5 ms·
America's 60-Year-Olds Are Staring at Financial Peril
- vundercind 2y agoWait until Gen X hits retirement, which is coming right up. Markedly lower inflation-adjusted net worth at-same-age than Boomers. And of course Millennials are even worse off than that. Gonna be a large swell of elderly poverty. We have that and a medical care cost problem set to reach crisis levels around the same time. The only meaningful activity right now that might alleviate any part of either problem is… Ozempic, LOL.
- paulpauper 2y agoI think it's more like a barbell. Some millennials doing really well, like inheritance and big salaries and home ownership, but on the other extreme is the college-educated barista.
- nytesky 2y agoAren’t they comparing medians, so it accounts for the tiny percentage do tech/finance that do well? I mean there were junk bonds and corporate raiders in the 80s, as well as the 90s stock bonanza and 2000s real estate. Even a state employee could afford a decent house and saw their net worth explode as housing exploded. That isn’t happening for GenX and Millennials…
- paulpauper 2y agoThat isn’t happening for GenX and Millennials… there are entire subs on reddit communities full of young people with sizable incomes/wealth. FIRE subs, tech subs, investing, and so on. The FANG job is today's '80s Wall Street job. Biased sample, sure, but it's still a lot of people. State employees still make good income. I think the only sector that has done the worst is retail.
- nytesky 2y agoI think you just a vocal minority on social media. It does seem likely that Millenials and GenZ may do better than boomers. https://fortune.com/2024/04/30/high-status-millennials-boomers-wealth-retirement-inflation/ https://fortune.com/2024/04/30/high-status-millennials-boome...
- GeoAtreides 2y ago> more like a barbell the technical term is bimodal distribution
- paulnpace 2y agoMy understanding is mortality rates are higher starting with Gen X, so fewer of them will have to deal with it.
- teractiveodular 2y agoThat seems to be driven largely by fentanyl, which has quintupled the number of deaths from drug overdose since 2000 (the current tally is over 100k per year). Demographically, these people are unlikely to have much in the way of retirement savings.
- paulnpace 2y agoWhen I looked into this a few years ago, it was across the board. The Fentanyl issue is very visible, but it's all the things when you compare generation to generation.
- scruple 2y ago> Gonna be a large swell of elderly poverty. To some measurable degree, it's always been this way. How many snowbird communities in Florida are just shitty trailer parks with Gulf access? > The only meaningful activity right now that might alleviate any part of either problem is… Ozempic, LOL. I invested heavily in $NVO ~1 year ago at ~$50. Lucky me...
- jrs235 2y agoYou want real controversy? Medicare/Medicaid is prolonging the lives of people that don't have money and need others to pay their bills/service their needs. Do corporations exist for humanity or does humanity exist for corporations? (Funny enough I rewatched The Matrix last night. Seems humans exist for AI/imaginary made up beings aka corporations, well actually those that own them and hide behind their limited liability).
- paulpauper 2y agoSo much for the common myth that all boomers and gen-x enjoyed decades of economic prosperity and thus are wealthier. Some are, but when talking huge groups of people like entire demographics, there is considerable variance. A lot of older people despite the post-war boom still are in a precarious financial situation, and it's not like healthcare has gotten cheaper. There is a reason retail occupations are full of older employees.
- rqtwteye 2y agoThat's what's so evil about these categories like "White Male", "Boomer" and others and blaming societal trends on them. Within these groups it's usually only a subsection that received the benefits they are being blamed for. For example, poor white cis males get no sympathies from anywhere. All of this painting of groups with such a broad stroke only distracts from the real problem with is income inequality and the erosion of social safety nets. It keeps the little guys fighting each other while the big guys keep moving ahead.
- kjkjadksj 2y agoCar break down? Roof leak? Furnace go out? Crown fall out of your tooth? All in one year? Congrats, you are now like $30k in the hole. It is easy for budgets to blow up especially if they were lean to begin with.
- Eduard 2y ago> So much for the common myth that all boomers and gen-x enjoyed decades of economic prosperity and thus are wealthier. or rather: maybe because they enjoyed these decades (which often equals spending wealth), they don't have wealth now.
- detourdog 2y ago60 year olds have to be the cusp of gen-x.
- lapcat 2y agoYes, 1964 is the typically defined end of the Baby Boomer date range.
- ghaff 2y agoMost of the people here probably don't especially want to advocate for 25-year jobs that pay a good pension (though mostly not that great in addition to social security) as the pole for retirement. Yes, as the article says, if people don't have retirement savings that isn't great. And, even with Medicare, healthcare isn't free for good coverage.
- vslira 2y agoI does not make sense to rely on an employer to guarantee your retirement income. Ideally you want it to be managed by an organization that is heavily regulated and specializes in this activity, instead of being a cost center (and a financial temptation) for a generic company.
- ghaff 2y agoNo argument. I actually have a non-trivial pension coming from a long-ago decade+ employer which I probably didn't even think about at the time but it's hard for me to think that staying at an employer for a decade or two should be a cornerstone of a retirement strategy. (Even given some regulations today about excessive raiding of the fund.)
