7 ms·
Maglev titanium heart inside the chest of a live patient
- fbdab103 2y agoWhy does the article not say how much that thing weighs? It looks hefty, though I suppose a human heart is also probably dense.
- floam 2y agoAnother article says 650g. https://www.forbes.com.au/news/innovation/bivacor-implants-first-in-human-artificial-heart/ https://www.forbes.com.au/news/innovation/bivacor-implants-f...
- Log_out_ 2y agoDid they solve the problem of unnatural pressurespikes causing clots and microbleeds?
- Jyaif 2y ago> the titanium heart is only meant to keep a patient alive while they wait for a heart transplant, which has always been the goal of fully mechanical heart development at this stage of the game. Why are we not aiming higher?
- nightfly 2y agoBecause we can barely get a temporary one working now. I'm sure they'd love to be able to make a permanent one, it's just not in the cards yet.
- WJW 2y agoSame reason as why we're not developing starships to go to the other side of the Milky way at the moment: We don't know how to and the leap from "what we can do right now" (ie we struggle to get people to the moon permanently) and "other side of the galaxy" is simply too big.
- didgeoridoo 2y agoThis article does a good job of outlining the challenges faced: https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20230217-the-61-year-long-search-for-artificial-hearts https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20230217-the-61-year-long... From the outside, it looks like a race between figuring out the biocompatibility and power issues for total artificial hearts vs. figuring out the immunological issues for xenografts (pig hearts, mostly). If I had to put money on it, I’d bet that the xenografts win. It doesn’t seem like we’ve made huge strides toward solving the power and durability requirements of total artificial hearts, while immunology advances are happening rapidly. Exciting times, nonetheless.
- iancmceachern 2y agoTotally, I've been following that space closely as well. Amazing times indeed, we are seeing xenografts and artificial organs in use.
- TaylorAlexander 2y agoWould be nice if a pig didn’t have to die to save a human though. This is not something everyone cares about but some people (like me) do care. Hopefully some day we can advance the technology enough with artificial solutions.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- didgeoridoo 2y agoThis is honestly a pretty niche concern. Even most religions that strictly forbid eating pork make an exception if a human’s life is at stake. Your best bet would probably be in advocating for the pigs to be engineered to prevent cortical development, ensuring they don’t become anything beyond twitching, unconscious organ bags. In many ways I think people would find this more disturbing, though.
- gregoryl 2y agoSomething like 6% to 10% of the population is vegan, a bit more than niche!
- tomcam 2y ago> Why are we not aiming higher? We've been aiming higher explicitly for at 70+ years (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artificial_heart https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artificial_heart). I've been following it for 50. Artificial hearts were 5 years away since at least 1972 or so when I first learned about this field. The problems (mechanical, surgical, electrical, biological) are endless and it's an astoundingly hostile environment for machinery. We have enough problems getting pacemakers to work without severe problems.
- Leynos 2y agoThe Abiocor device always fascinated me. It was developed with long-term implantation in mind. You can read about it here: https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/medicine-and-dentistry/abiocor https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/medicine-and-dentistry/... The use of inductive power transfer meant that no transdermal cabling was needed. Sadly, it sounds like for various reasons the dream was not achievable at the time.
- iancmceachern 2y agoI know people who worked on that, I've held one in my hand. It was not designed with long term implantation in mind. It was designed to get funding and keep the company alive. The device itself was very crude, not statenof the art at the time, and much of it was hand dip-molded with basic materials. It was a hand made research device that in all reality would have never been expected to be reliable and long lasting. The Bivacor, Heartmate III, these things are in a different class.
- iancmceachern 2y agoThe human heart is magical. They've been aiming higher since the 60s and this device is also aiming higher, but this is the stepping stone to that.
- enthulhusiastic 2y agoBecause our bodies are already peak technology. I think the 6-million-dollar man thing is a weird goal. Better to regrow, implant, perhaps supplement. Full-on replacement isn’t just a “when” but a “why” and a “how do you expect to do better than evolution”. Titanium is cool! That doesn’t make it better than muscle. Go for a run if you want a better heart
- enthulhusiastic 2y ago[flagged]
- dylan604 2y agoYou can do plenty of other things good for your heart that is much less damaging to the rest of the body. Running is horrible for joints. Just walking at a brisk pace will get the heart pumping. If we want people to get more active, there are much better things to suggest that go for a run. I ran long distance all through school, and refuse to run for running's sake. Playing soccer is the only running I will do, but at least there's a purpose. Walking, swimming, riding a bike, spin class, whatever are much easier suggestions for couch potatoes to start with
- kiba 2y agoRunnng being bad for your joint is apparently a myth.[1] 1. https://longevity.stanford.edu/lifestyle/2023/08/29/is-running-bad-for-your-knees-research-says-no/ https://longevity.stanford.edu/lifestyle/2023/08/29/is-runni...
- bawolff 2y agoYou first must crawl before you can run.
