7 ms·
The article is a bit doom and gloom. The debt to GDP levels are fairly middling against other developing countries. Also historically what usually happens to go
by tim333 2y ago
The article is a bit doom and gloom. The debt to GDP levels are fairly middling against other developing countries. Also historically what usually happens to government debt is that it isn't really paid back but sits there and is reduced in value over time by inflation. That will probably happen here.
- MuffinFlavored 2y ago> by inflation By average 2-3% a year inflation or by above-average heightened inflation (which hurts people)? https://www.google.com/search?q=inflation+tax https://www.google.com/search?q=inflation+tax
- enceladus06 2y agoBased on the amount of debt, inflation may exceed 2-3%, and there will be complaints. To fix the debt load, a combination of inflation, taxes, and spending cuts will be needed. Additionally, the intergenerational transfer of wealth from Boomers to Millennials and Zoomers will occur over the next 20ish years as Boomers die off. This wealth transfer could be used to increase tax revenues. One tax that could be raised would be the estate tax, which would be unpopular among the wealthy, but if lowered to 1MM-1.5MM (maybe 10% rate) and over 50MM (50% rate) would help to fill the deficit. The more likely scnario is the government allows higher inflation rates and we have a bag of cheetos costing $10 in <10 years.
- tim333 2y agoWho knows but back 30 years the US consumer price index is up 2.13x. My guess is that in another 30 years the debt will be there but reduced in value by something like that. And the CPI tends to understate inflation a bit.
- alephnerd 2y ago> The article is a bit doom and gloom The CEPR is an EU think tank supported by the French Government [0] France and Germany have been lobbying against US stimulus packages like the IRA and IIJA, and economic protectionism that has become mainstream politically [1]. It is becoming a trade war [2] Western European allies can tell the US what to do when they start carrying their weight like Poland, Romania, Czechia, etc. [0] - https://cepr.org/about https://cepr.org/about [1] - https://www.politico.eu/article/macron-heads-to-washington-on-mission-to-avert-transatlantic-trade-war/ https://www.politico.eu/article/macron-heads-to-washington-o... [2] - https://www.institutmontaigne.org/en/expressions/real-reasons-why-europe-concerned-us-inflation-reduction-act https://www.institutmontaigne.org/en/expressions/real-reason...
- panick21_ 2y agoPointing out the reality isnt 'telling what to do'. And France isnt in a position anyway to do that, since they have the exact same problem as the US.
- alephnerd 2y agoIt isn't a reality though. It's absolutely a biased piece of advice because it has subsidized American industrial players at the expense of players across Europe - which is why the EU has been in the process of lobbying against American deficit spending that is primarily being used for subsidizing industrial policy. Western European austerity has clearly hobbled France and Germany while the US was able to weather the GFC and COVID recsssion by using it's deficit. > And France isnt in a position anyway to do that, since they have the exact same problem as the US. Yet they are as Macron's lobbying blitz in 2022-23, the French Govt's Institue Montagaine has pointed out, and the French govt supported CEAP has been lobbying against.
- panick21_ 2y agoThat you don't like the messenger doesn't change the reality of the situation. You can find much of the same analysis from various institutions in the US who have come to the same conclusions. If you want argue that deficit spending is fine and no problem, then just do that. You don't have to sell us on how CEPR is an evil arm of French propaganda.
- gjsman-1000 2y ago“a bit doom and gloom” I don’t think there’s a scenario where you can look at any country with this much debt, break the news, and then have it not sound like gloom and doom. This just reminds me of the Mel Brooks Robin Hood Movie: “Maybe, if you break the bad news to me, but in a good way, then it won’t sound so bad!” https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Mi-YLIwkfJs https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Mi-YLIwkfJs “That will probably happen here.” Can you even conceive of how much inflation this would require, especially at the pace of the debt’s growth? People would be rioting.
- tim333 2y agoIn the UK where I live it went to over 250% of GDP after the world wars but life went on and it reduced to about 50% over the following decades, and then bounced back a bit. https://articles.obr.uk/300-years-of-uk-public-finance-data/assets/fc7VT0rSq2/government-borrowing-and-debt-since-1700-3125x1842.jpg https://articles.obr.uk/300-years-of-uk-public-finance-data/... I mean not ideal but the 50s and 60s were quite good in the UK.
