2 ms·
I'm not against rules. What irks me a bit is that they are supposed to be about bikes, but in reality they are only about bikes that look exactly like the ones
by eru 2y ago
I'm not against rules.
What irks me a bit is that they are supposed to be about bikes, but in reality they are only about bikes that look exactly like the ones they have in mind.
Eg (if I remember right) they also specify a minimum wheel radius, because at some point people started doing well with those, and the people in charge didn't like that.
And they might as well be right: they have an entertainment business to run. They don't care about finding the best or anything like that.
- angus-prune 2y agoI disagree that the sport is about bikes. I think the sport is about cyclists. The olympics is particular is built around human athletic competition not technical competition. How do you find the best cyclist if the quality of the bikes is wildly different? In any experiment, you have to control for the factors other than the ones you're looking to test. I don't think its fair to say that they don't care about finding the best, they're just trying to find the best of a different category than you're interested in. As GP said. There is also space for different competitions about technology (in motorsport, formula 1 has both a driver championship and a constructor championship which is about the technology).
- masklinn 2y ago> There is also space for different competitions about technology (in motorsport, formula 1 has both a driver championship and a constructor championship which is about the technology). And even then the technology is severely curtailed, it has to compete within a fairly restrictive design envelope.
- eru 2y ago> How do you find the best cyclist if the quality of the bikes is wildly different? In that case, you should probably give everyone the same 'official' bike.
- russfink 2y agoI agree, but sadly when officials start trusting, they stop looking, and this opens it up to more widespread cheating.
- eru 2y agoI'm not sure what you mean by that? Just produce the same identical bikes, and assign them randomly at the start of the race?
- olyjohn 2y agoEver go to a go kart track and notice that some karts are faster than others? They're all identical as far as the eye can see, but in reality tons of subtle differences pop up. You can have spec bikes, but there no way they'll all be tuned identically, all have the exact same lubrication in all the bearings, all have the exact chain tension, all have the axles torqued identically. All the derailers built exactly the same... One bike will get inevitably have an advantage over the others.
- eru 2y agoAssign the bikes randomly, and swap them around often enough between legs of the races. The Tour de France is pretty long.
- The_Colonel 2y agoThis would need to accommodate many different sizes, geometries, subjective preferences.
- eru 2y agoWhy? The whole point is to standardise, I thought? They are already _not_ accommodating preferences for eg recumbent bikes. So what measure are a few more preferences not accommodated? In any case, you can make a bunch of different official sizes.
- HPsquared 2y agoViewers are turned off if one of the competitors is seen to be winning simply due to having a better bike. The main characters in the show are the riders, not the bike builders.
- nradov 2y agoWhich viewers are those? Pro cycling fans are interested in bike manufacturers and technology, as well as in the riders. Gaining advantages through having better bikes (within reason) is a key part of the sport and part of what makes it fun to watch.
- masklinn 2y ago> I'm not against rules. Of course you are. If you’re against any rule you personally dislike or misunderstand you’re not for rules. > What irks me a bit is that they are supposed to be about bikes See that’s your problem: you completely missed what the competition was about. The competition is no more about bicycles than an archery competitions is about bows and arrows. The competition is about the athletes, the gear is only the means through which it happens. That’s why the name on the podium is that of the cyclist, not of the bike manufacturer.
- eru 2y agoJust give everyone the same official bike then. > Of course you are. If you’re against any rule you personally dislike or misunderstand you’re not for rules. Haha.