7 ms·
Flame is Lame
- weavejester 14y agoIt's a fairly nice summary of Flame, but it could do without the link-bait title, since the conclusion of the article is exactly the opposite.
- MehdiEG 14y agoIt's clearly linkbait but it is actually nicely written and informative so I'll give them a pass on this one.
- Spooky23 14y agoIt's satire.
- pbhjpbhj 14y agoNow I'm wondering if the submitter wrote a good title and some mod came along and bawdlerised it?? It's a terrible title. Fine for a media site trying to sell stories based on sensationalism but I thought we were building a brave new online community here.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- brunnsbe 14y agoWho said that Flame was Lame? I haven't stumbled on that much critique about Flame.
- mxxx 14y agoyeah, can't say that i have either. most of what i've read about it has been somewhat in awe of the complexity of the thing.
- bleusink 14y agoI think it's a reply to this article: http://xato.net/malware/flame-is-kind-of-lame/ http://xato.net/malware/flame-is-kind-of-lame/ (discussed on HN here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4087914 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4087914)
- mikkohypponen 14y agoSome examples: http://idealab.talkingpointsmemo.com/2012/05/flame-malware-mostly-smoke-and-mirrors-say-security-experts.php http://idealab.talkingpointsmemo.com/2012/05/flame-malware-m... "The hype surrounding Flame may be partially the result of the ITU" http://www.thetechherald.com/articles/Is-the-hype-surrounding-Flame-blazing-a-FUD-fueled-trail-of-panic http://www.thetechherald.com/articles/Is-the-hype-surroundin... "None of the methods of this malware are particularly new." http://xato.net/malware/flame-is-kind-of-lame/ http://xato.net/malware/flame-is-kind-of-lame/ "It’s just not that impressive as far as features go. In fact, 10 years ago it really wouldn’t have been that impressive." Mikko
- bjornsing 14y agoCompletely agree. That novel cryptographic hash collision thing is mind boggling, all the rest is just run-of-the-mill.
- jjguy 14y agoTo paraphrase Edison, anything worthwhile is 99% perspiration and 1% inspiration. The novel md5 collision/windows update propagation is Flame's 1%. The rest is just what's made possible as a result. It is a cogent reminder of the fragility of the Internet's security infrastructure.
- wglb 14y agoWell, I thought the unreadable, unprocessable, undeleteable file named '.' was rather clever.
- mtgx 14y agoIf this was indeed developed by NSA, wouldn't this sort of attack be easier for them since NSA gets access to Microsoft's source code for Windows?
- Tuna-Fish 14y agoThe access to source code is mostly irrelevant. Access to signing keys is very relevant, and I think there is a very real chance (p>0.2) that the huge oversight MS did with the terminal server keys happened because they were ordered to do it.
- tptacek 14y agoThat's an awfully baroque government backdoor --- a misconfigured X.509 attribute on a certificate that turns out to be signed with a hash for which controlled collisions turn out to be feasible.
- serialx 14y agoNo. The key to this malware being NOT lame is that it uses a new cryptographic attack. Which is, not helped by looking at Microsoft's source code.
- slig 14y agoHow come do they get access to MS code?
- patio11 14y agoI think tptacek has hummed a few bars in this direction before, but it has become received wisdom on some parts of the Internet that geeks vs. government is an asymmetric fight and that since governments are stupid geeks will win. You often see this in, let me cherry pick out of charitability, threads suggesting that the OSS community develop surveillance countermeasures for use by dissidents subject to certifiably evil regimes. It doesn't really matter whether the nation state in question is Iran or the United States. Do not pick fights with people who can respond to a hacking incident by writing a check for $5 million dollars to a defense contractor and consider that low-intensity conflict resolution. It will not end well.
- cheatercheater 14y agoYou forgot to mention black choppers. FTFY: "Do not pick fights with people who can fly black choppers"
- patio11 14y agoSo when you mention black choppers, people will assume you are either being ironic or crazy. There's a particular policy goal affiliated with these attacks, and a spectrum of options for achieving that policy goal. Those options included "There exist certain individually identifiable employees of a foreign government who are personally indispensable to implementing something which goes against our policy goals. We could assassinate them." If you read the papers you know that that option is neither a joke nor the fevered imaginings of a paranoid conspiracy theorist.