- fuzzfactor 2y agoListen to what Dr. Cohn says in the clip: https://abc13.com/post/artificial-heart-procedure-performed-houston-offering-new-hope/15100602/ https://abc13.com/post/artificial-heart-procedure-performed-... >Why are we not aiming higher? The final trajectory is not fully known but it looks like they have been preparing for a moon shot from the beginning anyway. You've got to get there from here. The higher the integrity, the more you under-promise and over-deliver :) not my downvote btw, corrective upvote to compensate
- _qua 2y agoThat white hose you see coming off the back of it is the drive line which passes out the chest and connects to an external battery. It's not a normal life with one of these in place, a heart transplant would be vastly preferable.
- billfruit 2y agoIs it not possible to avoid the cable passing through the chest, by using induction to pass currents between circuits inside and outside the body?
- nickburns 2y agodupe: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41086952 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41086952
- dang 2y agoLooks like that one was posted later* so we'll merge that thread hither. Thanks! * (you can tell from the item IDs)
- nickburns 2y agoah. was confused by the timestamping on my end (i.e. 41080654 shows just '2 hours ago' and 41086952 shows '7 hours ago'). must be some other inner-workings. but thanks for pointing out IDs to me for future reference.
- dang 2y agoThat's an artifact of HN's re-upping system. The system is described at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26998308 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26998308 and links back from there. About the timestamps, there are past explanations here: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=by%3Adang%20timestamps%20re-up&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que.... I hope that will make sense!
- ajb 2y agoWonder how the join the arteries to it. Any pressure seems likely to kill biological tissue, and while it might grow on, presumably that would take a while. Maybe some kind of glue?
- iancmceachern 2y agoThey have what they call sewing cuffs attached to short arterial and venous grafts which you can get already for surgical repair of blood vessels. The sewing cuffs are essentially little cuffs made from polyester velour and silicone and then the surgeon sews through the flanges on the cuffs to anastomose to the blood vessels. Here is a paper that talks about it for LVADs, which are similar but different https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10047-022-01350-3 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10047-022-01350-3
- floam 2y agoThe BiVACOR titanium artificial heart is sutured to the arteries, not glued. Surgeons use biocompatible synthetic graft materials (like Dacron or ePTFE) to connect the arteries to the device.
- iancmceachern 2y agoSometimes they use bioglue to cover up mistakes in their sewing, they're not supposed to, and you certainly can't do things like put bioglue all around the circumference, but my understanding is that it's used for touch up here and there.
- floam 2y agoThat’s interesting, thank you for the gentle correction and illuminating that caveat. I just shouldn’t make assertions about topics I have no background with when I know I just read about this on Google Scholar right before commenting. I’m basically confidently faking it like ChatGPT. “ah they stitch it to this neat synthetic graft stuff therefore glue couldn’t/wouldn’t be used”: wrong.
- perihelions 2y ago- "...active control system..." https://spectrum.ieee.org/this-maglev-heart-could-keep-cardiac-patients-alive https://spectrum.ieee.org/this-maglev-heart-could-keep-cardi... That's some high-stakes software programming! Passively-stable magnetic levitation is possible with diamagnetic materials (notably including superconductors), but those probably don't meet the requirements of this project. - "This positional control system works as follows: Tiny contactless sensors send out magnetic fields that interact with the rotor, determining its exact location many times per second. If the rotor is moving in one direction or another, the control system puts electrical energy into electromagnetic coils within several actuators, causing them to cancel out that movement."
- elromulous 2y agoYes, but not as high-stakes as an autopilot in a commercial aircraft!
- argiopetech 2y agoPerhaps, but there are a pilot and first officer to take over if the autopilot goes out. You better be in the OR if your titanium heart tries to kill you...
- iancmceachern 2y agoExactly. And systems for commercial aircraft are actually designed (by law) to be dual fault tolerant. This means that all safety critical systems on an airliner need to have 3 filly redundant, independent systems and each needs to be able to function without the other two. In even class III (implantable and safety critical meaning the patient is harmed or killed if they fail) medical devices are only required to be single fault tolerant.
- shiroiushi 2y ago>And systems for commercial aircraft are actually designed (by law) to be dual fault tolerant. Not true. Proof: Boeing 737MAX MCAS system, which relies on only one sensor, and when that sensor ices up, causes the aircraft to fly into the ground, killing many hundreds of people in two separate incidents. This design was fully approved by the FAA.
- yumraj 2y agoThis gives a new meaning to heavy heart
- low_tech_punk 2y agoIt's cool and spooky that the patient will no longer have heart beat, because the rotor will deliver continuous blood flow.
- JoshTriplett 2y agoI've read a number of reports about that. Apparently it's a little unnerving at first, but the biggest problem is that they have to make sure that any medical professionals or people they know are aware that they don't have a heartbeat and that's expected and does not mean they need CPR. Also, there's a long-term question of whether there are any processes within the body are keyed off of the heartbeat, because biological designs are often spaghetti and take full advantage of any random interaction and make it load-bearing.
- LelouBil 2y agoThe workings of our bodies are just the xkcd "holding spacebar makes the computer overheat" on a giant scale.
- mystified5016 2y agoThe regulation of any individual process in the body is a rube goldbergian nightmare of hormones and neurotransmitters and things that just happen to fire under the right conditions. I have absolutely no doubt that something in the body relies on a periodic heartbeat in some fashion, but it seems so far to not be anything particularly critical.