- crims0n 2y agoSomething most people don't seem to understand... to retire comfortably (in the US at least) you need to consistently save some percentage of your income all of your life, or a significant portion of your income most of your life. I don't know if their parents or education system is failing these people, but something needs to change.
- ThalesX 2y agoEh, one alternative as in my shithole in Eastern Europe is that they take 25% out of every pay you get throughout your life and when you do retire, you get some shit money for the 5 years of life expectancy you have left.
- paulpauper 2y agoI think a lot of these people get caught in the loop of renting and bad luck and healthcare spending and never have much left over. plus, kids. They just never seem to get it together. Half the population has an IQ below 100. I imagine these people will naturally struggle at saving compared to the other half.
- azemetre 2y agoYes, saving 20% when you have $20 left over your paycheck (or sometimes even negative dollars) might net you a solid $100k when you’re retirement age but I doubt you’ll be able to stretch it very fair since it’ll be likely you’re still renting and still have debts dragging you down. I think what we will see is a return to generational housing in America. More out of a necessity, like how divorced couples still lived together during economic strifes across the world.
- jillieco84 2y agoHowever, there is 55 and up communities across the country, and they offer affordable housing options. You can get a new trailer for 80k or a camper and live comfortably until you die. I am not buying a house but saving at least 100k for retirement. I’d prefer a million but will see. I’m going to start saving a 500 to a 1000 a month in a high interest account whether it is stocks, bonds, or a CD
- linotype 2y agoIt’s hard for me to feel sympathy for a generation that saw the largest expansion of wealth and failed to put $1000 a year away in an index. Over 40 years that’s just over $200k in current dollars at 7% inflation adjusted return.
- nly 2y ago1) $200K isn't a very good retirement fund. 2) I'm afraid 7% above and beyond inflation is pretty optimistic going forward
- ryandrake 2y agoExactly. I think people don't realize just how much they're going to need in order to live an arbitrarily long retirement. Retiring with only $200K is pretty much a retirement into severe poverty. $200K at a 3% draw-down is $6,000 a year. If you want to eat into your principal, do a 4% draw-down and you can live on a whopping $8,000 a year. And that's not today's dollars, that's the value of the dollar in the future. US Poverty level for a couple retiring today is $20K/yr. You need $500K saved up to get that kind of income in retirement. And next year, inflation means you need even more.
- hollerith 2y agoAlmost every American citizen of retirement age (currently 67) will receive a monthly social security check. Even if you never paid into the system (because for example you never worked a day in your life) you would get $943 for an individual and $1,415 for a couple.
- ryandrake 2y agoYea, I disregarded Social Security on purpose since there is so much political risk around it, especially the closer we get to the financial shit hitting the fan. When you consider it though, yes, it adds a non-trivial baseline amount to these calculations.
- SuperNinKenDo 2y agoFrankly, they should follow their own advice and just lay off the lattes and avocado toast. Being a millenial, I really do find it hard to care, sorry.
- keernan 2y agoI am 72. My father worked for one company his entire life. He worked for one company his entire life, from 1931 to 1976. He started sweeping floors and ended as a Senior VP. In 1975 his employer went bankrupt and my dad received 8 cents on the dollar for his pension. Later the Federal Government adopted a federal program insuring private pensions but that was no help for my dad. And employers, responsible for paying into the federal program, dropped private pensions like a hot potato. I never had a pension. Hardly any private companies offered them to my generation. And nobody sat us down and explained 'retirement' and who supports you after you work all your life. Nobody explained it to my dad, who thought he was being provided for. And nobody explained it to 'Boomers' because there wasn't anyone with knowledge to explain 'it' to us. Our parents had pensions. They knew nothing about a world in which there weren't pensions. The perilous and sad fate facing the Boomers in retirement has had the 'benefit' of at least providing us with the knowledge to educate our children about the perils of life. The hard rules are: In the United States, you are solely responsible for what happens to you your entire life. Health care and retirement are both your responsibility. As demonstrated by my father's plight, this has always been true - even if there were lies told to you making you think you had a pension (btw, my father's employer was far from the only one that didn't have the funds to pay its pension benefits). We live in a modern society in a modern world. However, it remains a world of winners and losers. And the losers far outnumber the winners when it comes to parceling out resources once you stop 'working for the man' the majority of your life.
- jillieco84 2y agoHere is something that I plan on doing as a millennial. I’m currently digging out of a financial mess after my son having cancer, and covid. I don’t plan on buying a house but have a lovely rental property to raise my children in. I’m finally making decent money and continuing my education to make even more. But my partner and I plan on saving 1000 a month or 10-12k a year. We can either do a high interest CD or bond, take it to an agency. At 10-12k a year in savings and calculating interest that would be around a million dollars to retire with. Then we plan on buying a small trailer in a 55 in up community which depending where you live can be under 100k. Will hopefully both have social security or other investments but ultimately we are going to live cheap and save. Buying a house is great but you spend a lot of money fixing, updating, insurance, and taxes. Will never see the equity that our parents did. Those selling their homes in the next five years. The current administration is taking a big piece of the pie in taxes atm. But yeah you need to start saving a lot of money before you are 50.