5 ms·
Logitech has an idea for a "forever mouse" that requires a subscription
- donohoe 2y agoI checked the date of the story - it was not April 1st
- tocs3 2y agoAre you sure? :) Also from TFA: "During the interview, Faber also discussed Logitech's goals of doubling its business and cutting its carbon footprint by 50 percent by 2031."
- dheera 2y agoWe need legislation that makes it illegal to restrict owners of hardware from using hardware that they own.
- lucianbr 2y agoAfter reading the article, I have no idea why this new mouse would require a subscription, other than the company is greedy. Also I have no idea what would be different about the mouse. In fact, there's almost no information other than "Logitech would like customers to pay them monthly".
- duxup 2y agoLogitech might just be one of those places where word comes down from on high. "CEO says we should have <poppycock>." "But there's no place in our product for <poppycock>, and our customers hate <poppycock>." -pause- "CEO says we should have <poppycock>."
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- potamic 2y agoYou can start with asking what problems customers are facing and offer to solve those problems in exchange for money. Or you can start asking how much money to make and find ways to convince customers to give you that money. Only they have asked the question, but haven't figured out how to convince customers to give the money.
- sillywalk 2y agoI'm pretty sure that's it. There is no reason. Of course, Logitech just launched a mouse[0] with a Chat-GPT button, but it requires the "Logi Options+ App" to use. It's like the 90s internet hype, no realistic business model, just +AI instead of +internet. [0] https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2024/04/ai-marketing-hype-is-coming-for-your-favorite-gadgets/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2024/04/ai-marketing-hype-is...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Arcuru 2y agoI'm generally a supporter of paying for software with a subscription if I expect to get updates...but does a mouse need updates?
- arrosenberg 2y agoThis is the same company that monopolized the smart TV remote market before shutting down the entire Harmony line. No one should trust them for "forever" anything.
- wmf 2y agoIs this [CEO] from HP? What's next, a mouse that requires proprietary ink cartridges? Edit: apologies for assuming gender
- tocs3 2y agoAs far as I know Hanneke Faber identifies as a woman (unless "guy" is being used more generically here). Hanneke Faber bio: https://www.logitech.com/en-us/about/leadership/hanneke-faber.html https://www.logitech.com/en-us/about/leadership/hanneke-fabe... Good or bad she seems to have led and interesting life so far but no Wikipedia. Still, the idea of a subscription mouse is a little depressing. I would assume it will quit working when you stop paying and/or Logitech discontinues the product. (edit for spelling)
- lambdaone 2y agoEnshittification has finally reached peripherals. I thought this story was a joke at first, but it evidently isn't. I can't imagine what extra services a mouse might offer, except in the role of acting as a dongle for other software. Presumably Logitech will enlighten us before launching this product.
- kmac_ 2y agoEnshittification is actually a hilarious process to watch when you know it's happening and have a way to escape it by switching to an alternative. I escaped from HP, Windows, Reddit, changed banks, and moved to a bunch of other products, sites, and services.
- al_borland 2y agoThe switching cost, and what is given up in the process, isn’t always that funny. I can only find in funny to watch if I was never a customer/user, and even then, I find it more sad than funny.
- ecshafer 2y ago> Speaking on a July 29 episode of The Verge's Decoder podcast, Faber, who Logitech appointed as CEO in October, said that members of a "Logitech innovation center" showed her "a forever mouse" and compared it to a nice but not "super expensive" watch. This is not a good idea. The fact their "innovation center" came up with a subscription is hilarious. I do actualyl like Logitech mice, this would turn me off of them permanently.
- dijksterhuis 2y agoI genuinely feel this could be an instance of “when Moss and Roy showed Jen ‘the internet’”. https://youtu.be/iDbyYGrswtg https://youtu.be/iDbyYGrswtg
- vxxzy 2y agoMaybe it will have FIDO2/U2F support? There is a use-case here maybe? I’ll stop giving ideas now…
- ch_123 2y agoI own Logitech mice from the late 80s/early 90s which still work perfectly. None of the issues which would prevent me from using them on a modern computer could be fixed by software updates delivered by subscription.
