7 ms·
Australia must treat housing as a human right: Former State Supreme Court judge
- jaimex2 2y agoWhere was this clown a quarter of a decade ago? Everyone voted for the mess we're in, deal with it.
- downrightmike 2y agoWhy didn't he do it when he was still a justice?
- defrost 2y agoAre you thinking perhaps of a politician arguing for a policy change and bringing that about through party support, or a human rights lawyer bring a landmark case before a justice and then a Supreme Court? As a general rule Supreme Court Justices only decide upon cases bought before them on the balance of the legal arguments made for or against them.
- exe34 2y agopeople mellow out and change their minds in old age.
- paranoidrobot 2y agoBecause people generally dislike and get nervous when Justices start doing things that look like political campaigning. Anything that appears to impact their impartiality is a problem, and campaigning for anything would do that.
- lmpdev 2y agoThe great unwashed voted for whom Murdoch told them to, especially Queensland. Queensland is also the biggest predictor of Federal election outcomes. It’s been this way since the early 90s, but ramped up in the 2010s. The period of 2013 to 2022 was the time we should have been slowly building back the calibre of our public sector that Howard had dismantled from 1996-2006. Murdoch ensured this wouldn’t occur, though. I’ve become extremely cynical about the nature of the Australian character; this is best exemplified by the original text spurring the phrase “The Lucky Country”. Australia is a beautiful and lucky country, filled with people weak of character or substance. We are effectively the halfwit-run mine for the rest of the world. We manufacture nothing. Innovate on little. It sounds awful, but we haven’t suffered enough. Our identity is only half developed, and our past is largely shameful. I love my country, but we need to be better and try much harder to be better people. We need to do what we can, not just what is easy.
- contingencies 2y agoThis. What sux is that we have so much space and decent tech and engineering education, we should be a renewables leader, but instead we have 1950s American suburban dystopia 2.0. I really think we could restructure industrial outcomes with Industry 4.0 style thinking along renewable lines, so that we can harness low cost energy in the periods where it makes sense. Aluminium smelting is a prime example. We have all these stupid sites like former open cut mines that are just begging for industrial uses, or space programs, or something else of forward-thinking potential. Not to mention oodles of flat land nobody wants to live on anyway. Unfortunately our federal government is AWOL on comm's, and the state and local government is even worse. Entrenched corruption and not my department is the order of the day. So many people see a degradation in social character, the new norm is 'me first' and 'who cares'. Our political system worked to defer change when post-WWII it didn't matter. Now reality is moving ahead and we're left with the rotting carcass of a social democracy where flesh-eating maggots (and I'm referring here to native politicians and business people especially, not well-meaning immigrants from less educated backgrounds who may not actually know another way) have already hatched and our public wealth is being carried out the door. It is a shame they tortured Assange so much, I had high hopes for his transparency applied to government. It's so sorely needed.
- defrost 2y agoA massive tender for wind and solar projects is to be launched next week to help repower Australia’s biggest aluminium smelter Tomago, near Newcastle, with its majority owner saying nuclear is out of the question because it is too slow and too expensive. The tender will be a landmark event for the Australian renewable energy transition, because the Tomalgo smelter – with annual demand of more than 8 terawatt hours, is the biggest single energy consumer in the country. ~ (Mar 13, 2024) https://reneweconomy.com.au/australias-biggest-smelter-to-launch-massive-wind-and-solar-tender-says-nuclear-too-costly/ https://reneweconomy.com.au/australias-biggest-smelter-to-la... Majority owner Rio Tinto this year has already announced two record-breaking contracts for wind and solar farms in Australia to provide power for its Boyne Island smelter in Gladstone, Queensland, and its two alumina refineries in the same port city. Those contracts included one for the first gigawatt scale solar project in Australia, the 1.1 GW Upper Calliope solar project in central Queensland, and the 1.4 GW Bungapan wind project to be developed by iron ore billionaire Andrew Forrest’s majority owned Windlab. > Unfortunately our federal government is AWOL on comm's, and the state and local government is even worse. They don't seem to be involved and it's not clear why they should be.
- yulingar5 2y ago[dead]
- KittenInABox 2y agoI hope this is the first of a wave of policy declaring access to stable housing a human right. It's practically impossible to avoid poverty and instability without this. Need an address to open bank accounts, get employment checks, receive medication delivery (useful for people with disabilities), and just to store your personal belongings safely.
- chii 2y agoshelter can be considered a right, but a lot of australians imply ownership when they want housing declared a human right.
