6 ms·
A Skype call in Ethiopia will now get you 15 years in prison
- mkhattab 14y agoSomething similar, to a lesser extreme, exists in Egypt. I believe this isn't an issue of security but an issue with the profits telecoms make on international calls. Telecom Egypt is sustaining significant losses due to VOIP and I assume it must be the same with Ethio Telco.
- mjwalshe 14y agoYep that is why in third world coutries the PTT minister is a highly desireable job - lots of opertunities for diverting cash to ones swiss bank account.
- yread 14y agoThank God it only happens in third world countries! We sure know better than these savages
- rfrey 14y agoCleptocracies exist. Systematic diversion of state and aid resources to personal accounts is a real and persistent problem in many parts of the world. To not acknowledge that out of fear of appearing neo-colonialist is, I think, misguided. Certainly North America and Europe (I assume that's what you meant by "we") have corruption issues, especially with deferred bribes in the form of industry appointments, and contract money flowing to well-connected companies. But that's decidedly different than seeing large percentages of tax revenue ending up as personal property, or state industries like telecoms being awarded as personal fiefdoms to cronies, who then use revenues like a piggy bank. "Political correctness" is not a dirty word in my vocabulary -- I usually see it as sensitivity or tact -- but censoring our appraisal of corrupt governments because there are elements of corruption in the west, out of fear we'll be accused of hypocrisy or colonialism, is not helpful.
- mjwalshe 14y agowell shall we say south of the border there was lots of Qustionable conduct "Hem Hem" - though Argentina expropraiting Telefonicas assets gave me a good laugh.
- GoodIntentions 14y ago>> third world countries like Canada. regulatory capture + an effective duopoly means I get to pay for gold plated service and actually get telcom services that the rest of the world laughs at.
- mjwalshe 14y agoWell The USA's botched derglation and mobile where the caller pays are another example of messed up telecoms.
- joelhaasnoot 14y agoReleveant speech from the Oslo Freedom Forum by exiled journalist: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pECH8Co_oxE http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pECH8Co_oxE (also provides some background - 40 000 put in camps during 2005 elections) Having lived in Ethiopia for almost 10 years, this is has been systematically going on for years. It ofcourse started as a way to keep revenue coming in from long distance phone calls, blocking services like net2phone. I've also been told that the whole country had a 2Mb satellite connection and everything was dialup. Traceroutes left Ethiopia and came back 750ms later in New York, but they now have fiber connections and seem to be connected through Djibouti. Now they're blocking Tor and snooping on opposition parties (what's left) and bloggers. SMS traffic also can be shutdown whenever they want.
- vecinu 14y agoI had no idea Djibouti was an independent state. Thank you for teaching me geography.
- guard-of-terra 14y agoThat's why state monopolies are bad. It's not state that owns the monopoly, it's the other way around.
- jhaglund 14y agoDictators and corrupt governments are bad. State monopolies can be bad. IMHO.
- jsilence 14y agoMay I be so bold to throw in the theory that states are bad?
- rmc 14y agoCountries without a state monopoly (e.g. UK) are talking about laws like this.
- molmalo 14y agoProtecting the state owned company its just the excuse to protect the corrupt government from having the same destiny as the egyptian, gaddafi's and so on. Some state monopolies are essential to democracy, for example justice, military, law enforcement. Imagine private judges.
- noarchy 14y agoI can not only imagine private arbitration, I've seen it. I don't wish to claim that applying this to the entire judicial system would be simple or without potential pitfalls. Private security, meanwhile, has been around for a long time, and is used extensively today.
- Heliosmaster 14y agoThe sentence " The new legislation empowers the state-owned telecom to prohibit the use not only of VoIP services, but also of video chatting, social media, e-mail, and any other data transfer service capable of communicating information. So that encompass pretty much all communication except for speaking aloud and talking within your own mind." scares the shit out of me...
- terhechte 14y agoThe sad part is that they're crippling innovation and thus, in the long run, crippling their and all their people's economic prospect. The digital industry is a lot like the invention of the steam machine. Ethiopia will feel, in several years to come, what it would have been like for an early European country, to back out of the industrial revolution. Once again, politicians are trading the long term for short term monetary gains. (by gains I mean probably the ability to snoop on citicens and to make more money).
- its_so_on 14y agoamateurs. you know you can just "ask" skype to let you in on all your subjects' conversations and they'll do it?