- ndiddy 2y agoGiven Logitech's current mice start double-clicking after about a year, I'm curious what they'd change about their designs to extend that lifetime to forever.
- Highlanderwolf 2y ago[dead]
- pelagicAustral 2y agoOh man! I can wait to have my manager come over and ask me why I'm doing fuck all, so I can tell him that someone in finance forgot to pay my keyboard and mouse subscription.
- theandrewbailey 2y agoAnd if the credit card on your mouse subscription expires, the mouse stops working, ironically preventing you from entering new credit card info to resume the subscription.
- sebastiennight 2y agoAs long as you're up to date on payments for your Forever Keyboard, you should be good.
- jmclnx 2y agoApt name. The forever mouse will sit forever on store shelves.
- tocs3 2y agoI think it would be bought in great quantities. It would be nice if humanity could work harder to educate people.
- RIMR 2y agoIt is obvious that they started with "Mouse with subscription fees", and worked backward from there. They haven't actually come up with a product that anyone wants, they just invented the product that they want to sell (and make passive income off of). This is one of the most ridiculous cash-grab ideas I have ever seen. There is no reason for a mouse to need a software update. This is a completely made-up narrative. All functions of the mouse should be accounted for without the need for follow-up; a company like Logitech should already have an excellent framework for mouse firmware that is free from bugs or inefficiencies that would require updating. And this comparison to a mouse as an analog to a "super expensive watch" is completely misguided. They're just coming up with an excuse to make a "super expensive mouse". Generally speaking though, most people who take computer peripherals seriously don't very much care about the mouse, and focus instead of on having a fancy and expensive mechanical keyboard. And there is no glory in buying some corporate "forever keyboard" with paid updates, your peers will ridicule you for not building your own from PCBs you ordered online and 3d printed casing. After all, the bigger a power-user you are, the less likely you are to even touch the mouse. This is dumb idea dreamed up by stupid people in a boardroom, where the topic of the meeting was "Money: how to make it".
- craigds 2y agoWho's throwing away mouses? They last at least a decade, likely two. And for most people there's no software involved (that isn't installed and handled by the builtin drivers in their OS)
- tocs3 2y agoPeople throw way entire computers. I have also seen people throw away any number of things for all sorts of reasons.
- JohnFen 2y agoJudging by the large bin of them (for sale at $1 each) at my local electronics reseller, it seems that a lot do.
- 5555624 2y agoMost new computers with a new keyboard and mouse. Most people don't need a second one. (And the HN crowd probably has a lot of users with KVM switches.)
- JohnFen 2y agoThis is why I've never needed to buy one of those $1 mice (some of which are very high-end). I have my own box full of them. Although I shouldn't say "never". I have a box full of keyboards, too, but needed a real PS/2 keyboard recently and discovered that I didn't save any from the last time I did an equipment purge. So I had to buy one from the reseller (which was where I donated my old ones to begin with. It's not impossible that I bought a keyboard I gave to them!)
- jacknews 2y agoThe ones that last a decade or two were made a decade or two ago. Modern mice seem to reliably break in a couple of years or less.
- al_borland 2y agoI’ve gone through a few at work. I recently got a new mouse, because I was having issues with it seemingly like the mouse button was being stuck down… but not exactly. The new mouse was more of a troubleshooting step and things got significantly better, so I kept it and the old one is trash. I had stuff like this happen o a few mice where they just seem worn out after a while. And of course there was one that I slammed on my desk in frustration over something and broke it. Oops.
- jprd 2y agorolls-up newspaper - bad Logitech! Bad!
- potamic 2y agoI already have a forever mouse. A Microsoft optical mouse from 20 years ago. Perfectly ergonomic, no batteries, plug-and-play that just works on any device new or old, and a build quality to last decades. How have we regressed from these ideals and gotten to where we are?
- kyleee 2y agoThe quest for recurring revenue? Who is driving that? MBAs?
