5 ms·
80% of developers are unhappy. The problem is not AI, nor is coding
- lampposthotdog 2y agoIt's because they work for companies that serve no real purpose and should not exist.
- tevlon 2y agoamen!
- oneplane 2y agoNo, it's because they are swimming in technical deficiencies and aren't in a position to do anything about it. On top of that, they are pressured for unrealistic results and attend meetings that serve no real purpose and should not exist (and should have been an email instead). It's all right there in the article. Perhaps the best way to one-line it would be: They are not allowed to achieve a suitable level of quality.
- JKCalhoun 2y ago> aren't in a position to do anything about it Most salient.
- jojobas 2y agoI've worked in quite a few companies which had tangible purpose, yet a lot of my code ended up in the bin and even more of my time spend at work was wasted on bullshit.
- r0fl 2y agoThey can’t find purpose outside of work?
- vitro 2y agoIf your work takes great amount of your time from your life, it better be meaningful and purposeful.
- silverquiet 2y agoReligion only takes a day a week (and maybe only an hour or two of that day). If time spent on task is where you find the most meaning, then work has to be first. Certainly that's the way it's been for me, and it is quite depressing, but for reasons that are specific to me, I need my health insurance more than most, and like most I also need to eat and have a place to live and all that mundane stuff.
- red-iron-pine 2y agoYeah singing to Invisible Sky Santa really makes my life better. I mean it doesn't change jack, but placebo effect + community are better than nothing. Plus it's a 3rd space that doesn't charge anything, usually.
- sph 2y agoPros: - not have to worry about replenishing your bank account every month - have all your modest needs in life met - workplace is in a way the only community of like-minded people have outside of family Cons: - help realise someone else's dream - you might forget you have any dreams of your own at all --- My adult mind has been shaped by the controversial, maybe conspiratorial discussion about self-employment rates over the past century in the Deus Ex game, and as I've grown older, I've found I'd rather struggle on my own path rather than making myself care about someone else's idea. https://youtu.be/0mAFryoa6Po?si=gGFMKRkLA_GKridQ https://youtu.be/0mAFryoa6Po?si=gGFMKRkLA_GKridQ (take it with an open mind and a grain of salt, it's cyberpunk conspiracy fiction after all) For a deeper discussion, I can only recommend Ross Scott's review of the game: https://youtu.be/rxOKEsBx4NU?si=fp3LTFAJrGtEDbZH https://youtu.be/rxOKEsBx4NU?si=fp3LTFAJrGtEDbZH
- netdevnet 2y ago> - workplace is in a way the only community of like-minded people have outside of family Not having friends is more of a modern American culture thing. When you have no social life independent of your work life you get that and the loneliness epidemic in US
- apples_oranges 2y agoBut then how come they get paid?
- flkenosad 2y agoSide-effect of a broken system?
- lmpdev 2y agoNot OP but capital is misallocated all the time by the market
- red-iron-pine 2y agoEvery bubble, ever, plus every rube that gets hustled by snake oil.
- reportgunner 2y agoPrinted money.
- Trasmatta 2y agoI've worked for companies that serve a positive purpose and should exist, and still felt immensely unhappy with my work. It helped, but didn't solve the problem.
- kierenj 2y agoThe article points out it's technical debt..
- atonse 2y agoI wonder how much of this is also that the solutions feel less tangible and more abstract, and fundamentally less satisfying. In carpentry or Plumbing for example, you can point to something being completed. The valve was either replaced or it wasn’t. The water is either leaking or it isn’t. (Sorry I can only think of residential plumbing issues, I know it’s more complicated than that). But in software it’s way more amorphous. Every feature has endless discussions, the product is less tangible, and you don’t often see people actually using what you built. But that’s just me projecting why a career in software (while very comfortable and I genuinely enjoy programming), can feel a lot less satisfying.
- silverquiet 2y agoI'm a systems person and I really miss the days where you actually got to go and rack servers, cable them up, and power them on. Having all your infrastructure in the cloud is unsatisfying on a few levels.
- blablabla123 2y agoComparing programming with plumbing seems comparing apples and oranges. In such jobs people probably dream of the worst imaginable IT micro managers. Such companies are typically lead by a bunch of furious old guys that do nothing. It's hard to take such an assessment seriously made by people who never worked in a similar job.
