. Many artists I follow are not on Spotify anyway.
- efilife 2y agoOnce one of my favorite underground artists deleted his album that was available on soundcloud. I messaged the guy without expecting any response, imagine how shocked I was when the guy made the album public on bandcamp just for me so I could download it for free. No way, I had to buy it
- _3u10 2y agoHopefully the times learns to love paywall blockers.
- bookofjoe 2y agohttps://www.nytimes.com/2024/07/31/magazine/how-music-got-free-documentary.html?unlocked_article_code=1.Ak4.LIQg.XsrAN1fJ5nkC&smid=url-share https://www.nytimes.com/2024/07/31/magazine/how-music-got-fr...
- neallindsay 2y agoPresumably there's a reason they make their paywall so porous.
- scelerat 2y agoNelson's faming here pretty much sums up how I feel about the whole ball of wax myself, a musician, and someone who started their career working for a major national concert promotor, worked for two streaming music services and who participates in a local music scene as performer, supporter and occasional promotor: """ The problem isn’t just the ever-decreasing viability of even established, popular artists keeping food on the table. There is also a cultural poverty that attends the streaming economy. There is the ruthless profit maximization and the constant steering of listeners toward the same music. There is the lock-step social engineering and manufactured consensus. There is the escalating — and demeaning — sense of music being treated as a utility that need not be meaningfully engaged with. """
- johnny22 2y ago> There is the ruthless profit maximization and the constant steering of listeners toward the same music. What is your reference time frame here? That's exactly how it was in the 90s and before. Feels like there was a tiny bright spot from the early 2000s to say 2010 or so, but then it was over.
- RiverCrochet 2y agoIt's CHEAP to make and distribute music. Production costs are low due to advances in PC and audio tech. Distribution costs are at the floor where the actual distribution is practically free and it is only the legal concerns that are a cost. The whole industry currently doesn't have a better physical value-add than the guy playing on the street corner with a money hat. If anyone can make music then music has demeaned itself, and maybe it simply wasn't ever a big deal in the first place. Many say the 60's and 70's were the best years in music, and this was the heyday of the time where if you wanted to listen to someone's song, you had to buy their record and you didn't really have any other choice unless you fooled around with expensive and bulky reel-to-reel tape decks[1]. Was that all it was - inability for the masses to create and distribute media without a middleman? Not that the middleman didn't perform a valuable function, but it was performing it for everyone who would buy records in the whole market. Now we get to choose or be our own middlemen, and people who don't want to do that kinda get what they deserve. [1] I don't know when the compact cassette started becoming popular - did people make mixtapes in the 70's?
- karaterobot 2y ago> What this means is that it is essentially impossible for all but a glancingly small number of musicians to make meaningful income from their recordings. I'm not sure what's supposed to happen, honestly. With the invention of home recording and all the attendant production tools, the lower barriers to entry, broader exposure due to the internet, etc., there was always going to be a vastly larger amount of music than there was 30 years ago. If the old model had not changed, we'd still be in a world with a glancingly small number of slots on the radio charts for each genre—those are the people the average person knows about, and spends money on—and most other musicians would be broke. I assume. I could be wrong. But my two points are that it's not like the old model was friendly to artists either, and that it's not actually very easy for me to imagine a coherent model for music that would work be equitable for all artists in the world today, given the other changes that've taken place. I don't think it's just to pretend that if there are 4-5x more people releasing music today, we would all would be spending 4-5x more on records and concerts than we did in 1996. And I am not saying that's what the author is saying, I'm just trying to work through the consequences of what I inferred from this article, the economics of which were a little hand-wavey.
- codexb 2y agoIt's also worth pointing out that, historically, a very small percentage of artists live off the income from recordings or reproductions of their works. This is true for musicians, painters, authors, actors, or any other creative artists. By and large, the only way to make a living as an artist is to continuously produce and perform copious amounts of work, or to have another source of income from a day job.
