8 ms·
All the existential risk, none of the economic impact
- christkv 2y agoI don't think we have seen the start of productivity gains. We are using it to write drafts for public competitions. It’s turned something that would be weeks of pain into days. That means the people involved can spend less time on trite and focus on editorial. It’s also let our small team take on more parallel bids with less frustration.
- titanomachy 2y agoAnd presumably your competition is also now free to bid on more contracts, meaning each contract has many more bids, which means the client needs to use AI to read them all... prompt -> your AI blackbox -> client's AI blackbox -> client picks winner Maybe someday the client will let you submit your prompt directly to their AI blackbox so you can save computing resources.
- christkv 2y agoIf im lucky we will provide our chat bot tuned with information about our product and their bot can talk to ours and voila lol
- titanomachy 2y agoPlease submit your application in the form of an executable binary under 100GB containing an interactive agent which will convince us to give you money!
- lowbloodsugar 2y agocrowdstrike end of the world: https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/likely-apocalypse https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/likely-apocalypse
- hankman86 2y agoAre there any independent statistics for how much AI based coding assistants like GitHub CoPilot improve an average software developer‘s productivity? I had hoped for something around 5%, which is not massive, but still a non-trivial number. Not sure how AI assistants in other “high value” professions far. Say in legal, healthcare, finance, civil engineering, business consulting to name a few. Does anyone have reliable figures?
- tim333 2y agoYou've kind of got two different things: 1) Current AI, mostly LLMs, not much economic impact, no extinction risk. 2) Sci-fi like future ASI, big impact, some existential risk. Discussing the second is tricky as we don't quite know how it will go and will probably change all sorts of things. But re 'we are all going to die' type stuff, currently we will with certainty due to age, with sci-fi AI, not necessarily. So that kind of p(doom) is much lower with ASI.
- JohnMakin 2y agoThe problems with the current generation and rollout of "AI" which I am using synonymously in this post with large language models, because that's the context it seems to be mostly used in print media - are so numerous that I could not list them out all in one post and this has been debated to an absurd degree already, on this site and on other platforms. I really can't think of many, if any real positives. One example I like to use is in video game tutorial articles. I don't know if you've tried to use basically any search engine to find reliable video game information/walkthroughs lately, but the amount of blatant misinformation that has proliferated in this space makes searching the web for even the most basic information an exercise in complete futility. This is something "AI" should be good at. Video game walkthroughs have been done to death, a game that's been out for 2+ years has likely already had every single secret and path in it discovered 10,000 times over and posted all over reddit and other sites. Yet, after completing my 2nd elden ring run this weekend, my first since 2022, I was struck at how much blatantly wrong info I stumbled across, even on websites I had considered "authoritative." And it's always subtle enough to be impossibly annoying - stuff like "head south from this site" when in fact, it should have said "north" Very small errors that seem like the result of hallucinations that cause an inordinate amount of time spent figuring out what's wrong - much like my experience with coding "assistants." If it can't get something like this correct - which I'm aware isn't necessarily a purely "AI" problem - how do we expect it to do anything important? I really have not seen a solid case yet and would love to be convinced otherwise, but the more I learn the less I like what I see.
- geoffmanning 2y agoPerhaps we should question how productivity is measured and learn to control all the various factors. I think there is much more than AI at play here, and in fact i would guess that AI has been a major factor in offsetting (preventing) an overall decrease in "productivity" (as currently defined).
- hsag 2y ago[dead]
- daft_pink 2y agoI think that the AI companies will not reap all the benefit of AI like the car companies with exception of a few winners didn’t reap the rewards of vehicles. I think that average human beings will receive the benefit of AI as I am spending $20 per month, but reaping huge rewards from writing the emails and documents that I write with them.
- refactor_master 2y ago> (…) reaping huge rewards from writing the emails and documents that I write with them But are most people reaping huge rewards though? The article seems to suggest otherwise. I’m not saying it’s useless, but we forget that humanity has survived with Grammarly, or Word, or dictionaries before that. I will agree that ChatGPT strikes gold at a marginally higher rate than Google, but hardly orders of magnitude more. Both automation and documentation have existed and continue to do so in many forms.
- julienreszka 2y agoThey want to buy the dip that’s all. Anybody who actually uses the models with a good workflow ( specs=> unit tests=> function that passes ) sees the benefits
- hnthrow289570 2y agoThis makes sense to me at the moment because these AI products are enhancements, not entire replacements. But even if they were replacements, companies do not suddenly drop all of their current processes and rewrite them from scratch using new shiny tools. And most companies are too slow to do that within the 2 years that ChatGPT/Stable Diffusion have been out anyway.