- atonse 2y agoYes, I am willingly comparing apples to oranges. I'm comparing the idea is that most IT work (like a lot of white collar work in general) is abstract, and less well-defined. Whereas with a lot of the trades in the physical realm, a lot of it is repetitive and you complete it. It's the same with plumbers, mechanics, etc. Yes there's the occasional problem that will escape you and bother you for weeks. But most of the work is repetitive, and has a definite start and an end. And you seldom have a feeling like you wasted a whole day and got nothing done.
- Trasmatta 2y agoI used to find the solutions satisfying, but it's so hard now. I think it's the combination of endless technical debt, bikeshedding, discussions that go nowhere, needing sign off from a million people to do anything, other developers favoring dogmatic design patterns over pragmatism, etc, etc.
- apples_oranges 2y agoFor me coding is kind of an anarchist activity. Computers can very powerful machines and we can teach them to do anything and it seems the only rules are theroretical limits.. I think it can be exhilarating and incredibly fun. But at work.. we work on uninspiring JIRA tickets and write boring unit tests and even more boring documentation.. it's just not quite the same. That's why I code at home, too ;) (And probably the whole Agile methodology is part of the problem, too.)
- silverquiet 2y agoEighty percent seems hard to believe. I'm often treated like I have some sort of mood disorder (it's entirely possible to be fair) when I point out the problems of modern life, to include an extremely alienating labor environment. I was under the impression that most people were at least able to adjust to their circumstances.
- mkmk3 2y agoMost people are in survival mode, and it's a socially vulnerable thing to admit you don't like the work. It requires a level of safety, by being honest about it and supportive of others hopefully we can get to the point where we can collectively acknowledge them and maybe try to address them. It's also just not fun to think about why life sucks, and it makes life a little harder to begin with I think. So it requires some tact. People bringing it up as a subjective and personal take that they just want to share, as opposed to an objective fact that needs to change, has made it easier for me to take others more seriously in this area. Sorry you felt like the minority, hope you can get to/create an environment where you feel better understood.
- silverquiet 2y agoYes, I've been in a company that was being dismantled by private equity. People would act like everything was normal in meetings and then you'd hear reports about people crying in more one-on-one type situations. Certainly it tore me up to the point that when the layoff came, I was actually relieved. I'm extremely introverted and have a hard time telling this sort of thing to anyone but my therapist, but I was under the impression that I'm a bit unusual. Obviously in this forum, I can speak my mind because of the relative anonymity. I often wonder if people do in fact understand what is making them unhappy; it often seems so clear to me. For instance, working from home is so sought after, but for me it was a disaster; the thought of being chained to a desk in my house for the next few decades of worked seemed close to living in hell (or at least the office). As I said, I'm quite introverted, but that level of singular toil is incredibly unnatural to me; I don't understand how anyone can do it, and yet people would accuse me of being some sort of shill on this site for laying that out. And so, I got an in person job at a company that makes a product that I think is useful. I would be laughed at if I said what I got paid or some of the old technologies we use, but you know what - I might actually be in the twenty percent these days. I've actually told people that my job is a source of pride and satisfaction for me. Now my biggest fear (it'll probably never go away) is that we lose relevance/customers and I'll have to find something else.
- cj 2y agoAm I missing something or did they leave out the question/answer graph showing 80% unhappy? Very curious how the question and answers were worded and wouldn't be surprised to see some survey bias issues. But not surprised that many developers are "unhappy" - I think you'd see the same thing in finance (or any high pressure industry that's highly paid where employers have very high expectations).
- amonith 2y agoI'm not sure I've met anybody happy this year (I live in Poland but it's not because I live in Poland I swear :D). It's not just job uncertainty. Our whole world (that is "1st" and "2nd" world countries) is currently unstable. A literal war is brewing, currently with Russia, maybe with China, maybe the Middle East stuff will escalate. Those maybes are a big problem. And let's not even start about the housing market and the possible future job market shift due to AI. Almost none of it is due to the current local job stuff. That doesn't matter. It's all about how the future seems to look like.
- cinntaile 2y agoIgnore the news. Almost none of it concerns you nor can you affect it.
- amonith 2y agoI do now but the damage is done. I already know what's happening even without updates. Also I have <200km to war-torn Lviv, so... kind of concerns me.
