3 ms·
I love threads like this because they show who's who. One of the many reasons I joined hacker news was to meet like minded people for possible future collabora
by edw519 18y ago
I love threads like this because they show who's who.
One of the many reasons I joined hacker news was to meet like minded people for possible future collaboration. Sometimes you really get to know each other here.
AFAIC, there is no gray area in ethical matters. Right is right and wrong is wrong. If you use situational ethics to justify what is clearly wrong, you may have made an interesting argument, but you have also done one other thing: you have automatically disqualified yourself from ever doing business with me (and probably many others here, I suspect.)
A little background:
I once wrote some software that a partner installed in a remote client site for which our company got paid. Unbeknowst to me, he also installed that software at another site and kept all the money.
I bought the used car from one of my partners at an agreed upon price and found out later that he had disconnected the speedometer for as many as 50,000 miles.
Another partner of mine had a side business selling hardware and negotiated a backroom deal with our customer that jeapordized our major project.
One IT director where I worked had software salesmen leave their documentation for "project review", photocopied it, and used it for our own functional specs, with no intention of ever buying anything.
Starting to get the idea of how "you wouldn't have made any money anyway" easily morphs into "fuck you"?
And as far as software pirating goes, I have only this to say:
If you steal from me, I will seek recourse any way I can. Period.
And for those of you who want to debate ethical considerations here at hacker news, you may want to think twice about the persona you end up revealing in this public forum.
- Zev 18y agoAnd for those of you who want to debate ethical considerations here at hacker news, you may want to think twice about the persona you end up revealing in this public forum. Likewise. You might want to take heed of your own advice. If you're treating everyone you do business with as people that will potentially rip you off, I wouldn't want to work with you. Its amazing at how quickly "Good intentions to prevent piracy" morph into "But my product cant be pirated. Fuck the customers. They're all crooks anyway."
- edw519 18y agoYou might want to take heed of your own advice. For better or worse, I stand by everything I've ever posted here. If you're treating everyone you do business with as people that will potentially rip you off That's a leap you made, not me. I have always given everyone I've ever worked with every opportunity to succeed. Once they take advantage of me, all bets are off. I wouldn't want to work with you. One less thing for either of us to worry about. See how well this forum works?
- Zev 18y agoThat's a leap you made, not me. I have always given everyone I've ever worked with every opportunity to succeed. Once they take advantage of me, all bets are off. That leap was primarily made because of the anecdotes you gave followed by If you steal from me, I will seek recourse in any way I can. Period. — There was nothing in the post that indicated that you would continue trust people (partners or customers) in business. However, you have since said otherwise, which is enough for me. One less thing for either of us to worry about. See how well this forum works? Quite well indeed. However I've never had a complaint about the workings of HN, on the technical side or otherwise.
- jbjohns 18y agoGood grief, where are you meeting all these "partners"?
- DenisM 18y agoSomehow you managed to pick up more than your fair share of unethical people. Maybe you are doing something wrong.
- tptacek 18y agoOr maybe he's just unlucky, or maybe he's just decided that by paying attention to how people treat other people, he can get a good readout on how they'll treat him when the chips are down. There's a classic sales interview trick that has to do with taking the candidate out and seeing how he treats the waitstaff and how well he tips. Same idea. It's also possible that he just has a lot more life experience than you.
- jimbokun 18y agoYou sound like Job's friends.
- brl 18y agoPirating software is not 'stealing' by legal definition or any other one. It is also not an issue of morality or ethics. If you cannot make money selling your software because everybody pirates it and nobody wants to buys it you are not a victim. You have simply chosen a failed business model.
- jbjohns 18y agoIt's not technically called "stealing", but license infringement. You should tell all brick and morter retail stores to get rid of their cameras, security and other security measures. If people are not willing to pay for their products and instead chose to just steal them they have obviously a failed business model. Seriously, are you taking the piss?