4 ms·
In a new book, Christof Koch views consciousness as a theorist and an aficionado
- waldrews 2y agoHow are people still publishing books without audiobook versions? What, are we supposed to read with our eyes, like animals?
- keybored 2y ago> Unraveling how consciousness arises out of particular configurations of organic matter is a quest that has absorbed scientists and philosophers for ages. Now, with AI systems behaving in strikingly conscious-looking ways, it is more important than ever to get a handle on who and what is capable of experiencing life on a conscious level. Lord give me strength. > Koch suggests that exercise, meditation, and the occasional guided psychedelic might be beneficial to many people. Substances such as psilocybin can enhance one’s feeling of well-being and facilitate pure presence. It is rare to have a close brush with death, and mystical transformations typically come unbidden; in contrast, psychoactive substances—though not entirely predictable—are more consistently available and can be managed safely. Koch’s book implies that there’s immense psychological benefit of entering "the flow" through chemistry that might outweigh the small risks involved. This is cool. I like that he considers states of consciousness for the everyman and is not talking about philosophical zombies (Angels on a Pinhead for the modern age).
- bbor 2y agoAs someone who spends a lot of time on this subject, and disagrees with this person passionately: great article, and a fascinating addition to the field! The critic (who triple majored?!) has her site + newsletter at the bottom, I'm certainly giving it a chance. I was going to quote-dunk a bunch of it, but I think it's beyond the point -- no one's going to be convinced on the scientific validity of "consciousness" in this thread alone. I will say that I recommend Patricia Churchland's Neurophilosophy and Noam Chomsky's [Language and The Mind](https://www.ugr.es/~fmanjon/Language%20and%20Mind.pdf https://www.ugr.es/~fmanjon/Language%20and%20Mind.pdf) for scientifically-minded views that don't share this persons goal.
- keybored 2y agoInteresting that you mention Chomsky. Is my feeling correct that Skinner and people like him represented the modern feeling—and at that time too apparently—that we only needed to find mechanisms of association and then would be able to mechanically simulate the interesting parts of the human mind? Btw from the Chomsky book you linked: > > The technological advances of the 1940s simply reinforced the general euphoria. Computers were on the horizon, and their imminent availability reinforced the belief that it would suffice to gain a theoretical understanding of only the simplest and most superficially obvious of phenomena – everything else would merely prove to be “more of the same,” an apparent complexity that would be disentangled by the electronic marvels
- foobarian 2y agoOne simple question I'm dying to know the answer to - does the consciousness found in biological brains rely on some hitherto unknown physical mechanism (e.g. some QD effect) or can it be recreated purely through interconnectivity of a data structure/algorithm?
- bbor 2y agoIt’s a bigger question than one can get into in a forum comment (I recommend typing some key words into https://plato.stanford.edu https://plato.stanford.edu for more!), but to share what I feel are the closest to empirical truths we have on the matter: There is, as of yet, no scientific justification for thinking that humans are different from computers in some fundamental physical sense. We can talk about differences in architectonic structure like this article does (densely connected neurons v sparsely connected transistors), but ultimately each neuron is a machine, and at this point they’re machines we understand pretty darn well. Like all other machines bigger than 0.0001nm or whatever, there’s not really a clear mechanism by which they could be meaningfully “controlled” or “influenced” by quantum interactions. In this light, the answer is simple: human brains are incredibly complex machines. Some of the main counter arguments are: 1. It “feels” like “something” to be “you”, which is a whole field science lacks the terminology/framework to study. This is the position taken by this author, more or less 2. All conscious beings so far (animals included) have been biological, so simple parsimony could argue that we need a counterexample first. 3. Humans are able to communicate with each other telepathically by tapping into an unknown physical field. Obviously won’t win a lot of fans on this forum, but it’s an interesting piece of trivia that this final point was the only one Alan Turing found plausible in his famous 1950 paper Computing Machinery and Intelligence. See page 17: https://courses.cs.umbc.edu/471/papers/turing.pdf https://courses.cs.umbc.edu/471/papers/turing.pdf
- swayvil 2y agoIn articles like this our study of consciousness is strongly colored by our preference for thinking and writing. And that's arguably unavoidable, being thinkers in a society and such, but there you go. A "clearer" study would require starting from some kind of zero. But nobody wants to go live in a cave and whoever did might not be inclined to write an article about it.