- red-iron-pine 2y ago... on the national and international level. but absolutely read your local / state news. it is 1) often very, directly relevant, and 2) is something you may have the ability to impact, and often directly. case in point: my sister in law and her husband got pissed off about speed bumps and signs (too many, and/or too few, in the right places), and started going to town hall meetings. show up with photos and make some valid points and things get changed...
- Trasmatta 2y agoThose factors are consistent for everyone, though, and it seems that developers have more job induced unhappiness than many other careers. There's something fundamentally wrong and broken with this discipline.
- croo 2y ago
- Trasmatta 2y agoIt's definitely not AI because this has been phenomenon for a long time. There's no simple answer to this question, I think it's the result of many different issues, and this post outlines a few of them pretty well. For me, I've begun to think that it's intractable for my own personal well being, and have been thinking about how to make my way out of the industry. Which isn't easy when you live in a HCOL area and don't really have other marketable skills.
- madduci 2y agoI am really surprised that 68% of developers code as a hobby outside their jobs. I thought people were dedicating far less time to code in their free time
- amonith 2y agoIt's based on a Stack Overflow user survey which is incredibly biased towards "enthusiastic junior" kind of developers. I mean "active user of Stack Overflow" (somebody who cares about some kind of survey on the website) is already a pretty strong filter. Also the further in career we progress the less SO we actively use. Edit: It kind of also explains the high-percentage of unhappiness. The junior marked is especially screwed right now.
- red-iron-pine 2y ago> The junior marked is especially screwed right now. yeah demand on the mid-to-high end, esp. SME's in specific areas like DB, front-end, ERPs, etc. -- all pretty high. you gotta know your stuff, but truly experienced folks with real creds go fast, and we struggle to hire and keep them. leadership roles seem to be okay; never easy to get into anyway, but the boomers and early Gen-Xrs are getting out of the market and things feel open. meanwhile we put out ads for junior-to-mid level and get 1000+ applications of dubious quality (all AI written), 30% of whom aren't on the same continent. respect to my homies in Kenya and Delhi who are hustling for Toronto jobs, but we don't sponsor, and that extra noise just makes it harder to find legit junior-hires.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- sebastianz 2y agoWould have been interesting for the article to compare with general job satisfaction across other fields. There a single sentence thrown in there about this which seems to have no context or source, just an opinion of the author: > Anecdotally, both plumbers and farmers are happier than them.
- JKCalhoun 2y ago> just an opinion of the author While I agree there is no source for this neither is there any indication it is the author's opinion. (And since it allies with what I have also come to believe is true, I am going to assume there is data backing it up ... somewhere.)
- wnolens 2y agoI resonate strongly with their points. > Working with imperfect systems demoralizes programmers, making it difficult to do quality work. > Developers are under pressure to complete tasks as fast as possible > Layoffs > coding is a sedentary job, and a sedentary lifestyle is extremely harmful to physical health. I recently started a new job where 2 and 3 are no longer a daily concern. But can't escape a high friction dev experience and sedentary (also highly non social) lifestyle at work.
- stubbedtoe 2y agoMy theory is that software engineering is fundamentally a lonely activity. Loading up the context required to solve a problem and hold that state for the several hours to write the code means to be alone with the computer and no one else. To think about abstract ideas and concepts instead of people and feelings. As a social animal, that's not what humans evolved to do. Software engineers need to prioritise connecting with people during their free time since they are unlikely to experience much of this during their job.
- shrimp_emoji 2y agoIf you're a social animal, you should have never gotten into coding to begin with. It's for introvert nerds with no social life! How else can you even learn it, anyway? Oh, that's right, by using the easy languages made by corporations (Java, C#, Go) to hire more devs with the promise of an easy paycheck.
- OutOfHere 2y agoIt is lonely, but that's a completely wrong explanation because software development is even more lonely when working on personal projects. Yet, personal projects bring happiness.
