26 ms·
Rockstar condemns Max Payne 3 cheaters to play only against each other
- fxm4139 14y agoWait, why do some of these "cheat" mode exist in production games? Isn't that the problem to begin with? Why does omething like "invincibility" exist in the game? Am I missing something here, or is this a noob question from a non-gamer?
- tlrobinson 14y agoThey aren't deliberate "cheat modes", they're hacks. Certain types of hacks are extremely difficult to prevent or even detect. There was an article on HN a few months ago (can't find it right now) that discussed hooking into the GPU to avoid detection.
- tseabrooks 14y agoMaybe this could apply to people hell banned from communities. Instead of a regular hellban, have a hellban community... Let all of the rolls play together.
- jiggy2011 14y agoI think that exists and it's called 4chan.
- lmm 14y agoInterestingly for certain topics there are banned users who join in by ghostposting in the archive (i.e. posting just to the archive, not to the actual thread - the archive is an independent site, so it doesn't matter if you're banned from 4chan proper) for those threads (the archive updates in realtime, so you can read threads there as they happen).
- MartinCron 14y agoI read about this when I first heard of hellbanning: http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/2011/06/suspension-ban-or-hellban.html http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/2011/06/suspension-ban-or-h... (There is one additional form of hellbanning that I feel compelled to mention because it is particularly cruel – when hellbanned users can see only themselves and other hellbanned users. Brrr. I'm pretty sure Dante wrote a chapter about that, somewhere.)
- jiggy2011 14y agoI have HN set to show me comments from hellbanned users. A lot of them are just trolls/spammers , however there are a number that I feel sorry for because they post relevant and sometimes long comments on threads and I imagine that they wonder why they are not getting any votes or replies. I think it's easy to get off to a bad start on an online community simply because you don't understand it's ethos rather than outright malice.
- disgruntledphd2 14y agoSo do I. I tend to upvote the sensible (i.e. not crazy) ones, in the hopes that someday they'll make it back to positive karma.
- ramidarigaz 14y agoI don't think the votes actually go through on hellbanned users unfortunately.
- hef19898 14y agoHellbanned? what does that actually mean? Seems i missed a lot online since around the early 2000s...
- neutronicus 14y agoYour account appears, to you, to function normally, but your posts are not visible to any other users. The rationale is that trolls and spammers will usually register new accounts upon being notified of a ban, but a hellbanned troll/spammer might continue to use the hellbanned account without realizing that their posts are ignored.
- WiseWeasel 14y agoI like it. There may even be practical ways for the antisocials to eventually meta-moderate each-other out from under the bridge. To be studied.
- henrikeh 14y agoFacepunch, the forum mainly connected to the sandbox game Garry's mod, has had this for a long time. If you broke a rule you were banned to "Refugee Camp" for some amount of time. Only you, the moderators and gold users (paying or 5+ years and no permaban) can see your posts in the Refugee Camp. Mostly people complained and tried to reduce or revoke the ban, but occasionally it let to rather creative or crazy time-wasting.
- SimHacker 14y agoBack in the ARPANET days, the convention was that if you wanted to be removed from a mailing list info-foo@mit-mc, you sent email to info-foo-REQUEST@mit-mc to contact the maintainer of the mailing list, instead of broadcasting a "please remove me" message to the entire mailing list. Of course there were people who didn't know the convention, and would violate this rule of netiquette. So a mischievous hacker who got sick of all the people asking "please remove me" set up a special mailing list called "please-remove-me@mit-mc" just for them, to which he subscribed people who didn't know the convention, so they could all talk to each other about how to remove themselves from mailing lists.
- anonymousab 14y agoAs long as they don't have the false and shocking "we NEVER make mistakes!" attitude towards their ban software that companies like EA, Valve and Bungie had, then that's neat.
- landr0id 14y agoBungie I don't think ever really did make mistakes though, mainly because their bans were based off of the number of times and frequency at which a player would betray teammates and get ejected from games/back out of games early to avoid a loss. I agree though, that mentality isn't really needed.
- CrazedGeek 14y agoThis is effectively what a VAC ban does, isn't it? I can't imagine why else you'd play on a non-VAC-secured server. (for reference: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Valve_Anti-Cheat http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Valve_Anti-Cheat)
- ConstantineXVI 14y agoClose. It's not clear if cheaters are actually informed they've been sent into no-man's-land.
- petitmiam 14y agoCS servers running third party anti-cheat software are non-VAC-secured.
- txo 14y agoSounds like CS 1.3 to me. Their so-called "hackers arms race" is what got me into coding in the first place.