- gamepsys 2y agoThe entire concept of making a living off recordings/reproductions didn't really start until the invention of the printing press which allowed for mass reproductions. Prior to that anyone with enough time on their hands and skills could legally reproduce any text, music, painting, etc for profit. Artist where largely compensated for performances or for original artwork. There was more relative demand for live performances because of the lack of other available entertainment options. Now the primary issue with being a successful artist is the attention economy is incredibly competitive, and the barriers to entry are incredibly low.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- cm2012 2y agoIt's a golden age for music. More than half of Spotify payouts go to non-agency talent, IE small musicians. It's a great discovery mechanism.
- ysofunny 2y agosure... until one realizes one has gotta pay the ripper if they ever wanna get recommended by "the" algorithm of spotify
- freedomben 2y ago"the algorithm" has got to be a tough one though. You can't recommend very many bad fits for the user before they will stop using it, and unknown/lesser known songs are a huge gamble. I badly want an algorithm that I can say, "Find me artists that sounds like <example-song> that have less than 1,000 subcribers (or whatever metric)" but I can understand why they don't do that (because there are very, very few people like me out there). It sucks.
- cue_the_strings 2y agoI'm afraid you'd be dissapointed if you got what you wanted, because it'd likely be AI-generated money-laundering-core.
- sahmeepee 2y agoI don't know if they still have it, but the AI playlist builder on Spotify could do stuff like that. If you play a regular playlist on Spotify called Reggae or Rare Reggae or obscure Reggae you can bet your life it has a few Bob Marley tracks on it. The AI thingummy was able to restrict to less popular artists only.
- cm2012 2y agoIt's the same story on every platform. No one is owed attention. Building an audience is a grind.
- ThrowawayTestr 2y ago
- legitster 2y ago> What this means is that it is essentially impossible for all but a glancingly small number of musicians to make meaningful income from their recordings. I mean, if you look back before radio, the amount of money artists made from recordings was $0 (Okay, maybe some money off of sheet music or player piano sheets). So in the grand scheme of human history, the primary income of musicians has been from their performances. That was true before recordings, and that is true again now. For a weird blip there was a cartel propping up the value of their recordings (of which the industry profited more than musicians). But this isn't a collapse of anything more than it's a regression to the mean - the marginal value of a copy of something approaches to 0 over time. When you hear about artists complaining about royalties from streaming, it was a very, very, very elite group of musicians who ever made money just from dropping albums. You are only hearing from the winners of the Label system. Most bands ended up "owing" money to their record labels. (The way record deals worked, you got paid an advance for songs/albums. But you only kept ~10% of album sales. From which you had to pay back your advance + recording expenses + marketing costs.)
- pelagicAustral 2y agoWhen I was a teen I used to download all my stuff from torrent, or DDL sites. Before that it was Limewire and other P2P networks... These days, with a stable job, I've kind of gone into a weird redemption ark that sees me paying for music from all the bands I used to listed back then... I'm probably about 50% into my collection and I now buy a lot from Bandcamp, but also iTunes... I feel like I'm seeking absolution from the music industry, or something like that...
- giantrobot 2y ago> I'm probably about 50% into my collection and I now buy a lot from Bandcamp, but also iTunes... I feel like I'm seeking absolution from the music industry, or something like that... Go see those bands live and buy something from their merch table, they'll make a lot more money than if you just buy albums.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoI don't think that is true? I would expect an artist to get a far larger cut off Bandcamp than merch or tickets. Artists get like 85% of a zero cost digital sale. I can't imagine a ticket being close to that after ticketmaster takes a cut, the venue takes a cut, and the band pays all the expenses of touring.
- giantrobot 2y agoAn artist only gets 85% off Bandcamp if they don't have a label. If they're on a label they're making a small portion of that 85%. I got the impression the stuff the GP was buying was not a bunch of independent small artists that only have a Bandcamp page and no label. Ticket and merch sales are likely to make a label artist more than download sales. Ticket sales also help get artists more gigs. Bands tour because they make more money than if they only tried to sell records (in any medium).
- Semaphor 2y agoTicket sales for bands I talked to rarely even make up the costs of the gig. Especially if they aren’t the main act with a decent fan base. Merch is what brings in some more money. But depending on the band, touring can even just be for the fun of it, where break-even is a victory. And then there’s the whole pay-2-play, where you get nothing of the tickets, and instead pay to be support. It’s really not as simple or homogenous as people make it seem.
