4 ms·
Doesn't rain fall on the leaves as much as the soil?
by SoftTalker 2y ago
Doesn't rain fall on the leaves as much as the soil?
- r2_pilot 2y agoIsn't the point of being smart human beings is that we do things better than what occurs in nature?
- NilMostChill 2y agoThat assumes that rain falling on leaves serves no purpose.
- stale2002 2y agoNature isn't perfect and has disadvantages compared to us. We don't have to invent ex post facto explanations for why something is the case in nature or why there is some un-intuitive reason as for why the natural way is better.
- twojacobtwo 2y agoNor are we perfect and we've been wrong about much in nature more often than we've been right over the past many millennia. The previous poster didn't imply either case regardless. The post simply pointed out an assumption being made. Frankly, I prefer the way that thinks of 'ex post facto' explanations for nature. At least that keeps us hypothesizing and not sitting there tooting our own horns.
- quaintdev 2y ago> Nature isn't perfect and has disadvantages compared to us. Wow we have completely different world views. I think nature is perfect and it's us who have gone too far away from it to notice and hence we are far from perfection as well. Ideally we should not be comparing us to nature since we are part of it. But somewhere deep down we know we are not aligned with it so we end up comparing it to humans which seems pretty grandiose on our end.
- throwthrowuknow 2y agoHow can nature be perfect when it is constantly changing? We alter our environment out of necessity, we would only be able to survive in a very small number of climates on Earth if we did nothing to change our surroundings. Lucky you if you happen to be somewhere with year round fruit to pluck from the vine and temperate climate in the winters but that leaves the other 8 billion people to die of starvation and exposure.
- freedomben 2y agoI'm sincerely fascinated by your perspective. I haven't heard this viewpoint before. Why do you think nature is perfect? I.e. what is your "gold standard" against which you measure? Something that immediately comes to mind for me is all the death and suffering that is abundant through nature. If the only thing that matters is propagation of life, then nature does seem pretty good at it, but as a being that operates some layers above the selfish gene, it seems far from perfect.
- quaintdev 2y ago> Something that immediately comes to mind for me is all the death and suffering that is abundant through nature What if this is the best it can do with all the things that can go wrong or are going wrong. Perfection does not mean things will never go wrong. They can and they will. I can give you example of process that is near perfection: photosynthesis. Nature can store energy and then utilize it without creating adverse effect on other life. This is just one example but there are many processes like this.
- NilMostChill 2y ago> Nature isn't perfect and has disadvantages compared to us. That's assuming that we are somehow outside of nature. > We don't have to invent ex post facto explanations for why something is the case in nature or why there is some un-intuitive reason as for why the natural way is better. We don't have to , no , but we do , because that's how we learn. Nobody was claiming the "natural" way was better, just that it might serve a purpose.
- lukas099 2y ago> That's assuming that we are somehow outside of nature No it isn’t. You know what they meant, you are just one-upping them on a technicality in a way that doesn’t advance the discussion at all.
- NilMostChill 2y ago> No it isn’t. Yes, it is. > You know what they meant. I have clearly stated what i think they meant. They specifically said "disadvantages compared to us." that heavily implies ( if not outright declares ) an us vs them. It seems you have a different interpretation, I'd be interested to hear what that is if you don't mind ? > you are just one-upping them on a technicality in a way that doesn’t advance the discussion at all. If you don't see how what i said was related to the discussion then we probably aren't going to agree on what constitutes a technicality.
- stale2002 2y ago> I have clearly stated what i think they meant. Hey and you were wrong. You are pretty bad at understanding what other people are saying. > how what i said was related to the discussion It wasn't related because the other person was correct in that you misunderstood my statement.
- NilMostChill 2y ago> Hey and you were wrong. You are pretty bad at understanding what other people are saying. Or you are bad at conveying an explicit meaning. > It wasn't related because the other person was correct in that you misunderstood my statement. I've outlined why i thought what i did, if that was a misunderstanding of your intention I'm willing to accept that, doesn't mean what you said was clear.
- lukas099 2y agoIf modern farming protocols are to water at the soil, I would be strongly willing to bet that is the best way to water, at least for our particular situation of growing the crops we grow on the farms we grow them on. Much has gone into studying how to best grow these crops, both at universities and research centers and on the field at farms themselves.
- username135 2y agoThat assumes that we are better at doing things than nature is. I dont know if im sold on that.
- jimbokun 2y agoWe can also do stupid stuff much faster and efficiently and at greater scale than nature, too.
- jahewson 2y agoI think it’s the difference in frequency. There’s likely other factors too, I’d suppose rain purges mold spores from the air for example, as it does with particulate pollution.