- gjsman-1000 2y agoTrue; but the UK had at least three advantages: Huge post-war economic growth, a high export market (rebuilding Europe takes material) boosted by US aid to those countries, and the Bretton-Woods system made negotiating the debt easier by ironically relying on the stability of the US dollar. The US would not have any of those advantages. There's not a more stable dollar alternative to look to, there's not an obvious ludicrous economic boom on the horizon, the export market's probably not growing that much, and US taxes don't have much headway to go up before being counterproductive and stalling growth (if they haven't already been doing so). Stalled growth results in less tax revenue, defeating the point of the tax increase. In a nutshell, the UK was partially saved by the US and countries rebuilding themselves. The US has no savior.
- tim333 2y agoThe US has the world reserve currency thing making it easier to borrow although I think that is a bit overrated. It is also the world leader in a lot of the most important industries especially tech and AI which should help things.
- phkahler 2y agoComparing to other countries is irrelevant. Their economies are smaller and maybe their ratio is stable? Also, the US budget was balanced in 2000. It is possible. I have no idea why so many people refuse to accept that there is a growing problem.
- amphibian87 2y agobecause it's not? revenue was reduced a ton by the 2017 tax scam. The number one sign of a weak nation state is the inability to collect taxes from their elites.
- Bostonian 2y agoYour opposing a tax cut does not make it a "scam".
- CryptoBanker 2y ago>Your opposing a tax cut does not make it a "scam". The scam part comes from how the tax cut was marketed to Americans
- tdb7893 2y agoI love how when people talk about making America Great Again they are generally talking about a time where the highest marginal tax rate was like 70% (of course no one paid that but people don't pay the top rate now either). I would love to bring that piece of history back. I love America and have benefitted a lot from it, I'm happy to pay more for my fellow Americans (which I do now via some donations but I need to do more)
- rayiner 2y agoPeople pay much more of the theoretical top rate today than they did of the higher top rate back then. Federal tax revenues as a percentage of GDP has been basically flat since 1950: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FYFRGDA188S https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FYFRGDA188S.
- lazide 2y agoMuch of US government debt is US social security debt, which is going to be drawn down over the next decade and a half.
- anonym29 2y agoSocial Security's current obligations are the largest single spending category of the entire U.S. Federal Government, and are continuing to grow rapidly. The SS trust fund is projected to be depleted by 2033, at which point benefits will be automatically reduced to just 79% of their current level, by laws that are already on the books. This information is freely available from the Social Security Administration themselves. [1] Keep in mind, Social Security's and Medicare's unfunded future liabilities grossly exceed the current liabilities of these programs. These defined benefit programs are mathematically reliant on a growing, rather than shrinking population, yet a shrinking population is what the entire industrialized world is currently on track for with our sub-2.1 TFRs. [1] https://www.ssa.gov/oact/trsum/ https://www.ssa.gov/oact/trsum/
- ryandrake 2y agoSocial Security is going to end up being yet another one of those ladders that the Boomers pull up once they're done benefiting from it. Just like low home prices and cheap college tuition.
- anonym29 2y agoHow do you figure that boomers, as a collective cohort, are uniquely responsible for the increases in college tuition and housing prices? I'm not stating your assertion is false, but I don't see the connection.
- lazide 2y agoNot the poster, but IMO it’s a bit like saying Gen Z is responsible for TikTok. If they weren’t there, or this was 100 years earlier, or Gen Z was fundamentally different than they had been raised to be, then yeah TikTok likely would not exist, or at least not be a notable problem. Post WW2 was an economic and population boom time. The boomers resulted from that boom, and the programs for them helped them, and that boom continued. Booms continue to grow until the fundamentals fall apart and the leverage can’t keep it going anymore - and then you get a bust. The longer and unhinged the boom, usually the longer and unhinged the bust. And here we are.
- rayiner 2y agoIt's not middling. At 122%, we are just behind basket cases Italy and Greece. We are above France or Spain, and more than double well-run countries such as Germany or the Netherlands. The EU target is 60% debt to GDP. Moreover, our debt is growing faster. Our deficit as a percentage of GDP, at 6.3%, is more than double the EU target.