- chasd00 2y agoAlso, things like LLMs are radically different than the assign, compare, iterate logic of current digital systems. LLMs are based on probabilities with no guarantee from one input/output combination to the next. It's pretty hard to model a process with an AI when there's no guarantee it will follow the process. Businesses are going to really struggle to adopt LLMs across their whole business like everyone is promising.
- incomingpain 2y agoEvery new tech breakthrough has the 'it's going to destroy us, think of all the stable boy jobs that will be lost.' Ultimately everything working out just fine. AI is not going to doom us. AI's gardening skills are so bad, even the weeds can't grow. Doomsayers can now downvote me.
- klyrs 2y ago> AI's gardening skills are so bad, even the weeds can't grow. Yeah, the future is farming and mining, because AI is trained on all the fun jobs. "Stable boy," my ass.
- mywittyname 2y agoPast performance is not guarantee future results. For example, hopefully this argument wouldn't fly with an education person, "we've been pumping CO2 into the atmosphere for like 200 years now, ultimately everything is working out just fine." It would be foolish to ignore the potential economic impacts of Gen AI. And just because we don't see the effects in the data right now, doesn't mean it won't happen.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- moandcompany 2y agoAI learned that electrolytes are what plants crave. Enough people on the internet said so.
- acuozzo 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Normalcy_bias https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Normalcy_bias
- blueyes 2y agoAnother Luddite take from someone who clearly doesn't engage the technology directly either as a builder or a seller. It takes years to decades for new technologies to achieve their full effect. Factories based on steam had to be rebuilt around eletricity. That took decades. It will take time to rebuild large operations around AI.
- te_chris 2y agoThat’s his point! And doing that invites the x-risk while also making things worse due to the stochastic nature of the models. I work in AI and I think he’s right to a degree.
- holtkam2 2y agoAgreed; as someone working on a GenAI app in a big tech company, the main lesson I've learned is the gigantic delta between the effort required to make a intriguing prototype and a true, production ready, scalable, customer-facing, useful app. The former takes a weekend or two, the ladder can take a year or two.
- jerf 2y agoI would also agree that the impact of AI, even in the best case scenario, will play out over years because it will take time to integrate even perfect AI into our processes. A world running on COBOL is not going to spin on a dime and run on AI, and I don't mean that sarcastically at all. That the world still runs on COBOL is an important data point in how quickly we can move things. In fact I consider this rather obvious and borderline self-evident to a careful thinker. However, the AI stocks are priced as if they are going to reap all the benefits, if not today, then perhaps even about a month or two ago. They are priced as if the current incumbents are the inevitable inheritors of all the promises, because the AI world is going to move so quickly to reap all this supposed value that there isn't even time for other companies to move in and displace nVidia. They are priced as if that productivity curve has already started to shoot up and it's just the beginning. If the curve isn't even budging, then the AI world is going to need to be seriously, seriously repriced. If AI is going to change the world, but in five years rather than five months, and gradually rather than all at once, then the time value of money implies that the value to be captured in today-dollars is much, much smaller. In five years, nVidia's AI may be getting stomped by a startup that hasn't even been founded yet; I'd give it low odds, but meaningfully non-zero odds. Whether I'm an "AI skeptic", I don't know. But I absolutely am an AI bubble skeptic. I haven't seen any evidence that the value creation is emerging at anything like the rate the bubble pricing implies. It'll probably arrive, but a lot more gradually than the market is currently believing.
- cbsmith 2y agoThe first comment I saw nailed it for me: in the 80's and 90's there was lots of investment in computers as the PC revolution took off, and the productivity gains were minimal. As with all new technologies, it takes a while for there to be macroeconomic scale changes to industry, and those changes aren't going to come without the up front investment. This article (and frankly, much of society) is looking at the ROI on the wrong time scale.
- levocardia 2y agoDitto for electrification of factories. It took a decade or more for productivity gains to improve.
- lesuorac 2y agoI think that's mostly people have a poor mindset. They think I have this workflow of A->B->C->D and how do I improve "B" using technology. Instead you should have something else of A->E->D where E wasn't possible or maybe just not practical. You don't want to use technology so that you can type keys faster; eliminate the typing of keys process. A lot of the current GenAI is around making images and summarizing text. Those largely aren't real business objectives. If you make a powerpoint 70% faster does that really close a sale 70% faster? I highly doubt it.