- vixen99 14y agoNo,I didn't know that. Can you give chapter and verse?
- its_so_on 14y agohere's one http://www.topsecretwriters.com/2010/02/the-skype-conspiracy-and-american-intelligence/ http://www.topsecretwriters.com/2010/02/the-skype-conspiracy... - not hard to find
- barik 14y agoJust curious, but are you actually using a conspiracy theory site as evidence of "not hard to find"? My favorite part of the article was perhaps this line: "The evidence comes from events that revealed the NSA’s true motives from 2005 through 2009." It sure is a shame that the author forgot to link to such evidence and actually present it; someone should notify the webmaster.
- alan_cx 14y agoI cant help thinking that while there are so many issues like this in the EU and US, having a pop at Ethiopia is a bit ridiculous. If we cant get privacy and freedom sussed out, why on Earth should Ethiopia be held up as some sort of evil?
- Flimm 14y agoCan't both Western laws and Ethiopian laws be bad? Why is it a must that the West fix their laws before Ethiopia consider fixing theirs? Isn't Hacker News for everyone, not just western readers?
- mikeash 14y agoIt's ridiculous to criticize a country for jailing people who use a piece of benign software, because other countries also have problems? What?
- moron 14y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tu_quoque http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tu_quoque
- instakill 14y agoYou sir, are an idiot.
- toyg 14y agoIf this sort of trend continues unabated (see also UK "snooper's charter" etc), VPN companies will soon make more money than Apple. (unless VPN software is also covered by this legislation, which the article doesn't say).
- jsilence 14y agoPretty sure it will be. At some point.
- noarchy 14y agoI have to think that VPNs will be targeted soon enough, along with any other solution that obfuscates/encrypts/etc the details of your Internet traffic. We've already seen China's firewall being tweaked to counter such measures. In the West, we'll probably see the usual suspects, like the UK, cracking down first.
- philhippus 14y agoThe only reason they get away with this is that it makes no difference to the day to day lives of the average Ethiopean. It's a bit like us in the west having legislation passed that says you are not allowed to go over Mach 2 in your private jet. I wouldn't expend energy fighting that, but take away my comms rights, and I'll burn your mansions to ashes.
- bradleyland 14y agoNot digging the analogy. The Arab Spring reinforced the role of free communication in the process of overturning tyrannical regimes. All analogies are broken at some level, but the discord in relevance here is too much. It may not be the case for the people of Ethiopia today, but mobile phones have proven to be a powerful disrupter in similar countries. Skype acts as a conceptual anchor for the reader in the article, but the law is not limited to Skype. You can't downplay this legislation. It is an assault on the very foundation of freedom. Make no mistake about it.
- philhippus 14y agoI agree that this is a very serious assault. My intention was not to downplay this legislation but to point out how it passed so easily in a population of 85 million. Their priorities are fending off starvation. i.e. they are being kicked while they are down.
- briandear 14y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_they_came%E2%80%A6 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_they_came%E2%80%A6
- molmalo 14y agoNot the same. Technology is making every day Internet use cheaper and cheaper. So it's not hard to imagine a broad adoption in a few years there. It's absurd to think the same happening with match 2 jets any time soon. (even when I'd like that). Also, Internet comms enables a lot of business to flourish, that will otherwise be badly damaged.
- josscrowcroft 14y agoThis is a lot more serious that just Skype calls... they also make using email and any form of non-State-owned communication illegal, too. Amazing to think somebody making an unsnooped call would get longer in prison than some murderers!
- pbhjpbhj 14y agoIt's like copyright infringement against billionaire corporations in The West ...
- raganwald 14y agoYou can say what you like about the Constitution, but my tin foil hat says that the reason you don’t have laws like this in North America is because we have the technology and can afford to snoop on Skype, email, and so forth at scale. Ethiopia simply doesn’t have the money and/or know-how to monitor VoIP and Email at scale. There’s no salient difference in policy between them and us. If we rewrite the law to say, “Thou shalt not use a communication mechanism we can’t monitor,” the behaviours of Ethiopia and US/Canada aren’t all that different.
- BCM43 14y agoWhich is why it's illegal for me to use gpg, otr, and tor, right?
