4 ms·
Tennessee Awards $5.5M to Strengthen Food Supply Chain Infrastructure
- darth_avocado 2y agoIs $5.5M enough for a material impact? My reference point is the fact that setting up a single new farming operation that is profitable, can set you back by millions.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mooreds 2y agoThe focus is on co-packing and other food processing facilities. > Using RFSI funding, the Tennessee Department of Agriculture will fund projects that increase access to commercial kitchens and co-packing facilities. Additional funded projects will expand processing capacity, including adding product types, increasing production volumes, and supporting new wholesale/retail product lines. The state’s priorities are informed by stakeholder engagement and outreach to underserved producers to better understand their needs. Looks like it costs 15k-250k to set up a commercial kitchen: https://www.kitchenall.com/blog/commercial-kitchen-cost.html https://www.kitchenall.com/blog/commercial-kitchen-cost.html A new product line is 85k-175k: https://www.foodresearchlab.com/blog/new-food-product-development/what-is-the-cost-of-developing-a-new-product/ https://www.foodresearchlab.com/blog/new-food-product-develo... I imagine they are doing grants that cover part of the costs not the whole thing. If they covered 50% of the cost and each project cost 100k, that would mean 110 projects, which is a lot in one state. I see 22 commercial kitchens in TN currently: https://www.thekitchendoor.com/kitchen-rental/states/tennessee https://www.thekitchendoor.com/kitchen-rental/states/tenness... so if half of the projects were commercial kitchens, that would be a 250% increase.
- darth_avocado 2y agoAhh interesting. I think I kind of expected the grant to only partially cover costs for any project. But it is very surprising to see the costs of setting up a commercial kitchen to be so low.
- kreims 2y agoI’m more familiar with transportation grants than food grants, but I would imagine you write a proposal and get matching funds up to a certain ceiling, like 80-20 state-private up to $250,000, hypothetically. The costs on those blogs seem to refer to just furnishing equipment in a ready commercial space, though. If you’re having to develop a new site and incur construction costs, I could easily see spending $5M on a single site. I’d think this is going to help producers upgrade or replace some existing equipment. Probably a good thing. $5.5M more than the market had, right? I do wonder if there is some low hanging fruit on more efficiently connecting different stages of food production. Like a traveling salesman problem with getting food producers to packing.
- quickthrowman 2y ago> Looks like it costs 15k-250k to set up a commercial kitchen That 15k is a bit of a misnomer, a vent hood plus fire suppression is going to be $20k+ installed (or more depending on how much ductwork is needed).
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoThis press release is so vague that I have trouble understanding what it is they’re actually doing. > Using RFSI funding, the Tennessee Department of Agriculture will fund projects that increase access to commercial kitchens and co-packing facilities. Additional funded projects will expand processing capacity, including adding product types, increasing production volumes, and supporting new wholesale/retail product lines. The state’s priorities are informed by stakeholder engagement and outreach to underserved producers to better understand their needs. So is it adding facilities that producers (of crops?) can use to go from harvesting to a product that is ready to sell? Is it because small farmers don’t have relationship with processors? Or is it that big farms do it all on their own and there is no one for small farmers to turn to? Also what will a few million achieve when individual machines probably cost a lot more? I would think any facility would be enormously expensive to build and operate.
- mooreds 2y ago> So is it adding facilities that producers (of crops?) can use to go from harvesting to a product that is ready to sell? Is it because small farmers don’t have relationship with processors? Or is it that big farms do it all on their own and there is no one for small farmers to turn to? As someone who used to work in the space, there are a lot of different ways for farmers to turn what they grow into something they sell. It can be as simple as a space at a farmer's market and as complex as a co-packer that turns fruit into jelly or chiles into hotsauce. In the middle are commercial kitchens that let small food businesses safely make food to sell in stores and at markets. These are more expensive per unit to use than co-packers, but don't require the commitments that co-packers do. There are also processors like grain or meat processors that have been consolidating. Here's a list of local grain mills: https://wholegrainscouncil.org/find-whole-grains/local-grains https://wholegrainscouncil.org/find-whole-grains/local-grain... . I see zero in TN, so maybe there's a need there? There are also all kinds of tasks that need to happen that aren't related to food production/cooking, such as finding distributors, marketing, customer development and more. That's what "supporting new wholesale/retail product lines" means to me. > Also what will a few million achieve when individual machines probably cost a lot more? I would think any facility would be enormously expensive to build and operate. See my comment about costs here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41142419 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41142419
- silexia 2y agoAs a farmer, what we actually need is de-regulation of food production. The big four meat packers have used government regulations on "safety" to create a monopoly where it costs millions of dollars to process your own meat. This $5.5m will disappear into the pockets of the cronies of politicians.
- TylerE 2y agoI do not trust Big Ag. I’m convinced they’d mix hog shit in with the sausage if they thought they could get away with it - and no, I don’t support allowing the commercial sale of unpasteurized milk, either.
- rightbyte 2y ago> I don’t support allowing the commercial sale of unpasteurized milk Why? Some of us would like to make proper cheese ...
- TylerE 2y agoBecause it kills people. “ According to a study conducted by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the Food and Drug Administration, there were 202 disease outbreaks in the US due to drinking raw milk between 1998 and 2018, leading to 2,645 illnesses, 228 hospitalizations, and three deaths. In 2017, nearly 5 percent of Americans were thought to consume unpasteurized milk products, including raw cheese, and raw dairy products led to 840 times more illnesses than pasteurized products.” 840x higher risk of food borne illness is significant.
- kerkeslager 2y agoI mean, saying 840x more makes it sound significant, but... US population in 2017 was 324 million. 5% of that is 16 million people. 2645 out of 16 million is 0.017%. Does that make it sound significant? Is that even as dangerous as refined sugar? In my mind that's well within the risk range of "slap a warning label on it and let people make their own decisions".
- GenerocUsername 2y agoAlternative headline: consultancy firm owned by politicians friend hired for 5.5 million dollars to produce a paper that suggest ways to do something that will never be actioned on... Thankfully because it will also be incredibly innacurate
- bankcust08385 2y agoThis is a drop in the ocean that will maybe help a few hundred mom & pop food products businesses get subsidized commercial kitchen space. Meanwhile: - Herbicide residues are put into food supply to save farmer's some money on harvesting - Monoculture GMO crops create a single point of failure vulnerability to disease and pests that could lead to famine - Big ag tells farmers they can't save their own non-GMO seed - John Deere, the McFlurry machines of farming, tells farmers to wait for a technician to reset a sensor using proprietary software during harvest season - The USDA doesn't regulate the entire food supply, mostly meat - Meat agriculture is a huge contributor to climate change, pandemics, antibiotic resistance, and air, water, and soil pollution
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]