- defrost 2y agoOwnership | affordability are currently linked to a degree; I meet a lot of Australians in the 20 to 35 year range who want even a one or two bedroom apartment to base themselves about that's stable and reliable in the sense of a rent or a morgage payment that can be relied upon for a decade or more. The big issues here are availability .. finding a place to rent or buy that's affordable can be a challenge, and dependability .. many rentals in recent years have been ripped out from under tennents and|or prices increased.
- robertlagrant 2y agoAll of this is related to demand vs supply. Too many people entering (population growth and net immigration) vs the rate of housing build.
- em500 2y agoA policy declaring some abstract right going to do very little. Most people can agree that more housing development is necessarily and desirable, in an abstract sense, or even on a national level. But when it comes to any specific location it's usually "but not in this neighborhood". Since this happens pretty much near every place that is at somewhat desirable to live (usually in/near large cities in developed countries) and consequently already have many people living there and we get the current outcome. This is the same story all across cities in Europe, Northern America and developed Asia/Oceania nowadays.
- scarab92 2y agoAustralia has heavily imbalanced supply-demand in housing. It accepts a very high number of migrants each year, compared to its population, and the design of it's migration system means that these are almost all white collar workers who need homes not blue collar workers who can build them. It's zoning system is also hyper-local, which results in NIMBY dominated planning schemes that typically prohibit increased density.
- robertlagrant 2y ago> It accepts a very high number of migrants each year, compared to its population Looked this up - Covid aside, Australia has taken in 250k people net every year for the last ten years, except for the most recent couple of years, where it's gone up to 400k-500k[0]. That requires the equivalent of a new Canberra[1] every year. Current population: 27m people[2]. I'm not sure what that rate per population is compared to most countries, but it's much higher than the UK's. In 2023 the UK took in 685,000 people[3], but on a base of 67.5m in 2022[4]. [0] https://www.abs.gov.au/statistics/people/population/overseas-migration/latest-release https://www.abs.gov.au/statistics/people/population/overseas... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=List_of_cities_in_Australia_by_population&oldid=1233421129 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=List_of_cities_in... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Demographics_of_Australia&oldid=1236343008 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Demographics_of_A... [3] https://migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/resources/briefings/long-term-international-migration-flows-to-and-from-the-uk https://migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/resources/briefings/lo... [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Demographics_of_the_United_Kingdom&oldid=1238001326 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Demographics_of_t...
- austin-cheney 2y agoThe economics of fixed resources, such as housing, are not directly vested in supply/demand ratios. As a proof the city where I live has gained about 80,000 new residents in the last 4.5 years. Supply cannot keep up with demand and its not effecting prices.
- scarab92 2y ago
- snapplebobapple 2y agoHousing is not a human right. The good news is the problem in most cases is government zoning and permitting policies that drastically restrict supply and there are lots of logical arguments for requiring the government to gtfo of our way in this case being close to a human right
- jltsiren 2y agoUniversal Declaration of Human Rights, Article 25, Section 1: > Everyone has the right to a standard of living adequate for the health and well-being of himself and of his family, including food, clothing, housing and medical care and necessary social services, and the right to security in the event of unemployment, sickness, disability, widowhood, old age or other lack of livelihood in circumstances beyond his control. Human rights generally represent a much higher standard than the minimal rights protected by national constitutions.
- robertlagrant 2y agoThat statement is meaningless if not backed up by money. That's why national constitutions are the way they are. They have to actually do it.
- tossandthrow 2y agoIt doesn't have to be funded. No law have to be funded. The mere idea that financial concerns is above law is a really new idea and not something to take for granted. The fact that central banks are divorced from the political process is just around 100 years old for the US (Federal Reserve Act).
- snapplebobapple 2y agoIt's not a new idea, it's one of the oldest ideas because it is a concern for property rights. Any of this style of "right" where it is promising to do something rather than not do something requires funding by definition, as the thing that it requires you to do will require resources and said resources will have to be forcefully confiscated from someone else. These types of "rights" are, by definition, coercive property transfers. it's fundamentally different than the original idea of rights (sometimes referred to as negative rights vs these positive rights) that cost nothing because they are of the form "The government will not do X". Further, I am extremely skeptical positive rights solve anything because the problem is pretty much never a need for coercive property transfer, it's almost always a need for more aggressive enforcement of negative rights to stop the governments doing stupid things that screw up markets (i.e. enforce property rights by relaxing zoning and forcing permits to be quick and painless with high likelihood of being quickly approved if they fit the relaxed zoning in this case) or market power abuse by private people/corporations which then needs more aggressive antitrust enforcement (i.e. stop collusion in the rental market by breaking up large rental trusts and/or fining the crap out of people using software to collude to raise prices for this specific example). coercive property transfer just makes things worse in this case because it doesn't fix the inability to build the needed housing stock where it is needed.
