6 ms·
How to Become a Registrar (2012)
- ggm 2y agohttps://www.icann.org/resources/pages/financials-55-2012-02-25-en https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/financials-55-2012-02-... gets to the heart of the matter. You have to pony up day #1 for application costs, you have to contract to ongoing annual payments, you. have to have USD70,000 on hand for business continuity or demonstrate why your particular model doesn't need that. I think any beneficent registrar right now is probably grandfathered-in.
- toast0 2y agoYou don't need $70k cash on hand, you need "Evidence of an externally verified document of the capital (such as by guaranteed bank loan or by a guaranteed credit line or letter of credit from a recognized financial institution) must be provided with the application." But even if you needed $70,000 cash on hand, that doesn't seem like that much money. You're going to need some working capital, and $70,000 feels like it should be a good enough start. IMHO, I'd go through a reseller program for a while to make sure I had the volume / revenue to justify the ICANN fees to be a registrar directly; of course, if you do make the jump, you'll likely need to stay in the reselling program for existing domains or convince/help customers move their domains over, which is extra hassle; I've seen some companies where they are an ICANN registrar, but they use resellers for some TLDs and legacy customers. When it was new, I set up two different employers as OpenSRS resellers; and I've been on and off considering setting it up for myself as a low effort side business, but I can't decide if it would be too much work for not enough reward. I hated dealing with money on the internet at the turn of the century, and I don't think it's gotten that much better.
- psychoslave 2y agohttps://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/median-income-by-country https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/median-in... How is $70,000 not much? OK sure, companies can be expected to deal with a bit higher number than the median revenues of citizens. However concurrent businesses won't flourish if there is an entry paying wall which by far exceed individual capacities.
- jkhsfdlkj 2y ago[flagged]
- scrollaway 2y agoFirst on barriers: Becoming a reseller to an existing registrar requires far less than $70k. In fact there's tens if not hundreds of thousands of these types of businesses out there. Second, being a registrar is a ton of responsibility and you cannot start thinking it should be as easy as starting your handmade jewelry business. And finally, no, $70k is not a lot of money especially for a stable business with a sound business plan. Banks especially love loaning money on reliable income sources, and domain names are very stable.
- toast0 2y agoWell, if you futher into documents, it's really > demonstration of the ability to procure liquid capital immediately available in the applicant's name at the commencement of the accreditation period in an amount of US$70,000 or more will be deemed adequate, although a lesser amount will be accepted upon a showing that in the circumstances it will provide adequate working capital. So, if you have a way to show that less will work, ICANN says they're flexible. IMHO, if you're a registrar trying to make money, you need to expect to sell a lot of domains, and so you'll probably need much more credit than $70k to manage payments from customers and to registries and ICANN. Fixed fees are $4k/year, per registrar variable fees were about $1.5k last year if I read the reports correctly. Registrar margin tends to be about 10%, unless you're a specialty registrar, so you've got to be selling $55k/year of domains to break even on the ICANN fees. Let's call that $4,500/month for easy math. But ICANN presumes you need 5 full time employees for customer service; indeed says 18000 INR/month for customer service base salary in India [1], which is about $200/month USD. Five employees is $1,000/month but my US rule of thumb is all-in costs is at least 2x, so you need $20,000/month in domain sales to cover that. With the icann fees and the employee costs, you need $24,500/month in sales to break even. I'm happy to ignore computing costs, it's probably not nothing, but you can do a lot with a little these days. $70,000 is not quite 3 times the minimum sales number. Having that much credit available means you can continue to pay suppliers(registries) if your payment provider puts an unexpected hold on your payments, as long as it's resolved within less than three months. That doesn't seem like an unreasonable ask for customer continuity. But, if it's too much; there are reseller programs. OpenSRS was reseller only when it launched in the first batch of ICANN accredited registrars. Annual fees and credit requirements are much less to be a reseller; if you end up with enough volume that being a registrar instead of a reseller makes sense, you'll likely have accumulated available credit, too. [1] https://in.indeed.com/career/customer-service-representative/salaries https://in.indeed.com/career/customer-service-representative...