- jiggy2011 14y agoWhich side were you on?
- txo 14y agoHaha, I played with the cheaters.. But only with other cheaters. There was a small subset of cs1.3 cheaters who played competitively vs eachother. The original OGC hook was released as source and gave me my intro to compiling editing and debugging, along with some help from unknowncheats.com at the time
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jkeel 14y agoI agree with the author that the cheater's pool would be cool to keep. I could imagine having two accounts - one account for regular play and one account for cheating to see who can do the best hacks. The author is probably right that it would just turn into a complete mess though.
- unwind 14y agoThe article just glosses over the fact that detecting cheaters is far from easy. It just makes it sound as if it's a done-deal, "if you cheat, you're isolated away". Speaking with at least some amount of insight, I can say that cheat-detection in modern networked multiplayer action games is far from easy.
- pestaa 14y agoThe first thing I remember from a multiplayer networking tutorial is that it is close to impossible to distinguish cheaters from really good players.
- Cushman 14y agoIt's a bit more complex than that, I think. It's easy to distinguish careless cheaters from good players. It's hard to distinguish conservative cheaters from good players. It's also hard to distinguish good, nonconservative cheaters from really exceptional players. But really, it doesn't matter. You can winnow out the obvious game-breaking things like wallhacking and instant-headshotting, but to the average player it doesn't make a difference whether the person who keeps killing them is a phenomenal player or just a skilled cheater; it's not fun either way. A solution to one is a solution to both: Your game needs to be designed such that it maintains balance and remains fun when some players are performing much better than others, for whatever reason.
- jamesaguilar 14y ago> It's hard to distinguish conservative cheaters from good players. True, but getting the flagrant ones is usually enough so that in any given game the average player does not have to deal with cheating.
- daenz 14y agoThere's a fantastic intro to modern game cheating and cheat detection here, for anyone interested: http://www.altdevblogaday.com/2012/04/02/extravagant-cheating-via-direct-x/ http://www.altdevblogaday.com/2012/04/02/extravagant-cheatin...
- jiggy2011 14y agoI remember the old days of Counterstrike and the infamous "myg0t" clan who would enter CS servers and use things like wallhacks and aimbots as well as excessive deliberate teamkilling. After they had got themselves banned from just about every server out there they launched their own "anything goes" server which could be actually be a fun experience to play on. Another interesting thing I remember from the CS days was that me and my friends used to play the game a lot which meant that we were much more skilled than the average player. The result of this was that admins would often accuse us of cheating (we weren't) simply because our kill/death ratio was so much better than anybody elses (I used to have screenshots of myself with 40/2 kill/death ratio on public servers using pistols only). Of course this made us pissed at the time since we kept getting banned from servers, but now I think about it where they so unjustified in doing this? Having a massive advantage over the average player whether it comes from skills or cheats still has the same affect of reducing the enjoyment of the game for average players & newbies. It's almost like having an olympic athletic squad turn up to the local school sports day and dominate every trophy. Since I don't have as much time or interest in games as I used to when I was a teenager I tend to avoid online play in many games because the experience is generally just getting curb stomped over and over again by more experienced/obsessive players and sometimes in team based RTS games I get kicked from a team because "I don't team with noobs". Another thing I don't understand about this is how invincibility cheats would work, I can understand things like aimbots / wallhacks because they are using information that has been pushed to the client but surely the game server should never allow something like the number of health points to be authoritative on the client end?
- libria 14y agoAnother advantage of "keeping them alive" is watching what they exploit so they know where to harden, sort of like a free pwnium contest. And after the dust settles, they may have a few interview candidates.
- horsehead 14y agoA Max Payne parallel universe!! I would make myself into a zombie character. With super fast running and the ability to bite people. in any case, it sounds like this could actually be a little more fun. I give it a 50/50 chance of working how they anticipate.
- citricsquid 14y agoThe reddit thread about this had some interesting discussion and excellent point: This is about cheaters that cheat their saves by giving themselves items that they haven't yet unlocked (or bought). It's punishing those that don't care for earning items or buying them. Source: http://www.reddit.com/r/Games/comments/uyk1v/rockstar_targets_max_payne_3_multiplayer_cheaters/c4zpw2k http://www.reddit.com/r/Games/comments/uyk1v/rockstar_target...