- kevinsync 2y agoApologies if this feels off-topic and ranting, but it's all connected: I'm convinced (in particular by years of reading Bob Lefsetz's punditry [0], as well as working alongside multiple successful musicians, DJs, and industry agencies for many years) that Spotify single-handedly saved the aging and out-of-touch record business, that their payments to artists are fair, and that it's more accessible now than ever before by an order of magnitude to build a real, sustainable career as a musician. You have to simply put in the work, and it is brutal, long, thankless, isolating work, on top of the Herculean task of creating something people legitimately want and connect with. And you should be attractive (not beautiful persay, but charismatic and authentic). And provide the illusion of access to you. And be kind to your fans. And maximize all of your potential channels (digital and IRL, from socials to tours to brand partnerships to merch/apparel to unpredictable, serendipitous syncs in film and tv (ex. Kate Bush "Running Up That Hill")), all the while cultivating fans like plants in a garden. You have to travel and perform, and be present, and be the soundtrack to their lives, always meeting your fans where they are, however they congregate, and and and and and! For years and years. It takes a long time to enjoy a tree you've just planted. People do not have the bandwidth, mentally or financially, to support or patronize more than a few artists that mean something significant to them. Just because the amount of people making and publishing music has exploded doesn't mean that listeners have available slots to add you into their mental playlist, until you keep doing what you're doing long enough that you appear, almost seamlessly, into a moment in their life that awes and delights and converts them into a believer. There is no "right place at the right time" -- you have to be in the right place ALL the time, and eventually your random times become other peoples' "right time". If you never give up, if you're always there, you'll also eventually be a staple on the scene -- you'll be, literally by default, "old guard" that people look up to. You'll have earned your respect, you'll have put in your dues, and the money / fame / power will come as an after-effect. Any other situation where it's overnight success, those acts are created as nothing more than products to be sold. Both can make a lot of money, but money isn't the goal. Craft, legacy, driving culture, these are what artistry is supposed to be about. Money is secondary, and always comes if you take the time to learn the business and take your fan stewardship seriously. The amount of shallow takes on Twitter, Threads, or god forbid LinkedIn about poor musicians who "deserve a living wage", who are "gamed by Big Tech", who are "slaves to the algorithm", who aren't living the dreams they weirdly feel entitled to, they don't deserve anything if their music and persona are nothing anybody wants, if they haven't put in the work, haven't shown up and met people continuously, haven't failed over and over, haven't paid for it with blood, sweat and tears, haven't stuck to their guns until they eventually get lucky -- not because the universe chose them, but because they made sure they were already all of what I wrote above when opportunity came knocking. Like, sorry, the world has become hyper-connected, super decentralized, insular, tribal -- MTV can't break you anymore. None of us are paying attention to the same things as anybody else. It's harder than ever to get attention, and what you're selling had better be damn good -- but if you succeed, the rewards are richer than they've ever been. Most plants get choked out on the jungle floor by the canopy, or end up adapting to quietly survive in their environment. Some defy all odds and break through the top. Chances are you're not going to the top, but you don't have to get choked out either. Anyways. [0] https://lefsetz.com https://lefsetz.com
- codexb 2y ago> "That path turns out to be streaming, a neat compromise between letting consumers listen to whatever they want online and collecting just enough money for it that big record labels are satisfied with their cut." I think it's a bit early to start claiming victory in a paradigm shift to streaming that makes pirating obsolete. The price of video and music streaming has quickly been increasing, and in many cases, we've come full circle to being forced to deal with ads again. It's entirely possible for the music business to price their customers out of the market again to the point that an on-demand pirate streaming service completely overtakes legal streaming. I think we're already approaching that for video streaming.
- skydhash 2y agoI'd love streaming if the client software were actually useful. All of them are disaster in UX if you do more than listening to music in the background. Peak design for me was iTunes 10 and Winamp 2. Which means control/status panel, a queue list and customizable table views for the songs (optional grid view to browse by album). Most streaming clients are click/scroll hell.