- hitpointdrew 2y agoThese aren’t really new rules, there is nothing to be be “grandfathered” into. Maybe they made some slight adjustments but I was looking at the process to become a registrar 5+ years ago and the process as I recall was pretty much the same.
- para_parolu 2y agoIn a world of blockchain is there anything popular for truly distributed DNS?
- withinboredom 2y agoHandshake is one unaffiliated with any existing chain. There’s also ENS on the ethereum chain.
- aragonite 2y agoOne thing I've sometimes wondered is why we need the two-tier system of registries and registrars. Economically speaking, what essential functions do registrars perform (specifically in their capacity as registrars [1]) that justify their existence? Why can't people register say a .org domain name directly with the Public Interest Registry? Why is an intermediary like GoDaddy required? There's even a ICANN rule I think that says a registrar and a registry can't be the same legal entity, which is why Google had to create a separate company called Charleston Road Registry for .dev, .app, .google etc (likewise Donuts created Dog Beach LLC and so on). [1] I know most registrars offer additional services like hosting which smaller (and often non-profit) registries may not be equipped to provide. But that doesn't really answer the question. Why can't registries handle basic domain registration themselves & leave hosting to specialized providers?
- big-green-man 2y agoI personally wonder why we need a central registry system at all. Couldn't we just use a DHT or similar? I understand why it was created this way to a good degree, but why we continue to use this I don't get at all, there have been wonderful practical advances in networking and distributed computing since this was all set up and I can't think of one good reason not to use those advances to make the internet better.
- can16358p 2y agoWe might speculate it's the same reason that AWS doesn't offer software development services or Facebook doesn't produce content. They create the platform for others to build on top of it.
- mgw 2y agoOne idea I‘ve been toying with is to set up a non-profit registrar funded by donations. It would just pass through the registration fees from the registries without markup. Similar to Let‘s Encrypt but for domains. Of course it would be more complicated because the entity would handle money, but nothing that couldn‘t be solved from what I can see. Does anyone with experience in the field have any insights on what roadblocks would be encountered?
- toast0 2y agoI don't have a lot of deep experience here, but I registered by first domain the old fashioned way, send an email, get an invoice from NetworkSolutions, and mail it back with a check. And I setup two low volume OpenSRS reseller accounts for two companies in 2000, IIRC. Registrar markup is not really that much. As I understand it, PIR, the operator of the .org registry charges registrars $9.05 / domain year [1], and low cost registrars typically charge end users $10 / domain year. I know there was a dust up over PIRs management recently, but I don't remember the details and couldn't find them in a quick look; if these aren't the actual numbers, they're pretty close. After payment processing, costs of included registrar provided services, customer service and operations, there's not really huge profits being made by registrars; providing service as a pass through at direct cost wouldn't be that compelling. You'd need some other reason to encourage people to use your services, but I'm not sure what that would be. I've used specialty registrars at work, and they've got features like presence services where they have real people in the jurisdiction that satisfy the requirements of TLDs that require someone in the country to register a domain and corporate registrars that will work with the registry to enable registry locking that makes it incredibly difficult to change domain settings [2]. These are compelling features for the right kind of customer, but I don't think it makes sense for a non-profit to provide them. [1] https://itp.cdn.icann.org/en/files/registry-agreements/org/org-appx-08-pdf-17jul18-en.pdf https://itp.cdn.icann.org/en/files/registry-agreements/org/o... [2] We moved to one of those after the current flavor of Network Solutions was phished and an unauthorized person used a customer service account to change our domain's glue records as well as some others; with registry lock, no changes can be made by the registrar unless the registry unlocks the domain after doing a song and dance routine with the end customer --- not very convenient, especially when the authorized person ignores the call to dance, but better than when a registry employee can get phished and change our domain without our consent
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- psychoslave 2y agoWhat are the alternatives to these centralizing naming services? I guess most people don't even use direct url address for anything. I often see people looking for "google" in the adress/search bar before searching the term from which they expect the link to the website they are looking for. So given this pattern, I don't feel like the domain name is something relevant for most end users. For a static page, or any autonomous js spaghetti, it's easy to simply save the document locally. As soon as some updatability comes in, like a comment section, then the issue of having a way to track a distant resource really becomes relevant. IP offer no guarantees of stability of resource provider. A domain name ensures transparent IP transition as long as the domain lessee is willing and able to pay the bill. This latter point is actually a very concrete security concern, which alone should bring enough consideration to look for other approaches.
