10 ms·
Retina MacBook Pro full of Air-style proprietary parts
- mdonahoe 14y agoI can't get too worked up by user serviceablility, or lack thereof. "My SSD died the other day. I tried to open it up and replace one of the flash chips, but they deliberately made it impossible for me to service. I had to buy an entire new drive!"
- pseudonym 14y agoThe problem is more in the "One of my ram chips went bad, so I had to replace the logic board."
- m_eiman 14y agoWell, you should have it under warranty in which case it's not your problem. And if it's not under warranty - it's time to buy a new one anyway! ;)
- jarek 14y agoNot sure why you're being downvoted since this is the exact policy Apple is instituting in this case. Sorry about that.
- kamjam 14y agoBecause it's a stupid view of the world. What if you bought a BMW and they said "sorry, if you want to replace those tyres or wiper blades then you need to bring it in to BMW, even though we don't actually make any of thee parts ourselves". (Yes, I understand these are serviceable parts, replace above with car battery if you like...)
- jarek 14y agoI'm not sure how you meant to map this onto a situation of replacing the motherboard because a RAM chip died. You don't have to replace the whole engine if your car battery dies, even in a BMW, regardless of warranty status.
- kamjam 14y agoYou don't have to replace the whole engine if your car battery dies, even in a BMW, regardless of warranty status. Yes, that was my whole point... I don't have to replace the engine because the battery isn't glued to it. So I may have to remove a few nuts and bolts and it may not be easily accessible, but they are replaceable. If someone told me that I should replace my car because the warranty had run out, and besides there is now a more powerful version out I'd probably call them mad!
- jarek 14y agoI take it you won't be buying this product then? I don't support Apple's policy in this case, but I just won't buy it so I don't really care how mad it is. m_eiman's description of Apple's policy was accurate, and I voiced my support.
- kamjam 14y agoAhh fair enough, I thought you were in support of the general principle. Agree it is Apple's policy, i presume there was meant to be a /sarc tagt in there some where :) I was considering buying it, but I am not an Apple user and would have just installed Windows on it. BUT I can't afford to pay up front for things I may or may not use either. I have refused to buy Apple for a number of years, because of things like not having a removable battery (which a lot of phones are doing now), no memory upgrade slot and biggest of all - iTunes!!!.I like carrying a spare battery cos it is not always possible to be by a plug. I like being able upgrade my storage because now 16gb isn't enough (and 32gb is much cheaper). But better to be informed about this kind of thing before purchase!
- kamjam 14y agoI'm waiting for someone in the UK to invoke the 6 year warranty rule, since obviously if the battery is glued in and the RAM soldered in it's gonna last forever right! http://blogs.thisismoney.co.uk/2010/03/tv-warranty.html http://blogs.thisismoney.co.uk/2010/03/tv-warranty.html
- Dobbs 14y agoThere is a difference between upgrading a major component like a HDD -> SSD or increasing the amount of RAM and replacing a sub-component of SSD. In addition Apple has historically charged 2-3x for things like RAM upgrades then you would get elsewhere.
- yellowbkpk 14y agoIsn't it obvious that your example is different than "My $3000 MacBook Pro's SSD died the other day. I tried to open it up and replace the SSD, but they deliberately made it impossible for me to service. I had to buy an entire new computer!" Sure, you can pull out a microscope and complain about how you can't fix your SMD components, but the vast majority of consumer (Apple, even!) laptops have previously been very easy to upgrade or repair and now that's different. SSD/hard disks have always been hard and there isn't an expectation that they are user serviceable.
- acdha 14y agoLaptops have a checkered history in this regard: the only thing which was consistently easy in Apple laptops was the memory. Drives ranged from trivial to involved depending on the model - I have the torx drivers to prove it. Except for the early WiFi era's AirPort cards, that's been it - and there's something like an order of magnitude step decrease for each one in my experience. A few people upgrade RAM and even fewer change the drive; everyone appreciates better battery life and lighter systems.
- X-Istence 14y agoThe SSD is a separate part that can be removed. In the future (within a year, before then Applecare will take care of defects) I am expecting manufacturers to have third-party SSD's available that will work in the new MacBook Pro's.
