11 ms·
"Charge a fair price for it." seems to be a meaningless platitude in this instance, sort of a soup-bone to the "I'm only pirating because it is overpriced" apol
by patio11 18y ago
"Charge a fair price for it." seems to be a meaningless platitude in this instance, sort of a soup-bone to the "I'm only pirating because it is overpriced" apologetics. Isn't the whole point of the anecdote that World of Goo is, umm, more than fairly priced? (Seriously, people are pirating a $20 pass to pure gaming joy which requires a machine minimally ten times as expensive to run. Probably a hundred times for many of the pirates, since they are gaming enthusiasts.)
Want a recipe for being pirated less? Make something that people wouldn't want to get for free. crickets chirp Actually, that probably won't even help -- I think a large portion of piracy is essentially pathological. Bingo Card Creator -- an which assists primary school English teachers who are, on average, not likely to be reading Chinese pirate forums -- got spikes of 10k+ downloads when the new cracks were released.
It even had a description translated into Chinese... which was hilarious. (My brother translated for me: "Apparently it's like a gambling game for English or some shit.")
Honestly its like putting a shiny object in front of that bird with the unhealthy fascination for shiny objects whose name I am forgetting at the moment. If your code compiles, it will be pirated. You could make a Windows forms calculator with only a plus button, with an equals sign available with a CD Key, and people would pirate that. (I've often thought of trying it.)
- ajkirwin 18y agoI see this argument a lot, "Oh well, it's cheap, so people should just pay for it!" and it seems to gloss over one important fact. Money is not an unlimited resource. If there are say.. $4,000 (purchase price) of fun and awesome things released in a year, and the average person after things like bills, rent/mortgage, etcetera only has say.. $500 left to actually spend on frivolity, then they might decide the following: "Well, I guess I will download the rest. It's not like they are losing a sale. I don't HAVE any money, anyway!". And, if this is the case, it's true. No-one actually LOSES anything. You can't lose a sale you could never have made anyway. So such numbers can be shockingly misleading.
- gcheong 18y agoBut is it OK for someone to benefit from something they aren't willing to pay for? What is the difference between someone who decides to go without because they don't or can't pay and someone who says I can't/won't pay so I'll just copy it from someone else? Is it morals or economics?
- ajkirwin 18y agoYou cannot really use morals in an example where you aren't depriving anyone of anything.
- gcheong 18y agoThe people who choose not to copy the game without paying are depriving themselves of the benefit of the game even though they don't have to vs. the people who decide its ok to play the game even though they can't or won't pay. So what is the difference between the two people? The economics is factored out (neither person pays) so the difference would seem to be one of personal morals.
- ajkirwin 18y agoI thought you were talking about depriving OTHERS. Which is what matters, is it not?
- tptacek 18y agoThank you for depriving me of a great deal of software that would otherwise not demand per-seat registration and kernel module license monitors. Thank you for depriving me of a great deal of software that would not cost $600 retail if it wasn't so hard to keep users from circulating it.
- ajkirwin 18y agoDepriving how, exactly? I'm talking about non-sales. I am talking about people who literally DO NOT HAVE ANY MORE MONEY. If they download something, how can you count that as a 'lost sale' or a 'loss to piracy'? You just can't. That's making something from nothing.
- Scriptor 18y agoI would agree with your opinion if a vast majority of people who have computers and Internet connections could not afford another $20. But what if there was no pirated version of this game available? I think you'd find that, if it's not too inconvenient, more people would actually buy the game. For example, console games don't suffer as much from pirating, but what if hypothetically it was as easy to pirate a game for your Wii or 360 as it was for your PC? I very much doubt that people would continue to buy the games. So basically, the very presence of pirated games available for free is taking sales away from the game makers, people are simply choosing the free option.
- ajkirwin 18y agoYou seem to be overlooking the scarceness issue. It's not about Just Another $20. It's about Just Another $20, And Another. And Another. You are saying that it would be wrong for me to download something, even if the very act of doing so does not make anyone lose any money, take the food from anyone's mouth (etc etc)?
- tjr 18y agoI think that misses the point. Suppose someone is selling clay pottery. They bought a machine to help them make it, but the clay itself is freely available. They just go down to the riverbed and grab a heap of clay. You could go get the very same clay. It's free; it's a public resource. We'll even say there is infinite clay. Now then. The producer is using a totally free resource to produce clay pots. It takes a few hours to make each one, and they are very nice. But the only material in the product is a free resource. If you were to steal the pots without paying for them, the producer isn't out anything, because the producer can just go get more clay; no big deal. You've taken no money, you've taken no food. All you've taken is a clay pot, made out of a substance of which the producer has an infinite supply. Is it okay to steal the pot?
- ajkirwin 18y agoNo. Because the producer isn't, once he's made his Clay Pot 1.0, simply using a replicator to run off infinite copies of it. But if he WAS, then yeah, it'd be fine, providing you had no way to getting the pots yourself.
- jbjohns 18y agoWhat you say is true, but what percentage of people are not paying because they can't afford it vs. the one's who just don't want to pay for it? While it is true that someone downloading a game that they couldn't have paid for doesn't deprive the maker of money, it's quite a slippery slope.
- tptacek 18y agoIt's not even true if you can't afford it. You have $500 to spend on "frivolity" this year. You choose not to spend $20 of it on World of Goo. Now you're not going to spend the money next year, either: you already took it. You might as well not spend the $500. Give it to charity, and just take everything you want. See, now you're Robin Hood!
- nazgulnarsil 18y agothey might have bought it next year.
- greendestiny 18y agoYou don't know how many people would prioritize this game over other spending if they couldn't get it for free. Only things that you can pirate can you choose to get for free so it gets prioritized lower than it deserves.
- pmorici 18y agoWhat about a hardware token? Are those effective?
- tptacek 18y agoNo, because the software title itself is still software, dongle or not; the exact same techniques crack dongle titles as crack downloadable shareware. Which is why very few titles use dongles.
- trevelyan 18y agoMagpie
- lunchbox 18y ago>You could make a Windows forms calculator with only a plus button, with an equals sign available with a CD Key, and people would pirate that. (I've often thought of trying it.) Made me think of this: http://blort.org/~kgasso/images/how-to-catch-script-kiddies.gif http://blort.org/~kgasso/images/how-to-catch-script-kiddies....