- JKCalhoun 2y agoA lot to pick through in the article. I have my own reasons as to why professional development went to shit and I began to be unhappy in the industry — naturally I looked in the article for validation. For me the reason I started out loving developing software and came to loathe it has everything to do with the environment within which we code. By this I guess I mean specifically management and expectations? I was never unhappy with my Apple salary (although you were often very aware that other engineers at Apple were being rewarded an order of magnitude more than you were) and the issue of "Technical Debt" I would cast differently than the article did. Did I hate technical debt? Not at all — if I was allowed to go in and "own" the code I was expected to fix/maintain. And this hints at one of the bigger changes that I saw over my career: when I started out at Apple in the 90's, engineers got their own "sandbox", got their own code they owned. If you wanted to, you could rewrite it from scratch — and we essentially did just that every two years or so with ColorSync (just as an example). Now I won't deny that "things were simpler back then" and rewriting an entire framework was something a pair of engineers could do in a release. I would not have been rewriting all of PDFKit a decade or so later (but I may have gone in and rewritten entire sections of it, like rewritten the PDF annotations for example). I still paint "technical debt" as a problem of "ownership" though. If I am free to rewrite as I see fit (perhaps in sections at a time) an entire framework, then I say bring on the technical debt. Hustle culture, bureaucracy — again, in the early days of my development career at Apple the engineers owned the schedule as well, owned the scheduling of the meetings.... "What do you think your team can deliver this OS release?" a marketing type might ask our tech lead. "We talked about that in a recent meeting," they might respond, "we have engineers already working on feature A and B and another engineer that wants to explore rewriting C on top of our new framework for some performance gains." The tech lead had made suggestions to the team, team had countered with their own requests or agreed, engineers had volunteered to take on the tasks... It goes without saying there was no scrum, etc. in those days. (And we liked it that way!) I know this is already long, but I think I want to jump off here with a comment on things like "agile" development, unit tests and code reviews — things that I personally think made the job miserable. All of these things that were brought on, that we suffered, didn't seem to have anything to do with improving development. Instead they seemed all about giving management cold comfort that "progress was being made" (or not). Management live in a world of dates and numbers, engineers live in a world of tasks, code robustness, error handling. Various efforts over the years seem to have been devised to burden the engineer with crap that give management the illusion of numbers and dates that they can take back to their own management. I guess to end this I'll just say it boils down to engineer autonomy, agency. There was a golden time when the engineers were steering the ship, and I liked it. > Despite being unhappy at work, most developers code outside of work as a hobby (68%) I think that one line from the article is the most telling.
- maeln 2y agoI started programming on the family computer at 11, because I was curious how video games where made and I wanted to try to make my own (it never really happened in the end!). In the end, I caught the programming bug. The act of programming was in itself magical. And it felt like a super power. From website to making art using some procedural algorithm, to making little games and solving them with genetic algorithm, everything felt fun. Even though the learning part could be complex and tedious, being able to approach it however I desire made sure that I kept my motivation. So when I had to choose what I was going to study after high school, I already knew. And this is when it started to go downhill. Not that school wasn't fun in its own way, and I did learn a bunch of things. But the more rigid form of learning and the mandatory exam still chip away at my motivation. And then work. It really makes you understand the concept of Alienation. Your agency is (mostly) taken away. You don't get to work on what you want, how you want it, with the tools you might prefer. You have limited ability to influence the direction of the project, to propose new ideas, etc ... Your self-expression, which for me was a important part of programming, is repressed. It gets better with time and experience. And some company are better than other at letting you experiment and learn new things. But coding various part of a UI for another business related backoffice, will never be as fun as spawning whole world from a few lines of code, reverse engineering a protocol to create your own client, making gfx, creating a small website for you friend's band, ... Work is work, and when your hobby turn to work, it can feel very frustrating at time. Especially since, after a day of "work" coding, my motivation for "hobby" coding is reduce to ashes. But at the same time, I don´t see myself doing anything else.
- MattPalmer1086 2y agoThis is pretty much why I stopped being a professional developer. I realised I love coding too much to do it professionally. Now I work in application security. It's not like this is magically a better job in most ways, but it doesn't kill my love of coding for fun.
- afloatboat 2y agoAs an unhappy front-end web developer I feel I'm mostly unhappy because my job title has stayed the same, while the responsibilities have changed drastically. I've always been a developer that liked to work on the UI. I got joy from creating good looking and feeling components, going the extra mile in terms of small animations and tidbits to make it feel just right. As the years went on JavaScript played a bigger part in that, so naturally I picked that up as well. But I still only learned JavaScript to enhance the visual components that I was building. Now, n years later I can barely work on the graphical side anymore because most of my time is spent on writing business logic on the client. Fetching data from the server, parsing and massaging it, data management, … So I've basically become a backend developer for the frontend now. The visual part of the web has been taken over by tools like Webflow and Framer or the other extreme with ThreeJs. I recently talked to some companies/recruiters just to casually see what was available and my desire to go back to the more graphical/ui/ux side of things, but everyone was just looking for a 'react developer', so just the same boat that I'm in now. So yeah, I power through, but that doesn't mean I'm happy about it. I'm also not completely unhappy, but things could definitely be better.