- tbeseda 14y agoCorrect. It seems faulty RAM will be the real trouble beyond that first year, as it's soldered to the board.
- generalk 14y agoI'd be annoyed if my HD or RAM started showing signs of failure and I had to take it into a service center and have it mailed to a facility somewhere to fix it.
- raja 14y agoHow many upgrades does average consumer make on their MacBook Pro? I'd argue it's ~0.
- learc83 14y agoRAM upgrades are fairly common. Most of my friends, even the non-technical ones, have upgraded the RAM in their macbook pros. When I worked at Geeksquad we used to get people in all the time for RAM upgrades ($29 labor charge). I'm still using an early 2008 macbook pro thanks to a cheap RAM upgrade. Additionally there is a huge secondary market for macbook pros. Plenty of people help pay for their new $2k+ computer by selling their old one. That won't work if it's completely obsolete in 3 years.
- danieldk 14y agoVirtually all people I know that have MacBook Pro's upgraded the memory. Some replaced hard disks by SSDs. Upgrading memory is especially attractive, since it's so much cheaper to buy it practically anywhere else then Apple.
- gamache 14y agoI know lots of folks who've added RAM and who've swapped out the spinning drive for an SSD. Maybe it's more of a "power user" thing, but here you are on Hacker News.
- kamjam 14y agoThis. And all the other same replies below. My manager just "upgraded" his old Mac by installing an SSD and gave it to his wife to use. Said it prolonged the life for another few years. I just upgraded RAM and HDD -> SSD on a friends computer. He had no clue what I was doing, but his computer ran "better than new". All he does it surf the web, use Outlook for email, write Word/Excel docs. Extended life for another few years for him. He certainly doesn't need a new computer (which is was about to go buy). If users themselves can't or don't know how to upgrade, they may well know someone who can. Or some small local indie shop who has the skills.
- jamesu 14y ago
- jwallaceparker 14y agoThis is going to be a trend with Apple. They have a good thing going with the iPhone and iPad devices which are both non-upgradeable: consumers are compelled to buy a new device every couple of years or so. It's pretty clear they're getting rid of the Mac Pro, which is highly configurable (with memory, storage and graphics cards) and thus has a much longer life span. So is Apple aiming for a future where you have to buy a new laptop every 2 years to have a machine that is relevant?
- udp 14y agoI thought they confirmed there's going to be a new Mac Pro next year?
- dpearson 14y agoThere will be, but, even if there wasn't, a Hackintosh might be an option for a professional-grade desktop.
- hexagonal 14y agoYour answer to "Apple doesn't make a decent desktop computer" is "hack OS X's DRM to install it on unlocked hardware"?
- kemiller 14y agoThere is no DRM on OS X. The only issue with Hackintoshes is drivers and hardware support.
- hexagonal 14y agohttps://www.pcworld.com/article/182218/apple_wins_court_victory_over_mac_clone_maker_psystar.html https://www.pcworld.com/article/182218/apple_wins_court_vict... A federal judge has dealt a crushing blow to Mac clone maker Psystar by ruling that the Florida company violated Apple's copyright as well as the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) when it installed Apple's operating system on Intel-based computers.
- hexagonal 14y agoBlogspam. Article is just a summary of http://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/MacBook-Pro-with-Retina-Display-Teardown/9462 http://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/MacBook-Pro-with-Retina-Displ...
- jQueryIsAwesome 14y agoBut maybe the blogspam had a stronger server; the link being used now (the same you provided) is down and Google Cache doesn't seem to have it. Link to blogspam: http://arstechnica.com/apple/2012/06/retina-macbook-pro-full-of-air-style-proprietary-parts/ http://arstechnica.com/apple/2012/06/retina-macbook-pro-full...
- sitharus 14y agoWhat do they mean 'virtually non-upgradable'? It's actually non-upgradable! Annoying that I can't upgrade the RAM though, that's the only part I've changed in recent years - because it's so much cheaper DIY.
- llgrrl_ 14y agoBecause it is upgradable. You just have to have the expertise to do it. Soldering a SMD component, while not exactly something that everyone can do, is indeed doable. Disclaimer: I can solder some SMD chips...
