7 ms·
Cuil Fail: Traffic Nearly Hits Rock Bottom
- mrkurt 18y agoAnd TechCrunch continues their transformation into FuckedCompany 2.0.
- vaksel 18y agosomeone's gotta do it...the guy who started the original has decided not to do it this time around: http://www.techcrunch.com/2008/12/27/fucked-companyadbrite-founder-philip-kaplan-to-launch-kaplan-index/ http://www.techcrunch.com/2008/12/27/fucked-companyadbrite-f...
- bfioca 18y agoI really don't think this is at all a fair or even correct statement. For one (and this should be obvious), FuckedCompany didn't report on emerging startups, just ones that were failing. Another thing is (and I feel this is pretty obvious too), I'm not surprised to see more posts about companies in trouble than ones succeeding in the first place (most companies don't succeed), and in an economic downturn this is even less surprising. What would be surprising to me would be to not hear about companies failing after having had years of reporting of emerging new startups.
- russell 18y agoHN had a posting about "postmodern programming" a couple of days back, so I thought I would give it a try. Google found at least 10 pages of documents, Yahoo a bunch, even answers.com found a couple. Cuil? Zip, Nada, zero. I guess I won't switch. EDIT: My bad. Apologies to Cuil and HN. I had a typo in my query. Cuil didn't catch it, but Google suggested the correct spelling when I gave it the typo.
- vizard 18y agoUmm I just tried that : http://www.cuil.com/search?q=%22postmodern+programming%22 http://www.cuil.com/search?q=%22postmodern+programming%22 It returned 516 results for me (when including quotes in query).
- schtog 18y agoWithout them too.
- gaius 18y agoLive.com can hardly get any traffic and their search works. I had high hopes for Cuil but gave up when it became clear that their search results were simply bad or missing. They should have held a closed beta for 6 months.
- raghus 18y agoWhat's your reference for saying that live.com can hardly get any traffic? http://www.alexa.com/site/ds/top_sites?ts_mode=lang&lang=en http://www.alexa.com/site/ds/top_sites?ts_mode=lang&lang... has them at #4 (which seems unbelievable but definitely past the bar of very high traffic sites)
- gaius 18y agoLook up the fraction of search traffic they get compared to Google (or even Yahoo) - and the ad revenue they can generate from it.
- pmjordan 18y agoPlus they must get a decent amount of traffic from mistyped URLs in IE - I've ended up at live.com a couple of times while trying to test some XHTML/CSS/JS in IE.
- bd 18y agoIsn't Live.com actually composed of gazillion sites? I think Alexa counts all subdomains together. On Wikipedia there are listed more than 50 subsites: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_Live http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_Live With many of these being used directly from Microsoft desktop software, it wouldn't be so unbelievable for Live.com to be #4.
- tokenadult 18y agoI suppose each user has his own preferred torture-test search terms. For mine, Cuil has recently (but NOT at launch) returned a better set of results that does Live.com. But neither wows me enough to pull me away from Google.
- blackvine 18y agotry duckduckgo
- villageidiot 18y agoCall me unambitious if you like but I would be happy to fail as Cuil has "failed". They still receive over 150K uniques per month. I would gladly take half of that. Thanks to the massive mainstream publicity they received around launch time as being a "Google Killer" they were able to expose their site to millions (yes, millions) and lock in an audience. Sure, the numbers have dropped off since then. So what? I'm tired of hearing the word "fail" bandied about so self-righteously as if Cuil should be ashamed of not beating Google at their own game. Like that's some kind of minor challenge. Yes, their implementation is lacking. Yes they have not taken advantage of the time since launch to work out its weaknesses. But their PR department certainly can't be accused of failure and I wouldn't be surprised if they're making some decent ad revenue off that kind of traffic. It would be more fair - to them and to us - to call them a mixed success. One of the problems of the word 'fail' used so liberally in these contexts is that it is a blanket refusal to look at the balance of someone's achievements in its context. Used this way, it's actually a bigoted term and has the very problematic side-effect of making us less willing to take a balanced perspective on our own achievements in addition to those of the people we label with it.
- chollida1 18y ago> Sure, the numbers have dropped off since then. So what? I'm guessing the problem has something to do with the 33 million in VC they took. > It would be more fair - to them and to us - to call them a mixed success Perhaps you could if they don't take any money but they did, and now they have to figure out how to get that 5-10 times return on the 33 million they took. That's the reason people consider Cuil to be a failure.
- axod 18y agoAgreed. With that sort of backing you'd expect a bit more traffic than they have left.
- villageidiot 18y agoFair point, but I assume they paid themselves a decent salary out of that 33 million. Plus they're incorporated so the worst they face is bankruptcy proceedings, which, again, will not have an impact on the individual members. Perhaps we could talk about a failure on the part of the VCs that invested in them but even they have an excuse - they were supporting "the next Google". The members of Cuil will come away with a significant high profile experience on their resumes and no doubt every member will have a story that will explain away the "failure" as someone else's fault. The members of Cuil have profited, learned and lost nothing - in other words, they are in an enviable position.
- acgourley 18y agoWasn't Cuil all about getting acceptable search results with less iron in the server room? If that's the case, no one should suspect they could beat Google. I really haven't researched this, but I was under the impression they were hoping to get bought by a search giant looking to cut the operating overhead of their search division. If that's true, they don't care about uniques, and thats why they don't seem to be doing much (from the outside).
- jonknee 18y agoBut the lack of users is a sign that they don't have acceptable results. I found the results to be horrible and like 99% of other people who tried it out won't be back.
- acgourley 18y agoNot true - their results would need to be substantially better than google to get people to navigate away from their iGoogle pages, add firefox search widgets, etc. Acceptable doesn't change user behavior.
- villageidiot 18y agoAgreed. But I sure wish I had their marketing team working for me - 5 million views the first month for a piece of crap like that is no small achievement.
- jonknee 18y agoToo bad they weren't working for you because I think Cuil would be better off if no one had heard of them yet. Five million people now know they are really shitty. They have to work extra hard to get those people back. It's like having a store's grand opening event with empty shelves.
- villageidiot 18y agoYes, they blew a huge opportunity - they would have benefited from waiting. But, assuming they haven't burned through their $33 million nest egg, if they spend wisely they could bring their numbers up and at the same time work on improving their algorithms. They still potentially have a huge cushion. The judgement they have displayed until now does not bode well for a comeback however.
- bprater 18y agoI don't think beating Google is all about "server hardware efficiency". I'm not sure how they sold VCs on this concept. It is about creating result sets so amazing that you pick up your phone and tell your friends and family about it.
- acgourley 18y agoGetting bought by Google just might be, though. (And yes, I know they turned down an offer when they first started up, but they may have just been holding out for more.)
- amirnathoo 18y agoCreating great results sets, or at least much better ones than the competition, is why Google won in the first place. But I think the real battle-ground now is the interface. If Cuil or SearchMe really believed their technology was so much better than Google's at delivering search results they would have no need to also experiment with the UI.
- rms 18y agoOn the topic, one of the best reddit comments of all time: Cuils as a unit of measure. http://www.reddit.com/r/worldnews/comments/7da5i/police_raids_reveal_baby_farms/c06cqxb http://www.reddit.com/r/worldnews/comments/7da5i/police_raid...