- eli 14y agoIndeed: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/05/29/world/obamas-leadership-in-war-on-al-qaeda.html?_r=1 http://www.nytimes.com/2012/05/29/world/obamas-leadership-in...
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoIt is likely that such assassinations are against both International Law (Geneva Conventions) and US law. Carter, Ford and Reagan all prohibited them through executive orders. Even if you think that knocking off some Hamas leaders is a good idea, you will experience scope creep - last year a (sort of) influential policy advisor suggested using drones against Julian Assange. Honestly, "we" (the West) are best armed, best funded, most free peoples ever to walk the earth. If we cannot put aside assassination and torture, then the human race has no hope. Here for an interesting review of legality of such assassinations: http://www.kentlaw.edu/perritt/courses/seminar/jerry-bekkerman-seminar%20paper%20%28final%29.htm http://www.kentlaw.edu/perritt/courses/seminar/jerry-bekkerm... Assange / assassination http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tom_Flanagan_%28political_scientist%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tom_Flanagan_%28political_scien... edit: for clarity, before I become flamed as a woolly left winger, I think that there are many people in the world, that if they were hit by lightning today, the world would be much better off. but a) I think the world is nett worse off if democracies 'arrange' that lightning, because it demeans the important point of a democracy - being a beacon of hope for the future generations. b) the choice of targets, is not discussed in a democratic manner, and almost certainly would not be my choice. (Now thats a referendum I would love to see:-) c) my guess is that, like crime, taking out the people committing the crime right now, magically someone else steps into their place. Sometimes someone who yesterday was not committing those crimes. Hmm, still pretty left wing there...
- sparknlaunch 14y agoI thought the big thing was that flame found itself into a network locked out from the outside world. So the intrigue lies in how it made it into this network ?
- Auguste 14y agoI hadn't heard about that (so please excuse my ignorance), but surely it's just a case of somebody accidentally/intentionally bringing it in on removable storage, like a USB drive, and plugging it in.
- celticninja 14y agoyes, the article says that it will put itself onto USB sticks so that it can be transferred out of a walled garden, therefore it can enter the same way.
- pbhjpbhj 14y agoNot only duplicating itself but putting data from inside the airgapped network on to pen drives so it can escape. I guess the one is useless without the other but this somehow seems far more impressive.
- ticks 14y agoI'm probably alone on this, but 'lame' is such a lazy word to use. Saying it repeatedly just made me stop reading.
- adewinter 14y agoFWIW (I didn't realize this either until the end), the article is actually pointing out that flame isn't lame for one very specific reason: the cutting edge cryptography research that went into it.
- gjm11 14y agoNo. The article is pointing out that Flame isn't lame in lots of different ways, and saying that the naysayers kept calling it lame until one single spectacular bit of non-lameness came to light. It's suggesting that they should have cottoned on sooner. At least, that's my reading of it.
- Tenhundfeld 14y agoIt's using lame as a response to this article: http://xato.net/malware/flame-is-kind-of-lame/ http://xato.net/malware/flame-is-kind-of-lame/
- kyebosh 14y agoApparently "gay" & "retarded" are horribly offensive & insensitive descriptors, but "lame" is ok. Who knew?
- MiguelHudnandez 14y agoI suggest it's because it's not commonly used today for its actual definition. People don't normally refer to themselves or people they love as "lame." Not so for "gay" or "retarded." A modern equivalent of "lame" might be "handicapped," even though it is not as specific.
- Niten 14y agoThe thing I find most interesting about Flame: whoever developed it surely understood that by being released into the wild like this, their new cryptographic attack was guaranteed to eventually be discovered and analyzed. And yet they spent that attack's secrecy on a (very sophisticated, but still) fishing expedition. So what cryptanalytical capabilities do they have which are considered too sensitive to expose via malware?