- noduerme 14y agoKick-ass solution. Our Bitcoin casino had more than its share of people crossing IP addresses over time and/or playing poker oddly. It's hard to prove anything and, especially when it relates to real-money poker, volumes have been written by players online claiming innocence and scouring the TOS for loopholes. My solution? I created poker rooms specifically for people who've shared IPs, and blocked them from entering other rooms at the same time as their friends. Result: Friends stop showing up and tilting general games, and a small friendly community develops in the "anything goes" room. Now if only the government took that view of people who play poker...but "play at your own risk" seems to be a concept western society lost around the time our governments got in the business of protecting people from themselves and every experience not mediated was considered dangerous...
- eupharis 14y agoAn elegant solution. Sorta like the idea that there should be two leagues for the Olympics, the Tour de France, et al.: one with steroids, one without. It would be interesting to see which got more viewers.
- walexander 14y ago> we're a bit intrigued by the potential for the "Cheaters Pool" to evolve into a new mode of play that some players might actually prefer. Unregulated cheats and hacks led a friend and I to inadvertently invent a proto-minecraft over a decade ago. Around 1998, I was playing Dark Forces 2: Jedi Knight when I started to experience cheats and hacks. Someone taught me how to do it, which was incredibly easy (each weapon file was a text file with variables you could change: projectile=bullet, damage=5, speed=3). Simply replacing the file client side would change the behavior. When playing around with the projectile=[id] with some ids I found while map making, a friend and I discovered we could modify all of our weapons to shoot out various world objects such as bridges, platforms, doors, etc. We started playing the game almost exclusively this way for quite awhile, going off to separate corners of a map, building things, then comparing our structures. So, I have to say, great idea on the quarantine, Rockstar!
- nohat 14y agoI made blaster rifles that shot destructions, but never realized you could shoot map features. That sounds like the potential for interesting fps: remake the map as you go.
- younata 14y agoThere's a TF2 mod that is kinda like that. You start the game, and have 2 minutes to create defenses. After that, it's a normal game of CTF. I forget what it's called though.
- visionpol 14y agoThe game mode is called Fort Wars. Source: http://wiki.teamfortress.com/wiki/FortWars http://wiki.teamfortress.com/wiki/FortWars
- stcredzero 14y agoSomeone should do a mod of that, based on characters from the old A-Team TV show, complete with the original theme music. The "build defenses" interval would be like the build weapons montage. http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Series/TheATeam?from=Main.TheATeam http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Series/TheATeam?from=M...
- ChuckMcM 14y agoI've always wondered if we had an Olympics type sporting event where 'anything goes' would be sport worth watching. My experience has been in two online games, one an Aces game where you flew against WWII planes and cheaters would make their planes make impossible turns or suddenly have 3000' of altitude etc. Made it unplayable. And in World of Warcraft where a sort of soft-core cheating or 'twinking' was making player vs player for non-twinks seriously non-fun, they added a 'twinks' mode where twinks had to play only other twinks. (this was done with a combination of things but it worked.) I enjoy playing games on 'god' mode some times, and its hilariously fun with friends, and have many fond memories of running a Unreal Tournament (UT) server with some really crazy environments. So I expect there is a market there. Very happy to see Rockstar being creative here.
- literalusername 14y agoI'd love to see sports leagues that allow not just performance-enhancing drugs, but also prosthetic enhancements of any kind. The athlete of tomorrow is a cyborg. Such a league would appear unplayable or non-fun to those players who abide by the traditional rule-set. So it's important to segregate players by skill-range. I wouldn't have much fun trying to play football against cyborgs, but I'd love to watch them compete against each other. Pro sports leagues are run by technophobes who don't even want to run lasers down the field to augment the referees' abilities, so we won't see cyborg sports any time soon. But online games are hardly run by technophobes, so we ought to see more and more of this insightful approach. All games should accept that players choose their own level of rule conformance. Place players in competitions based on their skill level, and and the games will be playable and fun for everyone.
- simba-hiiipower 14y agohonestly don't have much value to add here (not really much of a gamer) and from reading other comments, clearly there are some points of contention around the issue, but my takeaway from the post.. that sounds awesome. again, not a big gamer here, but i think that sounds like a totally reasonable way for the studio to minimize the negative impact of cheating on the majority of players who don’t, and while keeping those who do cheat (i’m assuming all of whom would have to be super-hardcore gamers/fans) engaged with the game and loyal to the brand (rather than being kicked-off outright). also, and more importantly, i’m just imagining how cool it would be, and what a rush one would get, in having to compete with other like-minded hackers in a never-ending arms race to dominate in a (game) world of cheaters!