- roenxi 2y agoThe headline is somewhat silly. Australia already has an extensive public housing program [0]. This suggests that we already agree that everyone should have shelter. Otherwise, why do we have a public housing program? Declaring something to be a human right doesn't magically make it easier to implement complex policy. And we don't need a book on the topic, someone needs to put a pdf up on the internet of a proposed policy change. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_housing_in_Australia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_housing_in_Australia
- smcleod 2y agoMigrants aren't the issue. People owning more than one house to make profit off renting out properties is a huge portion of the problem. The for-profit housing sector in Australia (and New Zealand) is absolutely disgusting and I don't think it'll change as the people with the power are also the people with the houses. Don't even get me started on the rigged and frankly corrupt banking sector. No human being should be able to make recurring profit from the need to put a basic roof over your head.
- parineum 2y ago> No human being should be able to make recurring profit from the need to put a basic roof over your head. I know a significant number of people who prefer renting because of the onerousness of ownership. Who is going to rent to them if they can't profit from it?
- tossandthrow 2y agoThis comment does take quite a number of steps to reach a conclusions. Parent said that nobody should be able to profit, this will not eliminate the rental market. You can still own housing and rent it out and take a rent that covers your cost (including the work you need to do in order to rent it out). This is already well established. Public housing also does not run on prayers and good intentions - and yet they manage to pay salary to contractors and run the administrative burden. The only cost there is associated with public housing is the opportunity cost which is indeed something the parent commenter argues should never be a concern in areas regarding core human needs - like shelter.
- tap-snap-or-nap 2y agoDiscussion about this subject only online is nearly impossible due to vested interests because people commenting here more likely do not represent the homeless and the poor.
- tossandthrow 2y agoYou don't feel like the interests of the homeless and the poor are represented in any of these threads?
- robertlagrant 2y ago> Discussion about this subject only online is nearly impossible due to vested interests because people commenting here more likely do not represent the homeless and the poor. This is backwards - almost noone here has a vested interest. A homeless person in Australia would have one.
- andrewstuart 2y agoAustralian housing is an epic disaster on the largest scale. A market open to buyers around the world. A market with no obligation to report money laundering. A market which is a ponzi that has now hit hyper growth, attracting even more global attention. Whilst children live in tents and cars. Politicians love it because the insane hyper growth makes them more rich because many of them own extensive housing portfolios. Australia has nothing on the horizon to fix it.
- globalnode 2y agoThis is actually the case, and its shocking to see there are so many things wrong with housing here. In the time since COVID lockdowns ended my rent has doubled. Literally doubled. And people seem to be acting like its all a normal part of a functioning economy. Only people who own houses here are drug lords, politicians and anyone over the age of 50 who bought property when it was affordable.
- andrewstuart 2y ago>> Only people who own houses here are drug lords, politicians and anyone over the age of 50 who bought property when it was affordable. Also foreign buyers and money laundering criminals from all around the world - who knows from where? No-one knows from where because Australia keeps no systematic records and has no enforcement systems for the laws and no interest in tracking or enforcing because anything that inhibits the flow of money is bad. You can't buy a mobile phone without 3 forms of ID but you can buy a house with a suitcase full of cash no questions asked.
- defrost 2y ago> but you can buy a house with a suitcase full of cash no questions asked. You could twenty odd years ago but I'm not sure you can anymore; IIRC cash transactions over $10K are now subject to some kind of statement as to where it came from after a laundering Bill became an Act of Law (or did it?). I did hand over 60K as a deposit for a house some years back, the Estate agent asked why and I said I was going to be charged to cut a banker's cheque so I asked for cash instead .. they wobbled a bit about taking it and I asked if they were going to refuse to accept legal tender and that was that, cash accepted, contract signed.
- yyy888sss 2y agoWe actually do need something like this, or at least the right to develop land. Right now in Australia we have tyranny of the majority, because the 30% of home owners + 30% of mortgage holders have realised they can get rich if the government restricts supply (bans development) and increases demand (adjusts immigration yearly to outpace construction). For a century there seemed to be a 'social contract' that getting young people a home and helping them start families was important for the country, now though that concept seems to be totally dead. Just creating a legal 'right' to build a house on your land would be the best fix and help a lot, but long term we really need to fix the social contract which held everything together in the first place.
