3 ms·
Great post. One thing I found interesting about this piece was the blatant revisionism on display in the second paragraph of the article: "less than two years
by timr 18y ago
Great post. One thing I found interesting about this piece was the blatant revisionism on display in the second paragraph of the article:
"less than two years ago, conventional wisdom dictated that the housing bubble would be painful but that global economic growth would remain stable."
Forgive me, Mr. Writer, but my recollection is that less than two years ago, few people in the mainstream were acknowledging that a housing bubble even existed. Hell, even a year ago, half of the mainstream press was essentially reprinting press releases from hacks like Lawrence Yun (widely quoted "expert" for the National Association of Realtors), who never saw a bad housing statistic that he couldn't spin for the positive. Those who were calling a bubble a bubble early on (as early as 2003) were labeled jealous curmudgeons who missed out on the easy-money party.
I keep trying to come up with a lesson from this, but the only thing I can think of is that our society doesn't reward dissent. No matter how insane and extreme the conventional wisdom, it doesn't pay to be the guy who vocalizes against the herd. If you're a contrary thinker, it's best to just keep your head down, your mouth shut, and do whatever you were going to do anyway.
- tokenadult 18y ago"my recollection is that less than two years ago, nobody in the mainstream was acknowledging that a housing bubble even existed." My recollection is different, because I was reading Business Week more than three years ago. The housing bubble has looked like a bubble for a long time to people who considered how much faster house prices increased than wages. Michael Lewis's collection of articles, Panic, http://www.amazon.com/Panic-Story-Modern-Financial-Insanity/dp/0393065146/ http://www.amazon.com/Panic-Story-Modern-Financial-Insanity/... includes articles that foresaw the housing crash more than two years ago.
- timr 18y agoYes, there were a few people who were calling the bubble early. However, their view wasn't in the mainstream two years ago. It certainly wasn't "conventional wisdom". I have edited my post to replace the word "nobody" with "few". Mea culpa.
- fallentimes 18y agoThey focused on the exception; you focused on the rule. It's entertaining watching the tulip bulb story happen over and over again. Hopefully next time I'll have more capital to take advantage of the situation.
- davidw 18y agoThe Economist, which isn't exactly some small rural newspaper, talked about housing looking bubbly a few years ago.
- petercooper 18y agoA Google for [ "property bubble" site:news.bbc.co.uk ] will show many references to the British property bubble in the 2002-2007 timeframe. However, your last paragraph is totally on the money.
- angstrom 18y agoA bubble is indistinguishable from a pyramid scheme legally run amok for the appearance of economic growth. Which is why I don't care for the naysayers opinions because they are far less useful than knowing a few average Joes who have the curiosity of cucumbers when it comes to economics, politics, etc. Once your average Joe catches onto the long tail of the curve, you know a bubble has run its course. The next bubble will likely be the green one. It's large, necessary, and completely possible to go overboard regardless of what you'll hear every pundit saying for the next 10 years.
- daniel-cussen 18y agoIf I remember correctly, two years ago people were taking about a soft landing.
- taylan 18y agoIt has something to do with economics of punditry. Basically, for pundits incentives are against voicing dissent. If you go against the conventional wisdom and your predictions turn out to be right, you'll still have hard time getting your voice heard, since it will probably drown in a cacophony of "nobody could have seen this coming" type mainstream media flood. On the other hand, if you dissent from the crowd and turn out to be wrong, you'll be labeled a lunatic and sent to oblivion. So the punishment and the risk you're taking by far outweighs any possible rewards. Thus we get herding; pundits' predictions will always be closer to each other than they are to the real value of the thing being predicted.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoIf you watched any of the stock punditry two years ago, everybody knew there was a housing bubble. You could tell by looking at the charts. The discussion, which as I recall went on for a year, would how hard and how localized the "pop" would be. Safe money was at least betting on the market being overvalued in major cities and stayed away from REITS. It was common knowledge. That's how I remember it, anyway. You might be confusing this with the mortgage crisis, which is an entirely different (but related) matter.