- bongodongobob 2y agoI only see this mentality here. On Spotify, I search for a song I want to hear and I play it. Or I add it to a playlist. What more do you want? For it to sense your mood and queue up what you played last year during Oct-November before 10 am while you were driving? I don't understand how the tech crowd thinks Spotify is so hard to use. My 70 year old parents have no issues navigating it.
- lucsky 2y agoNot "hard" to use, no, nobody's saying that. But painful to use for anything else than scroll/click/play, absolutely yes. Active music discovery is terrible, tracking your "progress" in your weekly releases listening is actively being made impossible (the list is seemingly being re-randomized, at random), the obsessive emphasis on tracks rather than albums or artists is very limiting, UIs are not flexible enough, and I could go on for a while. All streaming clients are currently hot garbage. Again, not hard to use, just extremely user hostile for anything more than click and play.
- zombiwoof 2y agoAsk any musician: they never made real money on anything but licensing/publishing fees
- rurban 2y agoAs Steve Albino taught countless indie bands how to make money in the music industry, give away the music to get bookings for a tour and sets, the same thing happens with the movie theatres. You cannot earn anything from the content, you'll only earn from selling soda and popcorn. This author manages to say nothing about this well-known phenomenon. Maybe the NYT also just writes brainless LLM articles now?
- rchaud 2y agoAlbini didn't account for a world where the ticket mafia owns both ticket distribution and venues.
- rurban 2y agoThat's partially true. Albini also called out Ticket Master, as well as Taylor Swift. You can still find independent venues, and sell tickets not via the ticket master mafia. Or if you are as big as Taylor even bypass the movie studios which are an even bigger mafia than ticket master.
- woolion 2y agoMusic distribution, as well as other worldly matters, cost money. It was also a strongly gate-kept industry, while this isn't the case anymore. The main reason for gate-keeping is supposedly to "keep the financial equation fair for everybody". The problem is nobody knows most of the parameter in the equation, not even the gate-keepers themselves. Why? Because the basis for how payments should be done, the mythical "play", is gamed by bot networks. The bot networks are used by small and big artists. Officially, the gate-keepers (Spotify) do not releases official numbers of real data, officially to not give better tools to the bad guys (bot networks). Of course, we know how well security by obscurity works, and it makes everyone dependent on trusting the gate-keeper, now Spotify rather than the music labels. Another point is while the revolution in the distribution model happened, another one happened which is that the gate-keeping essentially disappeared. In any case, the industry has embraced that through for example DistroKid being targeted at making a small revenue from any aspiring musician without any musical barrier. Note that Spotify has shares in Distrokid, even though they have pinky-sweared this special relationship does not give either to Spotify nor Distrokid any advantage regarding access to data from other involved third parties (other marketplaces, labels, etc). To round it up, even if the parameters of the financial equations are partly released, the creative industry is known for its "creative accounting" (also known as Hollywood accounting). The creative accounting lets the industry take advantage of the tax breaks that are offered to the music industry in basically all countries on some conditions, and stretch these conditions to situations that the spirit of the law normally excludes. There is another incentive to lie about the numbers. It gives the possibility to undercut any viable competition to consolidate a monopoly (the Amazon method). I believe that the only thing that can really improve the situation is way more transparency than we have. The complaints from musicians are often unrealistic, but it is not their fault as they cannot have a realistic view of what things really cost. So all they have is to try to strengthen their side in the tug of war. Ideally we would move away from that process towards a cooperative model, but this is possible only through trust, which cannot be obtained by obscurity.
- altacc 2y agoIronically as Paramount+ is unavailable where I live I'll have to pirate this documentary. Streaming music services are not perfect but at least for the most part I can move service and not lose access to the bands I enjoy listening to, whereas for video media the content is unique to the service. With the massive differences between music & video content financing & production costs, I wonder if there will ever be a consolidation to common video streaming services. E.g. you watch on Netflix or Paramount and the production company gets paid regardless.