- reeses 14y agoOWC has SSD upgrades for the 2011 MBAs (I bought one the day before the announcement–I should have waited until suddenly it became an obsolescent part) and I suspect they will develop the same for the new flat flash sticks. They also have a USB/fw/esata carrier for the old drive. It's all memory anyway. Registers, cpu cache, ram, "hard" drive, etc. I'm happy any time more memory gets closer to the CPU.
- brk 14y agoPersonally I don't really care. I recognize this going in, and I recognize that there are many many other hardware options if I want to unscrew my laptop and dork about with the internals. For me, I travel around a lot. Physical durability and integrity of the hardware, in the smallest possible form factor, is important to me. You don't often get expansion/flexibility to go along with svelte and rugged. I'm sure it's only a matter of time before laptops become one giant COB (chip-on-board) manufacturing process where the whole "laptop" is a 10mmx10mmx1mm chip glued to the back of an LCD panel with some battery wrapped around it. And I'll buy one.
- jammmuel 14y agoI believe what you've just described is an iPad
- jmillikin 14y agoTen years ago, a computer's useful lifetime was measured in months. Hardware specs were advancing so quickly that a two-year-old computer might not be capable of running newly-released software. RAM, disk, and even CPU upgrades were necessary to keep up to date. Except for gamers, this is no longer true. Computers without user-replaceable parts are a natural outcome of the fact that users no longer need to replace parts. Serviceability wasn't a goal, it was a workaround.
- phn 14y agoCan't this be seen the other way around? If a computer can last long, it is very useful to repair it / replace broker parts. If technology advances in such a way that new software needs a new computer, then it makes sense to buy a new computer instead of repairing the old one. Unless by serviceability you mean being able to upgrade your computer. Either way, I can see the benefits of trading that ability for a powerful but light/small machine.
- gamache 14y agoFunny, I got ten years out of a Mac SE/30, four years out of a PowerBook G4 (Lombard), and five years out of a white iBook G4. I also used a Mac IIcx for almost a year, ten years after its release. My unibody MacBook 13" was on track too, until I beered it. I do not agree.
- harpastum 14y agoI guess the question then is how many parts did you have to replace for each of those computers? Did repairs/upgradeability factor into the long lifetimes?
- gamache 14y agoUpgrades: The SE/30 started its life as an SE, so it got the 68030+SuperDrive upgrade, and we put a monitor card in the expansion slot (which I later replaced with a 10BaseT card). Upped the RAM from 1MB to an intimidating 8MB. I think I stuck some RAM in the Lombard and the iBook too. Repairs: invoked AppleCare once, two years in, when my iBook took a nasty fall off a table. Apple makes sealed machines with bizarro, non-standard components inside, but by no means are they treated as disposable.
- cobralibre 14y agoIn terms of aesthetics, form, weight, efficiency, and so on, there are obviously huge benefits to building computers that are not upgradeable or user-serviceable. It's important to remember, though, that serviceability/upgradeability is not just a matter of satisfying the urge to tinker. Serviceability makes it much more likely that old hardware can be reused and repurposed for years beyond its putative obsolescence date. I'd hate to think that a computer only has a few years of useful life before it's garbage.
- netrus 14y agoHas the problem with the high defect rate of SSDs been resolved? Not to long ago, I remember reading of many defects after about 1 year of usage. A SSD defect would now effectively brick the whole MacBook Pro.
- acdha 14y agoIt never existed for the Apple branded SSDs - the people who reported that were people who bought the cheapest SSDs and used them with non-SSD-aware filesystems which overwrote the same blocks repeatedly. SSDs with smarter controllers and filesystems which don't abuse the disk make a huge difference. Apple controls all of these so they should have a much better idea of the reliability factor - and even if you pay for repairs, there's a high risk that an early failure will make you less likely to buy from them next time.
- muraiki 14y agoThe "talking computer" text on their server load error page put a smile on my face. I love it.
- api 14y agoThe Retina MBP seems more like the "Macbook Air Pro." (Which is cool...)
- michaelcampbell 14y agoAnyone who's been around long enough or has read Jobs' biography has known this to be the modus operandi (and/or "vision") of Apple since, well, Apple was founded. One of the first real company disagreements between Woz and Jobs was the inclusion of expansion slots in the II. They WANT it not to be serviceable; they always have.