- cbsmith 2y agoA lot of the 80's adoption of the PC meant that people did the same presentations but they looked better. ;-) In fairness, it's not just mindset. It takes a while to understand technology and figuring out how it can be effectively harnessed. A->E->D isn't achieved simply by realizing you can do that. There's a whole sequence of steps to change the shape of A,E & D to make that happen. But you're right, a lot of GenAI right now is not being used for things that are real game changers. This is the first step to establishing the foundation from which the real game changers will spring.
- TylerE 2y agoPowerpoints? No. But if it gets good/easy/reliable/cheap enough I can see a lot of applications. Imagine storing incoming customer emails and being able to fish out all emails complaining about, say, slow shipping, even if they don't use that exact phrase.
- talldayo 2y ago> the longer AI takes to show up in any positive economic indicators, the more it becomes the case that AI has brought increasing existential risk in exchange for minimal upside. No? None of that is predecided. You are concluding that based on vague threats made by people who are "in the know" that can't even substantiate their own fear when confronted over it. Existential risk comes from when us, humanity, trusts our own lives in something that is faulty. The solution is to not use or design around fault-agnostic systems, not to fear scenarios where stupid people make mistakes. AI is not red mercury, it is not a magical force multiplier that terrorists use to make lunchbox nukes. I'm getting so tired of HN submissions like this that throw an alarmist opinion over the fence like this guy is secretly onto something. This is bunk.
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoIt's a somewhat hilarious non sequitur, equating uselessness with existential risk. Like, my cat is also failing to show up in national economic indicators.
- psd1 2y agoNo it isn't; it's two separate premises, which the author uses to synthesise a conclusion. Both premises are required for the conclusion. Neither premise is settled, and if you disagree with either, you're welcome to discard the conclusion. But you can hardly expect a blogger to start from first principles in every post.
- abeppu 2y agoI saw some blurb (I can't find it now) about the optimal time to launch an interstellar probe, and the punchline was that embarking too soon means you will be overtaken by a later vehicle which launched later but with better tech. When the rate of technological progress relative to the duration of a mission is above some threshold, it's rational to do more front-loaded research before actually committing to a particular plan to apply it. In the AI case, advancement has been so rapid that to a certain extent, it makes sense for large companies to delay some aspects of retooling, because better models that come out next month may have different characteristics or requirements. We haven't seen the big shifts in productivity because reorganizing around new tech is slow, and the tech itself is still changing so fast.
- rickydroll 2y agoI think another analogy that applies to AI is going to orbit. It's "not hard" for a sufficiently large rocket to be able to hit orbital heights. It's pretty hard for the rocket to enter orbit at the same height. In the AI world, we are at the suborbital stage of technology. For me, the 99% use case is accessibility tools (speech recognition, grammar correction) and coding. Image generation is like poor-quality Photoshop. Which, by the way, is the best target image generative AI could shoot for. Do what Photoshop can do, only better and easier.
- avaldez_ 2y ago>the optimal time to launch an interstellar probe, and the punchline was that embarking too soon means you will be overtaken by a later vehicle which launched later but with better tech. That's the wait calculation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Interstellar_travel&diffonly=true#Wait_calculation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Interstellar_tr...
- TylerE 2y agoMaybe, but all technology is built on what came before, so actually launching the thing and seeing what it does is a big part of enabling the next generation to be better.
- 2y ago
- photochemsyn 2y ago"The latest estimates, using official figures, suggest that real output per employee in the median rich country is not growing at all." If I can use an AI assistant to complete a job in 3 hours that used to take 9 hours, that's a win for me, because now I have 6 hours to spend on a personal open-source project, some family business, recreational (and healthy) exercise, or some community-beneficial volunteer activities. While this might not show up on the corporate balance sheet, it's going to make the overall society a lot healthier. The existential risk of AI to the current socioeconomic order might have more to do with AI systems making better economic decisions than the overcompensated executive-shareholder sector does, and at far lower cost to the corporation or institution that adopts it. This makes logical sense, since the skills involved in humans climbing to positions of power in organizations (manipulation of other people, hyping up one's capabilities, clinging desperately to power, etc.) don't translate into efficient well-run operations.