- averageRoyalty 2y ago> For a century there seemed to be a 'social contract' that getting young people a home and helping them start families was important for the country, now though that concept seems to be totally dead. In fact every federal and most state governments across the political divide have had some form of "first home buyer" grant or program for decades to get people into the market. Often these programs offer reduced interest, lump sums or deposits of 1-10%. This of course decreases supply. Notice that all of these homeowners (as a collective group) have pulled the rope up behind them. For a lot of them they can't afford their house value to go down as they're on a 35 year mortgage. A 20% drop in house value could effectively destroy 5-10 years of their work paying it off via devaluation. What would you have people do? These are self-created problems with no easy exit strategy.
- hackeraccount 2y agoIs there no easy exit strategy? I think that if you remove the barriers to making more houses people will do just that; that if there are more houses people will buy them. Would that fix all the housing problems? Probably not but I think it'd fix a number of them.
- averageRoyalty 2y agoAggressive increase in supply reduces demand, which reduces price of existing stock. Many, many people have a vested interest in keeping that stock at a high price (both single family home owners and investors). Wiping 10 years of payments a family has made off the value of a property overnight isn't popular. On top of that, housing is a key element of our economy ("safe as houses") and the impact on a big enough drop to make a difference would likely be very bad.
- globalnode 2y agoWe are facing or about to face a homelessness crisis here in Australia. It makes my blood boil the sheer greed driving this country, supported by algorithmic cartel price increases that the govt turns a blind eye to, in fact participates in. I can tell you from years of watching this that NOTHING will change. People will suffer, politicians will shrug and say "its out of our control, its the free market working as intended", and a few people will get rich while whole generations go under. I give up at this stage. Next election, people will come out and vote again for the clowns that caused all this. -- everything can be fixed but its not because greed.
- averageRoyalty 2y agoI can't imagine how unsurprised you'd be to find out most pollies own investment properties[1]. I don't believe that data covers property owned via trusts/family either, or large quantities of property sold just before moving to a leadership role[2]. 1. https://www.yourinvestmentpropertymag.com.au/expert-insights/how-many-property-investments-australian-politicians-own https://www.yourinvestmentpropertymag.com.au/expert-insights... 2. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10682663/Peter-Dutton-net-worth-property-portfolio.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10682663/Peter-Dutt...
- cpncrunch 2y agoIs housing unaffordable in Australia? In Sydney, the most expensive city, a small apartment rents for $500/wk. national min wage is $24/hr, or $813/wk after tax, but most jobs will pay more in sydney. Or you could live in a cheaper city earning min wage.
- scarab92 2y agoThat perspective makes sense in America where there is a strong supply response to increasing prices. In America, enough housing physically exists such that, it's typically just a matter of price. In Australia, the population increased so suddenly after covid, that we just haven't been able to build enough houses quick enough to stop homelessness. For context, at current occupancy rates, our housing industry is building enough new homes for about 240,000 additional people per year, but our net migration is about 600,000 per year. Unlike in America, most of our homeless population does have full time jobs, it's just that there are hundreds of people applying for every available property which means it often takes many months to secure one. Prices are increasing, and will eventually find a new higher equilibrium, but it's going to take years to build enough housing to solve our homelessness problems.
- cpncrunch 2y ago>For context, at current occupancy rates, our housing industry is building enough new homes for about 240,000 additional people per year, but our net migration is about 600,000 per year. That is certainly a problem that needs to be fixed, but my point was just that housing is not unaffordable at the moment. >there are hundreds of people applying for every available property which means it often takes many months to secure one. I find that hard to believe in general. If that was the case then prices would simply increase to match demand. You will always get news stories like this, but it doesn't apply to all properties. Probably just subsidized rent, or underpriced ones. If you go for the slightly overpriced properties, I'm guessing you won't have to compete with hundreds of buyers.
- averageRoyalty 2y ago61% of your wages going to rent (not even a mortgage) doesn't scream "affordable housing" to me. And although remote working normalisation has changed things a bit in some industries, most jobs are concentrated in cities and the cost of living in or near a city is much higher than (for example) the US.
- xcavier 2y agoIs this where we request commentators to ‘out’ themselves as Australian citizens/residents (or not) before they respond (born Brisvegas 1970 here)