- fuzzfactor 2y agoWith a basic Logitech gaming mouse from a few years ago, it had the simple default RGB effects at all times, Windows, Linux, even DOS. Recently on Windows 11 there was a firmware update from Logitech and now the RGB is controllable from W11 built-in FX interface. But no more RGB at all when you reboot to Linux ever since. I thought that was going to last forever, guess I was wrong. Turned out to be quite a dark mouse most of the time.
- Fr0styMatt88 2y agoIf you haven’t already, check if OpenRGB supports it.
- morkalork 2y agoI had a Logitech mouse last for 20 years till it finally started to glitch out and I had to replace it. I'm really not seeing the need for a subscription here.
- jqpabc123 2y agoLogitech needs to ask HP how this sort of marketing is working for them.
- necovek 2y agoSo what it seems everybody is reading is that Logitech believes they can create a computer mouse that will last decades without breaking in any way at reasonable price, but they don't wanna because they would jeopardize their sales of their lesser mice, and they actually want to figure out a recurring revenue model to go with it. How about this: you make a "forever mouse", sell it at a profit, and people simply keep buying it because it's so fricking great? They also buy one for their workplace (or get the company to buy it) since it's not the lightest mouse around, they might also buy it as a gift and... You get the point, just this thing might bring them enough revenue _if_ this is really such a good product that they would capture more of the market share even if their product is very durable.
- mystified5016 2y agoAh, you see the problem here is that the business model you propose is not profitable enough. Shareholders need returns that increase exponentially forever without bound, obviously.
- rolph 2y agoarcade controllers are quite durable, and if you search about the parts and adaptors required seem to be roundly, 150$ it just depends on how much kludge you want to do for a DIY forever mouse, or the whole controller suite for that matter.
- K0balt 2y agoI think I’m going to launch an AI powered SAAS enterprise that comes up with ways that brick and mortar companies can transition into zero marginal cost markets without actually adding value or doing anything at all of substance. Like a think tank on an API for extracting value without the hassles of generating value in the process. I’ll call it enshitify.ai , and it will be subscription based, of course.
- jaredhallen 2y agoSounds like a winner, but I'd suggest dropping the y. Enshitif.ai
- K0balt 2y agoI love this. It captures the vibe to perfection. Too cheap to include the y, no Y for you! We make you figure it out so we can monetise the Y without actually delivering it. On brand, 10/10
- Simulacra 2y agoSounds like another anticonsumer, asinine, business practice, right up there with charging a subscription fee for heated seats in your car.
- mystified5016 2y agoI'll just keep using the mouse I bought a decade ago. If the switches wear out, it's entirely trivial to replace them. My last mouse went through three sets before something else broke and killed it. Switches can last years or decades depending on quality and use. The rest of the electronics will last essentially forever. The only thing that can reasonably wear out or break permanently are the plastic and rubber parts. USB HID won't ever go away or change. As long as USB ports exist your mouse will still work. Logitech can go pound sand.
- nlawalker 2y ago> Logitech's CEO didn't discuss what durability features a long-lasting mouse might incorporate. The only one that matters is that you replace it for free or for a nominal fee when it breaks or becomes unworkable, at minimal inconvenience to the customer. See Darn Tough socks for reference.
- al_borland 2y agoIf there is a subscription to use it, there better not be an additional fee to replace it. Darn Tough doesn’t make me pay a monthly fee to wear their socks.
- yndoendo 2y agoSaaS program is just poor product design. Using a programmable Roccat where all customization is embedded in the firmware of the mouse. This means the configuration stays between switching computers and operating systems, and cannot be affect by overzealous OS and application security. Nothing like controlling the computer volume, mute, and active window right from the mouse. Great for seamless controlling game volume to better hear quite environments or reduce loud ones, quick mute when someone at work wants to talk. All of that would be come a nightmare with SaaS and waste CPU cycles.
- KomoD 2y ago"forever" as in they want you to give them money forever :D
- proc0 2y ago"You will own nothing, and you will be happy" Many companies are certainly heading in this direction. I think a better direction should be something like "you will own less because you will need less and it will last longer".