4 ms·
Institutional housing ownership in the US is not a material contributor to housing price inflation [1]. With that said, we are approaching a housing shortage of
by toomuchtodo 2y ago
Institutional housing ownership in the US is not a material contributor to housing price inflation [1]. With that said, we are approaching a housing shortage of +4.5M [2] units, and in concert with YieldStar's Backpage revenue maximization engine [3] (which is laundering landlord price fixing), renters are being squeezed (because where are you going to go if you can't afford to buy? you will pay, or you will be homeless, which certain jurisdictions are attempting to or have outlawed).
To solve housing for those who need housing, enact state level YIMBY policies to override local planning (who will always kowtow to local folks who show up to say no, and local folks who say no because it costs them nothing to do so as they already own), provide cheap money to builders [4], and build as fast as you can.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_and_impact_of_institutional_investment_in_housing_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_and_impact_of_institut...
[2] https://zillow.mediaroom.com/2024-06-18-The-U-S-is-now-short-4-5-million-homes-as-the-housing-deficit-grows https://zillow.mediaroom.com/2024-06-18-The-U-S-is-now-short...
[3] https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=yieldstar&sort=byDate&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...
[4] https://www.startribune.com/janet-yellen-minneapolis-treasury-fund-affordable-housing-financing-program/600375838/ https://www.startribune.com/janet-yellen-minneapolis-treasur...
(Edit: I would still support restriction of investment ownership of housing, depending on implementation details; you have to defend the young from the old and Capital, as they are treating the young as cattle to be squeezed for all they've got simply by virtue of their existence timeline [5] [6], and it's causing folks to simply give up)
[5] https://www.ted.com/talks/scott_galloway_how_the_us_is_destroying_young_people_s_future https://www.ted.com/talks/scott_galloway_how_the_us_is_destr...
[6] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K64GTDwWJo4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K64GTDwWJo4
(as always, think in systems)
- quacked 2y agoA 4.5M unit shortage wouldn't be present if the past several administrations hadn't allowed huge amounts of immigration in the past decade. Reality isn't constrained to "you have to build as fast as possible since your population is going to increase very quickly and there's nothing you can do about that". If every person who came to the US in the past ten years went home, there would be a colossal increase in housing availability and rent prices would crater.
- butshouldyou 2y agoSo would the economy.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoThere is some truth to their point. The economy in aggregate is receiving the benefit of immigration labor (through reduced labor costs and inflation) while socializing the harm on everyone who is competing for this housing (because, obviously, there are only so many affordable housing units available). There is probably a discussion to be had about governing immigration quotas according to available (not planned, available; hope is not a strategy) affordable housing. This would internalize the externalities currently being shifted around on the macro balance sheet. https://www.cnbc.com/2024/06/17/immigrants-help-economy-job-growth-inflation.html https://www.cnbc.com/2024/06/17/immigrants-help-economy-job-...
- quacked 2y agoA close relation of mine worked in a very, very high-up position in the Department of Agriculture. He has been farming-adjacent for his entire career, and years before he joined DoA he explained to me how meatpacking and butchery has slowly been taken over by a central set of massive corporate conglomerates who destroyed competition in the beef industry by pricing then out. All of these major central corporations are completely dependent on illegal labor, and if they hadn't been able to pay lower wages, their takeovers couldn't have occurred at the speed or scale they did. My relation talked about this issue in the DoA and many senior officials pushed back and said that since addressing this issue of illegal labor in the beef industry would cause a rise in beef prices, threatening the availability of the migrant labor base is a no-go. (Biden admin, not that it matters--I'm sure the answer would have been the same under any admin through at least GWB). That's where we are now, in US agriculture, residential construction, etc.. Prices must be kept low, and therefore the stream of low-skill desperate labor must not be turned off. Massive companies enjoy enduring near-monopolies because no one is willing to threaten the comfort of the American consumer.