- 8fingerlouie 2y agoIn 1992, the Danish representative for the music industry managed to negotiate a “Private Copying Levy” on all recordable media (mainly CDs, DVDs, VHS tapes , memory cards and USB drives). fees were around (per media) : CD media : $0.35 DVD media : $0.56 Memory card : $0.80 They then managed to pass a new law in 2022 that expanded the original law to also apply to phones, tablets, computers, basically anything that can store data. Hard drive < 128GB (SSD or magnetic, internal or external) : $0.59 Hard drive > 128GB : $2.34 Tablet / Phone / Computer : $6.59 No wonder the music industry loves piracy. For every tablet/phone/computer sold, they’re literally pocketing $6.59 without ever lifting a finger or even delivering any content (not even a bad U2 album). For every hard drive, memory card, or SSD sold, they’re pocketing from $0.59 to $2.34, again, those are not preloaded with music content either. Of course, having paid the fee does not entitle you to any form of piracy.
- rekoil 2y agoSweden too, its such bullshit. These laws are basically about the fact that you technically can store pirated music on a device, therefore you are, such a dirty racket.
- 8fingerlouie 2y agoBut if you are pirating, you’re still committing a crime and will be fined the full amount.
- tomsmeding 2y ago> No wonder the music industry loves piracy. For every tablet/phone/computer sold, they’re literally pocketing [...] With "the music industry" presumably you mean record labels, or even something else? Surely this money doesn't go to artists — how would anyone know how to distribute the money. Even distribution among record labels is super unclear.
- golergka 2y agoIf you're an artist who sold the rights to your music to the label, the money has already gone to you.
- s_dev 2y agoHere is how Ireland is trialling to pay some artists: https://www.citizensinformation.ie/en/employment/unemployment-and-redundancy/employment-support-schemes/basic-income-arts/ https://www.citizensinformation.ie/en/employment/unemploymen... tl;dr: Just give artists with body of work a basic wage and ask for nothing in return. See what they produce. We will see at the end of 2025/2026 some report that suggests either this is feasible or not to continue.
- fallinditch 2y agoOld legacy acts account for a significant proportion of streaming revenue. I don't know the revenue numbers but you can get an idea of an artist's popularity from the Monthly Listeners metric on Spotify. I would hazard a guess and assert that most of the middle ranking artists that make up the rump of streaming listens (with monthly Spotify listeners over 1 million) are legacy acts. A random example: Dan Fogelberg achieved some success 40 - 50 years ago, his style of soft singer songwriter has very little relevance today and yet he is getting 1.1 million monthly listeners on Spotify. It's really hard for contemporary artists to get to 1 million Spotify listeners even if they are critically-lauded. For example, here are some artists from the top of the Album Of The Year aggregate list of lists of the best albums of 2023 [0], together with their monthly listeners on Spotify. In other words these artists' albums were widely viewed by critics as among the best albums of 2023. Lankum - 93k Anohni - 452k Wednesday - 173k Young Fathers - 461k Sure, critical acclaim does not equal commercial success, but these numbers highlight how hard it can be to break through even if you are really good. And with the already massive catalog of recorded music swelling further and further every year the outlook for new artists is scary. The massive choice and availability of music on streaming platforms is absolutely fantastic for music lovers but the competitive environment for contemporary artists is one where they are trying to find and grow an audience in a massive glut of content. It's hard, and very different from the old music biz. I came across a new artist yesterday, NIKK has just 112 monthly Spotify listeners at this time, and their debut album is really great! Described as "ambient glitchpop soundscapes" give it a listen! https://nikk.bandcamp.com/album/you-see-me-through-your-eyes https://nikk.bandcamp.com/album/you-see-me-through-your-eyes https://open.spotify.com/album/7uPhwANGy9w6oJryJESh0f?si=vDxJehx-Sb2HzhUUEDgYJA https://open.spotify.com/album/7uPhwANGy9w6oJryJESh0f?si=vDx... [0] https://www.albumoftheyear.org/list/summary/2023/ https://www.albumoftheyear.org/list/summary/2023/
- jazz9k 2y agoThe software and music industry both learned a good lesson from piracy: start a subscription service so there is nothing to pirate. I don't think there is very much commercial software nowadays that doesn't include a subscription model. A direct result of rampant piracy
- Sophira 2y agoSurely this is glossing over the fact that the reason money is being made from streams is due to adverts, and that the same people who would pirate music back in the day are a subset of the people who block ads.