6 ms·
I appreciate the honest answer to what was a bit of a provocation. Can we assume a fraction of people would still be doing these relevant things and that it'd
by rbanffy 2y ago
I appreciate the honest answer to what was a bit of a provocation.
Can we assume a fraction of people would still be doing these relevant things and that it'd be enough to maintain a functioning society? If not, wouldn't that point towards the directions we need technology to evolve? Would paying more to the people who now don't need to work, but are willing to, suffice?
One thing I would bet on is that, in that scenario, degrading working conditions (as we frequently see in agriculture, transportation, etc) would make it harder to find people willing to subject themselves to them.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoCards on the table: I think the vast majory of people would do less, and perhaps very little socially productive work without the current financial incentives. > Would paying more to the people who now don't need to work, but are willing to, suffice? This is not possible because you cant simultaneously pay workers more (as a whole) and have them subsidize the non-working. I admit it may be possible to reallocate compensation among the workers so that some get more, while collectively they get less.
- nehal3m 2y ago> Cards on the table: I think the vast majory of people would do less, and perhaps very little socially productive work without the current financial incentives. I don't disagree, but aren't you implicitly admitting here that the vast majority of people don't want to spend their lives doing work? We get a few laps around the sun, once, before we return to oblivion. It seems a tragedy to me to force almost everyone into spending that brief spark of life on the drudgery of increasing shareholder value. If you agree, would you then also say that it would be in humanity's interest to work toward a situation where people can lead happy, fulfilling lives? I'm not saying I have any answers, but I am saying that implicit in your own assumption is a problem that needs solving.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoI agree with everything you said except the shareholder value part. people dont want to spend their lives doing work, but they do want to spend their lives consuming. If you eliminate the shareholders and shares, it still take the same amount of work to produce what we consume, so this wont help reduce work. In the 1930s, Keynes imagined that humans would live lives of leisure as productivity doubled every 20 years. However, the human hunger for material comforts is bottomless. The only offramp from work is reducing consumption or 2) freezing consumption (assuming productivity increases)
- kamarg 2y ago> it still take the same amount of work to produce what we consume Does it? Seems like if we don't have excess value going to shareholders, less work could be done to provide the current level of value for things people are consuming.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoValue isnt the same thing as labor/work. This would change where the value goes, not the amount of work done. A restaurant needs X hours of labor to make Y hamburgers. This is true if all the money goes to workers, or just a fraction of it. You could pay a worker more, but that doesn't increase the supply of hamburgers. Inversely, any value tied up in the share price is not being spent on hamburgers. The best you can hope to do is shift some consumption from investors to workers, but consumption differences are as great as wealth/value differentials. e.g. Musk & Bezos might have 1 million times as much value to their name, but they don't consume 1 million times as many hamburgers. The vast majority of excess value held by investors is not directed towards consumption.
- nehal3m 2y ago> The vast majority of excess value held by investors is not directed towards consumption. So why does it need to be created in the first place then? That takes work that apparently does not need to happen for any other reason than economic, not because it is valuable in and of itself.
- brigadier132 2y agoPeople dont want to work but they want the benefits of other peoples labor. Simultaneously they try to fight the automation that would lead to a world were humans dont need to work for things to exist
- rbanffy 2y ago> Simultaneously they try to fight the automation that would lead to a world were humans dont need to work for things to exist Because they are sure (rightfully so) the owners of said automation will not pay them enough to offset their lost jobs.
- throwaway22032 2y ago"Increasing shareholder value" is a meme. In both the US and UK over 30% of households are owned outright with no mortgage. The economy is made up of us, it's not (predominantly) a downtrodden serving a tiny elite. Most people work and do useful stuff for each other. Yes, there are bullshit jobs, but it's a huge exaggeration to pretend they all are.
- nehal3m 2y agoAlright, I'll concede the numbers, let's say some fraction of people are employed not because they see value in their work but because they're economically incentivised (in other words, to make ends meet). I'm saying that given the choice, those who are forced into spending their time in a way that is detrimental to themselves in any other term but economic would not do so, and furthermore, that humanity owes it to itself to remedy that situation in order to maximise for fulfilled lives. That is if you agree that societal progress means making people's lives better, and that spending one's time meaningfully is a good measure of better. What I'm not saying is all work is horseshit and let's all party.
- s1artibartfast 2y ago>I'm saying that given the choice, those who are forced into spending their time in a way that is detrimental to themselves in any other term but economic would not do so You cant have the fruits of labor without the labor. People make this calculus every single day, and nearly unanimously decide that it would be more detrimental to go without the fruits of labor (especially those that must be incentivized). It is obviously worth exploring how to make work less miserable, or better fit the interests of a worker, but that is a genuinely difficult matching an allocation problem. A "do what you want" policy would not result in the tasks people want done getting done. The closest equivalent to a system without transactional incentives is individual subsistence farming where one has to work for oneself so they don't die.
- laserlight 2y ago> A "do what you want" policy would not result in the tasks people want done getting done. That sounds weird to me. If people want it done, they would get it done, wouldn't they? Can you maybe expand with an example?