- 2y ago
- Qwertious 2y ago>enact state level YIMBY policies to override local planning (who will always kowtow to local folks who show up to say no, and local folks who say no because it costs them nothing to do so as they already own) It's more than that; it's a standard free-rider problem. If all the other districts in your city support development in their area, then your own property value will go up, but you won't be burdened by any local development costs. And if you develop in your district but nobody else develops in their district, then your property value won't go up (or will go up only slightly) but you're burdened by the local development costs. It's classic prisoner's dilemma stuff. The simple solution is to remove the local district's ability to veto local development. At least, as long as city-level/state-level planners don't have an agenda that favors certain districts over others.
- toomuchtodo 2y ago> The simple solution is to remove the local district's ability to veto local development. At least, as long as city-level/state-level planners don't have an agenda that favors certain districts over others. That is what state level YIMBY policy is intended to do, to override the free rider problem of existing property owners in the local domain. If the human can say no to any new housing, and it costs be nothing to do so, what is a human going to do when all of their incentives are to say no? As a YIMBY activist who also owns property, I have seen this first hand at local planning meetings. Rebutting complaints point by point (crime, decreased property value, traffic, etc) with data, we finally arrive at "because I don't like it" typically when having this discussions (happens all the time with utility scale solar permitting as well). I am only one person saying "yes, build, build, build." We need more of this, everywhere, and I argue the solution is not simple; if it was, this would be solved instead of being a herculean effort. Please consider attending local planning meetings to voice your support for building more housing in your communities. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=YIMBY&sort=byDate&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...
- inglor_cz 2y agoNIMBY seems to be one of the intrinsic faults of democracy. Some people really don't like any change happening around them, and, once empowered, will go to great lengths to stop anything from happening. This is probably something that democratic states need to address by reducing such empowerment. Much like your neighbor cannot tell you what to cook for dinner - even if he is a vegetarian and hates the smell of meat - he shouldn't be able to tell you not to build a house in his proximity.
- HelloMcFly 2y ago> Institutional housing ownership in the US is not a material contributor to housing price inflation I believe this nationally, but when you see things investors buying 1/3 of Atlanta homes in a given quarter [1] or investors buying 26% of the affordable homes, it becomes hard to believe there is not some level of effect occurring in target population centers. Most of the arguments I see about the small effect of investor purchases seems to focus on national averages (happy to be pointed elsewhere), but I think focusing on national trends will dilute the observed effect where it is occurring. [1] https://atlantaagentmagazine.com/2022/03/24/investors-purchased-one-in-three-atlanta-homes-in-q4-the-highest-in-the-country/ https://atlantaagentmagazine.com/2022/03/24/investors-purcha... [2] https://www.redfin.com/news/investor-home-purchases-q4-2023/ https://www.redfin.com/news/investor-home-purchases-q4-2023/
- pixl97 2y agoI also think there is far more informational to sellers that allow easier one way ratchets in price. Just a few houses selling higher than average in a neighborhood can increase housing prices in that area in the matter of days. In addition buyers are not limited to local market work. With online information you've brought the worldwide back to worldwide web. You see very view poorly listed underpriced houses any more. They get bought up insanely quickly.
- xivzgrev 2y agoInstitutional ownership is immaterial? Erm, from the same source, 10% of some metros is a lot, and that’s just moving the meter to 100+ homes. If you did 10+ or 3+ it would be even more. “This share rises to 3.8 percent of single-family homes for institutional investors owning over 100 homes, and up to 10 percent in certain metro areas such as Atlanta.” Then if you also consider foreign ownership of home, it would rise even more. Lots of wealthy folks have dollars due to it being primary international currency and they buy up our assets Unfortunately this is a big side effect of internet we haven’t solved yet. It’s made buying a home anywhere easier, which inflates prices (demand is much higher now for same number of houses), squeezing out middle class locals
- bryanlarsen 2y ago34% of Americans rent their homes, and having a good stock of rental units is good for America because it makes it a lot easier to move. Institutional owners provide the vast majority of rental units. Getting rid of institutional ownership would increase rental prices substantially, and that's bad for the poor and for the mobile.
