2 ms·
This is a wonderful comment. However, what psychologists know as g is the result of over-interpretation of a descriptive method known as factor analysis (which
by disgruntledphd2 14y ago
This is a wonderful comment. However, what psychologists know as g is the result of over-interpretation of a descriptive method known as factor analysis (which is very similar to principal components analysis).
http://cscs.umich.edu/~crshalizi/reviews/flynn-beyond/ http://cscs.umich.edu/~crshalizi/reviews/flynn-beyond/
Major thanks to Cosmo Shalizi who opened my eyes to these issues.
Also, the SAT grew from IQ tests, so it really isn't surprising that the two measures are correlated, given that the questions for SAT were probably kept on the test because they correlated with IQ tests.
That being said, the work of Kahneman (And the new paper which I should probably read instead of commenting on HN) is pretty rock solid as far as it goes. It is worth noting that there is a converse position in this field, that of Gerd Gigerenzer who argues that these heuristics exist because they are useful, and only go wrong in artificial situations.
www.cogsci.msu.edu/DSS/2007-2008/Todd/environments_that_make_us_smart.pdf
Personally, I incline far more towards the views of Gigerenzer than those of Kahneman, especially given that Gierenzer and colleagues attempt to model the mind given their theories computationally, which is something that psychology could do with more of.
Full disclosure: I'm a psychologist who's very frustrated with the lack of statistical sophistication and interpretation in my field.