- pohuing 2y agoI'd be hesitant about calling us Germans well run. We're lacking money for everything and the past 16 years's greatest accomplishment was pushing maintenance further back to purse a balanced budget. Not spending money has its own costs as we now have to suffer through.
- brnt 2y agoGermany doesn't lack money, it just reveres the lack of debt a bit too much. It's cheap for Germany to borrow and invest, and in all likelihood be able to debts down and benefit from the investments, but they don't, because debt scary. A mountain of unrealized goodwill. It's such a pity, because indeed much of infrastructure is barely maintained.
- dpiers 2y agoWell there was that one time Germany owed everyone a lot of money after the Treaty of Versailles and it kind of directly led to Hitler’s rise to power and another World War… makes sense for them to be a bit more conservative than other countries.
- panick21_ 2y agoInflation isnt magic. As you roll over debt, its afjusted for inflation expectation. And if you do it faster then ecpected its basically extra taxes.
- dataflow 2y ago> The debt to GDP levels are fairly middling against other developing countries Doom is about the future, not the present. Why are you looking at present levels instead of where the trend is taking us in the future?
- omgwtfbyobbq 2y agoIt can also be about the past. That's one problem with looking at charts that aren't indexed/real (inflation adjusted) and/or ratios. On it's face, our debt looks scary. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/GFDEBTN https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/GFDEBTN Looking at it as a ratio, it's still not great, but we've been in similar places in the past. Debt as a percentage of GDP. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/GFDGDPA188S https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/GFDGDPA188S Interest as a percentage of GDP. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FYOIGDA188S https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FYOIGDA188S
- tuatoru 2y agoIt's a bit of a stretch to call 1946 a similar place. In 1946 there was a lot of pent-up demand for housing and consumer durables and a young fast-growing population. Now, not so much. It's also a stretch to call 1990 a similar place for similar reasons. We really are in a never-before-seen place with our current population age structure (old age dependency ratio) and fertility rates.
- omgwtfbyobbq 2y agoI think there are some similarities. There's also a lot of demand for housing now, but it's mostly for affordable housing. Most housing was affordable after WWII, compared to now when a lot of housing isn't affordable. Population growth has slowed, but there's a good chance it would increase if affordable housing was available. We are in a unique place now, and I think we were in 1946 too. I'm not saying everything will be fine, but I don't think it benefits us to say that this is uncharted territory either.
- f38zf5vdt 2y ago
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- TeaBrain 2y agoThe US can't just withhold payments and wait for inflation to run its course. The debt is largely in government bonds and other debt securities. Payments have to be made on the debt securities when they are obligated to be due.
- zamadatix 2y agoIt is and isn't how it works, depending how nuanced a look you give the initial comment. On one hand you're absolutely right, i.e. 30 year treasury bonds have to be paid back in 30 years - right from the name even. That said it's not quite right the government expects to withhold payment as the way to avoid having to actually "pay back the debt" long term. Instead the fed expects to continue selling new 30 year bonds to pay off the old 30 year bonds as they have for many loops now. Usually people accept buying new bonds in this kind of scenario because it's an extremely low risk and easy to manage method of holding your e.g. retirement money without just having it sit there completely. Of course another level of nuance to that conversation is then asking "and what could happen to break that cycle and what would result"?
- TeaBrain 2y agoThat the US will continue to sell debt securities at some level in the future is incontrovertible. That is not what I was responding to, which was that idea that "historically what usually happens to government debt is that it isn't really paid back but sits there and is reduced in value over time by inflation". This is referring to current debt, not the idea of ending the debt cycle. The US doesn't have the option of letting current debt just sit for an arbitrary amount of time and get reduced by inflation, but has to pay according to the obligations of the outstanding debt securities. It also doesn't buy back the debt securities before they are due. The real value will be reduced due to inflation until the point where obligations are due, but there isn't a choice to arbitrarily let it sit.
- zamadatix 2y agoThe strong interpretation of GP was not having "the debt" refer to "the batch of securities providing the current proceeds of the debt" but instead "the outstanding balance owed". Conflating refinancing the debt balance with repayment of the debt only adds confusion to the conversation.
- salawat 2y agoPast performance is not indicative of future results. Discontinuities happen.
- grecy 2y ago> fairly middling against other developing countries Fascinating you're compare the US to other developing countries.. and saying it is basically middle of the road as far as developing countries go.