- ben_w 2y agoI think starting from zero would not work, as we all did that from wherever it is in our life cycle that consciousness emerges, be that "a cell at conception" or later. It would be another anecdote of one example of consciousness. What I think will work, is to examine all the different forms of consciousness — including not just animals, but also those humans we find unfathomable, alien, and impossible to empathise with.
- swayvil 2y agoThat would be putting the cart before the horse. Better to try for zero first, then theorize second.
- ypeterholmes 2y ago“The high connectivity [in a human brain] is very different from that found in the central processing unit of any digital computer, where one transistor typically connects to a handful of other transistors.” Has he been living under a rock? Modern AI models already outpace the connectivity of the human brain, and are only getting bigger.
- poikroequ 2y agoAI is just software. He's talking about the physical transistors in a computer.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ypeterholmes 2y agoThat's precisely my point. The database connections involved in a neural network are the corollary, not transistors. What am I missing?
- poikroequ 2y agoThe author is clearly talking about PHYSICAL connectivity in the brain. Thus why he says AI is unlikely to become conscious without the "advent of new technology". The brain is a physical neural network. AI is a software simulated neural network. Nowhere in the article does the author confuse the two.
- ryandvm 2y agoThe physical number of transistors is irrelevant. If in software you were able to perfectly simulate the 100T physical neuronal connections in a real brain, then you would perfectly recreate that brain's conscious experience. Granted, you would be doing it with a frame rate limited by the processing power of the computer, but that just means that a thought that takes a human 1 second to arrive at might take much longer for the AI (for now).
- Workaccount2 2y agoIIT is like the string theory of Neuroscience. Lots of people putting weight behind it, but also with a degree of hubris similar to the string theory guys of the late 90's. But just like string theory, it also has a lot of fair criticism and is mostly still in the hypothesis phase.
- axblount 2y agoThe key similarity between IIT (integrated information theory, for the uninitiated) and string theory is that both are unfalsifiable. Hubris can be forgiven. Unfalsifiability can not.
- mannykannot 2y agoDoes this mean that artificial computer systems, wired appropriately, can be conscious? Not necessarily, Koch says. This might one day be possible with the advent of new technology, but we are not there yet. He writes. “The high connectivity [in a human brain] is very different from that found in the central processing unit of any digital computer, where one transistor typically connects to a handful of other transistors.” For the foreseeable future, AI systems will remain unconscious despite appearances to the contrary. I think one would have to be unaware of the ability of simple Turing-equivalent machines to simulate devices of much greater complexity than themselves in order to find this argument persuasive. We see here that Koch is a fan of IIT; can he show one machine with a high IIT score that cannot be simulated by a simple (though sufficiently-sized) Turing-equivalent computer, possibly abetted with a source of entropy?
- slibhb 2y agoSimulating something isn't the same thing as being that thing. You can write a computer program that simulates pain. Perhaps even to the point that it convinces people that it feels pain. But, actually, it doesn't have a nervous system and can't feel pain. Maybe in the future we'll build machines that can feel (and are conscious) but currently we don't know how. It would be very strange if we build those machines accidentally while training LLMs.
- mannykannot 2y agoWhile it is true in general that simulating a thing is not that thing itself, a simulation may be the same as the thing being simulated in all aspects that matter. In particular, information-manipulating systems are amenable to simulation by other information-manipulating systems: one can, for example, make a simulation of a cryptographic machine that encrypts and decrypts messages. https://www.101computing.net/enigma-machine-emulator/ https://www.101computing.net/enigma-machine-emulator/ I agree that we don't know how to build machines that can feel (and are conscious); all I am saying here is that Koch's argument (at least as presented in this article) against a suitably-programmed transistor-based, von Neumann architecture digital computer becoming a conscious machine does not hold up.
- anthk 2y agoA few days ago I was reading a pop science magazine from Spain (this month was as a special issue about the brain/consciusness) and Koch was mentioned. Someone call Peat/Jung. JK, network effect at work, for sure. On consciousness, I'm interested on the integrated information theory.
- grantcas 2y ago[dead]