4 ms·
> Regardless though why would it potentially being higher in newer architectures be viewed as a good thing? Because SMT getting faster is a nearly free side-ef
by Dylan16807 2y ago
> Regardless though why would it potentially being higher in newer architectures be viewed as a good thing?
Because SMT getting faster is a nearly free side-effect. We didn't add extra units to speed up SMT at the cost of single-thread speed. We added extra units to speed up the single thread, and they just happened to speed up SMT even more (at least for the purpose of this theoretical). That's better than speeding up SMT the same percent, or not speeding up SMT at all.
Imagine if I took a CPU and just made SMT slower, no other changes. That would be a bad thing even though it gets the speedup closer to 0%, right? And then if I undo that it's a good thing, right?
- paulmd 2y agothis doesn't seem to reflect the reality of the way hardware is actually being added to the cores, where Zen5 features a fourth ALU which is only useful to a single thread in the low-single-digits. https://old.reddit.com/r/hardware/comments/1ee7o1d/the_amd_ryzen_ai_9_hx_370_review_unleashing_zen_5/lfcnnjs/ https://old.reddit.com/r/hardware/comments/1ee7o1d/the_amd_r... this isn't adding more units to speed up single-thread and SMT being a nice "incidental" gain, this is actively targeting wide architectures that have lots of pipeline bubbles for SMT to fill. and that's fine, but it's also a very different dynamic than, eg, apple silicon, where the focus is running super deep speculation and reordering on a single thread.
- Dylan16807 2y agoWhat do you think they should add instead of another ALU? The returns are diminishing, but a single digit bump is still a pretty good when your goal is faster single threads. Adding nothing to save space is obviously not the answer, because that leads to having more slower cores. Also the topic of the post, the 2-ahead branch predictor, exists specifically to get more ALUs running in parallel! > apple silicon, where the focus is running super deep speculation And to make that speculation profitable, the M1 cores have 6 ALUs among other wideness.