- aussieguy1234 2y agoIf you live long enough, everyone's heart will give out eventually. With a sufficiently advanced artificial one, maybe not?
- kaba0 2y agoThe heart is not necessarily the first organ to give out, the blood vessels themselves, non-dividing cells getting filled up with “junk” that won’t get cleaned up, all the space between cells do also to a degree. There never was evolutionary pressure to fix these issues (and there is none today either - people have children before 40, where these types of “faults” are not common yet).
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoThis video helped me understand what's going on: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HAajHSmplpA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HAajHSmplpA
- MOARDONGZPLZ 2y agoReally disappointed comments are turned off on this video.
- donaldcuckman 2y agoSo this is actually something I've worked on for 3ish years. Not this project but a similar BiVAD. Pictured is a dual centrifugal pump. The actual impeller is probably 20mm in diameter. The maglev/ pump portion is most likely a slice motor topology. Which is passively stable axially.
- _qua 2y agoThis is not the first cardiac support device using maglev technology. Some LVAD devices and Impella pumps also use maglev.
- ranger_danger 2y agoZip-ties: FDA certified to keep your heart running smoothly. /s
- fuzzfactor 2y agoAnd the arteries of your circulatory system well organized as you bundle your ethernet wires :)
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 2y agoGenuinely glad we're slowly approaching Syndicate-level body mods, this can't come soon enough.
- bumbledraven 2y agohttps://bivacor.com/ https://bivacor.com/
- userbinator 2y agoMaybe this is the first time this technology has been used in an artificial heart, but "maglev" pumps are not new --- they've been around for at least a few decades. It's known as "wet rotor bearingless" in existing literature, and they are found in numerous white goods such as dishwashers, washing machines, HVAC systems, as well as aquariums and computer water cooling. Usually the drive electronics are the failure point. Here's an article from 2002 about this type of pump: http://www.mech.ibaraki.ac.jp/~ismb8/pocpdf/0001.pdf http://www.mech.ibaraki.ac.jp/~ismb8/pocpdf/0001.pdf
- markovs_gun 2y agoYeah the novel part of this is the use of this technology in an artificial heart. We use these in the chemical industry for really harsh services such as a chemical that will destroy any uncoated metal or traditional pump seal.
- donaldcuckman 2y ago[dead]
- vjk800 2y agoDoes this heart speed up/slow down as the demand for blood in the body changes (like heart rate goes up or down)? If not, will people just pass out if they exert themselves more than the blood flow from the artificial heart can support?
- Daub 2y agoFrom the article it looks like it does not. Indeed it is hard to imagine a mechanism that could safely accommodate such a feature. maybe an external control knob?
- HPsquared 2y agoOxygen saturation sensor?
- sharpshadow 2y agoOne lung could be replaced with an artificial one which would work together with the artificial heart to regulate oxygen autonomously. The artificial lung could have an oxygen storage so one could hold the breath for hours. One step closer to cyborgs.
- jakobson14 2y agoCongratulations on supplementing one impossible thing we can't do yet with three more. There are very good reasons these artificial hearts are strictly temporary while waiting for a donor.
- eleveriven 2y agoThe bravery of the patient and their family! It contributes significantly to medical advancements.
- rbanffy 2y agoIt must be an interesting sensation to be alive with no pulse. When I am in complete silence, I can hear the blood coming in waves through my inner ear. With a heart like this, that sensation would be gone, as blood would be continuously pumped.
- swiftcoder 2y agoCyborgs really hitting the mainstream these days
- swiftcoder 2y agothis was not intended as a dig - the gradual progression towards "cyborg" via artificial spare parts minor and major is amazing to watch. From ceramic teeth to titanium hips... to entire hearts
- drakonka 2y ago> That being said, the titanium heart is only meant to keep a patient alive while they wait for a heart transplant, which has always been the goal of fully mechanical heart development at this stage of the game. Why is this? What are the downsides of just keeping this artificial heart forever? Do the components somehow wear out so fast that it makes more sense to have another surgery with a real heart, or is it something with the recharge requirements, or something else?
- Filligree 2y agoFor one thing there’s no pulse. The human body is very much designed assuming one.
- drakonka 2y agoI hadn't considered that. What are some practical implications for living without a pulse?
- gosub100 2y agohaving your feelings hurt when people use the phrase "anyone with a pulse"
- psunavy03 2y agoAt which point you say "I DON'T have a pulse and even I know X . . ."
- Filligree 2y agoIt’s hard to say for sure; we don’t have enough people doing it. But just for one… your arteries contain one-way valves and smaller pumps, to keep blood from pooling in your legs, or from failing to reach your head. These aren’t absolutely critical—children don’t die while standing on their heads—but I can’t imagine they’ll work quite as intended without pulses. You can’t just swap the main pump on a massive hydraulic system for a different design, and not expect something to go wrong.
- bayouborne 2y agore: Steady-state pumping - I wonder if we'll discover that the physiology of body has evolved to prefer (at least in the long term) pulsed blood pumping. That the change state from no velocity to high velocity has some beneficial scavenging effect on the arterial walls or something.