- tptacek 14y agoBear in mind that attacks on MD5 have an inherently limited shelf life, and that while the exploit used in Flame may be new, the underlying vulnerability and the fundamental technique used to exploit it are very well known.
- s_henry_paulson 14y agoThink about it this way. Flame was designed not to spread automatically, only when it was told to, meaning that a targeted attack like this would be difficult to discover since it affected a relatively few amount of computers compared to a virus designed to propagate at every opportunity, as well as the fact that fishing expedition was limited to only persons the owner were interested in. Combine this with the fact that we're now dating the creation of the virus to at latest summer 2008 [1], and you've got a sophisticated surveillance mechanism that has been installed on thousands of computers and evaded detection for at least 5 years. I'm sure there's lots more tricks that advanced virus authors like this have up their sleeve, but they're only useful to someone if they actually get used, and this seems to have paid off for whoever was behind this. [1] http://www.nation.com.pk/pakistan-news-newspaper-daily-english-online/international/12-Jun-2012/flame-virus-linked-to-stuxnet http://www.nation.com.pk/pakistan-news-newspaper-daily-engli...
- nikcub 14y ago> 7. The stolen info is sent out by infecting USB sticks that are used in an infected machine and copying an encrypted SQLLite database to the sticks, to be sent when they are used outside of the closed environment. This way data can be exfiltrated even from a high-security environment with no network connectivity. > "Agent.BTZ did something like this already in 2008. Flame is lame." Flame's approach is different and more impressive. Agent.BTZ copied itself and used an easy-to-discover autorun.inf file in the root directory of attached disks or network shares. Flame exports its database by encrypting it and then writing it to the USB disk as a file called '.' (just a period, meaning 'current directory') When you run a directory listing you can't see it. You can't open it. The windows API doesn't allow you to create a file with that name and Flame accomplishes this by opening the disk as a raw device and directly writing to the FAT partition. Impressive, right. While a lot of these individual features alone are not impressive the sum of the parts, combined with the collision attack on the certificate signature are very impressive. As for the main point of Mikko's post, I have never understood why so many folks in the netsec industry are arrogantly pessimistic about the innovation of others. I found Flame jaw-droppingly amazing. Nobody knew about it for years, yet it was derided when discovered and documented.
- EthanHeilman 14y ago>I have never understood why so many folks in the netsec industry are arrogantly pessimistic about the innovation of others. I found Flame jaw-droppingly amazing. People are unsure as to why it has such a large file size (do we know why yet?). One very common explanation is that it is bloated because of poor software engineering, some of the people that believe this explanation attempt to fit the facts to that narrative. Also Consider the culture of the demo scene/exploit writers. The smaller code the better the programmer. Personally I like to think that the flame authors intentionally exploited this prejudice and made it large so that: 1. it wouldn't look like malware, 2. if it was discovered no one would take it seriously and look deeper, 3. reverse engineering it would be complicated by it's large file size (cost > benefit from an AV perspective).
- tptacek 14y agoThe same question was asked of Stuxnet; the answer is probably boring: state-sponsored malware authors are not like demo scene writers and do not care if their code is particularly elegant. They probably care more that it's J2EE-style maintainable.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- at-fates-hands 14y ago>> Nobody knew about it for years, yet it was derided when discovered and documented. I had the same reaction, then I thought they did this on purpose to downplay how really impressive Flame is. I imagine the people writing these blogs are actually thinking "Holy S%$&!" behind closed doors or within other security circles.
- yassim 14y agoI'm curious. >9. Latest research proves that Flame is indeed linked to Stuxnet.... Whats the chance that this "Resource 207" is some 3rd party module that more than 1 developer had access to? I concede that placing the same resource in the same resource location in 2 different unrelated applications is a bit of a long shot, but I dont see it as a smoking gun either.
- cdooh 14y agoI've been meaning to ask, exactly how big a team would it take to design such a virus?
- ritratt 14y agoFlame caught all the attention because it made use of a new hash collision technique currently not know to anyone. Which would mean it was govt. backed.