- purple-leafy 2y agoExcept that’s not how it ever works. Any productivity gains will be consumed by your employer, and the expectations of your position will increase with the productivity gains. Ie: if your role is now 75% more productive on average, the new expectation of that role is a 75% increase in outputs. So it actually will get much worse for you, because you’ll be doing much, much more for effectively the same pay :) There used to be a single role that did the data layer, a single role that did QA/Testing, a single role for UI/UX, a single role for client side, a single role for server side, and a devops team. Then when the world became good at this stuff, the expectation shifted to, in many cases, a single role juggling all of this work
- ghaff 2y agoIt sort of depends on what you assume become table-stakes tools. Spreadsheets reduced some work, created more work (run a bunch of alternative models), and yes probably eliminated some work--for the people fluent in them. It's probably hard to argue that spreadsheets (which have become the most inarguably successful low-code tools) have markedly decreased the amount of work their users need to do in companies.
- ImHereToVote 2y agoThe ultimate marshmallow test for humanity.
- exe34 2y agoif that's no economic impact, there won't be existential risk.
- hankman86 2y agoIs this necessarily correlated? I would think that the potential to cause disaster is rather linked to whether AI is given authority to enact autonomously decisions, i.e. given access to critical systems.
- exe34 2y agoif there's no benefit, AI's net cost is more than traditional systems. no benefits, no access.
- theLiminator 2y agoYeah, it's flat out a bad take. If the AI is utterly incapable of doing anything useful, it would be utterly incapable of being an existential risk.
- exe34 2y agoi was thinking more if the current crop of AI are useless, they won't get enough money pumped into them to lead to runaway amplification. if there's genuine risk, then there will be rewards. if we're close to that kind of AI, then we can't afford for our enemies to find it first.
- bglazer 2y agoIf AI has no economic impact, it almost by definition also has no ability to marshal the kind of resources necessary to destroy all of humanity. All the doom scenarios seem to rely on quasi-magical abilities springing from advanced intelligence, but ignore that these scenarios require the AI to have access to significant resources. Then, suppose AI does somehow think itself into effecting human annihilation, what happens when all the humans are dead? At the current state of things, all electricity production on the planet goes dark in maybe two weeks. Nuke plants irradiate significant parts of the earth, chip fabs are bricked, metal production is toast. In short the AI necessarily dies too. The only way for this not to happen is AI controlled robots first gaining complete control of massive chunks of the economy. If AI is as useless as the article claims then that will effectively never happen. Thus, AI doom scenarios are always a murder suicide situation, and I’m not sure I believe anyone who says a superhumanly capable planner would pursue that plan. It even negates the “paperclip optimizer” as the AI’s demise obviously puts a hard upper limit on the number of paperclips produced.
- tivert 2y ago> All the doom scenarios seem to rely on quasi-magical abilities springing from advanced intelligence, but ignore that these scenarios require the AI to have access to significant resources. No. The doom scenario I'm most concerned with is basically the one from Manna (https://marshallbrain.com/manna https://marshallbrain.com/manna), which doesn't require any "quasi-magical" abilities. It's basically taking our current economic system and "fixing the glitch" (from the capitalist's perspective) that forces them to pay our salaries. That's (a slow) doom for the vast majority of the population, but not for humanity because the wealthy elite would survive.
- hyperpape 2y agoAnything that removes the need to pay salaries would have massive impacts on productivity numbers. (I am not arguing that would necessarily be good[1], but it would show up in the economic stats, in line with bglazer's point). [1] The big brain take behind "necessarily" is that: "no salaries, everything is free" seems cool, "no salaries, a few people hoard all the wealth" seems bad.
- ppqqrr 2y agoIf a miraculous new technology that helps individuals grok any conceivable topic has “no economic impact,” you should probably question how you measure of economic impact - perhaps even your very definition of the economy, the nature of human labor and collaboration. Fundamental changes at the base of the hierarchy will always escape the attention of high level managerial class, because the one thing they’re never taught to do is to consider the possibility that their inherited power structure may become irrelevant.
- wmf 2y agoThe simplest explanation is just that people aren't using it yet.
- Terr_ 2y ago> If a miraculous new technology that helps individuals grok any conceivable topic If you think that's happened, then you and I are living on very different Internets with different individuals. :P
- realharo 2y agoOr maybe that already happened decades ago with the Internet and search engines.
- ppqqrr 2y agoArguably, but imho the difference between search engines and GPTs is akin to punch card coding vs modern IDE - theoretically the same activity, vastly different in practice.
- realharo 2y agoFor generating output, sure, but when it comes to "helping individuals grok any conceivable topic" like the original comment said, you're still bottlenecked by how fast you can read and understand text, so it won't make as much difference there. Plus, from my experience, the more obscure topics, which are not easy to google, also tend to suffer the most from hallucinations when using LLMs. The topics which ChatGPT can explain perfectly usually have well-written explanations at the top of search results too.