4 ms·
The only branch of the government that seems to be able to do anything anymore is the judiciary, and all they seem to be able to do is flip the same light switc
by ryandrake 2y ago
The only branch of the government that seems to be able to do anything anymore is the judiciary, and all they seem to be able to do is flip the same light switch on and then off and then on again. Congress has been effectively gridlocked and do-nothing for at least 35 years--all of my adult life. The last time a party had over 59 Senate seats was when I was a toddler. The executive branch's powers are being quickly eroded by SCOTUS.
So, net neutrality (and other policy) is going to be forever stuck in this loop of constant arguing over law that was written during the time of fax machines. With one court stopping it, another court reversing the stoppage, the next court reversing the reversing of the stoppage, another case happening with more clever lawyers and so the next court reverses the previous reverse, and then on appeal that reverse gets reversed, and then a random judge pulls out some wording from a 1807 law and reverses again, and this is basically going to be what counts as governance for the rest of my life.
EDIT: Mods, feel free to destroy this thread--I can't delete it anymore. I try to talk about the inability to resolve Net Neutrality and it just turns into another unproductive flame war. Sigh.
- davidgay 2y agoActually the Democrats had 60 seats from July 2009 to January 2010 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008_United_States_Senate_elections https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008_United_States_Senate_elec...).
- Alupis 2y agoYes, and the OP's understanding (and in fairness, many people's understanding) of how the US government is supposed to work is at odds with how it works in reality. > Congress has been effectively gridlocked and do-nothing for at least 35 years--all of my adult life. Gridlock is a design feature. It literally means there isn't consensus on whatever the topic may be. Do you really want a government that rams through unpopular policies constantly, then 4-6 years later whiplashes back again? What people often express as "congress not doing their job" is in reality "they aren't passing the policies I want!". > The executive branch's powers are being quickly eroded by SCOTUS. OP means "restored" instead of "eroded". POTUS was never supposed to be as powerful as they have become. Executive Orders are the worst way to run a country, yet we've had several presidents in a row that have abused EO's to get whatever they want done... only for the next person in office to undo it all with the stroke of a pen. The only take-away one can have here is we need better civics classes in our schools...
- tzs 2y agoThe problem is that they are also not able to ram through popular policies that a majority of both liberals and conservatives in the general population are in favor of.
- singleshot_ 2y agoRunning a country by executive order seems neither much better nor much worse than running it by political judicial decision.
- Alupis 2y ago> than running it by political judicial decision Which country are you referring to? Because it's not the US.
- singleshot_ 2y agoThe US.
- readthenotes1 2y ago
- TheCoelacanth 2y agoFalse, they had 58 and two independents who usually cooperated with them. One of the 58 Democrats had also endorsed a Republican for president only a year earlier, so they were hardly a party loyalist.
- dralley 2y agoActually, they had 60 seats for about 7 weeks. Ted Kennedy was dying of cancer at the time and couldn't come in to vote. Then he died and got replaced with a temporary Democratic replacement which didn't have that availability issue, then the special election occurred and a Republican took the seat.
- ptero 2y agoIn 2008 democrats crushed it, getting the White House and both chambers of the Congress. They could have done as much as they wanted to.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- cute_boi 2y agoBut they don't want to do anything. They just want republican to mess up things and tell people republicans are bad etc..
- acc4everypici 2y agoyou've pointed out the problem with the contemporary american two party state. it's a see saw of nobody does anything but blame their systemic rival either USA party system gets more than two parties because they're on a steady stalemate, like other poster was saying, 35 years of gridlocked congress because of two way ties. or look at china, my prediction is that soon enough a ballsy european monarchy is gonna go full-blown one-party democracy or something clever like that
- jfengel 2y agoYou can't pass legislation without a majority. Adding more parties won't make that easier. It just creates more rivals.
- acc4everypici 2y agoor maybe it gives a voice (i.e. political representation) to a larger pool of diverse people and communities?
- jfengel 2y agoSure. Lots of voices. No actual legislation (or listening), but plenty of talking.
- paulddraper 2y agoThis is the consequence of the living Constitution nonsense, where every day is a new day and it's interpreted according to the "evolving standards of decency that mark the progress of a maturing society." --- People like new interpretations that give the outcome they like (Obergefell vs Hodges) but not the ones that don't.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- AzzyHN 2y ago> The executive branch's powers are being quickly eroded by SCOTUS. Funny, I'd say the executive branch has been gaining more and more power, and the Supreme Court has allowed it. Granted, I was born in 2001 so... I agree with your sentiment, though.
- pfisch 2y agoThrowing out Chevron really significantly eroded the power of the executive branch.
- wongarsu 2y agoThat's recency bias though. When talking about the last 35 years (or even the last 25 years) the power of the executive has massively expanded. Even the Chevron defense doctrine itself was only 40 years old.
- vlovich123 2y agoIn some ways the executive branch has gained power, in other ways SCOTUS has gutted it through the novel "major questions" doctrine to peel power away from the executive under the guise of handing it back to the gridlocked legislature. For example, see the recent overturning of Chevron in Loper. Sure, the executive has a lot of power to exercise military power without needing Congressional approval and minimal oversight. The courts have been happy to help expand and uphold that power. But power to regulate industry and other internal questions has generally been eroded since the 80s, and in accelerated fashion with Trump's further entrenchment of a more extreme right-wing ideology on the court.
- akira2501 2y agoThe executive branch is there to execute laws. Outside of that specific task it should have no "power."
- freitzkriesler2 2y agoThat's by design - the grid lock that is. And it's going to get worse as the voting populace becomes more filled with non-citizens.
- guelo 2y agowhy do people believe this? it's such obvious scaremonegring misinformation
- freitzkriesler2 2y agoHow naive are you? When you register to vote, what does it take to get registered? Easily stolen documents and drivers licenses that don't require proof of citizenship . If you haven't noticed the weak security then there isn't any hope for you.
- guelo 2y agohow naive are you? you have no proof besides what scaremongerers tell you why would anyone risk commiting a crime for voting? there's no personal gain for voting.
- freitzkriesler2 2y agoYou want proof? Here's your proof: https://www.facebook.com/story.php?id=100058134605609&story_fbid=906720021275810 https://www.facebook.com/story.php?id=100058134605609&story_... From the governor of Virginia himself. This is the tip of the iceberg. Keep telling yourself lies.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> only branch of the government that seems to be able to do anything anymore is the judiciary The 117th Congress was very productive, particularly taking into account the scale of its acts [1]. The 118th was one of the most bipartisan in memory. We’ve spent the GDP of medium-sized countries on infrastructure and onshore fabrication initiatives. What is the benchmark for doing something? [1] https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2024/apr/03/donna-brazile/is-the-current-congress-the-least-productive-of-ou/ https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2024/apr/03/donna-braz...
- juujian 2y agoYes, Congress can spend money. But it seems impossible to change the fundamental rules that govern society. Be it commercial, environmental or social. So the trajectory is a slow erosion through courts.
- trimethylpurine 2y agoI don't think people agree on the rules. Let alone Congress.
- voidfunc 2y agoThat's a feature not a bug. Slow is good.
- juujian 2y agoNot sure I get the point.
- brigadier132 2y agoThe point is most people are dumb and think they are smart. These dumb people think that if they just change everything everyone's lives will be better. Making it hard for these dumb people to make sweeping changes to society without the support of a supermajority is a good thing.
- 2y ago
- yieldcrv 2y agoI believe in the existence of consensus bridging representatives, and that means dropping party line stuff that will never gain consensus for a focus on things that will
- polski-g 2y agoThere was a nuclear deregulation bill that passed 98-2 a few weeks ago.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]