- toomuchtodo 2y ago> Getting rid of institutional ownership would increase rental prices substantially, and that's bad for the poor and for the mobile. Extremes are unhelpful, we must find balance. Institutional ownership restrictions reduces monopoly pricing power, and rent controls de-risk against rents rising faster than wages. Outright outlawing of institutional ownership is not a solution, but allowing it to operate in a highly regulated fashion (where there are still some, but more reasonable, returns and mobility is enabled for mobile consumers of this service). If the argument is continue increasing supply vs rent price controls, well, it is clear that isn't happening in the short term. TLDR Housing needs to be pushed more towards being a regulated utility, vs a free for all. If we regulate electricity like a utility, why not housing?
- bryanlarsen 2y agoThe standard refrain is that the housing market is over-regulated, NIMBY's have made it too hard to build. Adding more regulation discouraging instutitions from building sounds like making the problem worse rather than better.
- not_wyoming 2y ago> Institutional housing ownership in the US is not a material contributor to housing price inflation This statement and citation fail to account for the impact of AirBnB and other STR market-makers on the housing market. I strongly suspect a big part of housing price increases is the "small business" equivalent of institutional investors - someone buys 1-2 units that they do not plan to occupy and rent them as STRs. Similarly, vacation homes (aka homes that will go unused for the vast majority of the time) are now much, much more affordable if you can book a couple rentals a month to supplement a mortgage. I'm *sure* AirBnb has some fascinating data on this, but I don't expect to ever see it in the public eye without government intervention (much as we'll likely never see Meta's studies on teen users' mental health). tl;dr - but what about her airbnbs
- fn-mote 2y ago> I strongly suspect a big part of housing price increases is the "small business" equivalent of institutional investors - someone buys 1-2 units that they do not plan to occupy and rent them as STRs. This does not pass the smell test to me. Small businesses somehow are more inventivized to do this than institutional investors? Because the margins are not sufficient to attract the large businesses?? That needs evidence. In general, small landlords don't make sense to me as something to ban. Someone buys a two flat, lives in one and rents the other to help pay for the mortgage. That has classically been ok. You're only objecting to the short term ones?
- not_wyoming 2y ago> Small businesses somehow are more inventivized to do this than institutional investors? Because the margins are not sufficient to attract the large businesses? Yes. When Joe is buying a couple homes, he doesn't have to pay for HR, business dev, legal, compliance, etc etc. And - > That needs evidence. Fair enough! I care about this topic, but not enough about this thread to make a carefully cited case here (no offense to you, friend). I'm sharing from anecdotes and personal (albeit unscientific) research. > Someone buys a two flat, lives in one and rents the other to help pay for the mortgage. That has classically been ok. You're only objecting to the short term ones? Yep, and I've come around on this. I used to think landlord = bad (in college, we're all young and naive at some point), but I've come around to the real economic need for an LTR market. I'm thinking of cases where an individual buys up a handful of properties to use as STRs, removing them from the LTR market (which reduces supply which increases rates of the remaining units). I have seen this happen in my area in real time but I recognize that it is scientifically unsound to extrapolate that to other areas.
- mensetmanusman 2y agoCanadian leaders have finally admitted that high levels of immigration combined with no changes to housing policy has destroyed their affordability. This means immigration policies must be explicitly tied to housing policy if you don’t want to screw over your poor.
- com 2y agoMaybe more important over decadal spans: You also need to align housing policy to demographic changes such as family size, length of time that children remain living with parents, relatives or carers, as well as prevalence of work from home, availability of “local” work within affordable commute range, availability of public transport. In other words, “planning for the future”. The neo-liberal project destroyed more than western industries, it bankrupted our perception that there are more than just market incentives that can build healthier, happier, more resilient and, yes, wealthier societies.