- NotGMan 2y agoI assume it's because most devs work on stuff they don't actually like. Programming seems to promise freedom: you can programm whatever you want. But then devs get stuck in wageslave job and never pursue what they want. I'm sure that 90%+ of the devs unhappy would enjoy coding if they would work on a business of their own, something that they actually think should exist, regardless of "whether it's good or not for societity". People want to work on what they believe should exist. Modern dev jobs are the opposite for the most part. I mean c'mon, have you ever seen a young teenage/early 20 dev who was like "Yeah bro I really want to programm ads, so exciting".
- bryanlarsen 2y agoIt's the intersection of responsibility & agency. One can be happy and fulfilled without responsibility and agency, but not everybody is. We denigrate those who are as a type B personality, but that's unfair. Some few people have agency without responsibility. Rich heirs, for example. Some of them are happy, but you hear a lot of stories about them acting out for a reason. Those who have responsibility without agency are almost universally unhappy. This is where many developers are. We dislike those who carve out a piece of code and jealously defend that turf, but that is where this comes from, the desire for agency over something. Those who have both agency & responsibility are the ones who are fulfilled. The stress from the responsibility may make them temporarily unhappy, but the long term fulfillment is the most important, and it is those who have it. And it should be relatively straightforward to provide agency to developers. Let them feel ownership for a piece of their code. They'll take pride in their work and you'll get much better code out of them. Give them the information they need for proper decisions rather than just using that context to make the decisions for them.
- ryandrake 2y ago> Let them feel ownership for a piece of their code. Let them actually have that ownership. If you just let them "feel" like they have ownership but they actually don't, you're not going to fool them for long. I'm reminded of a (bootstrapped) founder I worked for briefly who, during chit-chat on a long flight, complained about his employees' work ethic and said he wished his employees worked like they owned the company. "I try so hard to help them feel like they own the company, but they just don't go the extra mile." I really wanted to tell him, dude, they don't act like they own it because they don't!--you own 100% of it! You have to give actual meaningful agency and control to people. Not just the feeling.
- rmsaksida 2y agoAnother problem, I think, is that there is something inherently unsatisfying about activities like programming where the result of your labor is usually abstract and not a thing you can physically touch and admire in the real world. Fixing things in my home, painting walls, assembling furniture often gives me more satisfaction and the feeling of a finished job than deploying an update for a web app. This wasn't an issue for me for most of my career, but it's something I feel intensely in the long term (10+ yrs) and as I get older. I think it's the reason why every now and then you see programmers switching careers to farming or carpentry.
- OutOfHere 2y agoSoftware developers need independent project ownership to be happy. They need freedom to maintain and to select items from a prioritized backlog without management or other team members breathing down their neck. Without this freedom, the project often fails in two to three years anyway because it degrades to the point where it's unmaintainable.
- JohnFen 2y agoAll I know is that I consider developing software to be really fun and fulfilling. I do it as a hobby when I'm not at work doing it. However, doing it as an employee (in most, but not all, workplaces) sucks the joy out of it. The workplace sometimes seems designed to make the task as unpleasant as possible.
- bradgessler 2y agoHas anybody successfully created a software collective? I think my ideal world would be building applications in Ruby with other late-career folks who are low drama, interested in making money, love talking to customers, and don’t get distracted by shiny new tech that becomes stupid tech debt a few months later. Cultured Code comes to mind, though I don’t know if they’re a collective.
- librasteve 2y agosome food for thought here, one point not mentioned is that in many firms, the coding work has been offshored or near shored to low wage countries - so the MBA types are always balancing the equation of the need to be productive locally vs. outsourcing chunks of code development
- SebFender 2y agoPeople are interested by what they understand. That's why so many non technical people implement processes, meetings and reviews - because that's what they understand - without understanding impacts they have on technical people that actually know what they do.