- nnnnnnnn 14y agoNot so long ago in the 90s people were being persecuted for developing and using cryptographic technology. Specifically, the author of PGP, Phillip Zimmerman, was prosecuted for developing the original PGP -- sparking considerable outrage. If you weren't around and paying attention in the 90s these links can help give you a feel of the general political climate: Author of PGP: http://www.contra.org/pgp/PhilZimmerman.html http://www.contra.org/pgp/PhilZimmerman.html More on Zimmerman: http://www.spectacle.org/795/zimm.html http://www.spectacle.org/795/zimm.html Popular T-shirt at the time: http://www.conchord.org/xeno/pgp.html http://www.conchord.org/xeno/pgp.html
- fghh45sdfhr3 14y agoWell I still think the intentions of monitoring here are still "good". There are people who think terrorists are a bigger threat to us than us turning ourselves into a more fascist nation. I disagree. But I still think the drive here is still primarily for security... albeit it theater. But the theater is just covering up incompetence, not evil malice. But in Ethiopia I think I recognize the familiar pattern of government wanting to prevent communication, especially large scale fast or instant communication, because that's what leads to popular revolutions. Totalitarian governments do that often, this is why the USSR slowly leaked the news of Chernobyl over three days. And why North Korea would not show its national soccer team's World Cup games live. Too much opportunity for too many people to find each other in the streets at the same time. We are not there yet. However, it's not like our current path leads any place else. And I wonder if well-of people like Singaporeans for example, simply don't engage in violent popular revolutions? This would mean, that as long as our quality of life stays mostly at industrialized world levels, we won't do anything that extreme.
- danso 14y agoThis Venture Beat piece is a riff of a TechCrunch article which is a riff off of a Al-Jazeera aggregation...the source article, I assume, is in Arabic: http://www.addisadmassnews.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=2328%3A2012-05-26-13-33-26&catid=1%3Alatest-news&Itemid=513 http://www.addisadmassnews.com/index.php?option=com_content&... Here is a blogger (a lecturer at Arba Minch University) who the Al-Jazeera aggregation links to; he has some interesting insights on what it means for the average Ethiopian: https://endalk.wordpress.com/2012/05/28/the-new-ethiopian-telecom-service-infringements-law-is-it-the-most-creative-way-copying-sopa-and-pipa/ https://endalk.wordpress.com/2012/05/28/the-new-ethiopian-te...
- wave 14y agoIt is in Amharic language written in Ge'ez script known as Fidel. Since you don't have the font installed, you weren't able to see it. For those who are not familiar with the alphabet, it looks like this: http://www.amharicmachine.com/alphabet.gif http://www.amharicmachine.com/alphabet.gif
- leeoniya 14y agosounds like they're taking all measures so their people can't organize an uprising and overthrow the government.
- azarias 14y agoWe deploy many research projects in Ethiopia, and the situation has always been murky. For example, it has been long outlawed to provide calling services for others over VOIP. So, if you run an internet café, and provide a calling service charging people, you faced jail. Private use of internet has been mostly unmonitored so far---but far too many people are now using their home internet for calling other people it appears. Given its very big diaspora population, communication is a very lucrative business in Ethiopia, and the government has made it clear in the past that the monopoly is going to continue this way because "it is one of the major sources of funds for development". This sounds like the next step in that approach.
- jackcviers3 14y agoThere was a time when U.S. Americans would have condemned any attempt by the government to inject itself into their lives. However, that time has long since passed, and with very little effect on the way most Americans live their lives. Though the government is surely monitoring internet communications, at least people aren't being disappeared. I'd like to see an amendment to the constitution that protects the citizens' right to privacy for all forms of electronic communications and personal digital storage. I think your online identity should fall under the same right of non-self-discrimination that spouses and accused persons have.
- technology 14y agoJust saw this on the comments on VB: "Can't imagine why they are one of the poorest countries on earth." Agreed ! I would add this relevant idea by Matt Ridley from The Rational optimist (http://amzn.to/KvuK4S http://amzn.to/KvuK4S) :- As long as human exchange and specialization are allowed to thrive somewhere, then culture evolves whether leaders help it or hinder it, and the result is that prosperity spreads,technology progresses, poverty declines, disease retreats, fertility falls, happiness increases, freedom grows, knowledge flourishes and the environment improves.
- goombastic 14y agoTechnology and information is on the verge of bringing disruptively empowering change to people and societies everywhere. Politicians have lately realized how dangerous that can be to their entrenched positions in power. Even places like India, America and many other supposedly democratic countries are now clamping down hard on the Internet using various excuses. All of this is disheartening to say the least. China seems to be the role model for where we are headed.