- RobotToaster 2y agoYIMBY policies just end up with a small number of luxury condos being built. You need SHIMBY policies, social housing in my back yard.
- BadHumans 2y agoThis doesn't sound true so I would need a citation on this.
- SoftTalker 2y agoAs long as you're not tearing down 10 units to build 5, more supply is more supply. Doesn't matter nearly as much whether they are luxury or basic.
- underlipton 2y agoNot if the investors are willing to warehouse units to keep prices high, rather than lower prices in order to sell. If prices of luxury units are high enough, you're talking a significant percentage of units that can just be held while investors still break even or profit. Why lock in a loss or low profit (and, in doing so, hurt the value of your other holdings)?
- HDThoreaun 2y agoWarehousing can work to an extent, but eventually there is enough supply to overpower it. Again, the answer is to just keep building. There's also very little evidence that it is happening. NYC has vacancy rates below 3%, its extremely difficult to get much lower than that.
- SoftTalker 2y agoMore supply is more supply. Eventually the strategy breaks.
- underlipton 2y agoI'll be happy to see when it does. We're not there. And, anyway, a break of that strategy probably means that inventory gets flooded to the point that you needn't have overbuilt at all.
- underlipton 2y agoYour first statement is flat-out wrong. The supporting citation does not actually support it, though it hints at how institutional housing ownership has contributed to housing price inflation. To wit: it explains how innovations during the GFC turned direct investment into an appealing proposition for investors. These investors helped to backstop housing values that would have fallen even further than they already had. In other words, the much-needed correction to the pre-GFC bubble that the GFC represented was disrupted and reversed. The actual solution to housing price inflation is a full correction that wipes out the inflated value of housing in this country, cutting each property's worth back down to its intrinsic value. Affordability and use would reset to what the real market actually can sustain, as when the income tax forced wealthy property owners to divest of and demolish or convert their grand mansions into apartments for people to actually live in. There is no housing shortage (Zillow has an obvious conflict-of-interest). There is no need to load even more money into the system by providing cheap money to builders (a naked corporate giveaway that will surely represent yet another wealth transfer from taxpayers to business-owners). Pop the bubble. Planning considerations can follow, once land and property values actually reflect their intrinsic worth. If you do it before that, you throw billions of dollars worth of resources and labor into misbegotten initiatives that do no good for the communities that they're supposed to serve (e.g., highway expansion).
- toomuchtodo 2y agoFannie Mae [1], a GSE, and the Federal Reserve [2] also provide data that confirms a housing shortage. I agree Zillow is potentially non biased, they are simply the most recent data point I've come across wrt to total shortage amount vs the slightly stale citations below. [1] https://www.fanniemae.com/research-and-insights/perspectives/us-housing-shortage https://www.fanniemae.com/research-and-insights/perspectives... [2] https://www.federalreserve.gov/econres/feds/files/2020044pap.pdf https://www.federalreserve.gov/econres/feds/files/2020044pap... > The actual solution to housing price inflation is a full correction that wipes out the inflated value of housing in this country, cutting each property's worth back down to its intrinsic value. Affordability and use would reset to what the real market actually can sustain, as when the income tax forced wealthy property owners to divest of and demolish or convert their grand mansions into apartments for people to actually live in. Your thesis is not grounded in reality, and will never occur due to how durable the economy is (preventing mortgage defaults) due to structural demographics as well as how much equity exists in housing in the aggregate (~$17T as of this comment), preventing a correction from MBS investment failures. As long as demand outstrips supply, no correction will occur, as owners and sellers can outlast buyers. There is no bubble, housing is what housing is worth based on limited supply. The market can sustain this as long as people are willing to buy at the prices on offer, and if demand diminishes (unlikely due to population growth, household formation, and immigration), prices will slowly deflate over years as sellers organize themselves in time series by motivation. Gotta live somewhere. "We are selling to willing buyers at the current fair market price."