- efilife 2y agoMay I ask why you used there's instead of there are? There is likely sounds wrong and is wrong and I see it very often
- ac29 2y agoIts written the way it'd be spoken, which seems fine for informal writing
- HPsquared 2y agoYep. The thoughts are evolving during the speech process. The speaker might start the sentence thinking about one factor, but decides to make it plural after the first words have already started.
- efilife 2y agoI don't think this is the case. 1. If you accidentally say There is and want to use a plural after, (for example, a lot), you can just say a number in between. The sentence stays correct, you just have to say 2 additional words. I personally never had this problem 2. This is internet. You are free to edit your comment and reread it a million times before posting Hope you understand what I'm trying to say, not being native sometimes restricts my ability to properly articulate semi-complex stuff
- samatman 2y agoYou have very strong opinions about correct English for someone who doesn't speak it as a native language.
- kylebenzle 2y agoYes, and rain fall causes the spread of fungal infestation as said above and it is why we farmers use drip irrigation when possible. FarmBot defenitly has a great marketing video, 3d animation and logo though!
- Grimblewald 2y agoPart of the problem is water composition. Water which contians fertilizers, surfactants etc is going to damage the protective waxy layer on leaves, while rain water will do so less. Next, when watering youre doing so as frequently as the plants can make use of, to encourage maximal growth rates. It would never rain that frequently. finally, the size of droplets is different. Rain drops tend to be big and fat and roll off the waxy leaves while smaller dropplets sit on / stick to the surface where they create a nice wet and likely to rot environment.
- RobotToaster 2y agoWhy would you water your plants with surfactants/soap? Genuine question, does it help the plants in some way?
- HPsquared 2y agoReduced surface tension will soak into the soil better and improve capillary flow to the roots.
- waldothedog 2y agoI believe this is common for large scale irrigation and ferti-gation as it breaks surface tension and helps the water flow
- ajuc 2y agoIt's a common traditional fix to aphids infestation.
- brikym 2y agoYes and that's a problem. Many modern plants aren't selected to grow in natural conditions. They're breed for properties like high yields, large fruit and often other characteristics are traded off to achieve that because the farmers can change the environment to deal with those problems with greenhouses, chemicals, fertilizers, irrigation etc.
- notatoad 2y agoin the wild, plants compete for space and resources and the leaves act as a funnel to direct water (including dew) to the roots that might not otherwise be captured. the leaves can also serve as a shield to prevent the soil around the roots from being eroded by rainfall. in a garden where plants do not have neighbours competing for space and water isn't scarce, there's no reason to water the leaves when you could just water the roots directly.
- gen220 2y agoJust a mild pruning: in natural/wild environments (I.e. not the sterile labs of monocultural agronomy), plants actually cooperate in the resources department, because each species and stage of maturity has different needs and resource extractive capacities. They’ll “use” their root systems and mycorrhizal connections (which are only reliably present in wild soil) as a medium of exchange. We do plants a disservice by studying them when they’re grouped together by species and age cohort, and generalizing their behavior under those conditions. You can recreate these circumstances in your garden by, for example, planting the three sisters (beans, squash, corn) together. You can also opt to grow perennial versions of your crops and stagger their planting / surround them with annuals the complement their chemical needs.
- lukas099 2y agoIt doesn’t have to be either/or. Plants can both compete and cooperate with each other in different ways.
- tonyarkles 2y agoHere's a wild thing: at many of the high end vineyards they'll do low-level helicopter flights over the vines every time it rains to blow the water off the leaves and fruit specifically to prevent infection and rot.
- 0_____0 2y agohaving worked at a cargo drone company, that is one thing that our platform would have excelled at. although ours had a tendency to simply flatten vegetation when "cornering" at low altitude.
- amoshebb 2y agoI’ve heard of this for frost prevention, but never rain. Do you know of a specific vineyard doing this?
- throwup238 2y agoNapa and Sonoma vineyards have been doing it for decades: https://www.sfgate.com/business/article/vintners-rush-to-dry-grapes-helicopters-being-2829662.php https://www.sfgate.com/business/article/vintners-rush-to-dry... (dated 1997) It’s pretty rare though. They usually only do it when it rains heavily right before harvest.
- amoshebb 2y agoparent comment said “every time it rains”… this article and your comment make it sound “pretty rare”.
- tonyarkles 2y agoI could certainly be wrong about the timing. I’m definitely not a grape growing expert by any means, I mostly know about it from being in the UAV world and having had some discussions about replacing the helicopters with drones for getting the water off.
- 2y ago
- ajuc 2y agoDepends on the plant. There's little rain in the lowest layer of a forest for example. Or in a desert.