- tliltocatl 2y agoIMHO Namecoin/.bit was the only blockchain technology that could actually have been somewhat useful. Didn't catch on and now the blockchain have got so much bad optics that it probably never will.
- shakiXBT 2y agohave you looked into ENS (https://ens.domains https://ens.domains) ? It's everything namecoin wanted to be and more. Also probably the only real usecase for NFTs besides pure collecting and speculation
- psychoslave 2y agoI’m not fond of crypto though, so I’ll be more interested with other approaches.
- tliltocatl 2y agoYes, that's exactly my point.
- hitpointdrew 2y ago
- jiveturkey 2y ago(2012)
- nicexe 2y agoAlthough old, this is the currently valid version.
- jiveturkey 2y agothe date tag on posts is not to indicate whether an article is deprecated vs current. presumably nearly every article posted is currently true (that's the "news" part). it's useful to hint whether it's interesting as a new thing, updated thing, or old but of current interest for some reason. for the same reason that clickbait headlines draw you in, dates are good to wave you away.
- bigbacaloa 2y ago[dead]
- alibarber 2y agoI am personally a Registrar, for the .ax domain. In fact, so are a lot of people - and anyone can become one: https://whois.ax/en/ https://whois.ax/en/ Functionally, it's almost exactly like managing something with any other registrar although if you're looking for a NameDaddyCheap like experience of actually hosting a website and email forwarding in a single package then you'll have to sort it out yourself, the only thing you can do here is designate the ownership (whois) details and supply name server addresses. You are billed directly by the government* of Åland - I guess it is easy and cheap enough for them to run this directly than miss out on profits that would go to an exclusive registrar. *Or whatever they are technically called being an autonomous part of Finland.
- 4ad 2y agoWait, what? Why? Plase explain this, is this just an .ax thing?
- isp 2y ago- https://portal.whois.ax/register https://portal.whois.ax/register - https://whois.ax/en/for-registrars/ https://whois.ax/en/for-registrars/ "Apply as ax-registrar" - seems like .ax makes it especially easy. (This is news to me!)
- jsheard 2y agoI wish there were something inbetween the typical registrars who make pennies per domain and need to aggressively upsell other services to stay in business, and the likes of CSC and Markmonitor who focus soley on domain management but won't even give you the time of day for less than 5 figures.
- AndyMcConachie 2y agoI wish I could more easily comparison shop. You're exactly right. There is a high-end and a low-end, but there is no middle. People have tried to create a middle, but both kinds of customers will ignore it for obvious reasons. The high-end customers know what they want and can judge quality service. The low-end customers just want the cheapest one.
- max_ 2y agoHow do I create something like ".something" like how Amazon has ".aws" or ".google"? Is it the same thing?
- anonu 2y agoThere should be more independent monitoring, oversight and regulation of registrars. I will take my recent experience with GoDaddy as an example: where actively searching for a never-before-used domain will cause them to be automatically registered by GoDaddy. They then turn around and sell it to you for an a few $100 or even a few $1000 more. This is basically highway robbery and ICANN should not allow registrars to run such backhanded, possibly illegal, practices.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]