- icebraining 14y agoIn my experience playing FPSs online (mostly Call of Duty 1/2/4), those assumptions are not quite true. For one, plenty of cheaters are not really very good players; they're not complete noobs, but they're often average players or below. Some are, but I don't think it's correlated with it. And for many, having to compete with other cheaters would be boring and annoying, since for them the main satisfaction is 1) making ridiculously large scores compared to others and 2) watching others complain and leave. An indication that this wouldn't be attractive to them is the fact that there are many Punkbuster¹-free servers out there, yet cheaters still spend time looking for cheats that can evade it. ¹ Anti-cheating system.
- cpeterso 14y agoAre the cheaters informed when they are sent to the "Cheaters Pool" penalty box?
- sturmeh 14y agoHopefully not, that would allow them to flag detectable hacks and buy new accounts to continue cheating with new tools.
- hcurtiss 14y agoIt's an elegant solution. In 1998, as a freshman in college, we kicked a lot of ass on Tribes. By my sophomore year, the hacks had completely ruined the game. Frankly, it inspired one of my teammates to go into CS so that he could "hack back."
- alf 14y agoAre you referring to skiing? Tribes is an interesting example of a "hack" that completely re-invents the game (in most people's opinions, for the better). For those not familiar, a bit of gaming history: Tribes is a FPS where the players have jetpacks and can fly around in the air. The jetpacks have limited energy, so players ended up having to spend a lot of time on the ground too. One particularly innovative aspects of Tribes was it's expansive maps. It was like a Battlefield game, but 5 years earlier. By only running and jetting, it could take minutes to get across a map, which is important considering the primary objective of the game was to move the opposing team's flag from side of the map to your team's side. The hack was: players discovered that jumping at the instant the player lands on downhill surface caused them to accelerate in the downhill direction. Mashing repeatedly on the jump key going down a large hill would cause the player to accelerate all the way down the hill, as if there was no friction with the ground (hence "skiing"). Someone wrote a script that automated this act so all a player had to do was hold down the jump button instead of pressing it repeatedly. This bug completely re-invented the game into something no one imagined it would be. Many players embraced it, I am sure some did not. It added a layer of complexity and made the game addictively fast paced (with skill you could now get across a map in seconds). The competitive community embraced the new style of play and the developers had no choice but to not patch the bug. This bug arguably became the defining gameplay aspect of Tribes. The lesson? As mentioned here many times, the users are what make your product special. Sometimes they will invent uses for it you never imagined :)
- hcurtiss 14y agoNo, skiing was awesome, and we were, frankly, some of the pioneers (it only worked on some keyboards, I had to buy a new one). I'm talking about the aiming scripts and when guys started walking through walls. Most of the base servers were later patched, but for a while they were hard to find.
- andygcook 14y agoKind of like the XFL for video games.
- barbs 14y agoKind of reminds me of skiing in tribes. Although not necessarily a hack, it was a glitch that was heavily exploited, and now it's an integral part of the gameplay, and a large part of what made it great. Giving people the freedom to be creative with the gameplay mechanics can lead to great things. Other examples would be DotA and CS.
- stcredzero 14y agoIf Rockstar is doing this right, then they will separate cheat detection from cheat consequence by 24 hours or more, and make this interval random. Why? Because to a cheat hacker, detection is a bug, and delaying the consequence of cheat detection by a random amount makes it a hard to recreate, latent bug. It inflates the difficulty of "debugging" from the cheater's POV.
- alextp 14y agoI wonder if cheating could be entirely solved with machine learning like TrueSkill that matches you with people with similar performance. Then matching cheaters with cheaters is almost guaranteed to happen, and a bad player cheating a little can still be a good adversary.
- i386 14y ago> It's as if Major League Baseball suddenly opened up a second, parallel league that allows players to use performance-enhancing drugs and teams to use an ultra-precise pitching machine that throws nothing but 120mph fastballs to the corners of the plate. The games might end up as an unwatchable mess, but they'd likely attract plenty of fans and players who want to see just how far the "baseball" experience can go. Sounds like a blurb to an awesome dystopian libertarian science fiction novel.
- angrytapir 14y agoI'm pretty sure there's something similar mentioned in one of the Red Dwarf novels (with the experience ending in the use of genetically engineered players).
- dimitar 14y agoIts seems exactly like prison. You have jails to separate criminals from the general population. However people who go to jail tend to come out more dangerous and knowledgeable than before.
- theDaveB 14y agoIf anyone wants to experience hacks and mods and have a Xbox, just try Call of duty 4 or 5 (world at war). The developers kind of abandon the older games once the new ones are out, so the modders move in. Dave