5 ms·
What happens if you connect Windows XP to the Internet in 2024? [video]
- usr1106 2y agoInteresting topic, but I would prefer it to be handled with more expertise than in this video. Seems to be a bit of unsystematic guessing. Also the connections opened could be watched in a router and/or with something like Wireshark.
- crashbrun 2y agoHypothesis: Running an [old, non-upgradeable OS] honeypot increases the probability of further scans and intrusion attempts on that range for awhile at least. paralax/awesome-honeypots: https://awesomerank.github.io/lists/paralax/awesome-honeypots.html https://awesomerank.github.io/lists/paralax/awesome-honeypot... Wireshark works with tcpdump over SSH. A VM guest virtual network adapter can also be monitored from the VM host. But a human could spend all day trolling for VM escape exploits with a honeypot.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Reubend 2y agoIs Windows XP on its own really this vulnerable to connections over the internet? This makes it seem like you'll get infected within 10 minutes. I'm sure there are plenty of vulns in Windows XP by now, but it seems surprising to me that a random IP is getting scanned + infected + exploited within such a span of minutes just because it's running an old OS. It would actually be pretty interesting to see which vulnerabilities are used for this type of thing. Sort of the opposite of a 0 day, I suppose... very old, well known exploits. But to do that on a PC with totally stock OS software is impressive.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- NikkiA 2y agoWindows by default, un-firewalled, will announce its presence to a network, and in old versions, that could even be the internet at large (back then you could even see SMB shares over the internet and would often see thousands of 'nearby' system). The malware he got appeared to use a PNG exploit to affect remote code execution once running, but we don't see what bootstrapped that malware into the system
- PaulCarrack 2y ago> Windows by default, un-firewalled, will announce its presence to a network, and in old versions, that could even be the internet at large By announcements you are referring to broadcasts which are limited to the broadcast domain of whatever IP the ISP has assigned you. Plus those are largely blocked by the ISP beyond that. So to say that you are broadcasting to the world that you have an SMB share available is not true. An attacker would have to scan for it (i.e. make an active connection to TCP port 445 on your machine).
- anyfoo 2y agoThis is the correct answer. Broadcast packets do not reach outside of a network segment. The “thousands” of Windows machines OP saw were probably part of the same office network they were sitting in (where other mechanisms may actually have made more of them visible than a simple broadcast would, but intentionally). Sitting at home connected to the Internet over a point-to-point link, you’d see zero Windows machines that are not inside your home, now and back then.
- skipkey 2y agoWhen I got my first cable modem in maybe 1995, there were about half a dozen of my neighbors computers in Network Neighborhood. Most with unprotected shares and printers. Basically everyone running Windows on my C block. It got cleaned up within a few months tho.
- codetrotter 2y ago
- tredre3 2y agoAll of Eric Parker's videos are faked, he installs malware manually for attention. In this particular video you can get a glimpse of that at 2:50, he forgot to close an Internet Explorer window in which he was searching for "XP sp3 worms".
- AmVess 2y agoYes. I've had a new install compromised immediately after first boot. This was over a poorly configured cable internet service. I could also see and connect to other computers in the neighborhood and had full access to shared resources. I did it to prove a point. ISP techs didn't believe it could happen. Yes, they were that bad. However, this was done at the time when every other machine everywhere was compromised in some way and sputtering out malware all the time. I have no idea what the results would be like today, but I suspect it would be far less dramatic because the exploits for XP have more than likely been offline for a long time.
- Terretta 2y agoUn-service-packed XP reachable from public would get owned in single digit minutes back in 2000s. You needed at least SP2 to slow that down. Win2K Server was better, but not markedly. By contrast, a Win2K3 box with service packs and security updates could act as a server with public address if you set it up appropriately before going online. Not an accident — turns out Windows Server 2003 was their first OS to undergo extensive semi-automated bug testing with PREfast, a tool that helped catch 12% of its bugs. Additionally, human software development engineers in test (SDETs) — a claimed 60% of Microsoft's 4500 Windows devs — were crucial in finding the rest. This combined effort made it Microsoft's most rigorously tested release at the time, significantly enhancing its security.
- JoBrad 2y agoYep. We tested SP2 vs SP3 on our college network. SP2 was compromised within 2 minutes. SP3 needed AV, but lasted over a day.
- dgeiser13 2y agoDoes he install ZoneAlarm on it?
- Dwedit 2y agoDoes this include all the official post-abandonment patches (from Microsoft POSReady), and unofficial service pack patches?
- bilsbie 2y agoRelevant xkcd https://xkcd.com/350/ https://xkcd.com/350/
- jmclnx 2y agoThat is one of the funniest ones. I printed it out and attached it to the outside of my cube ages ago.
- romanovcode 2y agoPlease. This is fake. The guy installs Trojans offscreen just to make a video.
- koito17 2y agoI've never really liked Windows XP, but this video is a bit dishonest. As other commenters have pointed out, at around the 2 minute and 50 second mark, the person has a search query for "xp sp3 worm" in Internet Explorer. While the person in the video admits to disabling firewall and other security features of Windows XP, he never mentions his intent to search for worms targetting the platform and execute them. There was a time when Windows XP would get infected by staying online overnight, but the most recent example I remember is the Blaster worm[1] from around 2003. I recall having an ADSL subscription back in 2007, and at the time, the ISP provided a device acting as both a modem and router. So in my case, at least since 2007, I wouldn't have to worry much about keeping a computer online overnight. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blaster_(computer_worm)?useskin=vector https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blaster_(computer_worm)?useski...